Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Matt Rattley, Oxford lecturer, and his prosthetic breasts

951 replies

Margaritaaahhh · 28/10/2026 13:53

From X:

"Matt Rattley, a non-stipendiary biochemistry lecturer at Oxford's St Hilda’s College and part-time in the Department of Biochemistry, shared recent photos of himself wearing noticeable prosthetic breasts while teaching. Critics raise concerns about the impact on students, including young female GCSE and A-level tutees and women at the historic women’s college, with some academics like Professor Michael Biggs suggesting it could create a degrading environment or even amount to sexual harassment. Oxford University emphasizes maintaining professional standards and respect for students while fostering inclusivity, but declines to comment on individual cases. The situation highlights ongoing discussions over personal expression versus workplace expectations in education."

Of course it's sexual harassment. I'd go as far as to say it's assault - forcing women to participate in his fetish without their consent. Women and girls - he also tutors A level and GCSE students.

I am so sick of these men and their perversions being forced on us, and if we do not consent we're the bad guys. Just, no. Enough.

Oxford Lecturer Wears Prosthetic Breasts in Lecture Hall

Oxford University's biochemistry lecturer Matt Rattley, who uses they/them pronouns, shared photos of himself wearing prominent prosthetic breasts during lectures, including one in a packed hall for first-year students. The university emphasized its co...

https://x.com/i/trending/2115394671744536727?s=20

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:33

FlirtsWithRhinos · 30/10/2026 19:31

I'm very interested to know on what basis a strap on is unequivocally a sex toy, but false tits of a size that would cause any woman who naturally grew them extreme physical (and sadly also social) discomfort to the point she'd be likely to get reduction surgery on the NHS is not.

Seems some obvious things can be definitively judged, while other equally obvious things cannot. Weird.

Also, I am very uncomfortable with anyone taking the tobacco / big oil play of "if you can't give me 100% certainty that this causes harm, I will carry on doing it with impunity until you can" approach to women's comfort and dignity. And noticing very much the double standards between the attitudes being claimed to be held here, and the "if there's the sightest hint a trans person might feel unsafe or offended just don't do it, right? It's not hard to show respect" approach demanded by the same posters.

One is made for the purposes of sex, the other is not. Hope this helps.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 30/10/2026 19:33

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 30/10/2026 19:25

Not many of the children did tell anyone, and if they did no one listened to them.

After all, as posters here like to point out re other creeps, he had not (or more accurately, few people yet knew that he had) committed crimes. He’d have passed one of these miraculous database checks that are supposed to keep everyone so safe.

At the time that program was big, I was being subjected to sexual touching by a near relative and so was developing a very sensitive creepometer. I didn’t at all like seeing how he held the children on his knee.

Even then aged about 10 I questioned whether I had got over-sensitive and was tarring all men with the same brush. But I didn’t like him or his smile and was very aware when I watched an otherwise enjoyable program of how much I wouldn’t want to sit on his lap.

Teaching girls not to trust their instincts is a big part of all this, as some spectacularly daft posters here keep demonstrating.

Teaching girls not to trust their instincts is a big part of all this, as some spectacularly daft posters here keep demonstrating.

Echoing this. It's important.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 30/10/2026 19:31

I'm very interested to know on what basis a strap on is unequivocally a sex toy, but false tits of a size that would cause any woman who naturally grew them extreme physical (and sadly also social) discomfort to the point she'd be likely to get reduction surgery on the NHS is not.

Seems some obvious things can be definitively judged, while other equally obvious things cannot. Weird.

Also, I am very uncomfortable with anyone taking the tobacco / big oil play of "if you can't give me 100% certainty that this causes harm, I will carry on doing it with impunity until you can" approach to women's comfort and dignity. And noticing very much the double standards between the attitudes being claimed to be held here, and the "if there's the sightest hint a trans person might feel unsafe or offended just don't do it, right? It's not hard to show respect" approach demanded by the same posters.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:31

BackToLurk · 30/10/2026 19:29

She’s talked specifically about Janet Murray being approached by students I think. And as I said, your own relationship with the truth has been somewhat fluid in the past, but if you want to keep aggressively going at her, you do you.

I’m sure you’re getting something out of it. Helps the lonely winter evenings fly by or something.

And specifically Janet herself hasn't claimed that his students have approached her, never mind 'spoken out' against him. So what does that make it? Is it a lie? Especially as she's now removed any doubt that she was simply mistaken...

I'm just waiting for my son to come home to watch a show I already know the ending of. I'm probably lying about that too though.

Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 19:30

Right. Off to a Halloween party. Considered going as an Oxford lecturer with a fake beard and pneumatic fake chebs but sadly all the costumes had been hired already so bin bag witch it is.

Have a lovely evening chaps!

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 30/10/2026 19:29

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:24

I think she is using her experience to make a judgement about how this particular item is used. ‘Sex toy’ seems apt to her. I wouldn’t characterise that as a lie. It’s an opinion.

She was quite clear that several of his students had spoken out. But that isn't the case. She lied about it. And when challenged has decided that she will no longer engage. So now I don't believe anything she's said.

She’s talked specifically about Janet Murray being approached by students I think. And as I said, your own relationship with the truth has been somewhat fluid in the past, but if you want to keep aggressively going at her, you do you.

I’m sure you’re getting something out of it. Helps the lonely winter evenings fly by or something.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:29

KittyWilkinson · 30/10/2026 19:21

Yes of course you do.

Do you think it's a particularly impossible career to have or something? Very odd post. I'm almost tempted to tell you which two celebrities win tonight just for a bit of chaos.

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:28

@alcovecupboards if you are a woman you sound incredibly fortunate to have not experienced creepy men. Lucky you. Most of us have not.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:28

Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 19:25

His students have spoken out, but they have felt the need to do so anonymously. I never once said that they had given their names or offered direct quotes.

How awful that they feel they have to remain anonymous. What a terrible indictment of the culture currently, wouldn't you agree?

No they haven't. Not even Janet has claimed his students have spoken out. You are the only one who has said many of his students have spoken out. So where are their words? No names needed, just one quote from a student who has spoken out. Just one? No? Because you made it up.

Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 19:27

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:24

I think she is using her experience to make a judgement about how this particular item is used. ‘Sex toy’ seems apt to her. I wouldn’t characterise that as a lie. It’s an opinion.

She was quite clear that several of his students had spoken out. But that isn't the case. She lied about it. And when challenged has decided that she will no longer engage. So now I don't believe anything she's said.

I am engaging with you, Alcove. Don't lie. It casts doubt etc...

OP posts:
Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 19:25

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:18

You claimed that his students had spoken out. That's not true though. So why lie? And why not just own up and say you were mistaken rather than continue the lie? It does cast doubt on everything else you say.

His students have spoken out, but they have felt the need to do so anonymously. I never once said that they had given their names or offered direct quotes.

How awful that they feel they have to remain anonymous. What a terrible indictment of the culture currently, wouldn't you agree?

OP posts:
ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 30/10/2026 19:25

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:06

Not many kids who sat on Jimmy Saviles knee reported being uncomfortable. Doesn’t mean they weren’t. Bloke who has live near me for years used to think it was ok to shout how he couldn't wait to ‘shag me sensesless’. Fat and unattractive. Had he been fit and attractive I would have been equally repulsed.

Not many of the children did tell anyone, and if they did no one listened to them.

After all, as posters here like to point out re other creeps, he had not (or more accurately, few people yet knew that he had) committed crimes. He’d have passed one of these miraculous database checks that are supposed to keep everyone so safe.

At the time that program was big, I was being subjected to sexual touching by a near relative and so was developing a very sensitive creepometer. I didn’t at all like seeing how he held the children on his knee.

Even then aged about 10 I questioned whether I had got over-sensitive and was tarring all men with the same brush. But I didn’t like him or his smile and was very aware when I watched an otherwise enjoyable program of how much I wouldn’t want to sit on his lap.

Teaching girls not to trust their instincts is a big part of all this, as some spectacularly daft posters here keep demonstrating.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:24

BackToLurk · 30/10/2026 19:21

I think she is using her experience to make a judgement about how this particular item is used. ‘Sex toy’ seems apt to her. I wouldn’t characterise that as a lie. It’s an opinion.

There were some reports that students or others have spoken out. People phrase things in different ways and people can be mistaken. Is that a lie or was she mistaken?

Given that you previously claimed to have objected to a Supreme Court position that it simply couldn’t have held, as the particular law you referenced was removed from the statute before the SC existed, then maybe you aren’t talking from a position of strength regarding honesty.

You seem to have decided to just take the opposite position to whatever position you think is held by the majority on here, based it seems on a misconception that there is some kind of party line. It’s weird and suggests you’re far more tribal than anyone else posting.

I think she is using her experience to make a judgement about how this particular item is used. ‘Sex toy’ seems apt to her. I wouldn’t characterise that as a lie. It’s an opinion.

She was quite clear that several of his students had spoken out. But that isn't the case. She lied about it. And when challenged has decided that she will no longer engage. So now I don't believe anything she's said.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:22

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:20

@alcovecupboards @tiresianlove you both remind me of a guy who was the IT guy in a school I worked in. Holed up in a windowless room. Geeky used to be the word. He went from being called A to b male/generic names to then a female name. Could not love his ‘boobs’ more. Got off on knowing we needed his tech knowledge. Was peevish as heck. He was clearly not ok. But as women we had to support ‘Katie’s’ struggle. Still did a massive man dump in the ladies loos every morning. If they can refine trans affirming procedures to stop that I might be more inclined to accept.

Of course I do. Because heaven forbid a woman disagree with you without being an incel man.

BackToLurk · 30/10/2026 19:21

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 18:56

She's also made a series of claims that have been shown to be false. Case in point - this is a sex toy - but there's no evidence of that. Many of his students have spoken out - no they haven't. Or are we accepting out and out lies because it's from someone GC-enough?

I think she is using her experience to make a judgement about how this particular item is used. ‘Sex toy’ seems apt to her. I wouldn’t characterise that as a lie. It’s an opinion.

There were some reports that students or others have spoken out. People phrase things in different ways and people can be mistaken. Is that a lie or was she mistaken?

Given that you previously claimed to have objected to a Supreme Court position that it simply couldn’t have held, as the particular law you referenced was removed from the statute before the SC existed, then maybe you aren’t talking from a position of strength regarding honesty.

You seem to have decided to just take the opposite position to whatever position you think is held by the majority on here, based it seems on a misconception that there is some kind of party line. It’s weird and suggests you’re far more tribal than anyone else posting.

KittyWilkinson · 30/10/2026 19:21

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:18

Yes, as in the actual development and production of television shows. Ones that you may watch. Not a euphemism.

Yes of course you do.

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:20

@alcovecupboards @tiresianlove you both remind me of a guy who was the IT guy in a school I worked in. Holed up in a windowless room. Geeky used to be the word. He went from being called A to b male/generic names to then a female name. Could not love his ‘boobs’ more. Got off on knowing we needed his tech knowledge. Was peevish as heck. He was clearly not ok. But as women we had to support ‘Katie’s’ struggle. Still did a massive man dump in the ladies loos every morning. If they can refine trans affirming procedures to stop that I might be more inclined to accept.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:19

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:13

His employer is most certainly worried he will sue them so they go down the weak management/DEI/bring your whole self to work route. As academics they will never, for the most part have ever worked in the real world.

So the answer is that it's acceptable to his employer?

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:18

Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 19:16

I've responded several times that women have approached journalist Janet Murray anonymously to air their concerns and discomfort, but that's not enough for Alcove. Only quotes and names will suffice.

Similarly the fact that latex bodysuits which include huge fake breasts and ribbed-interior fake vaginas are clearly sex toys is not enough evidence that they're sex toys. And if this man is 'only' wearing the breasts part of the bodysuit, which are available for sale on the same website, there's a possibility it's not a sex toy because... Reasons.

But as I said upthread, Alcoves agrees with us that this man is a creep and she wouldn't have him tutor her daughter, so her arguments defending him are a bit strange and redundant anyway. I honestly think that given that she agrees with us it's only fair we stop arguing the toss with her on this one.

You claimed that his students had spoken out. That's not true though. So why lie? And why not just own up and say you were mistaken rather than continue the lie? It does cast doubt on everything else you say.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:18

KittyWilkinson · 30/10/2026 19:15

Telly production? Lol. Euphemisms rule.

Yes, as in the actual development and production of television shows. Ones that you may watch. Not a euphemism.

Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 19:16

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:06

Not many kids who sat on Jimmy Saviles knee reported being uncomfortable. Doesn’t mean they weren’t. Bloke who has live near me for years used to think it was ok to shout how he couldn't wait to ‘shag me sensesless’. Fat and unattractive. Had he been fit and attractive I would have been equally repulsed.

I've responded several times that women have approached journalist Janet Murray anonymously to air their concerns and discomfort, but that's not enough for Alcove. Only quotes and names will suffice.

Similarly the fact that latex bodysuits which include huge fake breasts and ribbed-interior fake vaginas are clearly sex toys is not enough evidence that they're sex toys. And if this man is 'only' wearing the breasts part of the bodysuit, which are available for sale on the same website, there's a possibility it's not a sex toy because... Reasons.

But as I said upthread, Alcoves agrees with us that this man is a creep and she wouldn't have him tutor her daughter, so her arguments defending him are a bit strange and redundant anyway. I honestly think that given that she agrees with us it's only fair we stop arguing the toss with her on this one.

OP posts:
alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:15

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:06

Not many kids who sat on Jimmy Saviles knee reported being uncomfortable. Doesn’t mean they weren’t. Bloke who has live near me for years used to think it was ok to shout how he couldn't wait to ‘shag me sensesless’. Fat and unattractive. Had he been fit and attractive I would have been equally repulsed.

The difference being that no-one said at the time that a whole host of them had spoken out about their discomfort. Because that would be a lie. Like the OP's lie that many of his students have spoken about their discomfort. Will you condemn such a lie? Or is it OK because you want to believe that lie?

KittyWilkinson · 30/10/2026 19:15

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:12

Sorry, it's in telly production. Now be careful with your attempted insults or I'll spoil which two celebs wins the Traitors tonight!

Telly production? Lol. Euphemisms rule.

BlueLegume · 30/10/2026 19:13

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:11

So if his employer finds what he's wearing to be acceptable, then there's no issue?

His employer is most certainly worried he will sue them so they go down the weak management/DEI/bring your whole self to work route. As academics they will never, for the most part have ever worked in the real world.

alcovecupboards · 30/10/2026 19:13

Margaritaaahhh · 30/10/2026 18:59

For those wondering if latex breastplates and bodysuits are fetish wear and/or sex toys, other choice items on the website that I linked to which sells them also sells items such as these. Other websites are available, of course, but I've just run out of eye bleach so don't want to go looking at more of them.

I think that it's actually time to stop asking Alcove why she's defending this man. She's stated that she wouldn't hire him to tutor her daughter, so it's abundantly clear that however hard she appears to dig her heels in, she agrees with the consensus that this man is at best a creep, at worst a predator who engages in a sexual fetish at work without the consent of the women he encounters. Either way, she wouldn't want him near her daughter, which is very sensible and evidently she shares our concerns.

Now. Off to source more eye bleach and ironyometers.

No answer as to why you lied about this man's students then?