Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Totallygripped · 30/10/2026 18:41

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 16:35

I'm a retired A&E consultant. On a few occasions I have had a patient request a white doctor or more subtly a British doctor. I would whisper in their ear if they didn't like the doctor offered then they could fuck off. Nobody ever did.

Edited

So you have no skin in the game now. The union which used to represent you seems to have taken the position now that biological sex is an unscientific nonsense. Do you agree? And do you think a gender critical viewpoint equates to outright racism? I haven't followed all your posts but are we all supposed to be impressed by "I'm a retired A&E consultant" intro?

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 30/10/2026 16:35

MyAmpleSheep · 30/10/2026 08:40

I don’t know if the situation in Australia is different but in the UK as a patient you’re not required by law not to discriminate in any way; you can ask for a black doctor, a Jewish doctor, a gay doctor or a male or female (using anyone’s understanding of that word) doctor, the EA2010 doesn’t govern you and there are no legal consequences for you. The other staff might disapprove but you can’t get sued.

Edited

I'm a retired A&E consultant. On a few occasions I have had a patient request a white doctor or more subtly a British doctor. I would whisper in their ear if they didn't like the doctor offered then they could fuck off. Nobody ever did.

Wishesandhorses · 30/10/2026 14:52

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 11:34

@Emilesgran It’s not getting any coverage at all. I’ve only seen it on The Daily Mail and here. I’m not in the same state that it’s happened in so maybe there’s coverage in the state in question.

@MyAmpleSheep I have no idea if patients have that sort of protection here.

I'd think it's not unlikely that the hospital has rushed to hush this up to avoid the patient taking it any more public. I suppose we'll see if more comes out or whether some sort of settlement was very quickly and quietly made.

MyAmpleSheep · 30/10/2026 12:23

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 11:34

@Emilesgran It’s not getting any coverage at all. I’ve only seen it on The Daily Mail and here. I’m not in the same state that it’s happened in so maybe there’s coverage in the state in question.

@MyAmpleSheep I have no idea if patients have that sort of protection here.

It's a wider question: in most of the jurisdictions I know of, an injunction against unlawful discrimination is against the more powerful party in some kind of formal relationship: the service provider towards the customer, the employer towards their employees, the educational institution towards the students. It's not symmetric: service users and individual members of the public don't have those duties to each other.

It would be correct to note that you can't harass someone, but it would be a bold step to suggest that declining to be treated by an individual doctor (for any reason whatsoever) was an act of harassment against the Doctor.

Even in the genuine and disturbing case, I don't think the prisoner-patient who racially abused Nurse Melle was punished for it.

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 11:34

@Emilesgran It’s not getting any coverage at all. I’ve only seen it on The Daily Mail and here. I’m not in the same state that it’s happened in so maybe there’s coverage in the state in question.

@MyAmpleSheep I have no idea if patients have that sort of protection here.

SirChenjins · 30/10/2026 10:16

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/10/2026 09:09

Ab Inability to put aside one's own desires by accepting boundaries is the crux of this whole issue.

Edited

I agree.

While there are limited details here, what is clear is that this woman did not want him treating her, and was so concerned that he would that husband stayed with her. Upton has clearly stated his intentions when treating women who request a female doctor - his concern for their boundaries re their safety, privacy, dignity and bodily autonomy is zero - and so it's not surprising that some women may not want anything to do with him. It's a terrible indictment on the state of healthcare services that we're faced with men like him.

Wishesandhorses · 30/10/2026 10:11

Ok, if the determination is to believe that the quoted speaker gave a statement to a newspaper addressing the Health Minister without getting her facts straight, and may or may not have meant what she said, (or that what she said could be interpreted in other ways, or that there could be other innocent reasons why the patient's trust was so entirely damaged)

are we agreeing that if it does turn out that in fact a woman requested a female doctor, this was agreed to, and was sent Upton only to realise he was in fact male, this would be wrong?

Shortshriftandlethal · 30/10/2026 09:09

Ab Inability to put aside one's own desires by accepting boundaries is the crux of this whole issue.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 30/10/2026 09:04

LadyCapybara · 30/10/2026 06:07

I can agree with that.

I agree with you that the newspaper report is vague, and there is little evidence of Upton having misbehaved in Australia. Has he learned anything from his experiences in Fife? Don't know yet, but it's clear that Australian law and societal attitudes are not giving him clear boundaries, rather like NHS Fife.

MyAmpleSheep · 30/10/2026 08:40

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 06:08

There’s very little chance that the average Australian knows that a trans identifying person is legally regarded as being their chosen gender and that you can’t object, and if you do then you’re discriminating in the full legal sense of the word and can face legal consequences.

I don’t know if the situation in Australia is different but in the UK as a patient you’re not required by law not to discriminate in any way; you can ask for a black doctor, a Jewish doctor, a gay doctor or a male or female (using anyone’s understanding of that word) doctor, the EA2010 doesn’t govern you and there are no legal consequences for you. The other staff might disapprove but you can’t get sued.

Emilesgran · 30/10/2026 08:39

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 06:08

There’s very little chance that the average Australian knows that a trans identifying person is legally regarded as being their chosen gender and that you can’t object, and if you do then you’re discriminating in the full legal sense of the word and can face legal consequences.

This lack of awareness is a real problem, and not only in Australia - the widespread assumption by the general public is that it’s just a matter of “not attacking some poor transvestite for their bizarre appearance, and what decent person could object to that?” All the same, it’s amazing to me that the Sall Grover case has not been a turning point in public awareness in Australia.

TBF it’s not just the general public - it’s everyone’s starting point isn’t it? I think it was Rosie Kay whom I heard explaining that for ages she had been convinced that it was all a misunderstanding, and that if she could only explain properly, she would manage to get her point across, and everyone would realise that she wasn’t some horrible bigot but was concerned by perfectly reasonable issues that could no doubt be resolved. Except that the more she tried to explain, the worse it got for her. And of course she’s not alone in that. It really was a very clever wheeze to tie trans “rights” to gay rights.

But there have been so many times when I’ve thought “Well, this will make the reality of the problem clear to everyone”, and then “Well surely this will do it?” - and yet it’s like wading through treacle - the media continue to present things in such a biased way. Is that also what happened with Sall Grover’s court case over there? And how is this latest incident concerning Theo/Beth/Lis Upton being presented there?

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 06:08

There’s very little chance that the average Australian knows that a trans identifying person is legally regarded as being their chosen gender and that you can’t object, and if you do then you’re discriminating in the full legal sense of the word and can face legal consequences.

LadyCapybara · 30/10/2026 06:07

Helleofabore · 30/10/2026 05:40

If a female patient feels she has to have an advocate with her to ensure a male person doesn’t present himself as being a female doctor when she has requested a female doctor, even while waiting for another female doctor to arrive, there is a problem. That is a sign that the woman and her advocate have potentially a lack of clarity of expectation in policy or lack of trust that some hospital staff would respect her request. Or both.

Whether the woman was waiting for a female doctor after asking for one, had Upton present himself as the female doctor as requested and said she wanted someone else who was female, or was fearful of Upton potentially presenting himself after she has requested a female doctor, a major factor of the situation is not having that clarity of the policy. Or what is understood by the word ‘female’ in any Australian policy without detailed clarification.

I can agree with that.

Helleofabore · 30/10/2026 05:40

If a female patient feels she has to have an advocate with her to ensure a male person doesn’t present himself as being a female doctor when she has requested a female doctor, even while waiting for another female doctor to arrive, there is a problem. That is a sign that the woman and her advocate have potentially a lack of clarity of expectation in policy or lack of trust that some hospital staff would respect her request. Or both.

Whether the woman was waiting for a female doctor after asking for one, had Upton present himself as the female doctor as requested and said she wanted someone else who was female, or was fearful of Upton potentially presenting himself after she has requested a female doctor, a major factor of the situation is not having that clarity of the policy. Or what is understood by the word ‘female’ in any Australian policy without detailed clarification.

FeralWoman · 30/10/2026 05:27

Emilesgran · 29/10/2026 15:13

I find the idea, suggested earlier, that rural Australians might object to being treated by English as opposed to native Aussies but that those same patients would NOT object to being treated by a man in a dress to be laughable.

If they are so parochial that they want someone from their own town, there’s no way they’re going to accept a man in womanface.

It is laughable. The only man in a dress that they’d be likely to accept would be one that they know and have decided is an okay bloke and not some weird freak who isn’t right in the head. Rural Australians who might object to English staff would likely make some sort of insult/joke about whinging Poms, soap dodgers or something about bad teeth. Beyond that I think they’d leave it and not say much. My thoughts are based on my experience from growing up in rural Australia and going back to my hometown every year or so to visit relatives.

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 23:49

Wishesandhorses · 29/10/2026 21:19

I’m saying the DM did not present any specific evidence of NSW Health offering Dr Upton as a female doctor option after the patient asked for one.

From the article: Women’s Forum Australia CEO Rachael Wong said: ‘A woman in hospital should not have to defend her boundaries from the very people entrusted with her care. ‘The New South Wales health minister must urgently investigate why a vulnerable woman seeking emergency care felt she needed her husband’s protection to ensure her wish to be treated by a female doctor was respected'.

Are you calling Rachael Wong a liar then?

Sorry, I’m still not seeing what you seem to be. The patient may have been keeping her husband with her in case Dr Upton returned while she was waiting for a female doctor.

Wishesandhorses · 29/10/2026 21:19

I’m saying the DM did not present any specific evidence of NSW Health offering Dr Upton as a female doctor option after the patient asked for one.

From the article: Women’s Forum Australia CEO Rachael Wong said: ‘A woman in hospital should not have to defend her boundaries from the very people entrusted with her care. ‘The New South Wales health minister must urgently investigate why a vulnerable woman seeking emergency care felt she needed her husband’s protection to ensure her wish to be treated by a female doctor was respected'.

Are you calling Rachael Wong a liar then?

Emilesgran · 29/10/2026 15:13

FeralWoman · 29/10/2026 12:20

If a patient in an Australian hospital rejected English, Irish, Scottish or Welsh staff then they might be waiting for a while for a staff member! Lots of English etc staff in them. I had surgery last week in an Australian private hospital and had at least three English nurses at various stages of the seven hours I was a patient. They might have been one of the other UK/Ireland countries but I wasn’t concentrating enough to identify their precise accent because I was thinking about my surgery and a bit nervous. They were friendly, polite, attentive and good at their jobs.

It was gynaecological surgery and the operating theatre staff were all women apart from the anaesthetist. The gynaecologist works with him a lot and holds him in high regard. I hadn’t realised how uncomfortable I would have felt with male nurses in there until I walked into the theatre and was greeted by a group of happy young female nurses who introduced themselves, and the only male was the anaesthetist. I felt hugely relieved. I was about to spend nearly an hour in stirrups in an undignified position and completely exposed and vulnerable. I was very glad to be surrounded by women and the one man present was going to be solely by my head and busy keeping me anaesthetised and alive.

Australian women should definitely have the right to request biologically female doctors, nurses, radiographers, etc and not find themselves the potential subject of an anti discrimination case and public naming and shaming. I wish the government would fix the bloody Sex Discrimination Act and restore biological definitions of man/male and woman/female. It’s not a culture war. It’s important and it matters.

I find the idea, suggested earlier, that rural Australians might object to being treated by English as opposed to native Aussies but that those same patients would NOT object to being treated by a man in a dress to be laughable.

If they are so parochial that they want someone from their own town, there’s no way they’re going to accept a man in womanface.

FeralWoman · 29/10/2026 12:20

If a patient in an Australian hospital rejected English, Irish, Scottish or Welsh staff then they might be waiting for a while for a staff member! Lots of English etc staff in them. I had surgery last week in an Australian private hospital and had at least three English nurses at various stages of the seven hours I was a patient. They might have been one of the other UK/Ireland countries but I wasn’t concentrating enough to identify their precise accent because I was thinking about my surgery and a bit nervous. They were friendly, polite, attentive and good at their jobs.

It was gynaecological surgery and the operating theatre staff were all women apart from the anaesthetist. The gynaecologist works with him a lot and holds him in high regard. I hadn’t realised how uncomfortable I would have felt with male nurses in there until I walked into the theatre and was greeted by a group of happy young female nurses who introduced themselves, and the only male was the anaesthetist. I felt hugely relieved. I was about to spend nearly an hour in stirrups in an undignified position and completely exposed and vulnerable. I was very glad to be surrounded by women and the one man present was going to be solely by my head and busy keeping me anaesthetised and alive.

Australian women should definitely have the right to request biologically female doctors, nurses, radiographers, etc and not find themselves the potential subject of an anti discrimination case and public naming and shaming. I wish the government would fix the bloody Sex Discrimination Act and restore biological definitions of man/male and woman/female. It’s not a culture war. It’s important and it matters.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 11:02

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 10:56

indeed. What exactly would be enough for you?

A link to the policy that refers to what is expected in this situation.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 11:01

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:32

Remember too, we have seen people disparage this woman for having her husband there for her by at least one person.

"Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor"

This kind of reaction from people on account of her speaking out, even through an intermediary, is a huge deterrent. She has to still continue to live in the area if she is a local.

But apparently, we must believe that

-it never happened,

-that he has the right to not disclose his medical information to patients who request a female doctor,

-that she was a racist or general bigot and would have rejected him because he was English or another reason, not because he was a male doctor and she needed a female doctor,

-that a regional hospital will not have any female doctor available at all, even with a wait for treatment,

-that discussing the intention admitted under oath in court in the past does not give any indication to whether he would do this now,

-that if the patient was not offered treatment by this male doctor, that she should not have mentioned her concern at all either even though her concern highlights a very significant issue that the general public does not have clarity about their own rights in the instance if a male doctor DID present himself as a female doctor when a patient requests a female doctor.

An added reminder, we have also had a poster question what would deter the woman being clear about what happened.

Considering just what we have seen on this thread in an attempt to dismiss the possibility it happened, or that it was her own issue and not Upton’s if he did present himself as a female doctor, and the disparage of that women’s concern, really, is it any fucking wonder she has not made a public complaint?

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 10:56

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 10:23

What evidence is needed to have the discussion about what policy and law should be in place for this scenario, and understanding the next steps to make sure there is clarity?

What evidence is needed to understand what the consent and safeguarding issues are raised by this potential situation?

indeed. What exactly would be enough for you?

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 10:23

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 10:08

I suppose, then, if you can find any evidence that it did happen that would be great too.

What evidence is needed to have the discussion about what policy and law should be in place for this scenario, and understanding the next steps to make sure there is clarity?

What evidence is needed to understand what the consent and safeguarding issues are raised by this potential situation?

WearyAuldWumman · 29/10/2026 10:10

Hoardasurass · 29/10/2026 08:41

No hes not.
Hes lied about his sex, lied about sandie and kept notes about her refusal to change with him, has admitted under oath that he intends to sexually assault female patients who ask for female care and harmed an elderly patient at a previous hospital by kicking off and falsely reported her for abuse because she called him son.
That is not a good dr of nice person by any measure. Sandie on the other hand is a wonderful nurse with an amazing bedside manor and for those of us who have actually been treated by her or have family members who have can attest to how much she cares about her patients and their needs. Dr Upton should have been taking notes about how she treats patients so he could learn to be a decent human being not to try and bully her into stripping off in front of him for his own personal gratification or punishing her for not doing so

The thing that really pisses me off about the pensioner report is that elderly folk in Fife often use 'son' as a term of endearment when speaking to younger people and a doctor - someone who should have an understanding of dementia - had so little care for his patient that he reported her.

Absolute bar steward.

LadyCapybara · 29/10/2026 10:08

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:55

Great. My post was asking generally if people saying it didn’t happen, that Upton was not presenting himself as a female doctor to a patient that requested a female doctor or is following policy if he did, can support this with the guidance that makes them so confident that it didn’t happen.

I suppose, then, if you can find any evidence that it did happen that would be great too.