Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A Question of Science Podcast - how does biological sex affect health?

39 replies

CaveMum · 27/10/2026 21:58

Haven’t had a chance to listen to this yet, but the blurb sounds promising:

“Our biological sex affects every cell in our body, so how does it influence our health - from embryo development through to the risk of disease and diagnosis? How and why do some conditions affect females and males differently? And what can we do to ensure medicine is safe and effective for everyone, after decades of male biology bias?

Across autoimmune disorders, cancer, dementia, heart disease and even responses to everyday medications, sex‑based biological differences can shape who becomes ill, how symptoms appear and what treatments work.

Join our expert panel as they explore sex differences in biology, hormones and gene regulation.

Panel:
Prof Edith Heard, CEO of the Francis Crick Institute
Natasha Karp, Biostatistician at Astra Zeneca
Prof Petter Brodin, Garfield Weston chair of Neonatology and Professor of Paediatric Immunology, Imperial College, London
Caroline Criado Perez, Author of Invisible Women”

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/a-question-of-science/id1837162757?i=1000797381222

How does biological sex affect health?

How does biological sex affect health?

Podcast Episode · A Question of Science · 21 October · 46min · Video

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/how-does-biological-sex-affect-health/id1837162757?i=1000797381222

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 29/10/2026 17:20

HelpMeINeedWine · 29/10/2026 17:14

Will take a look, thanks. He had 5 days of IVIG in May, then had two Rituximab Infusions in July and is due to have them 6 monthly for the next 18-24 months.

Life has changed immensely for both of us so it's taking a lot of getting used to.

Anyway, thanks again and sorry for the derail.

Small comfort, I guess but at least he's on the biologics. I hope they work for him. I hope you have support too, it's tough on the partner when someone has a lifelong illness.

Seagulldancing · 29/10/2026 17:24

Imdunfer · 29/10/2026 08:49

MS is 4 times as likely to strike women as men because it's an autoimmune disease. The genes that regulate the immune system are on the X chromosome. Men have only one, women get a double dose.

Women have a stronger immune response than men because of this, and a stronger immune system is more likely to go rogue looking for something to attack.

I have rheumatoid arthritis and a woman is 8 times more likely than a man to have that. I hope you don't have MS?

Thats interesting. My family is rife with autoimmune issues, but oddly only in the men. That second X must be protecting the rest of us.

Imdunfer · 29/10/2026 17:44

Seagulldancing · 29/10/2026 17:24

Thats interesting. My family is rife with autoimmune issues, but oddly only in the men. That second X must be protecting the rest of us.

Well they are heritable, so maybe there's something problematic about the X's that your males are inheriting? Genes are very interesting in the way the exact same one can act differently in men and women. The same region of mutation on gene 15 produces either Prader Willi or Angelman's in the child, depending on whether the gene came from the father for the first or the mother for the second

ScrollingLeaves · 29/10/2026 19:11

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 09:37

Ive mot listened yet, but not everything is about trans people. They've got 45 minutes to cover a huge subject, I'd rather they didn't waste it on a tiny proportion of the population - many of whom aren't taking any hormones and so will be the same in their medical responses as any other member of their sex.

The introduction to the podcast is this:

"At the most basic level, sex is determined by our chromosomes. Two Xs for females, and an X and a Y for males. But as we'll hear, sex is broader than that. It refers to a set of biological attributes, including our hormonal levels, gene expression, and internal and external sex organs - all of which have implications for our health. Science has traditionally ignored the complexity of biological sex, with research and clinical trials largely focused on male biology. But we do know that females and males don't have the same susceptibility to disease, and respond differently to treatment."

Why would you refuse to listen to something that acknowledges that 8 times difference in your susceptibility simply because it may not cover a tiny group of other people who are irrelevant to the main argument and for whom there is barely any decent research?

a tiny group of other people who are irrelevant to the main argument

You would think so, so it is difficult to understand why a poster like this, even adorned with a rainbow, needs to be on the wall of a local hospital x ray waiting room regarding pregnancy.

Pregnancy status for X-ray examinations

We are legally obliged to rule out the possibility of pregnancy before we can proceed with certain examinations.

To maintain compliance with the lonising Radiation (Medical Exposure) Regulations 2017, Gender Recognition Act 2004 and the Equality Act 2010, we are obliged to ask ALL patients, aged between 11 and 55 years, who are undergoing X-ray examinations between the bottom of the chest and knees, their sex assigned at birth and determine their potential for pregnancy.

This includes individuals identifying as:

  • Non-binary
  • Transgender
  • Intersex
  • Gender non-conforming
  • Female
  • Male
Including those patients in same sex relationships, where one or both have childbearing capacity.

This information will not be recorded or shared without your consent.

*The Radiology directorate are committed to ensuring patients are free from discrimination regardless of their gender identity or sexual preference.

You would think that as a medical department at least they would not use the term ‘sex assigned at birth’ or suggest ‘male’ or ‘female’ are identities even though they had already listed ‘Transgender’.

A Question of Science Podcast - how does biological sex affect health?
MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 08:22

ScrollingLeaves · 29/10/2026 19:11

a tiny group of other people who are irrelevant to the main argument

You would think so, so it is difficult to understand why a poster like this, even adorned with a rainbow, needs to be on the wall of a local hospital x ray waiting room regarding pregnancy.

Pregnancy status for X-ray examinations

We are legally obliged to rule out the possibility of pregnancy before we can proceed with certain examinations.

To maintain compliance with the lonising Radiation (Medical Exposure) Regulations 2017, Gender Recognition Act 2004 and the Equality Act 2010, we are obliged to ask ALL patients, aged between 11 and 55 years, who are undergoing X-ray examinations between the bottom of the chest and knees, their sex assigned at birth and determine their potential for pregnancy.

This includes individuals identifying as:

  • Non-binary
  • Transgender
  • Intersex
  • Gender non-conforming
  • Female
  • Male
Including those patients in same sex relationships, where one or both have childbearing capacity.

This information will not be recorded or shared without your consent.

*The Radiology directorate are committed to ensuring patients are free from discrimination regardless of their gender identity or sexual preference.

You would think that as a medical department at least they would not use the term ‘sex assigned at birth’ or suggest ‘male’ or ‘female’ are identities even though they had already listed ‘Transgender’.

They are forewarning that they will ask everyone their birth sex so it's a trigger waring for the men in dresses.

SerendipityJane · 30/10/2026 10:26

This information will not be recorded or shared without your consent.

Not quite sure there is any point in expending resources on a procedure whose outcomes cannot be used. Unless it's for practice ?

(Although it seems rather redundant to announce results will not be recorded. I thought losing results was the NHS SOP ?)

ScrollingLeaves · 30/10/2026 12:20

I am not sure where the line between ‘Health’ as in the OP, and more general Child Safeguarding and mental and physical well-being can be drawn. But to me this is an interesting case where it seems Cafcass is not following the example of the NHS, or schools, which ( I believe) now say a person’s actual sex must be recorded.

I think the safeguarding of a child in social work necessitates knowing their sex. But this is about a CAFCASS officer in trouble for recording sex on documents, as also agreed with the child’s mother, instead of writing ‘they/them’ ( which they had used in relation to the child in person).

Telegraph Excerpt:
A social worker has claimed he was stripped of his role as a family's guardian after he refused to use "they/them" pronouns in official records.

Charles Plummer, a former family court adviser and social worker at the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service (Cafcass), said he had been removed from the position after a school and authority complained about how he had referred to a child in a case.

He said he had always used the child's preferred pronouns in person, but used "she/her" - rather than they/them - in written reports, because using the non-binary alternatives had made safeguarding documents "incomprehensible".

Mr Plummer, who resigned from Cafcass earlier this year, said: "Professional practice within child safeguarding requires clear, precise and non-ideological language."

He said he had spoken to the child's mother about it and that she had always been "entirely accepting of this and understood my reasoning".

I cannot link the following Telegraph and Times articles but the GB news link gives the gist of the matter, including Cafcass’s point of view.
…………………………………….

Social worker removed from case for refusing to use they/them pronouns
The Telegraph

“Social worker to sue over removal from case after pronoun row”
The former social worker claims he was discriminated against over his gender-critical views.” The Times

Social worker removed as family's guardian for 'refusing to use they/them pronouns'
“Charles Plummer was warned his use of she/her pronouns had caused 'clear reputational damage' to Cafcass”
GB News
www.gbnews.com/news/trans-row-social-worker-removed-guardian-they-them-pronouns

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 30/10/2026 13:52

"caused 'clear reputational damage' to Cafcass"

Telling. Not harm to the child.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 30/10/2026 13:54

SerendipityJane · 30/10/2026 10:26

This information will not be recorded or shared without your consent.

Not quite sure there is any point in expending resources on a procedure whose outcomes cannot be used. Unless it's for practice ?

(Although it seems rather redundant to announce results will not be recorded. I thought losing results was the NHS SOP ?)

They can use the information to decide whether/how to carry out the imaging, without recording or sharing it.

SerendipityJane · 30/10/2026 14:16

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 30/10/2026 13:54

They can use the information to decide whether/how to carry out the imaging, without recording or sharing it.

I am amused at the subtleties of "recording", "sharing", and "using".

How can you use something not recorded - even if just as a memory ? And don't you have to "share" it with the machine ?

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 30/10/2026 15:29

No. The patient says 'I'm female', you then know to check for pregnancy before pushing the button. Or he says 'I'm male' and you push the button immediately. Or you put a protective shield over the appropriate part of the anatomy, depending how they answered. Or you use a different type of scan instead of an X-ray. The machine just gets a button press or no button press - no 'information'.

'Recording' means 'outside your own brain' - on paper or on a computer. 'Sharing' means 'with another person'. All perfectly standard uses of words.

ScrollingLeaves · 30/10/2026 17:51

The patient says 'I'm female', you then know to check for pregnancy
I can see that just possibly the sex of a transman or transwoman might not be clear to the nurses and radiologists. But surely they usually do not really need to ask.

The notice could say, “If you are transgender, please tell the nurse if you were born female, and your age. You would hope they’d usually also have this information in their patient notes.

WittyLimeBiscuit · 02/11/2026 09:45

MarieDeGournay · 28/10/2026 08:34

Thank you OP.
I think the very title How does biological sex affect health? is worthy of a small fist-pump and a quietly-spoke 'reeee-sult!'Smile

It assumes that there is such a thing as biological sex, and that it affects health.
The blurb states 'Our biological sex affects every cell in our body,'

Those are strong statements of sex realism. The kind of thing that people have been put through disciplinary processes for stating🙄

The content may not live up to it, but it looks factual and evidence-based and that's A Good Thing.

I was in the audience for this and thought it over promised and under delivered. Will be interested to hear what people think of the edited version.
Caroline Criado Perez made some good points. There was a woman on the panel who pushed the line that chromosomes are far more complicated than a binary XX / XY 😡

CaveMum · 02/11/2026 10:12

WittyLimeBiscuit · 02/11/2026 09:45

I was in the audience for this and thought it over promised and under delivered. Will be interested to hear what people think of the edited version.
Caroline Criado Perez made some good points. There was a woman on the panel who pushed the line that chromosomes are far more complicated than a binary XX / XY 😡

How good to hear from someone who was there. Will be interesting to know if you thought there were things left out of the broadcast.

I noted the scientist who tried the “it’s complicated” angle, but thought they didn’t dwell on it.

Were there any other audience questions that made you eye roll, other than the one from the self proclaimed He/Him

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread