Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Australian documentary: Who decides?

158 replies

CassOle · 30/10/2026 19:37

https://whodecidesfilm.com/

"WHO DECIDES? is a feature documentary exploring the growing national conversation in Australia surrounding the participation of transgender women in female-only spaces, alongside broader questions relating to education, healthcare and public policy.

As these issues increasingly move from sporting fields and schools into courtrooms, government inquiries and parliamentary debate, the film looks beyond the headlines to examine how competing rights, public policy and lived experience intersect. Through interviews with people holding a range of perspectives, alongside those directly affected, experts, advocates, journalists, legal professionals and policymakers, WHO DECIDES? seeks to foster a thoughtful exploration of one of Australia's most contested public conversations."

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
JellySaurus · 31/10/2026 12:01

Keeptoiletssafe · 31/10/2026 09:30

There’s a bit of confusion at the moment about new builds because it appears Canberra has stated 50% of toilets should be unisex. That will be a huge social experiment because self contained, private toilets aren’t as safe or healthy as standard designs of separate sex toilet washrooms.

I scanned over the Australian documents and there’s no realisation on the impact of how design affects the cost, cleanliness, number of pathogens, drug use and overdoses, vandalism, survival rate if someone collapses or sexual or other assault rate, closure rate due to misuse.

Do 'unisex toilets' mean the same thing in UK and Australia? Here, UK, we understand that term to mean completely enclosed, single-occupancy rooms which include washing facilities and sanitary disposal of period products. In Australia, does unisex toilets mean that, or does it mean a different door sign on the usual communal facilities?

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 12:01

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 11:04

Look that's fine I have no issues with anyone promoting their view however disagreeable but don't pretend its balanced & then have the full cast of sky channel agit prop right wing pundits as the over arching view point. Its false advertising.

You haven't even seen it yet!!!
You can't pronounce it unbalanced before you do, if it is then you'll be able to point to whatever they said as proof that it's unbalanced but slagging it off beforehand just shows how unbalanced you are.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 31/10/2026 11:59

When the conversation is finally allowed, public opinion always shifts towards women's rights. Australia's experiment with regressive gender ideology is doomed. Even Gillard is trying to wash her hands of it.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 11:57

I wonder if the reason there is mostly men in the trailer is that the makers knew that men aren’t necessarily going to attract the abuse and death threats that Sal and Kirrilie have.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 11:27

But Sky Australia has Labour Party panelists and commentators as well if I remember correctly.

So, are those panelists part of your “full cast of sky channel agit prop right wing pundits”.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 11:20

Because I assume there are more hoyts in Sydney than anywhere else. Maybe the North Shore is a good indicator. I mean, Macquarie is the home of the Flying Bats. And Macquarie Centre could do with a Hoyts cinema in competition to Events.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 11:17

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 11:09

Its working fine. I don't need a fringe irrational echo chamber for validation.

You seem bothered tho, reality as in the real world bites….

Nah mate. Just pointing out that it really must bother you because you yelled it at us.

Again, more projection than a Hoyts multiplex though. You must be keeping Sydney lit up tonight.

Grammarnut · 31/10/2026 11:16

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 11:04

Look that's fine I have no issues with anyone promoting their view however disagreeable but don't pretend its balanced & then have the full cast of sky channel agit prop right wing pundits as the over arching view point. Its false advertising.

Neither of us has seen the documentary but the trailer was unbiased afaics - I suppose I could have done a click-survey. Best advice, Fairgo, just put 'bump' next time you want to bump something on here.

DialSquare · 31/10/2026 11:15

CassOle · 31/10/2026 11:10

"manipulated by Rupert"

I knew that Bear was up to something.

I never trusted him. It’s the trousers.

Looking forward to the documentary though.

CassOle · 31/10/2026 11:10

"manipulated by Rupert"

I knew that Bear was up to something.

Cartoon Wow GIF by Paul McCartney
OP posts:
Fairgo · 31/10/2026 11:09

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:58

So, howse that GENUINE FEMINIST discussion tactic working for you today?

Getting much traction as a position of authority? Do you yell it at people who won’t just fall in line with your discussion points that everyone you disagree with is being manipulated by Rupert?

Its working fine. I don't need a fringe irrational echo chamber for validation.

You seem bothered tho, reality as in the real world bites….

teawamutu · 31/10/2026 11:06

JellySaurus · 31/10/2026 09:04

You’ve omitted Whataboutery, Women haven’t lost any rights, Outdated, Never Happens, Nobody Cares, and Introduce Irrelevancies. Most of which our new TRA has already ticked.

True. Need an updated version.

Australian documentary: Who decides?
Fairgo · 31/10/2026 11:04

Grammarnut · 31/10/2026 10:59

You mean it is pro-women and sex reality? Doesn't give whole field to trans advocates is what you actually mean, isn't it? I watched the trailer. It is clear that trans voices are given half the space - and I heard Mr Tickle speak before I saw him and he is most definitely a man. A mentally unwell one who needs help.

Edited

Look that's fine I have no issues with anyone promoting their view however disagreeable but don't pretend its balanced & then have the full cast of sky channel agit prop right wing pundits as the over arching view point. Its false advertising.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 11:03

Reposting for anyone who just skipped over the past couple of pages.

Just in case anyone has missed this UK doco or wants to rewatch it in prep for next week‘s launch here is the link

https://adulthumanfemale.info/wp/

Of course, there are threads on MN about the protests that blocked the showing of the doco in Edinburgh at the Uni. How male people intimidated and blocked female people from watching it together.

https://archive.is/guKEW

All because feminists rejected that male people should be included in female single sex provisions and made a documentary about it.

No doubt, the Australian doco would be similarly protested if the location for the launch gets leaked.

ADH – My WordPress Blog

https://adulthumanfemale.info/wp/

Grammarnut · 31/10/2026 10:59

Fairgo · 30/10/2026 22:08

You can tell from the promo this is a heavily biased video masquerading as 'just asking questions' given that 99% of the clips are pushing an anti trans narrative.

Looks like the latest desperate attempt to get a grass roots anti trans movement going in Australia where none exists despite their many well funded media campaigns to do so. It will be forever a lost cause in Australia as we don't have the same anti egalitarian cultural influences as the UK does.

You mean it is pro-women and sex reality? Doesn't give whole field to trans advocates is what you actually mean, isn't it? I watched the trailer. It is clear that trans voices are given half the space - and I heard Mr Tickle speak before I saw him and he is most definitely a man. A mentally unwell one who needs help.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2026 10:58

So, howse that GENUINE FEMINIST discussion tactic working for you today?

Getting much traction as a position of authority? Do you yell it at people who won’t just fall in line with your discussion points that everyone you disagree with is being manipulated by Rupert?

CassOle · 31/10/2026 10:56

Well, I hadn't expected so many replies to this thread.

A big thanks to Fairgo for bumping it so many times - I didn't read a single word, so next time maybe just post: "Bump" as it would save you a lot of time.

Hopefully all the Australian MNers have seen about the film now and can decide for themselves whether they want to watch it or not.

An even bigger thanks to Keeptoiletssafe for your informative posts.

OP posts:
NowSober · 31/10/2026 10:53

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 09:39

Because 'app access' aren't considered a legitimate aim for obvious reasons.

Because 'app access' aren't considered a legitimate aim for obvious reasons.

Please can you explain? It doesn't seem obvious to me why lesbians aren't allowed networking apps.

Datun · 31/10/2026 10:48

ChoppingGoodGretelTottenhamEmilyNorthernBaileyHowseIcelandicnightsBeePattiesFairgo

So much rage against women. I hope this documentary is aired far and wide. I have friends in Oz, and they are just beginning to wake up to the issue.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 31/10/2026 10:46

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 10:19

Rupert's scaremongering tactics re immigrants, muslims, socialists & indigenous people have been 'sellers' in the past here & abroad so he naturally goes with what has worked in the past. That the younger generation aren't held hostage to the views of his media ownship now changes that. What's the contradiction in that?

As apposed to the TRA's scaremongering tactic of
SHOUTING 'literal genocide' when anyone questions the sense of GI.
Or SHOUTING for the 'decapitation' of women who dare speak up for themselves.

Or SHOUTING NAZI at anyone who mentions the reality that men can't be women.
Or SHOUTING about 'thousands of trans committing suicide' because they feelz unsafe.

The youngest generation aren't buying the crap, and are looking at the generations before who have as if they've all got a screw loose.

Wishesandhorses · 31/10/2026 10:42

Always interesting too that when the wheels fall off, the ranting and blame from activists is that everyone's tolerance has failed/bigotry/facism/right wing/ blah blah blah and thats why -

wholly ignoring that the tolerance was mostly there but was destroyed by the behaviour of the men with genders as soon as they got into women's spaces. And by the activists who then couldn't stop themselves bellowing the quiet bits out loud. Repeatedly.

Who was it so wisely said the other day something to the effect of 'it's not lack of visibility that is the problem - it's that this movement has had huge visibility and people discovered they really did not like what they were seeing, or what they realised they'd been facilitating'.

And the bottom line is always rage at being faced with other people having rights too, betraying quite a lot of the lack of health and capacity beneath a great deal of this movement.

Datun · 31/10/2026 10:40

Fairgo · 31/10/2026 07:19

Because as a GENUINE FEMINIST I'm not stupid enough to fall for a manufactured astro turfed moral panic designed to enable the ascension of right wing governments who give buggar all about women's rights.

As for women's rights what rights? There are no rights at risk given special exemptions exist for natal women under the anti discrimination act.

And what's absolutely galling is how this manufactured top down grievance that involves 0.5% of trans women has centred itself as the women's right's calamity of our time that effectively silences via its media saturation REAL problems like the epidemic level of domestic & sexual violence women face in this country.

So don't think for one second the women of Australia are going to give this colonialist victorian clap trap a second thought because we live in the real world where trans people are the least of our problems hence ZERO interest in this beat up at the grass roots level regardless of the political funding.

Again, it's absolutely baffling that you think it's a good argument to say that the men who should be allowed into women's spaces are those who really really want to, and who don't like to take no for an answer.

Adding that, come on, there's hardly any of them, really isn't the killer you imagine.

Justnot · 31/10/2026 10:38

You lot are the OG so they keep coming here to (try to) have a pop

solerolover · 31/10/2026 10:38

The man at the 1:37 mark says: "none of us voted for this, this has all just smuggled its way in," this seems to be the tactic with regards to trans ideology doesn't it? I'm reminded of the Denton's Report.

solerolover · 31/10/2026 10:33

If it wasn't for the self proclaimed "debate pervert" ChoppingGoodGretelTottenhamEmilyNorthernBaileyHowseIcelandicnightsBeePattiesFairgo boosting this thread with their very convincing arguments, that we totally haven't been hearing for the better part of a year, I would have missed this thread entirely, so cheers for that!😊

Swipe left for the next trending thread