Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral Evidence 29/10/27, 12.15pm

563 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 26/10/2026 11:15

This will be worth watching on Thursday. It will be on Parliament TV.

(Image incoming)

Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral Evidence 29/10/27, 12.15pm
OP posts:
Thread gallery
30
ArabellaScott · 30/10/2026 07:02

nicepotoftea · 30/10/2026 06:51

I suspect that many Labour politicians know the bill is flawed, but it was in the manifesto as a compromise because they didn’t want to tie themselves to self ID.

Because it was in the manifesto and because too many MPs won’t be paying attention, I fear that it will pass, but it’s a gift to Badenoch.

Possibly, in the long run. But it will take time to enact and the consequences will play out.

In its vagueness and potential impact it reminds me of the Scottish Hate Crime Bill. No definition of 'abuse'. A tool that can be used and misused by anyone. And of course, the process is the punishment. A parent accused of 'conversion' may risk losing their children.

nicepotoftea · 30/10/2026 06:51

Olderbadger1 · 29/10/2026 18:45

I realise that there's huge pressure on Burnham & co to push this Bill through, and that I'd be naive to assume that evidence & expertise will make any difference but that was SO cheering from our side. The eloquence, clarity, specificity, was inspiring. And the response to the human rights legislation question was a masterclass in the idiot's guide to unintended consequences. Don't know if Helen ever dips her toes into the FSG threads but, if you do Helen...
THANY YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!

I suspect that many Labour politicians know the bill is flawed, but it was in the manifesto as a compromise because they didn’t want to tie themselves to self ID.

Because it was in the manifesto and because too many MPs won’t be paying attention, I fear that it will pass, but it’s a gift to Badenoch.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 30/10/2026 06:02

So it's rigged, who'd have thunk. The performance of democracy, superficial and meaningless, just like the performance of 'woman'.
Thanks to RD for continuing to shine the light on the disrespect of parliament that is the hallmark of Liebour.

TheSandgroper · 30/10/2026 05:32

Another oral session on Monday. I can’t see who will be presenting.

https://committees.parliament.uk/event/28607/formal-meeting-oral-evidence-session/

KittyWilkinson · 30/10/2026 05:22

Thanks so much for the additional comprehensive posts. Really depressing reading. I'm a former Labour Party member and familiar with the almost Stalinist rigging of these things.

A quorum of 2 and Barros-Curtis as Chair. What could possibly go wrong?

It's depressing as hell, but we've got to keep exposing this lack of safeguarding for young people. Rosie Duffield is tenacious in not being cowed and is an inspiration.

VeryConcernedDad · 30/10/2026 03:37

If anyone expects justice for children, parents and therapists from the current Conversion Practices Bill, read thisfrom MP Rosie Duffield:
_
I want you all to know this. There are 650 MPs in Parliament. Yet the one MP chosen by
@UKLabour
to Chair the Bill Committee for the controversial, dangerous and dismally bad draft legislation, the Conversion Practices Bill, is Alex Barros-Curtis. Until July 2024, when Alex was given a very safe Labour seat in Cardiff, he was the Head of the Labour Party's Governance and Legal Unit in London. This was a department set up to investigate complaints against members of the Labour Party. Complaints of antisemitism, Islamophobia, abuse, and of course latterly, mostly women holding legally-protected 'Gender Critical' (sex realist) beliefs. Alex oversaw the investigation of hundreds of members who liked or tweeted gender critical or feminist views. I was one of them. He investigated me, as a sitting Labour MP, for 13 months. 13 months to 'investigate' one like of one tweet. I had a great lawyer, one of the names we're all now familiar with, and I had to crowdfund to pay for his (excellent) work. They first tried in 2020. But the screenshots crudely attached to that passive aggressive, threatening-sounding email from LP admin staff were so risible that I replied that it was too ridiculous for me to waste my precious time on. They left it. Years of Starmer bumbling and stuttering through interviews about whether he had spoken to me, whether he supported me, etc followed. My feminist sins continued apace. And then I 'liked' a tweet by my GC comedian friend
@Glinner
. He had mocked Eddie'Suzy' for comparing his choice to wear traditional women's clothing, fake plastic breasts and nails, to those being persecuted by the Nazis during WWII. I found his sarcasm, as a award-winning comedy writer in the face of such offensive narcissism amusing and so 'liked' it. I found it absurd and obscene that Izzard, an extremely privileged and wealthy man, who openly changed his 'gender' at will, should write himself into history falseley as someone who would have been oppressed due to a circumstance beyond his control. We all know the groups who were tortured, starved and killed... There is obviously more to my story, I will tell it all, it's just one chapter of the years of spiteful abusive and bullying practices meted out to me by the Labour Party managers. Not those who'd achieved office on merit, or even unexpectedly, but those in the club, often having failed to be elected themselves. So Barros-Curtis who we were repeatedly told led 'the many independent inquiries into women members and MPs like me, now often stands as a trans-rights activist on the Labour backbenches. He has also been gifted the role of Chair of this Committee and is a huge supporter of this Bill. And I am not a part of the Bill Committee, although plenty of TRA MPs are. Does that sound like the democratic scrutiny of legislation to you?
9:23 AM · 29 oct. 2026

The Labour Party

The Labour Party (@UKLabour) on X

Labour is the party of working people.

https://x.com/UKLabour

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 30/10/2026 03:13

On the quorum for the Committee - shockingly only TWO members need to be present for a quorum.

I don't know if that is normal but that is what it is for this Committee.

House of Commons Tuesday 8 September 2026 No. 39
Order Paper: Business Today & Future Business

7. Draft Conversion Practices Bill (Joint Committee)
No debate after 7.00pm (Standing Order No. 9(6))
Sir Alan Campbell
That this House concurs with the Lords Message of 1 September, that it is expedient that a Joint Committee of Lords and Commons be appointed to consider and report on the draft Conversion Practices Bill (CP 1604) presented to both Houses on 25 June.

That a Select Committee of six Members be appointed to join with a Committee appointed by the Lords to consider the draft Conversion Practices Bill.

That the Committee should report by 22 January 2027.
That the Committee shall have power—
(i) to send for persons, papers and records;
(ii) to sit notwithstanding any adjournment of the House;
(iii) to report from time to time;
(iv) to appoint specialist advisers; and
(v) to adjourn from place to place within the United Kingdom.

That the quorum of the Committee shall be two; and

That Olivia Bailey, Danny Beales, Feryal Clark, Samantha Dixon, Marie Goldman and Sir Jeremy Wright be members of the Committee.

https://commonsbusiness.parliament.uk/Document/106974/Pdf?subType=LargePrint

Maria Goldman is on the Committee (at least officially) because she is the LibDem Women & Equalities Spokesperson (and unofficially that pans out as the Trans Rights Spokesperson, as if the LibDems need one).

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe
"I understand they both (Lord Hope & Maria Goldman) have family members who identify as ‘trans’."

That's interesting. I had assumed that they didn't want to hear what the sane people had to say so that they could pretend it hadn't happened.

Perhaps they have family members who they are afraid might call them to account for their performance when faced with a panel of genocidal transphobic bigots? Or perhaps even for being in the same room as them?

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 30/10/2026 00:35

JanesLittleGirl · 29/10/2026 21:51

I'm sorry for not paying close attention to this thread but did the Greek guy actually suggest that the criminal standard of 'beyond reasonable doubt' should be replaced by the civil requirement of 'on the balance of probabilities'?

I really hope that I got this wrong. Otherwise, yer man is proposing a complete change to how criminal law should work.

Not in those words, but I'm also suspicious that's what he meant.

JanesLittleGirl · 29/10/2026 21:51

I'm sorry for not paying close attention to this thread but did the Greek guy actually suggest that the criminal standard of 'beyond reasonable doubt' should be replaced by the civil requirement of 'on the balance of probabilities'?

I really hope that I got this wrong. Otherwise, yer man is proposing a complete change to how criminal law should work.

borntobequiet · 29/10/2026 19:26

That was a surprisingly riveting watch, even the first panel’s repertoire of evasive, partial and obfusticatory answers to straightforward questions.

KittyWilkinson · 29/10/2026 18:49

Dennis Kavanagh, Helen Joyce and Dermot Kehoe were very clear in pointing out that the abusive practices referred to by the other side were already unlawful under existing criminal legislation. DK, in the very limited time they had, was very pointed about that.

Olderbadger1 · 29/10/2026 18:45

I realise that there's huge pressure on Burnham & co to push this Bill through, and that I'd be naive to assume that evidence & expertise will make any difference but that was SO cheering from our side. The eloquence, clarity, specificity, was inspiring. And the response to the human rights legislation question was a masterclass in the idiot's guide to unintended consequences. Don't know if Helen ever dips her toes into the FSG threads but, if you do Helen...
THANY YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!

wonder woman GIF
BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 29/10/2026 18:25

Thingybob · 29/10/2026 15:43

As far as I'm concerned that should be a declared interest

Definitely agree.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 29/10/2026 18:23

Stonewall has published online (27 October 2026):

https://www.stonewall.org.uk/news/help-make-abusive-conversion-practices-a-thing-of-the-past

Help make abusive conversion practices a thing of the past
^^
The Government published a draft Bill to ban conversion practices in June 2026, and the Bill is currently being scrutinised by a Joint Committee of MPs and Lords.
^^
On Monday 26th October the Joint Committee published a call for evidence, seeking views on how the draft Bill could be improved and how any issues in the current drafting of the Bill can be resolved.
^^
The deadline for submissions in Monday 16 November at 5PM. You can read more about the call for evidence here....

An arrow and text reading 'Stonewall'

Help make abusive conversion practices a thing of the past

On Monday 26th October the Joint Committee published a call for evidence, seeking views on how the draft Bill could be improved and how any issues in the…

https://www.stonewall.org.uk/news/help-make-abusive-conversion-practices-a-thing-of-the-past

Sammidge · 29/10/2026 18:22

Thingybob · 29/10/2026 15:43

As far as I'm concerned that should be a declared interest

Bloody right.

Wishesandhorses · 29/10/2026 18:22

nicepotoftea · 29/10/2026 17:55

I'm confused. Professor Ilias Trispiotis keeps saying 'it's a very high bar', but if the bar is so high, aren't we talking about actions that are already illegal?

That has been the point of DK and the Gay Mens Alliance since the first incarnation of this.

The Trojan Horse was caught with its trousers right down today. However we have many MPs stupid enough to wave it through.

nicepotoftea · 29/10/2026 17:55

I'm confused. Professor Ilias Trispiotis keeps saying 'it's a very high bar', but if the bar is so high, aren't we talking about actions that are already illegal?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 29/10/2026 17:43

What was so impressive was that unlike the supporters of the bill, DK etc were so clear. They've drilled down into detail - not just all the legal aspects but the human consequences for family life that this bill will impact on. How it will criminalise parenting, dismantle aspects of safeguarding and undermine parental rights / responsibilities.

Depressing to think that there are politicians who will dismiss this.

Justme56 · 29/10/2026 17:12

Not sure if the man at the back shaking his head has already been identified in the thread, but according to X he is Dr S Chelvan - Junior Barrister? LGBTQ activist who mainly deals with asylum law.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 29/10/2026 17:02

In theory it works both ways, but in practice we know how these sorts of things generally play out. I’m fully supportive of making the drafters aware of these unintended consequences though, see the current thread by TinselAngel about a trans widow perspective.

ProfPerformativeBewildermentOBE · 29/10/2026 16:53

I haven’t read the details of the bill but is it exclusive to conversion in the context of sexual orientation and gender?

Just wondering if there is a religious / proselytising element to it that could be considered alongside the GC belief / other WORIADS beliefs. E.g. a parent challenged by this could potentially turn it around to say they were being faced with ‘conversion tactics’ that challenge their protected beliefs.

Note - am thinking out loud, might be nonsense

Ereshkigalangcleg · 29/10/2026 16:51

KittyWilkinson · 29/10/2026 14:45

I don't think the second panel could have done any better. They were excellent.

Agree, so clear and engaged with all the questions in depth.

Wishesandhorses · 29/10/2026 16:43

Professionals could at least have a very carefully legally checked wording about how they absolutely do not fucking dare to ever get involved with a trans client are not experts on this very sensitive and special issue and therefore must refer all even possible gender issues to someone so qualified.

Parents will have no such escape.

Will the existence of anything that causes an uncomfy emotion in a special person instantly be prosecutable? Christmas lights? Women's spaces? FWR? JKR?

Wishesandhorses · 29/10/2026 16:40

Thanks all, catching up now.

My main takeaway really - this is a wish to make causing an uncomfortable emotion in someone who is claiming a gender identity to be a punishable offense.

With no definition or boundaries of any kind around what a non special person would have to do to be seen to be 'causing'. All motives irrelevant. And no evidence required. Which means even frantic indulgence of said special person at all times still may not save you.

Which renders it absolute farce, particularly when taken with the very obvious co morbidities, emotional issues, psychological and mental health issues etc involved.