Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…

544 replies

Sugarleaf · 24/10/2026 22:47

…Who’s stuck in the past. To be ‘cool and curious’ you need to use non- biological sex based pronouns. And this is about a ‘certain generation.’ I mean I’m 32 and think it’s bollocks.

plus, as a bonus, ‘if you don’t like me, fine, as long as you use my correct pronouns.’

ffs

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MostlyPeaceful · 25/10/2026 13:19

deadpantrashcan · 25/10/2026 09:49

I see. This goes for every single person?

Intellectual people can be the most credulous and stupid of all, they just don't know it Grin. Hence the dreadful case of the fantasist professor at Cambridge who, because of his identity, was feted, lauded, loved, promoted and encouraged by those who should have known better. An absolute tragedy that should NEVER have happened Sad. Thankfully there is now going to be a full independent enquiry into how it happened. Cambridge has blood on their hands imo.

savehannah · 25/10/2026 13:18

I actually have found both Chloe Petts and Mae Martin funny and entertaining on Taskmaster but I find the whole 'they' thing ridiculous and total nonsense. Especially when, as said above she describes herself as a lesbian! ie a woman who is attracted to women.

It's a shame when evidently intelligent and interesting young women feel the need to claim they aren't a woman.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 13:14

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 13:03

Noooooooooooooooooo 😱

How can that be a thing? Way beyond a reasonable cognitive load.

Indeed.

Hence the point some posters attempt to make that it is just a matter of respect etc, are usually very heavily invested in their own belief about this . Because the mental load to think about someone's demanded language when it is known or it is recognised what sex category the person you are referring to belongs to and the language demanded doesn't match is high.

It is not really acceptable to expect others to take on that burden of having to remember someone's expected language when it comes to remembering the ingrained sex category reference of the sex based language. That some people wish to take on that load is up to them. It is quite acceptable that others don't yet others will gaslight those who reject the language demand using language such as 'respect', 'kind' and that it 'has no negative impact'. Of course it does have a negative impact, but those who are overly heavily invested for any reason will simply deny it using gaslighting methods.

Teaandscone · 25/10/2026 13:13

They is the correct pronoun for more than one person. Anyone who argues otherwise is indeed a Philistine.

Rosiemate · 25/10/2026 13:12

testmatchspecial · 24/10/2026 23:47

I don’t think she knows what the word Philistine means.

Bella Ramsey on Celebrity Traitors was scrupulously they-ed by the other contestants, even though she’s said she doesn’t mind if people don’t use they/them.

The "they" for Bella grated on me every time, though I liked her.

It's all nonsense. "Gender nonconforming" - fine, though I don’t see why it’s necessary to announce it to everyone else. But the pronoun bit is just forcing other people to validate your choices and ideas whether they want to or not.
Third-person pronouns are about sex, not gender.

Shedmistress · 25/10/2026 13:12

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 13:03

Noooooooooooooooooo 😱

How can that be a thing? Way beyond a reasonable cognitive load.

Yes it was a thing. Needless to say, didn't catch on!

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 13:09

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:22

For billionth time, sex & gender mean two different things.

Yes we know.

Pronouns are sex based in English as it has evolved naturally and how children still naturally learn to use them. And how most people use them daily.

Some people want us to use pronouns that match their gendered beliefs about themselves, and not their sex.

It is a niche usage.

MostlyPeaceful · 25/10/2026 13:04

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 08:19

In other words, you believe you are entitled to determine other people's views of the world.

Does that work both ways? The Patriarchy would agree with you it doesn't.

My quote was: Someone's right to define themselves is lovely but it stops when I assert MY right to identify them by their sex and not some "gender" they imagine they are.

So I said precisely NOT what you have just asserted. Read my comment.

We both have rights. Someone can believe they are the opposite sex. I can SEE their actual sexed body and make a judgement. Women are hard-wired to do with instinctively and it can save their lives. Why? Because women know that male humans can hurt them easily. Women are extremely careful to be aware of the danger of strangers who are male.

I have no intention to lie and deceive in order to placate another, at my expense. Patriarchy? What nonsense.

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 13:03

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 09:28

I thought that she / they was the order you should be expected to use them in a paragraph. That first you use ‘she’, then you need to contort your memory and language and immediate consciousness and use they after that instead of ‘she’

Isn’t this how it was explained to us years ago on here?

Noooooooooooooooooo 😱

How can that be a thing? Way beyond a reasonable cognitive load.

MagpiePi · 25/10/2026 12:57

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:20

Wow, finally a substantive argument however flawed that's an achievement! Well done.

But you are totally confused. Understanding the definition of a word doesn't mean you believe the phenomena that underpins it exists. Lots of people understand the definition of trans but don't necessarily agree the phenomena has legitimacy just like a lot of people understand what the word stress or depression means but still think these are non existent conditions.

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

We’re back to the ‘you’re too stupid to understand’ argument. 🙄

AsiaFlyer · 25/10/2026 12:53

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:53

The idea that mouthing words destabilises belief is ludicrous. You act as if humans don't have the capacity to hold two different thoughts in their heads at once. Politeness has no proven magical link to destabilising beliefs & to suggest so is delusional.

That might be true for some or even most people and cases.

The issue is how to deal with people or cases where that’s not true.

For example, Chloe seems to feel that mouthing the wrong words can destabilise her belief, or at least cause distress. Others (including on this thread) feel similarly about how they use language.

Your position seems to be that: i) we should be liberal and that ii) liberalism requires that the latter group defer to the former.

I agree with you on i) but I don’t think you’ve made any convincing case for ii).

(I am multitasking though and haven’t read all your posts)

Alltheprettyseahorses · 25/10/2026 12:47

I don't want to judge Chloe but what she said seems to be very fixated on the idea of being cool and I think she looks like someone who has lived her life as an intrinsically 'uncool' person. Pronouns don't fix that uncoolness - they exacerbate it.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 25/10/2026 12:43

Children aren't 'unsafe' from learning about diversity in humans only from people who think they shouldn't.

The diversity that they're supposed to be taught about humans is, the diverse cultures, political systems, languages, religions etc not how many different personality types with different degrees of stupid that humans in the West can be.

Shortshriftandlethal · 25/10/2026 12:42

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:53

The idea that mouthing words destabilises belief is ludicrous. You act as if humans don't have the capacity to hold two different thoughts in their heads at once. Politeness has no proven magical link to destabilising beliefs & to suggest so is delusional.

Have you read '1984' by George Orwell? A very prescient book about the nature of a totalitarian regime/society

Forcing people/ a population into a position of cognitive dissonance ( holding two contradictory ideas in one's head at the same time) is the modus operandi of totalitarian regimes. Everyone has to pay lip service to the regime with harsh penalties for non compliance.

The subjugated population is expected to repeat a falsity so often that it ends up believing that falsity to be true. 2+2 = 5.

newrubylane · 25/10/2026 12:39

Logically speaking: if you want to declare pronouns fluid and state your preferences, then they can't equally be described as having the objective state of correct or incorrect. It's either one or the other.

I can tolerate, just about, being asked to respect a preference. I strongly object to being told I'm using them incorrectly if I don't do so.

Also, not sure this is a reasonable use of the word philistine. I can't see how this issue could be considered something of artistic or cultural value.

Shortshriftandlethal · 25/10/2026 12:37

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 10:35

Problem is the social convention of respecting another's choices despite not agreeing with them has long been broadly decreed into existence.

And also that even where there is a widespread social convention we should usually give space for those who don’t want to go along, and that this itself is central to true diversity and inclusion?

Of course, there's no obligation to be polite just as there's no obligation to socially include the impolite in social circles.

At work? That can border on discriminatory harassment & employers rightfully don't care for conflict particularly if it affects their bottom line.

"Problem is the social convention of respecting another's choices despite not agreeing with them has long been broadly decreed into existence"

Respect, of course, is earned not enforced.

In which societies has there" long been broad decrees that everyone must repsect everyone else's choices?" And what does this look like in practice?

Only in totalitarian regimes ( and there are quite a few around the world) is. a population expected to openly voice things they are actually in disagreement with, and/or which offends their own sensibilities.

Shortshriftandlethal · 25/10/2026 12:31

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:25

Children aren't 'unsafe' from learning about diversity in humans only from people who think they shouldn't.

Diversity is learned about by being exposed to diversity, not through indoctrination into correct thinking.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 12:31

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 11:37

Its particularly meaningless when you have men like India Willoughby describing themselves as a cis woman

Well, maybe sweetnsourr is one of the posters with the ability to detect who is and isn’t really transgender. They might be another user who should submit their knowledge to the world’s health organisations so that that ability is used to make lives better.

Maybe the poster doesn’t believe that Willoughby is really transgender at all so therefore the use of the word ‘cis’ as he uses it is not a trans person using the word, if you know what I mean.

Remember, there are posters who are not transgender themselves but who then post on MN FWR on behalf of trans people.

oldtiredcyclist · 25/10/2026 12:28

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:23

For the billionth time, sex & gender are two totally different concepts. Him/her can be both referencing sex or gender & that makes obvious sense given both cis & trans women exist.

For the vast majority of people, "cis women" do not exist, there are simply women and transwomen.

bellinisurge · 25/10/2026 12:27

Ironically this is the least fun group. Her stupidity is just part of the dullness

Shortshriftandlethal · 25/10/2026 12:22

Shortshriftandlethal · 25/10/2026 12:16

Was it she or the OP that used the term 'Philistine' I wonder?

Of course the term. 'Philistine' has become synonymous with suggesting someone is unspohisticated and primitive. The Philistines were a middle eastern tribe who fought with the Israelites at the time of King David, and from where the region and area now referred to as Palestine originated. 'Phoenicia' is modern day Lebanon.

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…
MarieDeGournay · 25/10/2026 12:17

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 11:20

Wow, finally a substantive argument however flawed that's an achievement! Well done.

But you are totally confused. Understanding the definition of a word doesn't mean you believe the phenomena that underpins it exists. Lots of people understand the definition of trans but don't necessarily agree the phenomena has legitimacy just like a lot of people understand what the word stress or depression means but still think these are non existent conditions.

Again, you act as if the brain can't hold two different thoughts at once.

If you were looking for an example of the condescending, de haut en bas, know-it-all, pretentious, snobby, disrespectful style of post I mentioned upthread, here's a humdinger!

Positively oooozes condescension, doesn't it?

Shortshriftandlethal · 25/10/2026 12:16

Was it she or the OP that used the term 'Philistine' I wonder?

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 25/10/2026 12:06

NotBadConsidering · 25/10/2026 09:30

I don’t think she knows what philistine means.

I am not a person who is “hostile, indifferent, or lacking in appreciation for art, culture, music, literature, and intellectual pursuits” simply because I won’t have my language controlled by genderwang.

I identify as a philistine, 'I don't know much about Art but I know what I like', I'm an old school philistine, and ever since the Tate's pile of bricks, I have zero interest or appreciation for anything the intelligentsia claim to be 'art'.
Literature is not worth the price of a book nowadays, it's all full of angst and tedious personal expose, it's all kitchen sink drama on steroids.
Intellectual pursuits nowadays usually means navel gazing claptrap.
So I'll happily accept the slur philistine.

HydrangeaFig · 25/10/2026 12:04

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 25/10/2026 09:52

Yes, you're right, I should have focused more on the 'gender fluid'... but even so, it's still performative when you announce to everybody that you're 'gender non-conforming' to the extent that it gets on to your Wikipedia page.

It also relies on the conviction that everybody has a 'gender' - and assumes that everybody else sticks rigidly and boringly to all of the stereotypes associated with that 'gender' (by which they usually mean sex, apart from when it's Schroedinger's gender, and they're deliberately seeking to dissociate it from sex).

Either way, it's essentially about being an individual and choosing to live your life as such. Nobody feels the need to mention that they are themselves, and are obviously not a different or generic person; so what's different with the whole 'gender' schtick.

Young, cool pop singer Mabel lives as herself - as do we all - and she doesn't feel the need to inform everybody at every turning that she is 'Mabel non-conforming', just because the majority of women who happen to be called Mabel (at least until the name came back into fashion) are now very elderly and are not famous pop singers. She doesn't need to identify as a 'young Mabel' or as an 'elderly Mabel' or as any other kind of Mabel who is and does what most Mabels are/aren't or do/don't do - she is just herself, which is absolutely as it should be for all of us.

If you go to "View history" on Chloe's Wikipedia article and then click on "oldest" it will show you that the page was created in 2024 by a user called Funcrunch. If you click on Funcrunch it takes you to their user page, which gives you a link to their personal website. Click on the link and it says in big letters that they (Funcrunch) are trans and use they/them pronouns. The first version of the page said that Chloe uses she/her and they/them pronouns but the page was actually written using "she". At a subsequent stage someone has changed "she" to "they" which I find makes it less easy to read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread