Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

For which services is separate by "gender" appropriate?

269 replies

MyAmpleSheep · 25/10/2026 12:36

Assuming it to be compliant with all relevant legislation (which is another discussion), which public services make more (or enough) sense to separate by self-defined gender rather than by sex?

We are often told that segregating by sex is permissible but not the only way to split "men" and "women" and that it's proportionate and appropriate to split men-identifiers from women-identifiers in some services in "appropriate circumstances" or some other phrase.

What are those services, and what are the appropriate circumstances?

This is a question about services, so I'm explicitly not referring to what the EA2010 covers under associations. Social groups are not services, and they can already be split or made exclusive in a much wider range of ways; I'm not asking about them. Only about public services. For clarity it's probably best to avoid terminology like "single sex spaces" because it's easy to misunderstand whether a "space" is a service - or an association.

So - which services can appropriately be segregated as women+trans-identifying men (women+ "trans women") and men+trans-identifying women (men + "trans men")?

OP posts:
DeanElderberry · 26/10/2026 18:06

ArabellaScott · 26/10/2026 15:59

Only women who are raped have the risk of pregnancy.

Or the risk of such severe physical damage that their fertility is permanently impaired, or lost.

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 18:02

JanesLittleGirl · 26/10/2026 17:50

I'll give this a go.

There is a demand for single sex women's gyms to meet the need for privacy, dignity and safety. Some women regard transwomen as women and are certain that there is no loss of privacy, dignity or safety where transwomen share their gym and that transwomen should share their gym for their privacy, dignity and safety.

The solution is to provide 2 gyms; one single sex and the other single gender. Both gyms would have to have equivalent facilities and be in the same area and probably have the same open area changing and showering facilities that are common in small, single sex changing areas.

I really can't see any problems with this. Women who need a single sex facility would have one. Women who don't feel that need would be happy with single gender. Transwomen would be welcomed into a space where they could feel at home.

Everyone would be happy.... or would they? I really don't know /s

We know, from what happened with ERCC, that the transwomen will be furious about the existence of the single-sex gym. Amnesty International would traduce it as an anti-rights organisation (cf Beira's Place).

It's not enough to accommodate them. We must adopt their beliefs and allow them in everywhere. Because they are women.

So sorry I missed your /s!

JanesLittleGirl · 26/10/2026 17:50

I'll give this a go.

There is a demand for single sex women's gyms to meet the need for privacy, dignity and safety. Some women regard transwomen as women and are certain that there is no loss of privacy, dignity or safety where transwomen share their gym and that transwomen should share their gym for their privacy, dignity and safety.

The solution is to provide 2 gyms; one single sex and the other single gender. Both gyms would have to have equivalent facilities and be in the same area and probably have the same open area changing and showering facilities that are common in small, single sex changing areas.

I really can't see any problems with this. Women who need a single sex facility would have one. Women who don't feel that need would be happy with single gender. Transwomen would be welcomed into a space where they could feel at home.

Everyone would be happy.... or would they? I really don't know /s

LeftieRightsHoarder · 26/10/2026 16:34

Well done to all those trying to debate this in good faith.
All I can think is that I can see the point of both mixed and single-sex facilities where appropriate.
But gender is such a nebulous concept, that seems to change according to the speaker or the barometer or the phase of the moon phase, that no one would ever be able to pin it down. And it’s so subjective that you might as well divide people up by their favourite colour or television programme, or their astrological sign.
The one thing that’s clear is that women need separate facilities in certain circumstances in which men have harmed or harassed women.

ArabellaScott · 26/10/2026 15:59

Lougle · 26/10/2026 12:25

I am of the view that it must be harrowing for any person to be raped.

When you break down all the different permutations, a TIM is still male bodied and therefore will not have the same experience of rape that a female bodied person will have.

I think it's all a bit irrelevant to the question posed by the OP, though.

I can't think of any service that would necessarily be segregated by gender. That's because I think that no matter how much effort a man puts in to emulating the life of a woman, they still have a male brain, male socialisation, male hormones (even if suppression and cross-sex supplementation is in play), and a male body (even if it has been altered to align more closely with the female physique).

I think that there are many TIM that are more 'feminine' than I am. I very rarely wear makeup. I only wear a wedding ring. I wear a dress once every 2 or 3 years. My hair hasn't been styled in a very long time. I barely look in the mirror and I have no idea what fashionable women wear. But they are still men and I am still a woman.

Only women who are raped have the risk of pregnancy.

BackToLurk · 26/10/2026 15:47

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 15:32

I think that 'just because it's what I want' is the only answer. Or, rather, the provider has the option (leaving legality to one side) to provide a service for the specific constituency of users who believe that everybody's gender identity outweighs their sex, and let the market decide. That's not been possible until now because single-sex services could not be offered and so were not available for users to choose.

The only common factor is the belief, and the type of service doesn't matter, as long as the users are adults who are able to choose freely. So, not applicable to schools, prisons, or hospital wards.

ETA am I the person who thinks single-gender services should be provided? I very much am not - I'm hypothesising them as a route to working out what they are for.

The answer seems to be, because some people want them: that's all there is to it.

Edited

As always with the genderists it's all very circular and vague
Which services?
The ones people want.
Defined how?
However people want.

ETA, they never seem to address questions around "what about all the other exclusive services people might want?".

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 15:32

MyAmpleSheep · 26/10/2026 14:24

I can certainly imagine services just for trans-identifying men, or just for trans-identifying women, or for both groups; but I still can't imagine a service that's relevant to trans-identifying men and women who do not identify as trans, certainly not a service that would make sense to actively exclude (other) men.

What I've got from this thread is that one possibility perhaps is the social group that isn't structured as an association and therefore falls to be a service (like the famous book group) where presence of absence of certain types of others is all of the point of, or almost all of the point of the offering. Leaving aside the legal definition a "book group" isn't really a service in the traditional sense though - a book club where only one person turns up is a bit, well, flat.

The second point I've understood is that someone thinks that any service that meets the strict conditions for the provision of a single-sex or separate sex service should also, at the sole preference of the provider, stands to be offered on a "single gendered" (self id) basis. I've tried to dig into the logic and reasoning behind this and there doesn't seem to be any. Just "because it's what I want" and then a lot of hot air and waffle to deflect the tough questions.

I think that 'just because it's what I want' is the only answer. Or, rather, the provider has the option (leaving legality to one side) to provide a service for the specific constituency of users who believe that everybody's gender identity outweighs their sex, and let the market decide. That's not been possible until now because single-sex services could not be offered and so were not available for users to choose.

The only common factor is the belief, and the type of service doesn't matter, as long as the users are adults who are able to choose freely. So, not applicable to schools, prisons, or hospital wards.

ETA am I the person who thinks single-gender services should be provided? I very much am not - I'm hypothesising them as a route to working out what they are for.

The answer seems to be, because some people want them: that's all there is to it.

alcovecupboards · 26/10/2026 15:15

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 13:20

OP specified that she is enquiring only about Schedule 3-type services, not Schedule 16 associations.

But, the hypothetical 'trans-inclusive' services do resemble associations in that participation is voluntary. If its boundaries are fuzzy, that's not our problem. We'll all use the parallel single-sex service, which has clearly defined boundaries.

@alcovecupboards hasn't yet come up with a solution for TRAs insisting on using the single-sex services, though.

Also, clubs can exclude people who don't have the relevant protected characteristic (unless it's skin colour), but policing is fuzzy because you can't immediately see some things, like sexual orientation and beliefs. In practice, the genderist services are for anyone who doesn’t mind genderism.

Edited

Because I don't need to. I've been clear that single sex should mean single sex. If someone wishes to use a single sex service but isn't that sex - then they can't. It isn't up to me to solve that issue.

If I am asked to say what I think should be legal to do - I'm under no obligation to then answer any nonsense about it being against the law and therefore impossible. Nor will I answer one rather peculiar user who changes her name and follows me around.

Thebigarsedbitch · 26/10/2026 14:42

MeridaBrave · 25/10/2026 12:42

For me the only thing that needs to be segregated is gym changing room to the extent that there are no cubicles! Now given I am taking off all my clothes I think it needs to be by sex. I’m less bothered by hospital wards assuming fully dressed there will be male visitors so don’t see the big deal about male patients. Even shop changing rooms as long as locking doors and no way to use cameras to take photos under the wall etc then I don’t care.

Please read the statistics on the sexual assaults that took place in UK hospitals last year and the tragic unsolved murder of Valerie Kneale in a Blackpool Hospital (spoiler - she was raped to death), both of which might make you think again about allowing men -any men - to access female hospital wards. And remember that womens' rights belong to all women, so what you personally think has very little relevance.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 26/10/2026 14:29

MyAmpleSheep · 26/10/2026 14:24

I can certainly imagine services just for trans-identifying men, or just for trans-identifying women, or for both groups; but I still can't imagine a service that's relevant to trans-identifying men and women who do not identify as trans, certainly not a service that would make sense to actively exclude (other) men.

What I've got from this thread is that one possibility perhaps is the social group that isn't structured as an association and therefore falls to be a service (like the famous book group) where presence of absence of certain types of others is all of the point of, or almost all of the point of the offering. Leaving aside the legal definition a "book group" isn't really a service in the traditional sense though - a book club where only one person turns up is a bit, well, flat.

The second point I've understood is that someone thinks that any service that meets the strict conditions for the provision of a single-sex or separate sex service should also, at the sole preference of the provider, stands to be offered on a "single gendered" (self id) basis. I've tried to dig into the logic and reasoning behind this and there doesn't seem to be any. Just "because it's what I want" and then a lot of hot air and waffle to deflect the tough questions.

As is so often the case…

Perhaps a “Trans+ Allies book group”? Something as trivial - by which I mean extraneous to actual needs like loos, medical care etc.

MyAmpleSheep · 26/10/2026 14:24

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 26/10/2026 13:57

I’d say perhaps something for the trans-identified, but in fact there’s no coherent category with includes women who know they’re women and men who claim they’re women, but excludes women who claim they’re men, and men who know they’re men… and that’s before we decide where people who claim they’re not mammals at all (“non-binary”).

But maybe a group of people who believe they have a gender that trumps their sex?

I can certainly imagine services just for trans-identifying men, or just for trans-identifying women, or for both groups; but I still can't imagine a service that's relevant to trans-identifying men and women who do not identify as trans, certainly not a service that would make sense to actively exclude (other) men.

What I've got from this thread is that one possibility perhaps is the social group that isn't structured as an association and therefore falls to be a service (like the famous book group) where presence of absence of certain types of others is all of the point of, or almost all of the point of the offering. Leaving aside the legal definition a "book group" isn't really a service in the traditional sense though - a book club where only one person turns up is a bit, well, flat.

The second point I've understood is that someone thinks that any service that meets the strict conditions for the provision of a single-sex or separate sex service should also, at the sole preference of the provider, stands to be offered on a "single gendered" (self id) basis. I've tried to dig into the logic and reasoning behind this and there doesn't seem to be any. Just "because it's what I want" and then a lot of hot air and waffle to deflect the tough questions.

OP posts:
ProfessoressaSazzasez · 26/10/2026 13:57

MyAmpleSheep · 25/10/2026 12:36

Assuming it to be compliant with all relevant legislation (which is another discussion), which public services make more (or enough) sense to separate by self-defined gender rather than by sex?

We are often told that segregating by sex is permissible but not the only way to split "men" and "women" and that it's proportionate and appropriate to split men-identifiers from women-identifiers in some services in "appropriate circumstances" or some other phrase.

What are those services, and what are the appropriate circumstances?

This is a question about services, so I'm explicitly not referring to what the EA2010 covers under associations. Social groups are not services, and they can already be split or made exclusive in a much wider range of ways; I'm not asking about them. Only about public services. For clarity it's probably best to avoid terminology like "single sex spaces" because it's easy to misunderstand whether a "space" is a service - or an association.

So - which services can appropriately be segregated as women+trans-identifying men (women+ "trans women") and men+trans-identifying women (men + "trans men")?

I’d say perhaps something for the trans-identified, but in fact there’s no coherent category with includes women who know they’re women and men who claim they’re women, but excludes women who claim they’re men, and men who know they’re men… and that’s before we decide where people who claim they’re not mammals at all (“non-binary”).

But maybe a group of people who believe they have a gender that trumps their sex?

nicepotoftea · 26/10/2026 13:54

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 13:20

OP specified that she is enquiring only about Schedule 3-type services, not Schedule 16 associations.

But, the hypothetical 'trans-inclusive' services do resemble associations in that participation is voluntary. If its boundaries are fuzzy, that's not our problem. We'll all use the parallel single-sex service, which has clearly defined boundaries.

@alcovecupboards hasn't yet come up with a solution for TRAs insisting on using the single-sex services, though.

Also, clubs can exclude people who don't have the relevant protected characteristic (unless it's skin colour), but policing is fuzzy because you can't immediately see some things, like sexual orientation and beliefs. In practice, the genderist services are for anyone who doesn’t mind genderism.

Edited

So in practice nobody is excluded and it is comparable to the barber's who will cut anyone's hair, not a single sex service.

BackToLurk · 26/10/2026 13:49

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 13:20

OP specified that she is enquiring only about Schedule 3-type services, not Schedule 16 associations.

But, the hypothetical 'trans-inclusive' services do resemble associations in that participation is voluntary. If its boundaries are fuzzy, that's not our problem. We'll all use the parallel single-sex service, which has clearly defined boundaries.

@alcovecupboards hasn't yet come up with a solution for TRAs insisting on using the single-sex services, though.

Also, clubs can exclude people who don't have the relevant protected characteristic (unless it's skin colour), but policing is fuzzy because you can't immediately see some things, like sexual orientation and beliefs. In practice, the genderist services are for anyone who doesn’t mind genderism.

Edited

The OP is clear, I'm not sure all the responses are clear that is what is being referred to. It's hard to say as they can't or won't give an example of a specific service.

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 13:20

BackToLurk · 26/10/2026 12:33

In relation to services (including spaces), there seems to be some conflation or misunderstanding of services that are targeted at, run by or catering to a specific demographic and those restricted to a specific demographic (and by extension excluding everyone else). So sure there are gay clubs, Irish centres, Black churches, Muslim dating apps etc, etc but they aren’t legally barring others.

OP specified that she is enquiring only about Schedule 3-type services, not Schedule 16 associations.

But, the hypothetical 'trans-inclusive' services do resemble associations in that participation is voluntary. If its boundaries are fuzzy, that's not our problem. We'll all use the parallel single-sex service, which has clearly defined boundaries.

@alcovecupboards hasn't yet come up with a solution for TRAs insisting on using the single-sex services, though.

Also, clubs can exclude people who don't have the relevant protected characteristic (unless it's skin colour), but policing is fuzzy because you can't immediately see some things, like sexual orientation and beliefs. In practice, the genderist services are for anyone who doesn’t mind genderism.

BackToLurk · 26/10/2026 12:33

In relation to services (including spaces), there seems to be some conflation or misunderstanding of services that are targeted at, run by or catering to a specific demographic and those restricted to a specific demographic (and by extension excluding everyone else). So sure there are gay clubs, Irish centres, Black churches, Muslim dating apps etc, etc but they aren’t legally barring others.

Lougle · 26/10/2026 12:25

BaobhanSith · 25/10/2026 17:45

You tried to equate rape and murder of women with rape and murder of men. Nothing misunderstood. Biological males will never have this same shared experience as biological females.

I am of the view that it must be harrowing for any person to be raped.

When you break down all the different permutations, a TIM is still male bodied and therefore will not have the same experience of rape that a female bodied person will have.

I think it's all a bit irrelevant to the question posed by the OP, though.

I can't think of any service that would necessarily be segregated by gender. That's because I think that no matter how much effort a man puts in to emulating the life of a woman, they still have a male brain, male socialisation, male hormones (even if suppression and cross-sex supplementation is in play), and a male body (even if it has been altered to align more closely with the female physique).

I think that there are many TIM that are more 'feminine' than I am. I very rarely wear makeup. I only wear a wedding ring. I wear a dress once every 2 or 3 years. My hair hasn't been styled in a very long time. I barely look in the mirror and I have no idea what fashionable women wear. But they are still men and I am still a woman.

Pingponghavoc · 26/10/2026 12:21

Its an interesting thought that a belief has to be practiced in a public toilet.

The 'woman gendered' toilets would have to be clearly marked to allow women to consent. It would have to be clearly labelled mixed sex, and probably any unaccompanied child wouldnt be allowed in.

So the toilet couldnt be ambiguous- it couldnt be mistaken for a woman's toilet or a single use, universal one. And be clear its not suitable for children.

The signage wont be affirming to the izzards of the world.

nicepotoftea · 26/10/2026 12:06

Shedmistress · 26/10/2026 07:52

We keep being told 'sex isn't gender stupid' and 'is fine to just use gender instead, nobody gets hurt' and yet when the specifics in actual everyday life get questioned, not one person who advocates these can name one single instance where it would be a legitimate aim to segregate or provide services by 'gender'.

Edited

Or how you would do that in practice.

I think the reality is that if I tried to use the Hampstead Men's pond the assessment would not be whether I had a male gender, but whether I looked as though I were part of the Q+ community.

Otherwise the closure of the mixed pond for winter looks as though it is very discriminatory against people who are gender fluid/non-binary/a-gender etc. Is the assumption that their gender identity is less important to them?

nicepotoftea · 26/10/2026 11:53

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 09:31

The legitimate aim is to enable transgenderists to practise their beliefs by setting up services that operate in accordance with them, whilst leaving the rest of us out of it.

In the same way, we permit minority religions to circumcise boys, force women to cover themselves, and segregate the sexes during worship. It's not ideal, but it's a sacrifice we make in order to maintain a pluralist society, and we do our best to repair the damage (to women, mostly) through education, public messaging, and the criminal law.

I'm not endorsing it. But the OP's question leads inexorably to this being a religious matter. Transwomen and their female allies share nothing but a woman-despising belief system.

ETA obviously no TRAs will want to argue their case based on freedom of religion and belief. But, tough, it's all they've got.

Edited

So this is all under the auspices of the PC of belief?

Would this be similar to schools selecting pupils on the basis of their religion?

I think the problem is that the implication is that there would be a boundary, but nobody seems able to say where that boundary would be.

Alisonsy · 26/10/2026 11:35

Yes, this.

As a woman (female sex) i want segregation based on biology. I don’t want to share spaces with males if it makes me uncomfortable.

For all other aspects in life, men are very welcome.

BackToLurk · 26/10/2026 09:45

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 09:31

The legitimate aim is to enable transgenderists to practise their beliefs by setting up services that operate in accordance with them, whilst leaving the rest of us out of it.

In the same way, we permit minority religions to circumcise boys, force women to cover themselves, and segregate the sexes during worship. It's not ideal, but it's a sacrifice we make in order to maintain a pluralist society, and we do our best to repair the damage (to women, mostly) through education, public messaging, and the criminal law.

I'm not endorsing it. But the OP's question leads inexorably to this being a religious matter. Transwomen and their female allies share nothing but a woman-despising belief system.

ETA obviously no TRAs will want to argue their case based on freedom of religion and belief. But, tough, it's all they've got.

Edited

In the same way, we permit minority religions to circumcise boys, force women to cover themselves, and segregate the sexes during worship. It's not ideal, but it's a sacrifice we make in order to maintain a pluralist society

This isn't strictly true. Anyone can request a private non-medical circumcision, I don't think there is any law against it, it's not a privilege permitted only to the religious. While you or I may believe that women are forced to cover themselves many women argue there is no force, and a woman could seek recourse through the law, specifically legislation around coercive control, if she was being forced. Religion wouldn't provide a defence.

Otherwise I do like the parallels with other religions, and those parallels do demonstrate a problem the genderists may hit. Just like the Muslim Council of Britain doesn't see Ahmadis as Muslims, so the 'Chipping Sodbury Women & Transwomen Book Club' may not see the Pip Bunce's of this world as a transwoman, but the 'Chipping Sodbury Women & Transwomen Quiz Team' might. Let the schisms commence.

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 09:31

Shedmistress · 26/10/2026 08:31

I'm not even talking about the users, it is the legitimate aim that could be described in court that is the issue here.

Once we have a legitimate aim, then the communication to the users would be key but we have to start from the first principle of 'why'.

The legitimate aim is to enable transgenderists to practise their beliefs by setting up services that operate in accordance with them, whilst leaving the rest of us out of it.

In the same way, we permit minority religions to circumcise boys, force women to cover themselves, and segregate the sexes during worship. It's not ideal, but it's a sacrifice we make in order to maintain a pluralist society, and we do our best to repair the damage (to women, mostly) through education, public messaging, and the criminal law.

I'm not endorsing it. But the OP's question leads inexorably to this being a religious matter. Transwomen and their female allies share nothing but a woman-despising belief system.

ETA obviously no TRAs will want to argue their case based on freedom of religion and belief. But, tough, it's all they've got.

Shedmistress · 26/10/2026 08:31

theilltemperedmonster · 26/10/2026 08:09

Thinking about this some more (I really need to get out more):

Assume the single-sex and single-gender services are otherwise identical to each other, and that users have perfect knowledge.

Then the users of each single-gender service share a 'gender identity' and a belief that gender identity is more important than sex.

Since users have perfect knowledge of crime statistics and sporting records, it follows that all voluntary users of single-gender services share an additional belief: that the safety of, and fairness to, women is less important than the psychological comfort of trans people (although, a transman in this situation is only weighing her own safety against her own psychological comfort).

So it's a metaphysical belief that says (some) men >> all women. Not very novel: we have plenty of religions like that. They just shouldn't be forced on anyone.

I did not mention privacy as an aim, because a perfect gender believer should be totally unembarassed to strip off in front of a member of the opposite sex, if one of them claims a cross-sex gender identity. And so forth.

I'm not even talking about the users, it is the legitimate aim that could be described in court that is the issue here.

Once we have a legitimate aim, then the communication to the users would be key but we have to start from the first principle of 'why'.

ArabellaScott · 26/10/2026 08:27

murasaki · 25/10/2026 12:39

I'd say none. If it doesn't need to be segregated by sex, then it doesn't need to be segregated. I have nothing in common with TW that I don't have in common with any other man.

That. Mixed sex or single sex.

However, the EA is about exclusions, not inclusions.

Is there a service that should exclude all masculine-identifying people? I can't think of one.