Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral Evidence 29/10/27, 12.15pm

563 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 26/10/2026 11:15

This will be worth watching on Thursday. It will be on Parliament TV.

(Image incoming)

Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral Evidence 29/10/27, 12.15pm
OP posts:
Thread gallery
30
TwoLoonsAndASprout · 08/11/2026 12:06

OhBuggerandArse · 08/11/2026 09:52

Meanwhile in Scotland... (trying to get an archive link for this but not working so far - if anyone else can would be really grateful for a share)

https://www.thenational.scot/news/26707296.groups-already-mobilising-scotlands-conversion-practices-ban/

Archive for you (and all):

https://archive.ph/mkE6c

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 08/11/2026 08:10

Igneococcus · 08/11/2026 07:17

Thank you for this. Good to see it in The Times as well.

But what this bill proves most of all is, as long as there are politicians who outsource their thinking to activists so they never have to make their own decisions, and who prioritise buzzwords over proper understanding, then gender ideology will never die.

We need more politicians like Tonia Antoniazzi, who think for themselves and speak with their conscience. In short, public servants, which is what most politicians used to be, or at least try to be.

Most of them now (Andy and Bridget, looking at you) wouldn't understand moral probity if it smacked them in the face.

ArabellaScott · 08/11/2026 07:49

Its good to see Labour MPs talk out against the Bill, but concerning that this may not be enough.

I know I keep harping on about Scottish Bills, but we saw opposition to the GRR ignored- even sensible amendments like 'dont put rapists in womens jails'.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 22:52

impossibletoday · 07/11/2026 21:48

Labour MPs urge Burnham to scrap trans bill

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/667f405142aa53f7

That's real progress - presumably labour MPs are embarrassed that such an indefensible bill's been produced in their name.

As @BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp points out upthread, there are some involved in this who evidently have "the goal... to disrupt safeguarding, whoever is providing that, and destabilize society in such a way that children can become easy targets for predators".

If you don't want to be seen as predators, leave children alone. Stop trying to criminalise parents. Don't write draft legislation that doesn't distinguish beteen children and adults. The last decade has seen a relentless assault on children and their right to grow up free from indoctrination from all manner of sources. It needs to stop.

ArabellaScott · 07/11/2026 22:14

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 07/11/2026 14:37

It sounds like a way to coercively control others - which is a central tenet of TRA ideology - make them walk on eggshells, fearful to say anything. Do they really think this will improve anyone's life, if everyone is scared to talk to the individual? It really is the Lives of Others in real life.

As Tanya DeG has pointed out on the this isn't working podcast, employers would be mad to invite anyone would could use this criminal coercive control route into their business.

employers would be mad to invite anyone would could use this criminal coercive control route into their business.

Anybody could use it if the definitions are loose enough.

This was the same with the Scottish Hate Crime Bill. The problem was the absolute and total lack of definitions. Anyone can call anything abuse. If legislation isnt clearly enough written, it can become a tool to threaten and abuse - and as we've seen so many times, the process is the punishment, so its not just about the criminal threshold but the chilling effect that expands beyond.

ArabellaScott · 07/11/2026 22:09

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 06/11/2026 16:18

This is an aside: the Telegraph seems to really have the bit between its teeth on this. Does anyone know how are we to square that with the announcement that their new owners are apparently TWAW and that they are clearing their stables of all GC writers?

😱

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 07/11/2026 22:04

impossibletoday · 07/11/2026 21:48

Labour MPs urge Burnham to scrap trans bill

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/667f405142aa53f7

Archive link:

https://archive.ph/CiSDi

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 07/11/2026 15:43

I've always believed that, for some gender and queer theory activists, the goal has always been to disrupt safeguarding, whoever is providing that, and destabilize society in such a way that children can become easy targets for predators. There will be some of those activists hard at work on this Bill right now.

Just think: if these powerful activists had actual problems that they needed to deal with, they wouldn't have any bandwidth or spare time left to manufacture ways to destabilize society. I'm talking about the wealthy, powerful, and privileged here, not (often) the vulnerable and weak minions that they use for their own purposes. Some of these privileged, evil people will be contributors and enablers of this Bill.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 07/11/2026 15:29

Wishesandhorses · 07/11/2026 13:55

I'm also concerned that the bill, if I've understood correctly, seems to judge someone's actions on the effect they have on someone else. This would mean that we would need to judge someone's mental state accurately before saying anything that they might not like. Many of us with trans-identifying friends and relatives already walk on eggshells because disagreement is framed as attacking their very identities.

This. The number of gendered people with Autism is also relevant.

Those of us with teen loved ones with Autism experience the difficulties with perceiving the motives of others including family members, literal comprehension of something innocent that was said which turns it in their mind to something concerning, and/or black and white thinking, impulse control, difficulty perceiving the equality of others, and many other executive function needs. Disclosures to police or social services when someone has annoyed them or thwarted them isn't an unknown thing, and they can believe wholeheartedly in the injustice or what they thought happened, or it can be intentionally false to punish the person they perceive as having transgressed against them.

Would they push this button on a friend, a sibling, a younger child, a parent when angered? Yes. If it was an option, absolutely. And no evidence is needed, no proof of intent on the part of the other person, that the accuser merely has to be clear they were upset.

Yes, they very likely were. Sincerely. And need help with that. Destroying their family and friendships, is probably not the way though. Or making people afraid to be near them, as again, those of us with those loved ones know, some days a sibling or parent existing, breathing, and just being a safe target for other frustrations is enough. This will move from police/social services knowing a person is given to making such disclosures, checking their safety and then everyone moving on (and parents where possible more closely supervising phone/internet use, and that's hard enough), to having to just get straight on with criminal procedings.

Why is it that no one's needs, feelings, perceptions or anything else is relevant in comparison with the person claiming a gender identity? Why is this always about an attempt to escape from other people being permitted rights and equality too?

True fact - I once called childline as a child because my parents wouldn't do something I wanted them to do or let me do something I wanted to or were telling me I needed to do something I didn't want to. I can't actually remember what it was, it might have been their request that I tidy my room. The kindly person on the other end asked me about my (comfortable, well cared for) life and gently challenged my suggestion that my parents setting boundaries was abusive. We had a long chat. It was nice. It made me think, in a good way, about things and about how lucky I was.

Presumably under this legislation that kindly person would now be sent to the gulag and my parents prosecuted.

I really had very emotional mood swings during puberty (DD2 is a lot like me and I've seen it coming already with her) where things just seemed really really awful all at once for no obvious reason and I would cast around for a reason. Obviously the reason was 'hormones' but there you are, that doesn't involve someone to blame, does it? Blaming evolution and biological reality is a bit underwhelming.

So grateful I didn't end up in care and being raped by men in grooming gangs because I called childline on my parents. It's so upside down, you've got to wonder what the motivations are of the people behind this as it flies in the face of all knowledge of child development, child safety and healthy relationships.

At this rate the safest thing will be never to speak to anyone, ever. Is that the intent? We can only ever voice approved opinions from Big Brother?

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 07/11/2026 14:37

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 13:26

I'm also concerned that the bill, if I've understood correctly, seems to judge someone's actions on the effect they have on someone else. This would mean that we would need to judge someone's mental state accurately before saying anything that they might not like. Many of us with trans-identifying friends and relatives already walk on eggshells because disagreement is framed as attacking their very identities.

Identity is an interesting word. It used to be that identity was recognised as being formed out of many aspects of one's life and interests. So you could be a gay French cyclist who loves reading, or a Muslim connoisseur of French cuisine, each of which examples would include many other facets of interests and personality and background. Making one thing the defining identity is a new concept to me. It's another cult-like aspect of 'progressive' thinking, which seems at odds with the concept of 'intersectionality' (as popularised, not as the initial insight into how aspects of identity can interact).

It sounds like a way to coercively control others - which is a central tenet of TRA ideology - make them walk on eggshells, fearful to say anything. Do they really think this will improve anyone's life, if everyone is scared to talk to the individual? It really is the Lives of Others in real life.

As Tanya DeG has pointed out on the this isn't working podcast, employers would be mad to invite anyone would could use this criminal coercive control route into their business.

Wishesandhorses · 07/11/2026 13:55

I'm also concerned that the bill, if I've understood correctly, seems to judge someone's actions on the effect they have on someone else. This would mean that we would need to judge someone's mental state accurately before saying anything that they might not like. Many of us with trans-identifying friends and relatives already walk on eggshells because disagreement is framed as attacking their very identities.

This. The number of gendered people with Autism is also relevant.

Those of us with teen loved ones with Autism experience the difficulties with perceiving the motives of others including family members, literal comprehension of something innocent that was said which turns it in their mind to something concerning, and/or black and white thinking, impulse control, difficulty perceiving the equality of others, and many other executive function needs. Disclosures to police or social services when someone has annoyed them or thwarted them isn't an unknown thing, and they can believe wholeheartedly in the injustice or what they thought happened, or it can be intentionally false to punish the person they perceive as having transgressed against them.

Would they push this button on a friend, a sibling, a younger child, a parent when angered? Yes. If it was an option, absolutely. And no evidence is needed, no proof of intent on the part of the other person, that the accuser merely has to be clear they were upset.

Yes, they very likely were. Sincerely. And need help with that. Destroying their family and friendships, is probably not the way though. Or making people afraid to be near them, as again, those of us with those loved ones know, some days a sibling or parent existing, breathing, and just being a safe target for other frustrations is enough. This will move from police/social services knowing a person is given to making such disclosures, checking their safety and then everyone moving on (and parents where possible more closely supervising phone/internet use, and that's hard enough), to having to just get straight on with criminal procedings.

Why is it that no one's needs, feelings, perceptions or anything else is relevant in comparison with the person claiming a gender identity? Why is this always about an attempt to escape from other people being permitted rights and equality too?

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 13:26

I'm also concerned that the bill, if I've understood correctly, seems to judge someone's actions on the effect they have on someone else. This would mean that we would need to judge someone's mental state accurately before saying anything that they might not like. Many of us with trans-identifying friends and relatives already walk on eggshells because disagreement is framed as attacking their very identities.

Identity is an interesting word. It used to be that identity was recognised as being formed out of many aspects of one's life and interests. So you could be a gay French cyclist who loves reading, or a Muslim connoisseur of French cuisine, each of which examples would include many other facets of interests and personality and background. Making one thing the defining identity is a new concept to me. It's another cult-like aspect of 'progressive' thinking, which seems at odds with the concept of 'intersectionality' (as popularised, not as the initial insight into how aspects of identity can interact).

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 07/11/2026 12:42

I think there is a big difference between prayer asking for someone, in their presence, to be straight or gay or to have a particular understanding of gender, and prayer asking for someone, in their presence, for help to work out their understanding of themselves and to find a good way forward. Jayne Ozanne seems to have experienced the former, and so I can understand where she is coming from.

I have concerns about what should be criminalised. Existing law, mainstream Christian ethics and societal pressure already make the former scenario one that many churches avoid. Those fundamentalist churches and sects that exercise a lot of control over their members do so in other areas as well. I would like all churches to respect everyone's right to "work out their own salvation" (Philippians 2:12) rather than try to control them, but the State telling churches what their positions have to be is in itself controlling behaviour.

Wishesandhorses · 07/11/2026 12:38

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 07/11/2026 08:00

Thank you, another excellent article. This particularly struck me:

"But before we even get into the many reasons why this latest loony trans legislation should be scrapped, can we establish a few home truths that appear to have been lost in this increasingly perverse debate? We are now having to enter into debates about whether a parent should be jailed for questioning whether their child can <a class="break-all" href="https://archive.ph/o/gK7n9/www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/20/rye-college-children-neo-pronouns-cats-moons-rishi-sunak/" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">self-identify as a cat"

.... we are living in a country that is broke, where people are afraid to put the heating on this winter, where we're under threat of war to the point the govt are actively messaging the public to prepare -

and our paid electives are actually spending time writing, tabling and sitting in the HoC discussing this stuff.

Can anyone seriously imagine the reaction of the ministers of this country prior to 2012 if they were asked to devote attention and government time and resources to this?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 11:41

Rightsraptor · 07/11/2026 08:30

They may have claimed religious support but that tide is turning. Both the CoE and the RC churches are now speaking out against this Bill (read in the online Telegraph yesterday).

So pleased the DT is waging war against this

We know from experience that children and families have been targeted by transactivists for years. The fact the churches (with a history of pandering to the trans lobby) have finally seen the reality is important.

Rightsraptor · 07/11/2026 08:30

They may have claimed religious support but that tide is turning. Both the CoE and the RC churches are now speaking out against this Bill (read in the online Telegraph yesterday).

So pleased the DT is waging war against this

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 07/11/2026 08:25

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 07/11/2026 08:00

It’s a complete breach of societal norms.

I, and many others here, could have written this article, word for word.

This week I was sent the “gender identity and gender questioning” policy of a primary school in Leeds, which stated: “There is a spectrum of gender which is wider than just boy/man or girl/woman.”

It goes on to suggest that: “School staff should not disclose information that may reveal a child or young person’s gender questioning status or gender non-conforming presentation to others, including parents/carers and other members of the school community unless legally required to do so or because the child or parent/carer has given permission for them to do so.”

I'm pretty sure this kind of activity by the school is unlawful, according to KCSIE. Someone with more knowledge of this can no doubt confirm?

Trans identification remained a fringe phenomenon among children until the advent of the smartphone.

This 100%.

As ever, the <a class="break-all" href="https://archive.ph/o/gK7n9/www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/05/stonewall-trans-helped-draft-law/" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">fingerprints of organisations like Stonewall are all over this latest madness, having been allowed to exert a disproportionate institutional influence over government, education and the media for years.

I'm glad The Telegraph are all over this. It may not be enough, but it can't but help.

ps. sorry, don't know what happened with the Telegraph's own link above.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 08:22

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 07/11/2026 07:59

More from the Telegraph - note, in this article it states outright that the paper is campaigning against the bill:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/06/trans-law-risks-criminalising-prayer-says-church/

https://archive.ph/drTVq

Good to see opposition mounting. Notewarthy that the "Cabinet Office spokesperson (possibly the highly paid transactivist appointed to wedge all this into the heart of government) repeats that "our draft bill has already been welcomed by religious groups"
He may be talking the endless self absorbed utterances from Jayne Ozanne. They always contain countless personal anecdotes that - grim as they are - should not give her the power to to influence draconian legislation that negatively impacts children and families.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 07/11/2026 08:00

And more in the Telegraph, from Camilla Tominey:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/06/id-rather-go-to-prison-than-accept-labours-trans-lies/

https://archive.ph/gK7n9

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 07/11/2026 07:59

More from the Telegraph - note, in this article it states outright that the paper is campaigning against the bill:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/06/trans-law-risks-criminalising-prayer-says-church/

https://archive.ph/drTVq

AnotherAngryAcademic · 06/11/2026 16:26

I've seen a post on Facebook by a journalist called Sadie Nicholas who is looking for a mum worried about this bill for an (anonymous) interview. I don't think I can post the details here - pretty sure would be against mumsnet rules - but if anyone is interested in contacting her, the post is in an open Facebook group run by her and Jill Foster called "FeatureMe! UK".

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 06/11/2026 16:18

This is an aside: the Telegraph seems to really have the bit between its teeth on this. Does anyone know how are we to square that with the announcement that their new owners are apparently TWAW and that they are clearing their stables of all GC writers?