Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…

544 replies

Sugarleaf · 24/10/2026 22:47

…Who’s stuck in the past. To be ‘cool and curious’ you need to use non- biological sex based pronouns. And this is about a ‘certain generation.’ I mean I’m 32 and think it’s bollocks.

plus, as a bonus, ‘if you don’t like me, fine, as long as you use my correct pronouns.’

ffs

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:25

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:22

Its relevant to pronouns use

If I see a male what characteristic might help me to decide whether to refer to them as he or she

Its none of your business unless they tell you that's the purpose of pronouns. Gender is a spectrum so its not always obvious anyway.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:24

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:15

This is where you are bizarrely confused. Its like saying because I call my self a Christian everyone else must be one. Self identification is speaking for one's own interpretation of the world as it applies to them & noone else.

If this demented interpretation was anywhere connected to reality don't you think it would be illegal as well?

I am not "confused". I am simply prepared to think to through the actual implications of your beliefs in a way you are not.

I get that you will not allow yourelf clarity here and I do understand why. But nevertheless, whether you admit it to yourself our not, this is the place the things you believe end up.

Oh, and your "Christian" simile doesn't work, because most people don't call themselves "Christian".

What it is actually like is saying that you are a Christian because you eat fish on fridays and that's the only thing that being a Christian requires. Pissing off both the millions of people who also consider themselves Christian and think there's a little bit more to it than that, and the millions of other people who eat fish on Fridays and think the Bible is a bunch of fairy stories.

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:23

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:21

I said cis/natal woman.

That's not one word

Theeyeballsinthesky · 25/10/2026 21:23

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:20

Now you're venturing into territory outside of the subject matter of this thread which is pronouns usage so perhaps start another thread so its not derailed?

god you ppl are embarrassingly inept at arguing your case

I mean if I were a trans person, the ppl who come here and attempt what they think are coherent arguments are the last ppl I'd want in my corner

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:22

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:20

Now you're venturing into territory outside of the subject matter of this thread which is pronouns usage so perhaps start another thread so its not derailed?

Its relevant to pronouns use

If I see a male what characteristic might help me to decide whether to refer to them as he or she

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:21

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:14

People like her remind me of the really militant atheists (and I say this as an atheist) who bang on and on about even the smallest aspect of religion and say things like “oo if I go in the church it’ll burn down”. There’s a real ‘lady doth protest too much’ element to it. As though, if they get too close to the thing they reject - gender, religion - they’ll get sucked into it. Always suggests a bit of a flimsy sense of self or lack of confidence in who they are to me.

Absolutely. It feels like she’s trying to prove something to herself and insulting the rest of us in the process.

Hopefully she will get over whatever difficulties have brought her to this point and be more accepting of herself in the future.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:21

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:19

So you don't have a word that can be used exclusively for female human adults. Why is that when we have specific words for the different sexes of most animals

Edited

I said cis/natal woman.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:20

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:18

somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way.

Could you give some examples of this 'typical behaviour' for each sex?

Now you're venturing into territory outside of the subject matter of this thread which is pronouns usage so perhaps start another thread so its not derailed?

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:19

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:17

As I said woman & man possess both sex & gendered connotations so that's where prefixes like trans & cis/natal solves the distinction.

Edited

So you don't have a word that can be used exclusively for female human adults. Why is that when we have specific words for the different sexes of most animals

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:18

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:02

"Trans gender" is a ubiquitous term in modern liberal societies. People might not know the ins & outs of gender but they would know its somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way. That they might disagree on how trans people come into being is a moot point because either way they exist.

That you believe people can't tell the difference between the concepts of a natal woman/man & a trans woman/man is severely underestimating human intelligence but perhaps you are speaking for yourself.

That we should agree there should be better terminology shows an ignorance of the most basic mechanism of why gendered terms exist in the first place which is an association to common sexed behaviour. And while common sexed behaviour distinctions exist so to will their associations to them.

Good luck with changing that btw.

somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way.

Could you give some examples of this 'typical behaviour' for each sex?

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:17

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:14

If woman and man are gendered words what word would you use for female adult humans that excludes male adult humans

As I said woman & man possess both sex & gendered connotations so that's where prefixes like trans & cis/natal solves the distinction.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:15

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:10

Now this is of course a problem, because when a trans woman names herself a "woman", she is thereby misgendering me.

But again, you know this. We've ridden this roundabout many times before. We both know you will twist and turn and never ever ever give a coherent answer as to why a transwoman's understanding of himself as a woman because of his mind should have more authority than my understanding of myself as a woman because of my body.

I don't have much urge to repeat the same points, but I'll find some links of the previous runarounds for you.

This is where you are bizarrely confused. Its like saying because I call my self a Christian everyone else must be one. Self identification is speaking for one's own interpretation of the world as it applies to them & noone else.

If this demented interpretation was anywhere connected to reality don't you think it would be illegal as well?

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:14

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:07

Being hostile to difference

This is the thing though. She is not different. She’s a woman, like all other women. She may be clever and funny (I’m taking pps word for this as I have no idea who she is) but she is still a woman and gets the same pronouns as the rest of us.

Her stance sets all other women up as conforming to some humdrum ‘stereotype’ of womanning that she is way above because she is so special and different. She conveniently forgets that we all have our own interests and personalities that often don’t remotely conform to the stereotypes. It is quite an arrogant and insulting position to hold.

People like her remind me of the really militant atheists (and I say this as an atheist) who bang on and on about even the smallest aspect of religion and say things like “oo if I go in the church it’ll burn down”. There’s a real ‘lady doth protest too much’ element to it. As though, if they get too close to the thing they reject - gender, religion - they’ll get sucked into it. Always suggests a bit of a flimsy sense of self or lack of confidence in who they are to me.

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:14

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:10

A natal male that associates with the gender of natal female is a trans gender woman. Woman/man denotes sex & gendered associations.

If woman and man are gendered words what word would you use for female adult humans that excludes male adult humans

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:13

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:10

A natal male that associates with the gender of natal female is a trans gender woman. Woman/man denotes sex & gendered associations.

So, sex and gender are very different but also have to use the same names. Bit daft, no? Bit almost-certain-to-lead-to-confusion-distress-and-a-bunch-of-expensive-and-embrassing-court-cases?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:11

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:07

Being hostile to difference

This is the thing though. She is not different. She’s a woman, like all other women. She may be clever and funny (I’m taking pps word for this as I have no idea who she is) but she is still a woman and gets the same pronouns as the rest of us.

Her stance sets all other women up as conforming to some humdrum ‘stereotype’ of womanning that she is way above because she is so special and different. She conveniently forgets that we all have our own interests and personalities that often don’t remotely conform to the stereotypes. It is quite an arrogant and insulting position to hold.

A bit more than "quite", in my opinion!

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:10

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:00

You keep saying this, but I think it would be helpful if you explained what you think the relationship is between sex and gender (if any).

Genderists use sex-based pronouns to denote gender, so sex and gender can't be completely unrelated to each other in genderists' minds.

For example, what is the gender of a man who wants to be a woman? His sex is still male, but what is his gender?

A natal male that associates with the gender of natal female is a trans gender woman. Woman/man denotes sex & gendered associations.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:10

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:05

Noone is being compelled to "mouth the words". They just can't deliberately misgender in the work place. If they don't want to 'mouth the words" the ycan use the person's name. Much ado about nothing…

Now this is of course a problem, because when a trans woman names herself a "woman", she is thereby misgendering me.

But again, you know this. We've ridden this roundabout many times before. We both know you will twist and turn and never ever ever give a coherent answer as to why a transwoman's understanding of himself as a woman because of his mind should have more authority than my understanding of myself as a woman because of my body.

I don't have much urge to repeat the same points, but I'll find some links of the previous runarounds for you.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:07

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 25/10/2026 16:16

I'm sorry your life is so dull, that you think 'just be tolerant, and learn about difference' is funny 😁

I've learned no transphobia at all, true.

Being hostile to difference, attempting to justify it by inventing bizarre conspiracy theories - then reading similarly ignorant people's conspiracy theories - isn't scholarship. It's literally just bigots trying to prove themselves right.

Being hostile to difference

This is the thing though. She is not different. She’s a woman, like all other women. She may be clever and funny (I’m taking pps word for this as I have no idea who she is) but she is still a woman and gets the same pronouns as the rest of us.

Her stance sets all other women up as conforming to some humdrum ‘stereotype’ of womanning that she is way above because she is so special and different. She conveniently forgets that we all have our own interests and personalities that often don’t remotely conform to the stereotypes. It is quite an arrogant and insulting position to hold.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:07

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:02

"Trans gender" is a ubiquitous term in modern liberal societies. People might not know the ins & outs of gender but they would know its somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way. That they might disagree on how trans people come into being is a moot point because either way they exist.

That you believe people can't tell the difference between the concepts of a natal woman/man & a trans woman/man is severely underestimating human intelligence but perhaps you are speaking for yourself.

That we should agree there should be better terminology shows an ignorance of the most basic mechanism of why gendered terms exist in the first place which is an association to common sexed behaviour. And while common sexed behaviour distinctions exist so to will their associations to them.

Good luck with changing that btw.

You misunderstand.

Obviously, everyone can tell the difference between female people and the vast majority of those male people who pretend to be female, (and vice versa for those female people who pretend to be male)

But what has pretending to be a different sex got to do with this "gender" thing?

As I said, "gender" certainly does not apply to the great many things that were labelled as "man" or "woman" using the original sex-based meanings way before the phrase "gender identity" was coined - for example single sex spaces like bogs, changing rooms and prisons, the politcal movement of Feminism, the history of female people, and women's sports, to name but a few examples.

So, when you say "woman" now means a type of mixed sex gender identity rather than simply of the female sex, what does this new "gender" of woman have to do with the original use of "woman" to mean female sex? What's the connection here between these two different things that justifes taking the name of one and using it for the other?

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:06

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:02

"Trans gender" is a ubiquitous term in modern liberal societies. People might not know the ins & outs of gender but they would know its somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way. That they might disagree on how trans people come into being is a moot point because either way they exist.

That you believe people can't tell the difference between the concepts of a natal woman/man & a trans woman/man is severely underestimating human intelligence but perhaps you are speaking for yourself.

That we should agree there should be better terminology shows an ignorance of the most basic mechanism of why gendered terms exist in the first place which is an association to common sexed behaviour. And while common sexed behaviour distinctions exist so to will their associations to them.

Good luck with changing that btw.

People might not know the ins & outs of gender but they would know its somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way

A cursory look at trans supportive comments across social media would suggest a significant amount of people believe someone transgender is an unfortunate person who has been ‘born in the wrong body’.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:05

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 20:50

Compelling someone to speak using terminology which conflicts with their beliefs could also be considered harassment.

Edited for clarity.

Edited

Noone is being compelled to "mouth the words". They just can't deliberately misgender in the work place. If they don't want to 'mouth the words" the ycan use the person's name. Much ado about nothing…

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:02

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 20:47

Indeed sex is not gender. I entirely agree.

This is why using words that have always meant sex to label this totally unconnected thing "gender" is causing so many problems.

It is true that in some parts of society, "Man" and "Woman" have reecently been partially appropriated to label personal feelings of "gender", but this is by no means at all a generally accepted meaning, and certainly does not apply to the great many pre-existing things that were labelled as "man" or "woman" using the original sex-based meanings way before the phrase "gender identity" was coined - for example single sex spaces like bogs, changing rooms and prisons, the politcal movement of Feminism, the history of female people, and women's sports, to name but a few examples.

Clearly, this new and very niche use of "man" and "woman" to label the inchoate concept of "gender" is an unhelpful and misleading, not to mention sexist, development.

In a rational world we should all, Genderists and Feminists alike, be agreeing a much better approach for all concerned is to coin new terminology entirely separate from "man" and "woman", and indeed from any originally sex-based language, to label this thing Gender that, whether or not we happn to agree is a good thing in its own right, we do all agree is different to sex.

Because as I said, appropriating other people's reality as a metaphor for ones own identity is not a "right", it is an offensive negation of other people's right to their own identities, their own self knowledge and their connection to their own history.

Edited

"Trans gender" is a ubiquitous term in modern liberal societies. People might not know the ins & outs of gender but they would know its somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way. That they might disagree on how trans people come into being is a moot point because either way they exist.

That you believe people can't tell the difference between the concepts of a natal woman/man & a trans woman/man is severely underestimating human intelligence but perhaps you are speaking for yourself.

That we should agree there should be better terminology shows an ignorance of the most basic mechanism of why gendered terms exist in the first place which is an association to common sexed behaviour. And while common sexed behaviour distinctions exist so to will their associations to them.

Good luck with changing that btw.

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:00

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 20:36

As has been explained to you many times before, sex is not gender.

You keep saying this, but I think it would be helpful if you explained what you think the relationship is between sex and gender (if any).

Genderists use sex-based pronouns to denote gender, so sex and gender can't be completely unrelated to each other in genderists' minds.

For example, what is the gender of a man who wants to be a woman? His sex is still male, but what is his gender?

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 20:52

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 20:41

No its an example of respecting another's right to their preferences however invalid we may find them. Other examples would be using 'dr' for social scientists or 'madam' 'sir' 'Ms' instead of 'Mrs'…none of which confer any authority.

It’s your example of people who believe royal & aristocratic titles are made up out of date clap, ignoring and subsuming their own beliefs due to ‘politeness’. Sounds pretty deferential.