Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…

544 replies

Sugarleaf · 24/10/2026 22:47

…Who’s stuck in the past. To be ‘cool and curious’ you need to use non- biological sex based pronouns. And this is about a ‘certain generation.’ I mean I’m 32 and think it’s bollocks.

plus, as a bonus, ‘if you don’t like me, fine, as long as you use my correct pronouns.’

ffs

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
putitonthewrongway · 25/10/2026 11:52

They/them pronouns make conversations so confusing. There was a contestant recently on Traitors that the presenter was speaking about describing the contestant as “they/them” and I kept thinking the presenter was talking about a group of people rather than that particular contestant. It makes no sense in normal conversation at all.

FancyKeyboard · 25/10/2026 11:47

Saw Chloe recently in a comedy thing and she's excellent. Best one on Taskmaster too. Pretty sure she introduced herself as a massive lesbian. So I don't really get why she denies her sex.

She's a masc-presenting woman and that's great. Lean into that. Being born the female sex does not mean you need to dress in any way at all. So push the boundaries of that. Why go for a different pronoun? What does it actually achieve?

Pingponghavoc · 25/10/2026 11:42

Chloe will have an easy time convincing the people around her that concealing her sex is progressive and positive.

After all the comedy circuit is dominated by men and the media in general has an appalling track record in ignoring safeguarding.

Or maybe her profession has convinced Chloe that concealing her sex is progressive and positive? Who knows.

But its harder to convince women on a parenting site that its positive. Its easy to explain away queer theory to the media who are focused only on profit, than to women who need to keep their children safe.

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 11:37

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 11:34

In your belief maybe. But cis is also a meaningless term considering it is used to describe male athletes with DSDs. I can quote people on MN telling us this.

So cis is a repurposed term that is effectively meaningless and it requires someone to believe in gender identity theory for it to gain any meaning for humans at all.

Edited

Its particularly meaningless when you have men like India Willoughby describing themselves as a cis woman

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 11:36

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 11:32

Surely what’s ‘died out’ is the whole idea that ‘politeness’ overrides boundaries and consent. Unless @sweetnsourr is trying to take us back to more deferential times.

I reckon just to a recent thread.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 11:34

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:23

For the billionth time, sex & gender are two totally different concepts. Him/her can be both referencing sex or gender & that makes obvious sense given both cis & trans women exist.

In your belief maybe. But cis is also a meaningless term considering it is used to describe male athletes with DSDs. I can quote people on MN telling us this.

So cis is a repurposed term that is effectively meaningless and it requires someone to believe in gender identity theory for it to gain any meaning for humans at all.

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 11:32

NotBadConsidering · 25/10/2026 11:28

So you’re saying it doesn’t matter if some people don’t believe that “she” means a man who is a woman, those people can believe what they want but the word’s meaning has changed around them.

There’s an entire appendix at the end of Nineteen Eighty Four about just that.

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

Oh I understand this completely. You are simultaneously holding the idea in your head that you’re passing this off as a simple act of “politeness” while at the same time relishing in the idea that our defence will somehow “die out”. You’ve argued for gender identity beliefs for a very long time, it’s clear your “politeness” argument is just a front.

Surely what’s ‘died out’ is the whole idea that ‘politeness’ overrides boundaries and consent. Unless @sweetnsourr is trying to take us back to more deferential times.

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 11:31

For the billionth time, sex & gender are two totally different concepts. Him/her can be both referencing sex or gender

If I use sex based pronouns for all people then I'm not discriminating against trans people by dint of using sex based pronouns regardless of whether people are trans or not. Im not misgendering anyone because I'm referencing their sex not their gender and they are two different things

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 11:28

Pingponghavoc · 25/10/2026 11:23

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

Can you explain sex/gender to children while maintaining safeguarding?

I would like to hear exactly how you would do this.

How would a child know that its wrong if Eddie izzard is in a female space, but its ok when Ellen Page is? How would you explain that chloe is a 'them' and is allowed to be in a female space, but a male 'them' isnt?

Edited

How would you explain that chloe is a 'them' and is allowed to be in a female space, but a male 'them' isnt?

How indeed.

NotBadConsidering · 25/10/2026 11:28

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:20

Wow, finally a substantive argument however flawed that's an achievement! Well done.

But you are totally confused. Understanding the definition of a word doesn't mean you believe the phenomena that underpins it exists. Lots of people understand the definition of trans but don't necessarily agree the phenomena has legitimacy just like a lot of people understand what the word stress or depression means but still think these are non existent conditions.

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

So you’re saying it doesn’t matter if some people don’t believe that “she” means a man who is a woman, those people can believe what they want but the word’s meaning has changed around them.

There’s an entire appendix at the end of Nineteen Eighty Four about just that.

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

Oh I understand this completely. You are simultaneously holding the idea in your head that you’re passing this off as a simple act of “politeness” while at the same time relishing in the idea that our defence will somehow “die out”. You’ve argued for gender identity beliefs for a very long time, it’s clear your “politeness” argument is just a front.

Pingponghavoc · 25/10/2026 11:28

Ive edited my post since you replied.

Can you explain to me how you would explain this bit of safeguarding to children? How can we explain that its wrong for men to be in women's spaces when its wrong to call these men men?

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:25

Pingponghavoc · 25/10/2026 11:23

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

Can you explain sex/gender to children while maintaining safeguarding?

I would like to hear exactly how you would do this.

How would a child know that its wrong if Eddie izzard is in a female space, but its ok when Ellen Page is? How would you explain that chloe is a 'them' and is allowed to be in a female space, but a male 'them' isnt?

Edited

Children aren't 'unsafe' from learning about diversity in humans only from people who think they shouldn't.

Pingponghavoc · 25/10/2026 11:23

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

Can you explain sex/gender to children while maintaining safeguarding?

I would like to hear exactly how you would do this.

How would a child know that its wrong if Eddie izzard is in a female space, but its ok when Ellen Page is? How would you explain that chloe is a 'them' and is allowed to be in a female space, but a male 'them' isnt?

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:23

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 11:18

I see.

And around we go in yet another cycle.

Where reference words magically can mean the opposite at the same time as the evidenced supported terms and apparently communication is completely impacted and clear.

And that male people don’t have to have any female referenced experience to claim the use of the use of the female terminology, them just ‘recognising’ themselves using that descriptor is all that is required. No need for material reality or even logical coherence.

oh. That is right. Incoherent = coherent so anyone can use those words and people can apply their own definitions.

Good to know.

For the billionth time, sex & gender are two totally different concepts. Him/her can be both referencing sex or gender & that makes obvious sense given both cis & trans women exist.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:20

NotBadConsidering · 25/10/2026 11:12

So on one hand you’re saying just being polite doesn’t affect people’s beliefs, but on the other hand repetitive use of words in a different context - in this case pronouns changing to mean men can be women - gradually evolves the meaning of those words over time.

So it’s not just “polite” is it? It’s something that fundamentally changes the meaning of words. You’re acknowledging that using wrong sex pronouns is a way of changing their meaning to suit your beliefs.

It’s just not going to happen mate. We aren’t going to let it and the younger generation thinks it’s all a load of bollocks too.

Wow, finally a substantive argument however flawed that's an achievement! Well done.

But you are totally confused. Understanding the definition of a word doesn't mean you believe the phenomena that underpins it exists. Lots of people understand the definition of trans but don't necessarily agree the phenomena has legitimacy just like a lot of people understand what the word stress or depression means but still think these are non existent conditions.

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 11:18

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:53

The idea that mouthing words destabilises belief is ludicrous. You act as if humans don't have the capacity to hold two different thoughts in their heads at once. Politeness has no proven magical link to destabilising beliefs & to suggest so is delusional.

I see.

And around we go in yet another cycle.

Where reference words magically can mean the opposite at the same time as the evidenced supported terms and apparently communication is completely impacted and clear.

And that male people don’t have to have any female referenced experience to claim the use of the use of the female terminology, them just ‘recognising’ themselves using that descriptor is all that is required. No need for material reality or even logical coherence.

oh. That is right. Incoherent = coherent so anyone can use those words and people can apply their own definitions.

Good to know.

NotBadConsidering · 25/10/2026 11:12

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:03

Words become established meaning by broad usage so its just the opposite of an imposition. In other words, the more people use a word the more it becomes popular meaning & given the younger generation dictate the future evolution of language, gender pronouns are here for now. Not to mention the arc of history bends towards liberalism & by extension self determination.

So on one hand you’re saying just being polite doesn’t affect people’s beliefs, but on the other hand repetitive use of words in a different context - in this case pronouns changing to mean men can be women - gradually evolves the meaning of those words over time.

So it’s not just “polite” is it? It’s something that fundamentally changes the meaning of words. You’re acknowledging that using wrong sex pronouns is a way of changing their meaning to suit your beliefs.

It’s just not going to happen mate. We aren’t going to let it and the younger generation thinks it’s all a load of bollocks too.

FunPartyIdeas · 25/10/2026 11:09

Summeriscumin · 25/10/2026 11:01

I can honestly say I've had no hostility. In the early days I said, "I prefer Ms, if that's ok" And it was not a problem. There was the occasional "joke" but nothing offensive. I was never aggressive about that and the kids I taught called me Miss or Mrs and I wasn't snarky enough to correct them, they were only little.

I took my husbands name because I didn't have the courage in the early 70s to keep my own. He wasn't fussed either way. A few years later, I'd have kept it.

I'm quite a laid back feminist in many ways but get very annoyed about certain causes. I was born a woman, I have no penis and the correct hormones for my birth state. That makes me a woman. When I wear trousers, which I nearly always do, I don't feel like a bloke. Neither do I identify as one.

I believe in a woman's right to choose and men need to stay out of the argument. No uterus? Not your business.

I raised money for women's refuges when they were just an idea. I still support them and there is no place for penises in them, unless on children.

My elder son told his teacher I was a radical feminist and he was pleasantly surprised to find I'm quite sociable.

I am pretty radical about certain causes but I always try to argue nicely because that seems to work better.

Not always though. I have been known, when infuriated by misogyny, to lose my cool loudly. DH has been known to turn into a cringing Basil Fawlty when my hackles start rising.

Sorry for the essay.

Amazing! I think you're brilliant!
I'm a Ms MyName (married) and I've had "Your husband is a simp/You're disrespecting your husband/you don't love your husband/you're legally a Mrs(!) etc.
I am unapologetically a feminist which some women have suggested they feel threatened by (which I don't understand if I'm honest).
I am really concerned that women are being erased and don't want to be a part of that. Example: I went for my routine HPV screen the other day (formerly a smear test), and the info inviting me read: "People with a cervix".

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:03

AsiaFlyer · 25/10/2026 10:57

You try telling them that!

(I do agree that language shifts. I just see the idea that we get to choose our own pronouns as a niche belief and practice, which is fine, but that imposing that on others is the illiberal step, not the liberal one).

Words become established meaning by broad usage so its just the opposite of an imposition. In other words, the more people use a word the more it becomes popular meaning & given the younger generation dictate the future evolution of language, gender pronouns are here for now. Not to mention the arc of history bends towards liberalism & by extension self determination.

Summeriscumin · 25/10/2026 11:01

FunPartyIdeas · 25/10/2026 10:23

Did you get any "kick-back" on your decision to be a Ms? I have nothing but respect for you and can imagine it would have been quite different back in the day?
I'm 46 and the comments I get at being a married Ms can be appalling! Not that I care!

I can honestly say I've had no hostility. In the early days I said, "I prefer Ms, if that's ok" And it was not a problem. There was the occasional "joke" but nothing offensive. I was never aggressive about that and the kids I taught called me Miss or Mrs and I wasn't snarky enough to correct them, they were only little.

I took my husbands name because I didn't have the courage in the early 70s to keep my own. He wasn't fussed either way. A few years later, I'd have kept it.

I'm quite a laid back feminist in many ways but get very annoyed about certain causes. I was born a woman, I have no penis and the correct hormones for my birth state. That makes me a woman. When I wear trousers, which I nearly always do, I don't feel like a bloke. Neither do I identify as one.

I believe in a woman's right to choose and men need to stay out of the argument. No uterus? Not your business.

I raised money for women's refuges when they were just an idea. I still support them and there is no place for penises in them, unless on children.

My elder son told his teacher I was a radical feminist and he was pleasantly surprised to find I'm quite sociable.

I am pretty radical about certain causes but I always try to argue nicely because that seems to work better.

Not always though. I have been known, when infuriated by misogyny, to lose my cool loudly. DH has been known to turn into a cringing Basil Fawlty when my hackles start rising.

Sorry for the essay.

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 10:59

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:35

Problem is the social convention of respecting another's choices despite not agreeing with them has long been broadly decreed into existence.

And also that even where there is a widespread social convention we should usually give space for those who don’t want to go along, and that this itself is central to true diversity and inclusion?

Of course, there's no obligation to be polite just as there's no obligation to socially include the impolite in social circles.

At work? That can border on discriminatory harassment & employers rightfully don't care for conflict particularly if it affects their bottom line.

So do I have to eat the brisket or not?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 25/10/2026 10:58

I didn't realise the Absent Commas and the Overused Ampersand were playing here today.

Disappointingly derivative so far though...

AsiaFlyer · 25/10/2026 10:57

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:45

The point is language can change it isn't as fixed as you presume it to be.

You try telling them that!

(I do agree that language shifts. I just see the idea that we get to choose our own pronouns as a niche belief and practice, which is fine, but that imposing that on others is the illiberal step, not the liberal one).

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:53

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 10:47

These are irrelevant examples and they are not comparable.

They refer to social situations and they can and often are ignored with no person suffering negative repercussions if they don’t do this.

They do not, however, refer to a specific reference term that has had its meaning destabilised by an individual’s personal and philosophical belief.

Next will you be posting that a male person describing himself as a ‘woman’ or a ‘female’ has no negative impact on female people individually and collectively. And that a male person’s identity belief that they are female is based on a ‘coherent’ explanation?

The idea that mouthing words destabilises belief is ludicrous. You act as if humans don't have the capacity to hold two different thoughts in their heads at once. Politeness has no proven magical link to destabilising beliefs & to suggest so is delusional.