Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:55

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 09:40

I’m not “denying” it. 🙄 I’m saying the DM did not present any specific evidence of NSW Health offering Dr Upton as a female doctor option after the patient asked for one.

I think the sequence of events is that Dr Upton was the first doctor the saw her in the ED. It was only after that she requested to be seen by a female doctor only - and that would make sense. But that is only my supposition and I have no evidence for it, obviously.

Great. My post was asking generally if people saying it didn’t happen, that Upton was not presenting himself as a female doctor to a patient that requested a female doctor or is following policy if he did, can support this with the guidance that makes them so confident that it didn’t happen.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 29/10/2026 09:40

Newname26 · 29/10/2026 09:02

Sandie is honest
Theo / Beth / Liz is not can't even keep his name straight

Theo / Beth / Liz is not can't even keep his name straight

It's been reported that his name is now Lis (does this rhyme with cis?).

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 09:40

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 04:58

And yet, NSW Health may be just that stupid (or the relevant people who have responsibility in that hospital). Hence the discussion. I don’t believe anyone has provided clarity since the story broke.

If Health VIC allows this to happen, why are we to believe NSW Health wouldn’t? After all, the states would need to compost to the federal policy which would be impacted by the Anti-discrimination act.

If anyone is denying that this would have happened, any links to guidance to support that claim? After all, surely if someone is denying this could have happened they would have something to support that statement?

Women’s groups around Australia have found no published guidance for NSW Health, if you are denying it could have happened, what do you personally know that others don’t?

After all, if it could not have happened it would be very much in women’s interests to have this confirmed that there is a policy to prevent it happening. Please link up the guidance so that we can read it and send links to the women’s groups who have missed it.

I’m not “denying” it. 🙄 I’m saying the DM did not present any specific evidence of NSW Health offering Dr Upton as a female doctor option after the patient asked for one.

I think the sequence of events is that Dr Upton was the first doctor the saw her in the ED. It was only after that she requested to be seen by a female doctor only - and that would make sense. But that is only my supposition and I have no evidence for it, obviously.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:32

Remember too, we have seen people disparage this woman for having her husband there for her by at least one person.

"Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor"

This kind of reaction from people on account of her speaking out, even through an intermediary, is a huge deterrent. She has to still continue to live in the area if she is a local.

But apparently, we must believe that

-it never happened,

-that he has the right to not disclose his medical information to patients who request a female doctor,

-that she was a racist or general bigot and would have rejected him because he was English or another reason, not because he was a male doctor and she needed a female doctor,

-that a regional hospital will not have any female doctor available at all, even with a wait for treatment,

-that discussing the intention admitted under oath in court in the past does not give any indication to whether he would do this now,

-that if the patient was not offered treatment by this male doctor, that she should not have mentioned her concern at all either even though her concern highlights a very significant issue that the general public does not have clarity about their own rights in the instance if a male doctor DID present himself as a female doctor when a patient requests a female doctor.

Newname26 · 29/10/2026 09:02

Sandie is honest
Theo / Beth / Liz is not can't even keep his name straight

Hoardasurass · 29/10/2026 08:41

Galexia · 24/10/2026 22:11

Nurse Peggie is a nasty piece of work.

Dr Upton is by all accounts a good doctor and a nice person, but needs to stop conflating biological truth with gender identity imo.

The patient in Australia has the right to be treated by a biological female.

No hes not.
Hes lied about his sex, lied about sandie and kept notes about her refusal to change with him, has admitted under oath that he intends to sexually assault female patients who ask for female care and harmed an elderly patient at a previous hospital by kicking off and falsely reported her for abuse because she called him son.
That is not a good dr of nice person by any measure. Sandie on the other hand is a wonderful nurse with an amazing bedside manor and for those of us who have actually been treated by her or have family members who have can attest to how much she cares about her patients and their needs. Dr Upton should have been taking notes about how she treats patients so he could learn to be a decent human being not to try and bully her into stripping off in front of him for his own personal gratification or punishing her for not doing so

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 08:23

cryupmykingdom · 29/10/2026 08:18

I think you mean 'comport'

Nah. I meant to write comply. But my eyesight on the small screen doesn’t catch all the autocorrect changes.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 08:22

Imdunfer · 29/10/2026 08:13

But we know that a woman was so in fear of being compelled to accept a doctor who she could see was male that she asked her husband to stay with her to prevent that from happening.

So you have to ask how the hospital created that fear in that woman, if they didn't send a male when she asked for a female, or if she didn't ask for a female after seeing Upton and he and/or the hospital gave her the impression he would be examining her against her wishes?

She also told a friend that she was deeply concerned about it.

Apparently, though this expression of concern is to be dismissed if the patient hasn’t made a direct report to the media, putting herself at risk of negative repercussions. Including a law suit if she uses words that describe a male person as a male person as we are seeing in the cases of Kirrilie Smith and Jasmine Sussex.

When does dismissing an account due to lack of media statement become victim blaming under the current conditions of women seeing what is happening to Kirrilie Smith and Jasmine Sussex?

cryupmykingdom · 29/10/2026 08:18

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 05:58

compost = comply

and

“Women’s groups around Australia have found no published guidance for NSW Health”

should have had an addition of ‘obviously’

Women’s groups around Australia have obviously found no published guidance for NSW Health

I think you mean 'comport'

Imdunfer · 29/10/2026 08:13

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 00:20

The DM didn’t provide enough information for me to make any judgement about how the woman was treated. We don’t have the full story there. I would hope eventually she was given the care she needed in comfort.

I don’t think Dr Upton was offered as a female doctor. There’s no evidence of that in the DM article.

But we know that a woman was so in fear of being compelled to accept a doctor who she could see was male that she asked her husband to stay with her to prevent that from happening.

So you have to ask how the hospital created that fear in that woman, if they didn't send a male when she asked for a female, or if she didn't ask for a female after seeing Upton and he and/or the hospital gave her the impression he would be examining her against her wishes?

SirChenjins · 29/10/2026 08:02

Regardless, I'm sure we all agree that no woman should ever fear that her wishes will be ignored when she goes into hospital. Unless this woman has been living under a rock, she'll know the Dr Upton has publicly stated he believes he's a biological woman, that he will treat a female patient who requested a female doctor, and would only stop if she requested one after he started treatment. Not every woman would be mentally or physically able to tell him to stop, not every woman would have the courage to stand up to a Dr or healthcare system. That is wrong.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 29/10/2026 07:01

Totallygripped · 28/10/2026 18:25

Not wanting to get bogged down in semantics but why did you use the phrase "when we had to"? Rather than eg when we were asked? "Had to" suggests it was all considered a bit of a faff.

Sorry, you are getting bogged down in semantics. "Had to" does not mean we considered it a faff it reflects that we rarely got a request for a female doctor. For anything intimate a chaperone would be provided not just offered.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 05:58

compost = comply

and

“Women’s groups around Australia have found no published guidance for NSW Health”

should have had an addition of ‘obviously’

Women’s groups around Australia have obviously found no published guidance for NSW Health

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 05:16

https://archive.is/lMqSj

Adding the link for The Times article which had no additional information.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 04:58

And yet, NSW Health may be just that stupid (or the relevant people who have responsibility in that hospital). Hence the discussion. I don’t believe anyone has provided clarity since the story broke.

If Health VIC allows this to happen, why are we to believe NSW Health wouldn’t? After all, the states would need to compost to the federal policy which would be impacted by the Anti-discrimination act.

If anyone is denying that this would have happened, any links to guidance to support that claim? After all, surely if someone is denying this could have happened they would have something to support that statement?

Women’s groups around Australia have found no published guidance for NSW Health, if you are denying it could have happened, what do you personally know that others don’t?

After all, if it could not have happened it would be very much in women’s interests to have this confirmed that there is a policy to prevent it happening. Please link up the guidance so that we can read it and send links to the women’s groups who have missed it.

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 00:20

NotBadConsidering · 28/10/2026 10:25

Not when you’re filling up the thread with circular arguments when the real issue of what happened to this woman is being forgotten.

What’s your view on how this woman was treated? What’s your view on the fact a man was offered as a woman?

Edited

The DM didn’t provide enough information for me to make any judgement about how the woman was treated. We don’t have the full story there. I would hope eventually she was given the care she needed in comfort.

I don’t think Dr Upton was offered as a female doctor. There’s no evidence of that in the DM article.

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 00:14

Newname26 · 28/10/2026 16:19

It certainly makes sense that same sex care if done on a best efforts basis, their will always be times its just not possible.

But its absolutely not acceptable to say someone is same sex when they aren't.

Finally we’re getting to some kind of understanding here after pages and pages of debates about what my each one of my words meant!

And no. There is absolutely no proof that the hospital offered Dr Upton after the patient asked for a female doctor. I don’t think a great deal of NSW Health, but even they are not that stupid.

Totallygripped · 28/10/2026 18:25

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 28/10/2026 16:04

When we had to satisfy a request for a female doctor we always did it on a best efforts basis.

Not wanting to get bogged down in semantics but why did you use the phrase "when we had to"? Rather than eg when we were asked? "Had to" suggests it was all considered a bit of a faff.

Wishesandhorses · 28/10/2026 17:55

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 16:36

I think that's fair enough - we have to be pragmatic and accept we may not get what we want re the sex of our Dr, or accept we may have to wait longer if it's non- negotiable.

As @Newname26 says though, being lied to about the sex of the Dr treating us is absolutely not on.

This.

"I'm sorry, I know you'd prefer a female doctor (actual female), but one isn't available today, would you like a chaperone/any other way that would help?" is one conversation. It's honest. It's transparent. It's respectful.

"Yes, absolutely you can have a female doctor, I'll send one in," and then sending in a man? That's quite another.

And you could have a third conversation "We have a transgender doctor who identifies as a woman, are you comfortable with that?" Which would save both woman and Upton and probably in time a whole court a lot of time and money and stress.

But it would throw off the emperor's groove, wouldn't it?

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 16:36

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 28/10/2026 16:04

When we had to satisfy a request for a female doctor we always did it on a best efforts basis.

I think that's fair enough - we have to be pragmatic and accept we may not get what we want re the sex of our Dr, or accept we may have to wait longer if it's non- negotiable.

As @Newname26 says though, being lied to about the sex of the Dr treating us is absolutely not on.

Newname26 · 28/10/2026 16:19

It certainly makes sense that same sex care if done on a best efforts basis, their will always be times its just not possible.

But its absolutely not acceptable to say someone is same sex when they aren't.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 28/10/2026 16:04

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 15:39

Everything is possible, and unless Australia has fallen into the abyss it's still possible to make the request. The issue is whether the request would or could be honoured.

When we had to satisfy a request for a female doctor we always did it on a best efforts basis.

SirChenjins · 28/10/2026 15:39

cryupmykingdom · 28/10/2026 14:07

I'm being pedantic but surely the only situation in which it 'would not be possible to request' would be where even making the request would see you frogmarched to the door by the security-wallah.

What is meant here is surely 'it is not possible to insist that the request be honoured or acted on.'

Edited

Everything is possible, and unless Australia has fallen into the abyss it's still possible to make the request. The issue is whether the request would or could be honoured.

cryupmykingdom · 28/10/2026 14:16

Maybe security-wallah marches you out if you even look like you're thinking of requesting it !!

Helleofabore · 28/10/2026 14:09

cryupmykingdom · 28/10/2026 14:07

I'm being pedantic but surely the only situation in which it 'would not be possible to request' would be where even making the request would see you frogmarched to the door by the security-wallah.

What is meant here is surely 'it is not possible to insist that the request be honoured or acted on.'

Edited

“would not be possible to request” is definitely open to interpretation. Hence the communication break down.

Swipe left for the next trending thread