Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

For which services is separate by "gender" appropriate?

269 replies

MyAmpleSheep · 25/10/2026 12:36

Assuming it to be compliant with all relevant legislation (which is another discussion), which public services make more (or enough) sense to separate by self-defined gender rather than by sex?

We are often told that segregating by sex is permissible but not the only way to split "men" and "women" and that it's proportionate and appropriate to split men-identifiers from women-identifiers in some services in "appropriate circumstances" or some other phrase.

What are those services, and what are the appropriate circumstances?

This is a question about services, so I'm explicitly not referring to what the EA2010 covers under associations. Social groups are not services, and they can already be split or made exclusive in a much wider range of ways; I'm not asking about them. Only about public services. For clarity it's probably best to avoid terminology like "single sex spaces" because it's easy to misunderstand whether a "space" is a service - or an association.

So - which services can appropriately be segregated as women+trans-identifying men (women+ "trans women") and men+trans-identifying women (men + "trans men")?

OP posts:
alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:27

Shedmistress · 25/10/2026 17:21

Why would anyone wish to host a 'single gender' service or facility rather than just an 'mixed sex' one? What sort of service do you mean?

Because they wish to welcome trans women or trans men into their service alongside biological women or men.

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:26

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 17:21

You point was men and women have the same experiences and the same feelings of vulnerability?

My (very clear) point was that women and trans women can share the same experiences and feelings of vulnerability and it is nonsense to suggest they cannot.

Soontobe60 · 25/10/2026 17:26

Truinio · 25/10/2026 17:17

A book group is an association, which is treated differently to a service in the Equality Act. For a start, the exceptions are far wider ranging: an association can legally discriminate on all protected characteristics except race.

So does that mean the an association that was set up for, say, Black African asylum seekers would also have to include Iranian asylum seekers?

StealthTroublemaker · 25/10/2026 17:25

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 16:43

I recognise - as do many other people - that trans people exist. While a trans woman is male, she is not a 'man' in either thought or presentation. You may disagree - and I'm sure there will be screams of 'HE'S A MAN!!!!111' being typed out even more - but I'm trying to explain why I believe there's a difference. And again - before I'm accused of all manner of nonsense - I believe single sex spaces should mean single sex.

So what is the difference between a male with a trans identity and one without that makes one welcome according to you in female spaces and one not?

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 25/10/2026 17:24

Truinio · 25/10/2026 17:17

A book group is an association, which is treated differently to a service in the Equality Act. For a start, the exceptions are far wider ranging: an association can legally discriminate on all protected characteristics except race.

What if it were a book group offered by a Council-run library? Would that make it a service?

Shedmistress · 25/10/2026 17:21

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:15

As I've answered - any that wish to.

Why would anyone wish to host a 'single gender' service or facility rather than just an 'mixed sex' one? What sort of service do you mean?

nicepotoftea · 25/10/2026 17:21

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:20

So one example from 2024 shows 'quite a lot of call'? Interesting.

Sorry - so you think there isn't problem with racism in the UK?

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 17:21

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:18

No, I think they have shared the same horrifying experience. As was the point of my post. Surely you didn't miss the point quite so spectacularly?

You point was men and women have the same experiences and the same feelings of vulnerability?

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:21

Soontobe60 · 25/10/2026 17:18

Go on then, how many men who claim to be women have been raped or murdered in the UK this year? And while you’re at it, which sex did the raping and murdering?

Why?

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:20

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 17:18

You don't understand my answer then.

Here's one example for you. Modern version of a pub with a "No Irish" rule. https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/irish-traveller-settles-race-discrimination-claim-support-equality-watchdog

Because I'm extra nice to you, it also illustrates my point about the EA. Hopefully this helps you understand.

So one example from 2024 shows 'quite a lot of call'? Interesting.

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:18

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 17:16

No less of a victim than any other raped and murdered man. Or do you think otherwise?

No, I think they have shared the same horrifying experience. As was the point of my post. Surely you didn't miss the point quite so spectacularly?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 17:18

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:11

I understand that you can't provide any examples.

You don't understand my answer then.

Here's one example for you. Modern version of a pub with a "No Irish" rule. https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/irish-traveller-settles-race-discrimination-claim-support-equality-watchdog

Because I'm extra nice to you, it also illustrates my point about the EA. Hopefully this helps you understand.

Soontobe60 · 25/10/2026 17:18

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:03

Is a raped and murdered trans woman less of a rape and murder victim than a raped and murdered biological woman?

Go on then, how many men who claim to be women have been raped or murdered in the UK this year? And while you’re at it, which sex did the raping and murdering?

Truinio · 25/10/2026 17:17

murasaki · 25/10/2026 12:47

Seriously though, we'd need to define services first. E.g. I don't think a book group is a service.

A book group is an association, which is treated differently to a service in the Equality Act. For a start, the exceptions are far wider ranging: an association can legally discriminate on all protected characteristics except race.

Talkinpeace · 25/10/2026 17:17

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:00

Male or female, surely? 'Men' and 'women' are gender constructs.

Woman = Adult human female = biology, not a construct, observable long after death
Man = Adult human male = biology, not a construct, observable long after death

Masculine = a societal construct that varies between cultures and over time
Patriarchy = a series of societal constructs that preserve the rights of men over women

Feminine = a societal construct of how women should dress and behave that varies between cultures and over time
Matriarchy = a rare social system that puts women in the position of power

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 17:16

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:03

Is a raped and murdered trans woman less of a rape and murder victim than a raped and murdered biological woman?

No less of a victim than any other raped and murdered man. Or do you think otherwise?

nicepotoftea · 25/10/2026 17:16

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:10

Am I required to agree or disagree with Stonewall? I'm not entirely sure what Stonewall has to do with anything here. I've given my opinion. Is there another entity you wish to point out that I disagree with? English National Opera? British Gas? Julie's Caff on the M22?

As to your second point - whoever wishes to. There are quite a few organisations that have been forced to stop being single-gender when they would prefer to continue.

According to wikipedia Stonewall is the largest LGBT rights organisation in Europe, so I would assume that their opinion stands for something and is more likely to hold sway over public policy than any individual posting on this site.

There are quite a few organisations that have been forced to stop being single-gender when they would prefer to continue.

Can you give examples? Can you give examples of the kind of person they might turn away for being the wrong gender?

murasaki · 25/10/2026 17:15

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:12

It's a question. You said: "I'm sorry but transwomen have no idea how vulnerable women can feel. They are men. They cannot share the same experiences. Ever." I'm giving you an extreme example and I'm asking you if you stand by your claim.

And I do. That horrific example you used potentially happened to a man rather than to a woman. It is different.

And given you used murder, no one is available to speak to the vulnerability.

It was a ludicrous thing to say.

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:15

Shedmistress · 25/10/2026 17:14

I believe the question is 'for which services is seperation by gender not sex appropriate?'

What services are you saying would be appropriate for women and men who say they are women and not for men or women who say they are men; or indeed vice versa?

Edited

As I've answered - any that wish to.

Shedmistress · 25/10/2026 17:14

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 16:43

I recognise - as do many other people - that trans people exist. While a trans woman is male, she is not a 'man' in either thought or presentation. You may disagree - and I'm sure there will be screams of 'HE'S A MAN!!!!111' being typed out even more - but I'm trying to explain why I believe there's a difference. And again - before I'm accused of all manner of nonsense - I believe single sex spaces should mean single sex.

I believe the question is 'for which services is seperation by gender not sex appropriate?'

What services are you saying would be appropriate for women and men who say they are women and not for men or women who say they are men; or indeed vice versa?

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 17:14

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 16:53

But plenty do - when they are single-gender.

Where they object, people object to mislabelling.

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:13

Soontobe60 · 25/10/2026 17:12

If a ‘transwoman’ is not a man, which is an adult human male, what is he? He’s certainly not an adult human female?
He’s a man who wants to be seen as a woman. But as the word ‘woman’ means adult human female in law, I’m afraid he can’t be.

So the entire thread is pointless and no-one should have any thoughts that disagree with the law as it currently stands. Good to know.

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:12

murasaki · 25/10/2026 17:05

Wow, that's a leap. I did not say that. That is a disgusting to say.

Experiences are different, that's all i said.

I won't say what I really think of that and you or I'll get put on the naughty step.

It's a question. You said: "I'm sorry but transwomen have no idea how vulnerable women can feel. They are men. They cannot share the same experiences. Ever." I'm giving you an extreme example and I'm asking you if you stand by your claim.

murasaki · 25/10/2026 17:12

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:10

Am I required to agree or disagree with Stonewall? I'm not entirely sure what Stonewall has to do with anything here. I've given my opinion. Is there another entity you wish to point out that I disagree with? English National Opera? British Gas? Julie's Caff on the M22?

As to your second point - whoever wishes to. There are quite a few organisations that have been forced to stop being single-gender when they would prefer to continue.

If you mean the WI and the Girl Guides, they never were. They were in breach of their charters until it was pointed out.

Soontobe60 · 25/10/2026 17:12

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 16:43

I recognise - as do many other people - that trans people exist. While a trans woman is male, she is not a 'man' in either thought or presentation. You may disagree - and I'm sure there will be screams of 'HE'S A MAN!!!!111' being typed out even more - but I'm trying to explain why I believe there's a difference. And again - before I'm accused of all manner of nonsense - I believe single sex spaces should mean single sex.

If a ‘transwoman’ is not a man, which is an adult human male, what is he? He’s certainly not an adult human female?
He’s a man who wants to be seen as a woman. But as the word ‘woman’ means adult human female in law, I’m afraid he can’t be.