Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Australian documentary: Who decides?

158 replies

CassOle · 30/10/2026 19:37

https://whodecidesfilm.com/

"WHO DECIDES? is a feature documentary exploring the growing national conversation in Australia surrounding the participation of transgender women in female-only spaces, alongside broader questions relating to education, healthcare and public policy.

As these issues increasingly move from sporting fields and schools into courtrooms, government inquiries and parliamentary debate, the film looks beyond the headlines to examine how competing rights, public policy and lived experience intersect. Through interviews with people holding a range of perspectives, alongside those directly affected, experts, advocates, journalists, legal professionals and policymakers, WHO DECIDES? seeks to foster a thoughtful exploration of one of Australia's most contested public conversations."

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 10:26

borntobequiet · 31/10/2026 10:25

Nice to hear from a GENUINE FEMINIST.
Scotland had something similar at one time, if I remember correctly.

Yes, maybe she’ll pop in as she used to 😂

borntobequiet · 31/10/2026 10:25

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:19

Because as a GENUINE FEMINIST I'm not stupid enough to fall for a manufactured astro turfed moral panic designed to enable the ascension of right wing governments who give buggar all about women's rights.

As for women's rights what rights? There are no rights at risk given special exemptions exist for natal women under the anti discrimination act.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country.

So don't think for one second the women of Australia are going to give this colonialist victorian clap trap a second thought because we live in the real world where trans people are the least of our problems hence ZERO interest in this beat up at the grass roots level regardless of the political funding.

Nice to hear from a GENUINE FEMINIST.
Scotland had something similar at one time, if I remember correctly.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:25

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 10:19

Rupert's scaremongering tactics re immigrants, muslims, socialists & indigenous people have been 'sellers' in the past here & abroad so he naturally goes with what has worked in the past. That the younger generation aren't held hostage to the views of his media ownship now changes that. What's the contradiction in that?

Any evidence that he has in any way supported, let alone even knows anything about it? Or are you just hoping that mentioning his name invokes the cloak of fear of guilt by association that people will discredit a documentary that you seem to be heavily invested in discrediting.

Wonderfully, proving the reason that any attempt to pull together information so people have a better overall understanding of the situation is very much needed in the first place.

Meanwhile, people can follow the link and decide for themselves whether it is a valuable documentary or not.

https://whodecidesfilm.com

Thanks again for the uplift in activity for the thread. Brilliant stuff.

Who Decides? film artwork: a collage of faces, newspaper text and Parliament House.

Who Decides? | A Documentary Film

An Australian documentary exploring competing rights, public policy and lived experience across sport, education and healthcare. Sign up for release updates.

https://whodecidesfilm.com

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:19

Keeptoiletssafe · 31/10/2026 10:16

Yes I’ve been over this already and the usual posters couldn’t answer it then.

If someone is one of the unlucky people who have a cardiac arrest in a toilet compartment (11% of cardiac arrests are in toilets), or a seizure, hypo, choking episode, overdose, head injury, stroke etc then it’s better not to be in a unisex design of toilet because no one will know you are having a medically emergency. But this was overlooked by Canberra because they were concerned about one thing above health and safety.

They should have done a risk assessment. Separate sex toilet washrooms are designed with sinks outside the toilet area and not to be fully enclosed for health and safety reasons. But for these designs they have to have a proper definition of sex which Australia doesn’t seem to have now.

The policy of increasing unisex provision will have most impact on Australian women, children and anyone as their most medically vulnerable. When design is written into policy, it matters.

I collate data here but I have a small amount of data from Australia. I have also been in contact with Australian academics. I know this policy will have lasting impacts.

I believe one poster recently told you that they would not interact with you again. So I guess if that is the case, they will ignore you no matter what name they are posting under.

We all appreciate your posts regardless of who answers.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 10:19

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:11

The introduction of Rupert into the discussion is hilarious really.

It is a contradictory argument. Telling us that Rupert would think women’s rights are going to influence politics in Australia while at the same time telling us that no woman in Australia is concerned about female single sex provisions.

All while then admitting that there is no evidence at all to support that Rupert had anything to do with making the film.

Great stuff.

Rupert's scaremongering tactics re immigrants, muslims, socialists & indigenous people have been 'sellers' in the past here & abroad so he naturally goes with what has worked in the past. That the younger generation aren't held hostage to the views of his media ownship now changes that. What's the contradiction in that?

Keeptoiletssafe · 31/10/2026 10:16

Dragonasaurus · 31/10/2026 10:01

I somehow don’t imagine that Fairgo will trouble us with a reply to your very important points

Nor to the issue of many documented attacks by transwomen on natal women in single-sex spaces

Nor to the issue that MoJ statistics suggest that transwomen commit sexual offences at a higher rate than other men

Nor to the fact that transwomen are such a tiny proportion of the population, but can nevertheless remove single-sex spaces/sports/services from 100% of women

Nor the fact that polling repeatedly shows that the majority of women do not accept men in their single sex spaces/sports/services, regardless of how they identify

inconvenient truths

Yes I’ve been over this already and the usual posters couldn’t answer it then.

If someone is one of the unlucky people who have a cardiac arrest in a toilet compartment (11% of cardiac arrests are in toilets), or a seizure, hypo, choking episode, overdose, head injury, stroke etc then it’s better not to be in a unisex design of toilet because no one will know you are having a medically emergency. But this was overlooked by Canberra because they were concerned about one thing above health and safety.

They should have done a risk assessment. Separate sex toilet washrooms are designed with sinks outside the toilet area and not to be fully enclosed for health and safety reasons. But for these designs they have to have a proper definition of sex which Australia doesn’t seem to have now.

The policy of increasing unisex provision will have most impact on Australian women, children and anyone as their most medically vulnerable. When design is written into policy, it matters.

I collate data here but I have a small amount of data from Australia. I have also been in contact with Australian academics. I know this policy will have lasting impacts.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 10:15

Another keyboard Gender Idiot warrior trotting out all the same ol', same ol' tired mantras. It shows why this film is needed, there's no hope for the likes of our poster, they're gone beyond the rim and are deep in the abyss but if we have any hope of preventing future generations from such stupidity, this ideology has got be stopped now.
Come on Aus you can do it, you know it's not fair, as a sporting nation you of all nations can see how unfair it is to let men compete in the women's sporting category.

Ignore your idiot offspring and do what's right and proper, give women back their rights.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:14

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 10:07

A legitimate aim would be that female people with a particular sexual orientation could meet without male people. It is not just a matter of their interest. It is also a safeguarding issue for those female people.

Maybe, it hasn't been determined yet.

Thanks again for bumping this thread so much, and showing just why the doco has been made.

I'm sure the women of Australia will be all ears to MN musings! 😂

There are plenty of Australian women on MN. But the audience for the doco is not limited to Australia at all.

Isn’t global interest wonderful? The internet makes it all so quick and easy to!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 10:11

LeftieRightsHoarder · 31/10/2026 10:07

For the first time I’m starting to feel hopeful for Australia. As soon as the transactivists start in with their hyperbolic insults, you realise someone’s trying to give women a fair chance.

Australia used to be renowned for its tough male culture, with the unfortunate downside of misogyny and sexism. But that seemed to be changing for the better a few decades ago.

Then the trans industry got a foothold and demolished women’s single-sex rights amazingly fast.

Worldwide, the bizarre thing is that men’s sex fetishism has been taken up as a basic human right by people who consider themselves progressive or even left wing.

So I hope this film shows the reality and wakes a lot of people up to reality.

I was in Oz for 5 weeks earlier this year, had a lovely time and mostly it wasn’t particularly woke! I imagine most people have no idea just how mad it’s got, I think people in the uk have been exposed to more media about it maybe.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:11

The introduction of Rupert into the discussion is hilarious really.

It is a contradictory argument. Telling us that Rupert would think women’s rights are going to influence politics in Australia while at the same time telling us that no woman in Australia is concerned about female single sex provisions.

All while then admitting that there is no evidence at all to support that Rupert had anything to do with making the film.

Great stuff.

GrumpyPanda · 31/10/2026 10:11

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:39

Because 'app access' aren't considered a legitimate aim for obvious reasons.

App access to be used to, among others, arrange safe female-to-female ride-sharing opportunities. Yeah, can't see how that would be legitimate.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 10:07

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:53

A legitimate aim would be that female people with a particular sexual orientation could meet without male people. It is not just a matter of their interest. It is also a safeguarding issue for those female people.

If the ability to exclude was there in law, then they would be able to exclude those male people.

Thanks again for bumping this thread so much, and showing just why the doco has been made.

I am looking forward to watching it.

A legitimate aim would be that female people with a particular sexual orientation could meet without male people. It is not just a matter of their interest. It is also a safeguarding issue for those female people.

Maybe, it hasn't been determined yet.

Thanks again for bumping this thread so much, and showing just why the doco has been made.

I'm sure the women of Australia will be all ears to MN musings! 😂

LeftieRightsHoarder · 31/10/2026 10:07

Fairgo · 30/10/2026 22:08

You can tell from the promo this is a heavily biased video masquerading as 'just asking questions' given that 99% of the clips are pushing an anti trans narrative.

Looks like the latest desperate attempt to get a grass roots anti trans movement going in Australia where none exists despite their many well funded media campaigns to do so. It will be forever a lost cause in Australia as we don't have the same anti egalitarian cultural influences as the UK does.

For the first time I’m starting to feel hopeful for Australia. As soon as the transactivists start in with their hyperbolic insults, you realise someone’s trying to give women a fair chance.

Australia used to be renowned for its tough male culture, with the unfortunate downside of misogyny and sexism. But that seemed to be changing for the better a few decades ago.

Then the trans industry got a foothold and demolished women’s single-sex rights amazingly fast.

Worldwide, the bizarre thing is that men’s sex fetishism has been taken up as a basic human right by people who consider themselves progressive or even left wing.

So I hope this film shows the reality and wakes a lot of people up to reality.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 10:06

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:32

I see.

So you have no information and you are just slinging shit at the wall to see what sticks. You are just making assumptions based on your own prejudiced biases.

And howse that working? Because so far if you read back your posts are incoherent and I am wondering if you are ok.

Oh how tedious. Wish we had an ignore button, though I’d have to keep updating it with all the names.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 10:04

Looking forward to seeing this when it streams. It looks great!

Dragonasaurus · 31/10/2026 10:01

Keeptoiletssafe · 31/10/2026 09:30

There’s a bit of confusion at the moment about new builds because it appears Canberra has stated 50% of toilets should be unisex. That will be a huge social experiment because self contained, private toilets aren’t as safe or healthy as standard designs of separate sex toilet washrooms.

I scanned over the Australian documents and there’s no realisation on the impact of how design affects the cost, cleanliness, number of pathogens, drug use and overdoses, vandalism, survival rate if someone collapses or sexual or other assault rate, closure rate due to misuse.

I somehow don’t imagine that Fairgo will trouble us with a reply to your very important points

Nor to the issue of many documented attacks by transwomen on natal women in single-sex spaces

Nor to the issue that MoJ statistics suggest that transwomen commit sexual offences at a higher rate than other men

Nor to the fact that transwomen are such a tiny proportion of the population, but can nevertheless remove single-sex spaces/sports/services from 100% of women

Nor the fact that polling repeatedly shows that the majority of women do not accept men in their single sex spaces/sports/services, regardless of how they identify

inconvenient truths

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:57

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:52

It was. Its small inconsequential population comparatively. That you can't even bring yourself to admit basic maths is testimony to the insecurity of your argument.

I think you are projecting even more than a Hoyts multiplex at this time.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:55

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:52

It was. Its small inconsequential population comparatively. That you can't even bring yourself to admit basic maths is testimony to the insecurity of your argument.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women

That is what you posted.

NowSober · 31/10/2026 09:55

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:39

Because 'app access' aren't considered a legitimate aim for obvious reasons.

Because 'app access' aren't considered a legitimate aim for obvious reasons.

Please can you explain? It doesn't seem obvious to me why lesbians aren't allowed networking apps.

AudHvamm · 31/10/2026 09:53

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:38

Clue:

Banging on incessantly about your personal hyper disgust sensitivities regarding 0.5% of the population as if they were an existential threat to civilisation as we know it ain't it.

God I love it when you come and tell us how to feminist.

Fucking banging on about things that affect women as a sex class is all that feminism is.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:53

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:50

Exemptions from discrimination requires a legitimate aim to prove a disadvantage. There's no right for anyone to exclude protected groups otherwise.

A legitimate aim would be that female people with a particular sexual orientation could meet without male people. It is not just a matter of their interest. It is also a safeguarding issue for those female people.

If the ability to exclude was there in law, then they would be able to exclude those male people.

Thanks again for bumping this thread so much, and showing just why the doco has been made.

I am looking forward to watching it.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:52

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:50

That isn’t what you posted though.

It was. Its small inconsequential population comparatively. That you can't even bring yourself to admit basic maths is testimony to the insecurity of your argument.

AudHvamm · 31/10/2026 09:51

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:30

I think you need it printed on a shirt in huge letters.

Aha, I'll go get my paint pens out.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:50

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:47

The point is the 100% is only 0.5% of the population.And for those very bad at maths means they barely exist.

That isn’t what you posted though.

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:50

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 09:38

How’d that work out for the lesbian group?

If there was an ability to exclude male people, why did they have to go to court in the first place? And remind us again, did they win the ability to meet with out male people ?

Exemptions from discrimination requires a legitimate aim to prove a disadvantage. There's no right for anyone to exclude protected groups otherwise.