Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

A Question of Science Podcast - how does biological sex affect health?

39 replies

CaveMum · 27/10/2026 21:58

Haven’t had a chance to listen to this yet, but the blurb sounds promising:

“Our biological sex affects every cell in our body, so how does it influence our health - from embryo development through to the risk of disease and diagnosis? How and why do some conditions affect females and males differently? And what can we do to ensure medicine is safe and effective for everyone, after decades of male biology bias?

Across autoimmune disorders, cancer, dementia, heart disease and even responses to everyday medications, sex‑based biological differences can shape who becomes ill, how symptoms appear and what treatments work.

Join our expert panel as they explore sex differences in biology, hormones and gene regulation.

Panel:
Prof Edith Heard, CEO of the Francis Crick Institute
Natasha Karp, Biostatistician at Astra Zeneca
Prof Petter Brodin, Garfield Weston chair of Neonatology and Professor of Paediatric Immunology, Imperial College, London
Caroline Criado Perez, Author of Invisible Women”

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/a-question-of-science/id1837162757?i=1000797381222

How does biological sex affect health?

How does biological sex affect health?

Podcast Episode · A Question of Science · 21 October · 46min · Video

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/how-does-biological-sex-affect-health/id1837162757?i=1000797381222

OP posts:
CaveMum · 29/10/2026 08:32

Glad others found it interesting. I did get round to listening to it and thought it was mostly very good. Bit disappointing to hear one of the scientists say that it was not as simple as XX = female and XY = male, but I suppose you could argue that that’s true if you account for DSD, but they should have said that the number affected is vanishingly small.

The he/him question was also pretty clumsy but I thought the answer was sensible - not enough research - and they quickly moved on.

It would be interesting to know if there was anything that didn’t make the edit, but that need someone who was there live.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 28/10/2026 11:36

Be nice to know why MS is three to four as likely to strike women as men.

I have this on my bottom-of-the-playlist. .. I hope to get round to it.

(Was disappointed in a recent The Rest is Science to hear them crowbar "gender" where "sex" was the scientifically correct term ...)

Shortshriftandlethal · 28/10/2026 09:49

It is fascinating why women suffering a heart attack often have different symptoms or warning signs to men. I wonder why? For example, stomach pain is often a symptom of a heart attack in a woman, but not in a man.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 09:37

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 07:19

When you've listened to it, can you tell us if it distinguishes between differences which are removed by cross sex hormones and which are not hormone moderated? If they do I will listen to it, though I don't really like podcasts.

I sit here with a red throbbing thumb because as a person with 2 X chromosomes (called " a woman") I am 8 times more likely to have autoimmune arthritis and no amount of trans treatments will give someone born male that risk.

Edited

Ive mot listened yet, but not everything is about trans people. They've got 45 minutes to cover a huge subject, I'd rather they didn't waste it on a tiny proportion of the population - many of whom aren't taking any hormones and so will be the same in their medical responses as any other member of their sex.

The introduction to the podcast is this:

"At the most basic level, sex is determined by our chromosomes. Two Xs for females, and an X and a Y for males. But as we'll hear, sex is broader than that. It refers to a set of biological attributes, including our hormonal levels, gene expression, and internal and external sex organs - all of which have implications for our health. Science has traditionally ignored the complexity of biological sex, with research and clinical trials largely focused on male biology. But we do know that females and males don't have the same susceptibility to disease, and respond differently to treatment."

Why would you refuse to listen to something that acknowledges that 8 times difference in your susceptibility simply because it may not cover a tiny group of other people who are irrelevant to the main argument and for whom there is barely any decent research?

ItsCoolForCats · 28/10/2026 09:37

MrsOvertonsWindow · 28/10/2026 08:53

Isn't it pleasing to see the shift to accurate reporting in the media. Not there yet, but the BBC are finally making efforts to report accurately.

Sad that the bar is so low but small steps and all that.
Will give it a listen later today.

It's crazy, isn't it. I haven't listened to the podcast yet, but what is said in the blurb is so... uncontroversial. Yes, just a year or two ago, there would have been people at the BBC (successfully) censoring this type of content. How did we ever get to a point that talking about biological sex was considered a dog whistle?

Neversofaraway · 28/10/2026 09:37

Interesting programme, it really stressed the differences between the sexes. I hope the questioner who introduced himself as he/him learned something.

RoyalCorgi · 28/10/2026 09:15

Very pleased to see the BBC covering this. Quite an acknowledgement from them. Criado Perez's book Invisible Women was brilliant.

And surely it's significant that it's Brian Cox - we know that his wife, Gia Milinovich, is gender-critical, and there has been a suggestion that the mutual antipathy between her and Robin Ince played a part in Ince being dropped from The Infinite Monkey Cage.

Anyway, whatever the background, it seems that Cox is taking a firm stand on the reality and importance of biological sex. Hurrah for him.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 28/10/2026 08:53

MarieDeGournay · 28/10/2026 08:34

Thank you OP.
I think the very title How does biological sex affect health? is worthy of a small fist-pump and a quietly-spoke 'reeee-sult!'Smile

It assumes that there is such a thing as biological sex, and that it affects health.
The blurb states 'Our biological sex affects every cell in our body,'

Those are strong statements of sex realism. The kind of thing that people have been put through disciplinary processes for stating🙄

The content may not live up to it, but it looks factual and evidence-based and that's A Good Thing.

Isn't it pleasing to see the shift to accurate reporting in the media. Not there yet, but the BBC are finally making efforts to report accurately.

Sad that the bar is so low but small steps and all that.
Will give it a listen later today.

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 08:48

MarieDeGournay · 28/10/2026 08:34

Thank you OP.
I think the very title How does biological sex affect health? is worthy of a small fist-pump and a quietly-spoke 'reeee-sult!'Smile

It assumes that there is such a thing as biological sex, and that it affects health.
The blurb states 'Our biological sex affects every cell in our body,'

Those are strong statements of sex realism. The kind of thing that people have been put through disciplinary processes for stating🙄

The content may not live up to it, but it looks factual and evidence-based and that's A Good Thing.

You're absolutely right there. Would it even have been made before the SC ruling? It's a great step forward.

MarieDeGournay · 28/10/2026 08:34

Thank you OP.
I think the very title How does biological sex affect health? is worthy of a small fist-pump and a quietly-spoke 'reeee-sult!'Smile

It assumes that there is such a thing as biological sex, and that it affects health.
The blurb states 'Our biological sex affects every cell in our body,'

Those are strong statements of sex realism. The kind of thing that people have been put through disciplinary processes for stating🙄

The content may not live up to it, but it looks factual and evidence-based and that's A Good Thing.

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 07:19

When you've listened to it, can you tell us if it distinguishes between differences which are removed by cross sex hormones and which are not hormone moderated? If they do I will listen to it, though I don't really like podcasts.

I sit here with a red throbbing thumb because as a person with 2 X chromosomes (called " a woman") I am 8 times more likely to have autoimmune arthritis and no amount of trans treatments will give someone born male that risk.

ItsCoolForCats · 28/10/2026 07:17

Thanks OP. It has Caroline Criado Perez on the panel, so it should be good.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 28/10/2026 06:59

It sounds promising, although the Prof is from Imperial College London, a captured institute, so we'll see.

Dutchhouse14 · 28/10/2026 06:39

Thanks OP looks really interesting, about to listen to it