Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…

544 replies

Sugarleaf · 24/10/2026 22:47

…Who’s stuck in the past. To be ‘cool and curious’ you need to use non- biological sex based pronouns. And this is about a ‘certain generation.’ I mean I’m 32 and think it’s bollocks.

plus, as a bonus, ‘if you don’t like me, fine, as long as you use my correct pronouns.’

ffs

Taskmaster: if you don’t use ‘correct’ pronouns you’re a philistine…
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:51

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:46

Lots of things in the world impact our inherent traits. Just because a person is white/black/asian/disabled/ homosexual etc doesn't mean that they centre their identity around that trait.

Exactly.

Which is why someone's "identity" is irrelevent to needs and rights, language and anaysis, concerning the impact of an inherent trait like sex.

And therefore why using the language of sex, including the very-much-originaly-and-for-most-people-still-sex-based words "man" and "woman" to mean anything to do with gender is such a bad idea.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:49

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 21:46

How? If you don’t know their name.
You can still refer to another person without knowing their name.

For example “It was that man over there, he left his bag on the seat”.

How does language function without sex based pronouns?

No offense but you sound like a gametal obsessive needing to know everyone's sex. Just use 'there's a person over there' & describe them if you are unsure.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:47

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:42

You know what sex stereotypes are surely being gender critical so don't come at me with trolling like you don't.

I think you misunderstand why you are being asked.

People want to know is what sex stereotypes mean to you because you are basing your arguments on them.

Obviously, applying our understanding of sex steroetypes as Gender Critical Feminists in your logic doesn't work, because if one uses our definitions in your logic, your logic ends up defining people by outmoded and limiting stereotypes which I assume (at least I hope) is not what you think you are advocating for.

Therefore, to make sense of your position, we need your definitions not ours.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:46

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:42

My reality is that I am an embodied female. This will impact my life regardless of how I may or may not identify. I need language to express this clearly, and sometimes I need rights and protections, physical or otherwise, because of it.

This is a reality I share in one way or another with every other female human there is, was or will be, and with no male human now or ever.

On what basis is someone's identity relevent to this?

Lots of things in the world impact our inherent traits. Just because a person is white/black/asian/disabled/ homosexual etc doesn't mean that they centre their identity around that trait.

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 21:46

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:40

Use their name then. Its really not that hard.

How? If you don’t know their name.
You can still refer to another person without knowing their name.

For example “It was that man over there, he left his bag on the seat”.

How does language function without sex based pronouns?

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:44

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:42

You know what sex stereotypes are surely being gender critical so don't come at me with trolling like you don't.

Being gender critical means that I reject sex stereotypes. I don't use them to try and determine someone's "gender"

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:43

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:35

It’s ok to admit you have no answer.

Um, not indulging trolling isn't an admission of ignorance dear.

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 21:43

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:25

Its none of your business unless they tell you that's the purpose of pronouns. Gender is a spectrum so its not always obvious anyway.

The purpose of pronouns is to enable one to refer to a third person clearly without using their name.
They are a general part of language function.
They don’t “belong” to individuals.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:42

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:39

At least you are clear that it is an internally experienced and subjective feeling so isn’t at all relevant to the rest of us.

All self identification is subjective including basing your identity on sex instead of gender. The traits that defines ones self are a values belief based choice not an objective truth. That objective facts exist that people use to define themselves isn't the same as choosing to centre or define their identity by them.

My reality is that I am an embodied female. This will impact my life regardless of how I may or may not identify. I need language to express this clearly, and sometimes I need rights and protections, physical or otherwise, because of it.

This is a reality I share in one way or another with every other female human there is, was or will be, and with no male human now or ever.

On what basis is someone's identity relevent to this?

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:42

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:36

Perhaps you shouldn't have derailed it by saying that gendered terms only exist because of "common sexed behaviour".

If you're going to argue that sexed pronouns only exist because of these behaviours you should be able to name the behaviours the pronouns are based on.

It's relevant to this thread about pronouns because according to you, there would be no sexed/gendered pronouns if these behaviours didn't exist.

So what are those behaviours?

You know what sex stereotypes are surely being gender critical so don't come at me with trolling like you don't.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:40

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:36

They are nowhere near me. Never spoken to them. Don’t know who they are. Not allowed to speak about them?

ETA. Given you’ve said pronouns are based on sexed behaviour, couldn’t I just observe that? What should I be looking for?

Edited

Use their name then. Its really not that hard.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:39

At least you are clear that it is an internally experienced and subjective feeling so isn’t at all relevant to the rest of us.

All self identification is subjective including basing your identity on sex instead of gender. The traits that defines ones self are a values belief based choice not an objective truth. That objective facts exist that people use to define themselves isn't the same as choosing to centre or define their identity by them.

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:37

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:21

I said cis/natal woman.

That's what you said.

What you actually mean is "woman".

There are no male women.

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:36

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:33

Maybe ask them if they have preferred pronouns?

They are nowhere near me. Never spoken to them. Don’t know who they are. Not allowed to speak about them?

ETA. Given you’ve said pronouns are based on sexed behaviour, couldn’t I just observe that? What should I be looking for?

OldCrone · 25/10/2026 21:36

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:20

Now you're venturing into territory outside of the subject matter of this thread which is pronouns usage so perhaps start another thread so its not derailed?

Perhaps you shouldn't have derailed it by saying that gendered terms only exist because of "common sexed behaviour".

If you're going to argue that sexed pronouns only exist because of these behaviours you should be able to name the behaviours the pronouns are based on.

It's relevant to this thread about pronouns because according to you, there would be no sexed/gendered pronouns if these behaviours didn't exist.

So what are those behaviours?

nutmeg7 · 25/10/2026 21:35

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:25

Its none of your business unless they tell you that's the purpose of pronouns. Gender is a spectrum so its not always obvious anyway.

Oh so there must be a spectrum of pronouns then.

What are they?

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:35

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:31

Look it up yourself if its not self evident which it is to every rational being. I'm not your personal dictionary.

I don't do trolling.

It’s ok to admit you have no answer.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:35

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:31

Look it up yourself if its not self evident which it is to every rational being. I'm not your personal dictionary.

I don't do trolling.

Word to the wise.

You might think telling someone to "look up" a concept you have been basing your entire argument on is a clever way of avoiding having to say something concrete and having it immediately be challenged due to its inherent sexism.

It's not. It just makes you look evasive, unable to make your case, or both.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:34

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:25

Its none of your business unless they tell you that's the purpose of pronouns. Gender is a spectrum so its not always obvious anyway.

At least you are clear that it is an internally experienced and subjective feeling so isn’t at all relevant to the rest of us.

Particularly when we are calling out a man for using a space set aside for women as sex segregated spaces are based on sex not some internal feelings of ‘spectrum’.

I knew you’d get there eventually.

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:33

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:30

So I see someone male at work. I say to another person “Who’s that? I’ve never seen him before” and they say “are you some kind of philistine, they are a ‘she’ (or indeed ‘they’)”. How would I have known their ‘correct’ pronouns?

Maybe ask them if they have preferred pronouns?

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:31

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:29

On the contrary, it is precisely within the subject matter of this thread. The comedienne is rejecting what she perceives the stereotype of female or woman.

You purport to know a lot about all this, and offered the definition of *somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way.

The least you can do is explain what you mean by these sex stereotypes.

Look it up yourself if its not self evident which it is to every rational being. I'm not your personal dictionary.

I don't do trolling.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 25/10/2026 21:31

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:19

So you don't have a word that can be used exclusively for female human adults. Why is that when we have specific words for the different sexes of most animals

Edited

Not just the sex of aninals - apparently different hair colours, or people who live on different sides of the Mersey, are also different enough to need their own names.

But the different sexes of humanity? Meh, just bundle that up with some unverifable, unobservable, self-claimed, never-defined, not-even-the-same-for-each-person quality of "gender" and it'll be fine.

After all, it's not like what physical sex you are has any actual practical impacts in your life, is it?🙄

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 21:30

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:25

Its none of your business unless they tell you that's the purpose of pronouns. Gender is a spectrum so its not always obvious anyway.

So I see someone male at work. I say to another person “Who’s that? I’ve never seen him before” and they say “are you some kind of philistine, they are a ‘she’ (or indeed ‘they’)”. How would I have known their ‘correct’ pronouns?

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 25/10/2026 21:29

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:20

Now you're venturing into territory outside of the subject matter of this thread which is pronouns usage so perhaps start another thread so its not derailed?

On the contrary, it is precisely within the subject matter of this thread. The comedienne is rejecting what she perceives the stereotype of female or woman.

You purport to know a lot about all this, and offered the definition of *somebody who doesn't conform to the typical behaviour of their sex & wants to live that way.

The least you can do is explain what you mean by these sex stereotypes.

spannasaurus · 25/10/2026 21:28

sweetnsourr · 25/10/2026 21:25

Its none of your business unless they tell you that's the purpose of pronouns. Gender is a spectrum so its not always obvious anyway.

So to be safe and not assume anything about a person's gender i should stick with non discrimatory sex based pronouns for everyone