Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral Evidence 29/10/27, 12.15pm

563 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 26/10/2026 11:15

This will be worth watching on Thursday. It will be on Parliament TV.

(Image incoming)

Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral Evidence 29/10/27, 12.15pm
OP posts:
Thread gallery
30
ArabellaScott · Yesterday 19:12

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 18:08

I've been wondering if Andy is just waiting for the consultation to finish before he says that it's clear the Bill needs more work, and then spend the next few years until 2029 pretending that he never heard of it before?

(she says optimistically)

I wonder if he'll even go near it. I get the distinct impression that he is unwilling to get even tangentially involved. He doesn't want to do a Starmer women with penises thing, nor does he want to catch terf cooties.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 19:10

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 19:00

The abuse they have already given her is pretty clearly behind her assertion that the bill would be used by those with malicious intent. Lovely bit of shadenfreude.

Yes, it was interesting to hear her explicitly make the point about malicious actors.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 19:03

Just had a thought: if the Bill becomes law, would that scupper the puberty blocker trial? Surely, giving children drugs to stop them growing up would be a form of conversion?

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 19:00

borntobequiet · Yesterday 18:33

I hope Baroness Cass doesn’t get further abuse from the TRAs over this, but expect she will, sadly.

The abuse they have already given her is pretty clearly behind her assertion that the bill would be used by those with malicious intent. Lovely bit of shadenfreude.

borntobequiet · Yesterday 18:33

I hope Baroness Cass doesn’t get further abuse from the TRAs over this, but expect she will, sadly.

borntobequiet · Yesterday 18:33

I hope Baroness Cass doesn’t get further abuse from the TRAs over this, but expect she will, sadly.

Thingybob · Yesterday 18:29

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 18:15

I know the deadline for evidence is today, but are the panels also finished now? That was the last one today?

No at least 3 more, next is on Thursday at 11:20.

Signalbox · Yesterday 18:17

Well this was a happy end to the committee stage. I was expecting so much less criticism. Surely they can’t go forward with this now in its current form.

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 18:15

I know the deadline for evidence is today, but are the panels also finished now? That was the last one today?

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 18:08

I've been wondering if Andy is just waiting for the consultation to finish before he says that it's clear the Bill needs more work, and then spend the next few years until 2029 pretending that he never heard of it before?

(she says optimistically)

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 18:05

That seems like the best news so far re this stupid Bill.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 17:49

Furthermore she said she’s been thinking of a way to legislate against this type of abuse for some years and hasn’t yet been able to come up with wording that won’t have a chilling effect that will harm the very children the bill aims to protect and be at risk of vexatious reports

Oh good for her! Brilliant to have this point come from someone with her influence.

Theeyeballsinthesky · Yesterday 17:31

I am very pleasantly surprised and relived by baroness cass evidence to the committee

Cantunseeit · Yesterday 17:18

Wow! That was better than expected! I mean she more or less said put your draft in the bin.

Furthermore she said she’s been thinking of a way to legislate against this type of abuse for some years and hasn’t yet been able to come up with wording that won’t have a chilling effect that will harm the very children the bill aims to protect and be at risk of vexatious reports

Obviously I am paraphrasing v broadly.

They kept asking specific questions about how the wording could be tweaked so she’d support it and I kept expecting/wanting her to say “well I wouldn’t start from here”!

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 17:18

“I unfortunately don’t think the definitions are anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.” A strong opening from Baroness Hilary Cass on the risks posed by the Conversion Practices Bill for healthcare professionals, parents and vulnerable young people. She warns that “malign actors” may weaponise the Bill, and explains that the approach in the #CassReview has already been described as “conversion practices”.

X - The Everything App

https://x.com/i/jf/onboarding/web?redirect_after_login=%2Fhashtag%2FCassReview%3Fsrc%3Dhashtag_click&mode=login

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 17:17

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:09

I would be happy to interpret this as “because these issues are difficult to discuss, you need to assume that both parties will be upset by the discussion. This does not mean that the discussion should not happen.”

If this is indeed what Cass is saying, she has shifted infinitesimally closer to sanity in my estimation.

Edited

that's what I took from the clip, yep

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 17:17

Well that's a relief. And it's satisfying to see her pointing out Olivia Bailey's incompetence in public.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 17:13

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:09

I would be happy to interpret this as “because these issues are difficult to discuss, you need to assume that both parties will be upset by the discussion. This does not mean that the discussion should not happen.”

If this is indeed what Cass is saying, she has shifted infinitesimally closer to sanity in my estimation.

Edited

If this is indeed what she means by "difficult" then I wish she would just say that. Her ambivalence is doing my head in.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:09

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 17:06

After the decade we've all had, we're going to need a new dictionary definition of "difficult" that doesn't imply something that I just don't wanna do even if I'm required to do it.

I would be happy to interpret this as “because these issues are difficult to discuss, you need to assume that both parties will be upset by the discussion. This does not mean that the discussion should not happen.”

If this is indeed what Cass is saying, she has shifted infinitesimally closer to sanity in my estimation.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 17:06

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 17:01

Professor Gillian Leng, President, Royal Society of Medicine
and Hillary Cass both say these issues are 'intrinsically difficult to discuss'

After the decade we've all had, we're going to need a new dictionary definition of "difficult" that doesn't imply something that I just don't wanna do even if I'm required to do it.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 17:01

Professor Gillian Leng, President, Royal Society of Medicine
and Hillary Cass both say these issues are 'intrinsically difficult to discuss'

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 16:57

There are three minutes left, wims, time yet!

Thingybob · Yesterday 16:57

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 16:55

On our side or on the other side?

Our side

Question: Do you support the draft bill in its current form?

Cass "NO"