Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

For which services is separate by "gender" appropriate?

269 replies

MyAmpleSheep · 25/10/2026 12:36

Assuming it to be compliant with all relevant legislation (which is another discussion), which public services make more (or enough) sense to separate by self-defined gender rather than by sex?

We are often told that segregating by sex is permissible but not the only way to split "men" and "women" and that it's proportionate and appropriate to split men-identifiers from women-identifiers in some services in "appropriate circumstances" or some other phrase.

What are those services, and what are the appropriate circumstances?

This is a question about services, so I'm explicitly not referring to what the EA2010 covers under associations. Social groups are not services, and they can already be split or made exclusive in a much wider range of ways; I'm not asking about them. Only about public services. For clarity it's probably best to avoid terminology like "single sex spaces" because it's easy to misunderstand whether a "space" is a service - or an association.

So - which services can appropriately be segregated as women+trans-identifying men (women+ "trans women") and men+trans-identifying women (men + "trans men")?

OP posts:
MyAmpleSheep · 28/10/2026 16:15

Manxexile · 28/10/2026 15:52

This ^

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

"Woman" and "female" when used to refer to humans (just like "man" and "male") can only refer to biological sex - nothing else.

If you were convinced gender existed the relevant words would be "feminine" and "masculine". eg feminine men and not transwomen

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

I agree, but it's worse than obfuscatory; it's deliberately deceptive. An analogy would be deciding that the word cat includes some kinds of dogs in order to escape that particular kind of dog being covered by the Dangerous Dogs Act, which doesn't anywhere define what a "dog" is.

Its purpose is not to confuse: it is deliberately to deceive.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 28/10/2026 16:28

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:44

I'm asking for examples of the call for them which is apparently so overwhelming very little evidence can be produced.

Late to the party on this one, and not clear how it's actually relevant to the point MyAmpleSheep was making, but investigations on London nightlife by both the BBC and Vice.com showed that venues were vetting people based on skin color, though normally a lot more subtly than an outright ban because, as court cases on discrimination against Travelers have shown, that's foolish if you don't want to get taken to court.

There's plenty of demand to keep, especially high cost, venues more white but the law being as it is, the methods owners use to try and achieve those aims are, like much hiring sex discrimination, fudged and not written into policies and procedures and rarely clearly stated in writing and so hard to prove.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 28/10/2026 18:52

MyAmpleSheep · 28/10/2026 16:15

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

I agree, but it's worse than obfuscatory; it's deliberately deceptive. An analogy would be deciding that the word cat includes some kinds of dogs in order to escape that particular kind of dog being covered by the Dangerous Dogs Act, which doesn't anywhere define what a "dog" is.

Its purpose is not to confuse: it is deliberately to deceive.

Even more so, it changes.

If they used “dogs” to mean “all dogs except St Bernards, and SOME but not all cats” it would be merely absurd, but at times they mean that, at times they mean “dogs”, and at other times they seem to mean “dogs, cats and a limited number of giraffes”. But they won’t say when.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 28/10/2026 19:09

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 28/10/2026 18:52

Even more so, it changes.

If they used “dogs” to mean “all dogs except St Bernards, and SOME but not all cats” it would be merely absurd, but at times they mean that, at times they mean “dogs”, and at other times they seem to mean “dogs, cats and a limited number of giraffes”. But they won’t say when.

They (well, a specific them) have only started doing this recently, probably as a result of having been presented with the simple but irrefutable point that half the human race is female so it's not unreasonable that we should have a name to refer to us collectively by.

Most Genderists want both Woman and Female to be used for gender, and no specific nouns for sex, only qualifiers (none of which alone recreate the classification of sex)

The original Feminist construction, gender critical as all actual Feminism is although at that point the term was not needed, was "Woman", "girl" and "female" for the actual sex, and "feminine" for gender constructs. Note there wasn't a noun for "a person who identifies as feminine" because we didn't conceived of gender as a thing you are, just a quality of things you did or were presented with.

"Woman", despite Genderist retconning, never meant "person of either sex who feels "woman" is the right name for them" until this political movement of Genderism started to promote it..

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 28/10/2026 19:21

Back when the first whispers of this whole insanity began to reach me, in the year 2000, I thought it not impossible that in certain specific contexts one could be regarded as ritually the other sex (as in a specific kind of performance of role).

The context was that I’d been living in a country where the heir to the throne was hugely unpopular, his sister massively popular, & most people hoped she could take the throne.

Bur not only had there never been a female monarch, aspects of the duties of the ruler were very symbolically male (as in fertilising the fields, annointing sacred phallic pillars, etc). After all, Elizabeth I seems to have conceptualised her rule as that of a “Prince”.

Thing is, almost nothing in our lives is ritually sexed. And sex doesn’t matter most of the time: but when it does, it really does.

(I should add that the son has since come to the throne, the very much beloved daughter lives abroad, & the king is quite unpopular with many, especially women…)

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 19:42

in certain specific contexts one could be regarded as ritually the other sex (as in a specific kind of performance of role)

Like Nefertiti etc al having false beards because the pharaoh always had a beard. Yes, it's a fudge - and better to fix the system and allow beardless pharaohs - but it can be a useful interim step in that type of context. And is quite different from this sort of thing.

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

Which I agree is just nonsense. It's an attempt to invert the structure and make 'female' a subset of 'woman'; whereas in reality 'woman' is a subset of 'female' - because girls are female, as are approximately half of giraffes and holly trees, and the majority of bees. And both terms exclude all men as potential subsets.

Awkwardisfunny · 28/10/2026 19:47

MeridaBrave · 25/10/2026 12:42

For me the only thing that needs to be segregated is gym changing room to the extent that there are no cubicles! Now given I am taking off all my clothes I think it needs to be by sex. I’m less bothered by hospital wards assuming fully dressed there will be male visitors so don’t see the big deal about male patients. Even shop changing rooms as long as locking doors and no way to use cameras to take photos under the wall etc then I don’t care.

What about male patients in shared hospital rooms when staying overnight?

I'd say any space where you don't want a camera: there shouldn't be a man, for safety reasons.

murasaki · 28/10/2026 19:50

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 19:42

in certain specific contexts one could be regarded as ritually the other sex (as in a specific kind of performance of role)

Like Nefertiti etc al having false beards because the pharaoh always had a beard. Yes, it's a fudge - and better to fix the system and allow beardless pharaohs - but it can be a useful interim step in that type of context. And is quite different from this sort of thing.

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

Which I agree is just nonsense. It's an attempt to invert the structure and make 'female' a subset of 'woman'; whereas in reality 'woman' is a subset of 'female' - because girls are female, as are approximately half of giraffes and holly trees, and the majority of bees. And both terms exclude all men as potential subsets.

Hatshepsut rather than Nefertiti?

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 19:52

Thank you, yes.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 19:53

I blame having just come out of a Pilates class, my brain and legs are both jellyfied.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 28/10/2026 20:02

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 19:42

in certain specific contexts one could be regarded as ritually the other sex (as in a specific kind of performance of role)

Like Nefertiti etc al having false beards because the pharaoh always had a beard. Yes, it's a fudge - and better to fix the system and allow beardless pharaohs - but it can be a useful interim step in that type of context. And is quite different from this sort of thing.

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

Which I agree is just nonsense. It's an attempt to invert the structure and make 'female' a subset of 'woman'; whereas in reality 'woman' is a subset of 'female' - because girls are female, as are approximately half of giraffes and holly trees, and the majority of bees. And both terms exclude all men as potential subsets.

Ironically that is what the GRA was supposed to be - a fudge to allow a person to hold an opposite sex role in certain state rituals and constructs like marriages, pre marriage being opened up to same sex couples.

The idea that the state allowing legal sex markers to change or society (at one stage) accepting a certain type of ritually feminised man into female spaces means state and society agree trans people ARE in some metaphysical way the opposite sex, changing what sex actually means for everybody, is a wild retcon.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 30/10/2026 18:11

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 28/10/2026 19:42

in certain specific contexts one could be regarded as ritually the other sex (as in a specific kind of performance of role)

Like Nefertiti etc al having false beards because the pharaoh always had a beard. Yes, it's a fudge - and better to fix the system and allow beardless pharaohs - but it can be a useful interim step in that type of context. And is quite different from this sort of thing.

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

Which I agree is just nonsense. It's an attempt to invert the structure and make 'female' a subset of 'woman'; whereas in reality 'woman' is a subset of 'female' - because girls are female, as are approximately half of giraffes and holly trees, and the majority of bees. And both terms exclude all men as potential subsets.

I was also thinking of the Roman Catholic priesthood, but it hasnt happened. I don't see them ordaining trans-identified women any time soon (I believe castrati were also forbidden ordination: as they say, you have to be able to be a father to be a Father…)

BeSpoonyTurtle · 02/11/2026 10:13

MyAmpleSheep · 28/10/2026 16:15

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

I agree, but it's worse than obfuscatory; it's deliberately deceptive. An analogy would be deciding that the word cat includes some kinds of dogs in order to escape that particular kind of dog being covered by the Dangerous Dogs Act, which doesn't anywhere define what a "dog" is.

Its purpose is not to confuse: it is deliberately to deceive.

It is, but as others have said, the attempt to sow confusion is entirely intentional.

totino · 02/11/2026 10:22

MyAmpleSheep · 28/10/2026 16:15

The TRA argument that "woman" and "female" are two entirely different concepts has always seemed to me to be obfuscatory sophistry.

I agree, but it's worse than obfuscatory; it's deliberately deceptive. An analogy would be deciding that the word cat includes some kinds of dogs in order to escape that particular kind of dog being covered by the Dangerous Dogs Act, which doesn't anywhere define what a "dog" is.

Its purpose is not to confuse: it is deliberately to deceive.

The female equivalent to a dog is also a dog.

Keeptoiletssafe · 02/11/2026 10:45

The internationally recognised pictograms for single sex spaces are defined as female, male and unisex.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 02/11/2026 11:15

totino · 02/11/2026 10:22

The female equivalent to a dog is also a dog.

In this case, dogs aren't bitches but bitches are dogs. Female dogs get a word to describe them apart from male dogs, and male dogs don't get the same courtesy. That's a peculiarity of language development. Dogs, whether male or female, don't as far as we know have gender identities! They don't demand different treatment on that basis.

To an extent, it used to be the case (and occasionally still is) that 'man' was the catchall equivalent of 'dog'. Because of the imbalance of power, women pointed out that this implied that man was the default human (note that we have a word that always encompasses both sexes of the species) and that this hid women from view and often failed to recognise their worth. I think the default for dogs being 'dog' possibly could have a similar effect, but with dogs there isn't the same societal devaluation of the female, so the effect is far smaller.

StealthTroublemaker · 02/11/2026 12:25

totino · 02/11/2026 10:22

The female equivalent to a dog is also a dog.

So why do we call female dogs bitches then? So if “woman” includes some males, what is the word to describe an adult human female?

nicepotoftea · 02/11/2026 15:56

totino · 02/11/2026 10:22

The female equivalent to a dog is also a dog.

Be careful if anyone sells you a puppy.

nicepotoftea · 02/11/2026 16:02

FlirtsWithRhinos · 28/10/2026 20:02

Ironically that is what the GRA was supposed to be - a fudge to allow a person to hold an opposite sex role in certain state rituals and constructs like marriages, pre marriage being opened up to same sex couples.

The idea that the state allowing legal sex markers to change or society (at one stage) accepting a certain type of ritually feminised man into female spaces means state and society agree trans people ARE in some metaphysical way the opposite sex, changing what sex actually means for everybody, is a wild retcon.

Ironically that is what the GRA was supposed to be - a fudge to allow a person to hold an opposite sex role in certain state rituals and constructs like marriages, pre marriage being opened up to same sex couples.

But drawing the line at theoretically allowing Lady Mary to use a GRC to inherit Downton, however potentially sincere her claim to be a man.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page