Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
cryupmykingdom · 28/10/2026 14:07

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 09:15

It’s not possible to request the sex of a treating doctor in Emergency

That is inaccurate. It is possible to request one, we all know it is - but you seemed very sure that it was not possible, in the same way that you were sure the level 5 regional hospital in question was "tiny", when we all know it's not. Now, whether a woman will be provided with a Dr of her preferred sex is unknown, but that's very different from it not being possible for her to make that request.

I appreciate that you then sought to justify your initial claims when these were challenged as inaccurate statements and changed your later wording. That is not 'picking', nor did posters misunderstand your unambiguous initial claims.

I'm being pedantic but surely the only situation in which it 'would not be possible to request' would be where even making the request would see you frogmarched to the door by the security-wallah.

What is meant here is surely 'it is not possible to insist that the request be honoured or acted on.'

Helleofabore · 28/10/2026 14:07

Newname26 · 28/10/2026 13:26

I actually don't think a female could give informed consent if they have asked for a woman and got him.
I think it could be a form of assault.

Just need some strong Auzzie to take him to court

I agree.

It is not fully informed. And if a woman or girl asked for female doctor and got a male doctor, even if they assumed good faith he was male, that cannot be considered freely given consent. Because the patient asked for a female doctor and trusted the hospital that this would be a female doctor. A woman or girl could have any number of reasons to not understand the full situation including sight difficulties.

However on the other thread, there is at least one poster who has claimed that language is very fluid and that he would be in the right not to expect to disclose his medical information and his personal definition of the word female includes him. They refuse to answer the direct and accurate question just constantly deflect and post abtruse paragraphs in defence of their philosophical belief.

But good to find out whether people supporting him believe women can give consent this way or not.

Emilesgran · 28/10/2026 14:03

Newname26 · 28/10/2026 13:26

I actually don't think a female could give informed consent if they have asked for a woman and got him.
I think it could be a form of assault.

Just need some strong Auzzie to take him to court

The problem is that Sall Grover’s judgment seems to be based on the idea that TWAW because the law says so.

I’m not quite sure how far up the system her case has gone (has she exhausted all the appeals?) but it seems that judges are taking the position that the law is clear and that if the law is wrong it’s up to the government to change the law, not for the courts system to find work-arounds so as to continue the pretence without subjecting the country to ridicule.

International ridicule it must be, apparently. So I wouldn’t be at all sure that it “just needs” another court case.

cryupmykingdom · 28/10/2026 13:54

The reason the name 'Macquarie' is found all around Australia is he was governor of New South Wales, at a time when 'New South Wales' constituted more than half the Australian continent.

So, Hobart, what would become the second state, Tasmania, has a Macquarie Street, as do Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane . . . I'd be surprised if there's any big city that doesn't have one.

Scots names are very noticeable in Australia and NZ (way more so than in England) just as they are in other Scots hangouts, like Hong Kong and Penang.

Newname26 · 28/10/2026 13:26

Helleofabore · 28/10/2026 12:49

I think it would be great to clarify if anyone who defends Dr Upton believes that a female patient can give consent that is with full knowledge and no coercion if a male doctor (who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans and who they trust would act ethically and that they have to trust to treat them) presented themselves as being the female doctor that they requested?

It does seem that when that question is asked it gets ignored.

I actually don't think a female could give informed consent if they have asked for a woman and got him.
I think it could be a form of assault.

Just need some strong Auzzie to take him to court

Helleofabore · 28/10/2026 12:49

I think it would be great to clarify if anyone who defends Dr Upton believes that a female patient can give consent that is with full knowledge and no coercion if a male doctor (who they expect to understand the difference between male and female humans and who they trust would act ethically and that they have to trust to treat them) presented themselves as being the female doctor that they requested?

It does seem that when that question is asked it gets ignored.

Newname26 · 28/10/2026 11:57

Its not just Doctors its everyone from Surgeons to the student Nurse.

If someone requests same sex care its so wrong to fob them of with a person pretending to be that sex.

I've thought. older men would prefer same sex care. But I can't imagine any 25 man would be that happy with a trans person pretending to be their sex help them in a shower.

Its a different level of exposure. Its not like a gynecologist with his hand up your hoof, when he's seen many hoofs before, while keeping as much dignity as possible. Your dignity is gone.

MyAmpleSheep · 28/10/2026 11:35

Just to be clear, if a female patient asks for a female doctor at that hospital are they going to be told “we don’t do that here” or “let me see if I can find one, it may take a bit longer”? And if the latter, is DU going to turn up and offer himself? I think that’s the salient question.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 28/10/2026 11:08

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:09

@SirChenjins I have no interest in replying further to you. No doubt you’ll claim this as a win for you, but I’m tired of rehashing the same thing with you over and over and not getting through. You are either a little dense or disingenuous. (I’ll go with disingenuous.) Not posting in good faith, anyway.

In defence of SirChenjins, I think the issue may be that you have an unusual understanding of the word "request". Here is one dictionary definition:

the act of asking for something to be given or done, especially as a favour or courtesy; solicitation or petition.

You appear to be using the word "request" to mean "demand".

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 10:50

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:09

@SirChenjins I have no interest in replying further to you. No doubt you’ll claim this as a win for you, but I’m tired of rehashing the same thing with you over and over and not getting through. You are either a little dense or disingenuous. (I’ll go with disingenuous.) Not posting in good faith, anyway.

Excellent.

Now both points have been clarified, let's get back to discussing the rights of women and the man (a Dr of all people) who has shown nothing but contempt for them.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 28/10/2026 10:28

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:17

Bez, Port Mac is actually a really beautiful beach location. That’s why it’s popular with retirees.

The reason ‘Macquarie’ pops up so often as a place name or other name (there’s even a Macquarie University) is a former Governor of NSW from 1810 called Lachlan Macquarie. So it’s a hangover from the colonial age.

Not to mention Macquarie Bank that asset stripped Thames Water to the tune of £2.9 billion.

NotBadConsidering · 28/10/2026 10:25

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:21

You don’t have to read it. I can post if I wish.

Not when you’re filling up the thread with circular arguments when the real issue of what happened to this woman is being forgotten.

What’s your view on how this woman was treated? What’s your view on the fact a man was offered as a woman?

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:21

NotBadConsidering · 28/10/2026 10:17

Good, stop going on about it. It’s been put to bed. It IS possible, like everyone has said.

You don’t have to read it. I can post if I wish.

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:17

BezMark · 28/10/2026 10:07

Looking at the map, PM wouldn't be my first second or third choice of location, at all.

I got a bit mixed up about the location because bladdy every other geographical feature is named after this fella MacQuarie. I've spent a wee bit of time near Lake MacQuarie which is obviously nowhere near Port MacQuarie, why would it be?

I spent a few months working in one of the big finance companies in the Sydney CBD and some further months going feral in Byron. Port MacQuarie is definitely flyover country for me, no offence!

Bez, Port Mac is actually a really beautiful beach location. That’s why it’s popular with retirees.

The reason ‘Macquarie’ pops up so often as a place name or other name (there’s even a Macquarie University) is a former Governor of NSW from 1810 called Lachlan Macquarie. So it’s a hangover from the colonial age.

NotBadConsidering · 28/10/2026 10:17

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:09

@SirChenjins I have no interest in replying further to you. No doubt you’ll claim this as a win for you, but I’m tired of rehashing the same thing with you over and over and not getting through. You are either a little dense or disingenuous. (I’ll go with disingenuous.) Not posting in good faith, anyway.

Good, stop going on about it. It’s been put to bed. It IS possible, like everyone has said.

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 10:09

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 09:15

It’s not possible to request the sex of a treating doctor in Emergency

That is inaccurate. It is possible to request one, we all know it is - but you seemed very sure that it was not possible, in the same way that you were sure the level 5 regional hospital in question was "tiny", when we all know it's not. Now, whether a woman will be provided with a Dr of her preferred sex is unknown, but that's very different from it not being possible for her to make that request.

I appreciate that you then sought to justify your initial claims when these were challenged as inaccurate statements and changed your later wording. That is not 'picking', nor did posters misunderstand your unambiguous initial claims.

@SirChenjins I have no interest in replying further to you. No doubt you’ll claim this as a win for you, but I’m tired of rehashing the same thing with you over and over and not getting through. You are either a little dense or disingenuous. (I’ll go with disingenuous.) Not posting in good faith, anyway.

BezMark · 28/10/2026 10:07

Looking at the map, PM wouldn't be my first second or third choice of location, at all.

I got a bit mixed up about the location because bladdy every other geographical feature is named after this fella MacQuarie. I've spent a wee bit of time near Lake MacQuarie which is obviously nowhere near Port MacQuarie, why would it be?

I spent a few months working in one of the big finance companies in the Sydney CBD and some further months going feral in Byron. Port MacQuarie is definitely flyover country for me, no offence!

Datun · 28/10/2026 09:59

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 07:45

No. You just don’t appear to understand that the statement “It’s not possible to request a female doctor” doesn’t preclude anyone from actually saying “Can I have a female doctor?” They can. It doesn’t mean that in a busy ED environment that one will be provided straight away, though.

But because you wanted to keep picking, you pretended not to understand that, I suppose.

There were no inaccuracies.

The thing is, given Australia's current attitude to women and their needs (because of identity politics), where they have effectively ruled that there is no such thing as a woman, to many people, it would be entirely plausible that you're not allowed to make that distinction.

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 09:57

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 09:15

It’s not possible to request the sex of a treating doctor in Emergency

That is inaccurate. It is possible to request one, we all know it is - but you seemed very sure that it was not possible, in the same way that you were sure the level 5 regional hospital in question was "tiny", when we all know it's not. Now, whether a woman will be provided with a Dr of her preferred sex is unknown, but that's very different from it not being possible for her to make that request.

I appreciate that you then sought to justify your initial claims when these were challenged as inaccurate statements and changed your later wording. That is not 'picking', nor did posters misunderstand your unambiguous initial claims.

“We all know” - what, you’ve all been there? Extraordinary.

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 09:15

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 07:45

No. You just don’t appear to understand that the statement “It’s not possible to request a female doctor” doesn’t preclude anyone from actually saying “Can I have a female doctor?” They can. It doesn’t mean that in a busy ED environment that one will be provided straight away, though.

But because you wanted to keep picking, you pretended not to understand that, I suppose.

There were no inaccuracies.

It’s not possible to request the sex of a treating doctor in Emergency

That is inaccurate. It is possible to request one, we all know it is - but you seemed very sure that it was not possible, in the same way that you were sure the level 5 regional hospital in question was "tiny", when we all know it's not. Now, whether a woman will be provided with a Dr of her preferred sex is unknown, but that's very different from it not being possible for her to make that request.

I appreciate that you then sought to justify your initial claims when these were challenged as inaccurate statements and changed your later wording. That is not 'picking', nor did posters misunderstand your unambiguous initial claims.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 28/10/2026 08:59

cryupmykingdom · 27/10/2026 09:39

Only use "cisgender" when attributed. The term may be unfamiliar to many, and is offensive to some. [BBC Style Guide, 2026]

My little campaign against the c_s slur appears to have borne fruit.

C-s is part of what Robert J Lifton calls cults 'milieu control', framing things according to the cult's view as tho it's normal. It's best to avoid their jargon.

Edited

Yes, absolutely.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 28/10/2026 08:56

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 01:05

No, I thought because I live in the actual region this took place some local knowledge might be of interest. Instead, everything I wrote was picked apart. It’s incredible to know that the women of Britain know more about the ins and outs of regional hospitals in NSW than a woman living in regional NSW, whose Grandmother died in that actual hospital! Just amazing.

Tbf several of the other posters on this thread appear to live in or be familiar with the same area.

MarieDeGournay · 28/10/2026 08:26

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 07:45

No. You just don’t appear to understand that the statement “It’s not possible to request a female doctor” doesn’t preclude anyone from actually saying “Can I have a female doctor?” They can. It doesn’t mean that in a busy ED environment that one will be provided straight away, though.

But because you wanted to keep picking, you pretended not to understand that, I suppose.

There were no inaccuracies.

I'm sorry if references to this hospital have brought up sad memories of the death of your grandmother.

Is this a case for 'can' v 'may'?

There's no doubt that anyone CAN speak the words
'I want to be treated by a female doctor'.
The issue is -
[a] do you have the right to ask to be treated by a female not a male doctor ? in other words MAY you ask for a female doctor;
[b] does the hospital have the duty to respect your wishes?
[c] if it does have that duty, will it consider a trans-IDing male doctor as meeting your request for a female doctor?

Anyone can say 'Can I have a female doctor?' and I think we all accept pragmatically that asking doesn’t mean that in a busy ED environment that one will be provided straight away, though.
and in the circumstances a woman may decide to accept a male doctor.

But what if if someone asks 'Can I have a female doctor?' and the response is 'Of course, no problem - Dr Upton? could you come and see this patient please....'

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 07:45

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 06:31

It was picked apart because you posted inaccuracies.

Edited

No. You just don’t appear to understand that the statement “It’s not possible to request a female doctor” doesn’t preclude anyone from actually saying “Can I have a female doctor?” They can. It doesn’t mean that in a busy ED environment that one will be provided straight away, though.

But because you wanted to keep picking, you pretended not to understand that, I suppose.

There were no inaccuracies.

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 06:31

LadyCapybara · 28/10/2026 01:05

No, I thought because I live in the actual region this took place some local knowledge might be of interest. Instead, everything I wrote was picked apart. It’s incredible to know that the women of Britain know more about the ins and outs of regional hospitals in NSW than a woman living in regional NSW, whose Grandmother died in that actual hospital! Just amazing.

It was picked apart because you posted inaccuracies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread