Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Newname26 · 25/10/2026 18:56

Emilesgran · 25/10/2026 15:17

Well of course … except that since Aus law appears to say quite explicitly after Sall Grover’s defeat that transwomen are women, it seems impossible for hospitals to admit that someone like Beth/Liz Upton is male without breaking the law. So even proposing a chaperone could be problematic.

Not to mention that the chaperone could also be a TW. For the same reasons.

Until ordinary people in the country have had enough of this madness and insist on changing the law, it looks as though Upton and other males will be able to do as they wish.

The tide will turn.
Most people are tolerant until they really think it though or it affects THEM or someone in their circles not some other random.

Datun · 25/10/2026 18:56

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

Nah, it's because this heterosexual man who has already violated a nurse's boundaries, pretends he's a lesbian and doesn't understand biology has said he would show up to treat a woman who had explicitly asked him not to show up, and has engineered a position where he can do exactly that, and so her husband is making damn sure he won't.

SirChenjins · 25/10/2026 18:54

totino · 25/10/2026 18:50

I don't perceive or categorize trans women as men so it's hard to answer. If a woman is actually distressed at the prospect of being treated by a trans woman, then a cis female doctor should be sent instead. Ideally, nobody should be treated by a doctor they feel unsafe with. But two things, 1) I don't think the number of patients with this particular need is that big, 2) I think inclusion should be the default and exclusion the exception, so I don't think Dr Upton is in the wrong to offer treatment. I also think it's ingenious to imply sexual or fetishistic motives; I would expect a Dr to offer treatment.

But not to go against the wishes of his patients or claim to be the sex of the Dr a woman has requested when he's not?

BackToLurk · 25/10/2026 18:53

totino · 25/10/2026 18:50

I don't perceive or categorize trans women as men so it's hard to answer. If a woman is actually distressed at the prospect of being treated by a trans woman, then a cis female doctor should be sent instead. Ideally, nobody should be treated by a doctor they feel unsafe with. But two things, 1) I don't think the number of patients with this particular need is that big, 2) I think inclusion should be the default and exclusion the exception, so I don't think Dr Upton is in the wrong to offer treatment. I also think it's ingenious to imply sexual or fetishistic motives; I would expect a Dr to offer treatment.

You say you don’t perceive or categorise transwomen as men, but do you acknowledge they are male? Because that was the scenario. Whether a female patient should expect a female person when they request one.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:52

totino · 25/10/2026 18:50

I don't perceive or categorize trans women as men so it's hard to answer. If a woman is actually distressed at the prospect of being treated by a trans woman, then a cis female doctor should be sent instead. Ideally, nobody should be treated by a doctor they feel unsafe with. But two things, 1) I don't think the number of patients with this particular need is that big, 2) I think inclusion should be the default and exclusion the exception, so I don't think Dr Upton is in the wrong to offer treatment. I also think it's ingenious to imply sexual or fetishistic motives; I would expect a Dr to offer treatment.

I will repeat the question because this is very much a swerve. it is not hard to answer at all. It is actually a yes or no answer.

Do you think female people in Australia should have confidence that if they do ask for a female doctor or female health care professional, that they will get a female person, or at least be told that there are none available right now and other arrangements can be made?

Because there are female people in Australia right now who don't believe they have clarity around that specific scenario.

Do you think that they should?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 25/10/2026 18:51

ChequerToRed · 25/10/2026 18:44

I would say that it’s amazing that there’s so many posters on here who will indulge in any amount of disingenuous sealioning to defend, or even make a victim out of, this absolute scrote.
But it’s not amazing at all unfortunately, it’s boringly predictable and pretty much par for the course when some bloke with special lady feelz behaves like the horrible specimen of a man that he is.
golf clap

So open minded their brains have fallen out.

totino · 25/10/2026 18:50

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:37

Also, maybe you can answer whether you think female people in Australia should have confidence that if they do ask for a female doctor or female health care professional, that they will get a female person, or at least be told that there are none available right now and other arrangements can be made?

Because there are female people in Australia right now who don't believe they have clarity around that specific scenario.

Do you think that they should?

I don't perceive or categorize trans women as men so it's hard to answer. If a woman is actually distressed at the prospect of being treated by a trans woman, then a cis female doctor should be sent instead. Ideally, nobody should be treated by a doctor they feel unsafe with. But two things, 1) I don't think the number of patients with this particular need is that big, 2) I think inclusion should be the default and exclusion the exception, so I don't think Dr Upton is in the wrong to offer treatment. I also think it's ingenious to imply sexual or fetishistic motives; I would expect a Dr to offer treatment.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:47

totino · 25/10/2026 18:42

No I think the husband's posturing is a little humorous considering there is no scenario where this would have ever occurred unless the patient was dying and Dr Upton was the literal only Dr on earth

Do you support Dr Upton if he presented himself as a female doctor if a female patient stated she needed a female doctor? yes or no?

wellnotexactly · 25/10/2026 18:46

What a fucking surprise.

I’m surprised it took so long for the good doctor to pop back up again.

I half expected him to pop up at another NHS trust with this as I wasn’t sure if the Australia thing was true.

They’ll probably make him a saint over there

SirChenjins · 25/10/2026 18:44

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:40

"Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor"

Could you show your hatred for women any more with this comment?

It a typical post from this poster.

ChequerToRed · 25/10/2026 18:44

I would say that it’s amazing that there’s so many posters on here who will indulge in any amount of disingenuous sealioning to defend, or even make a victim out of, this absolute scrote.
But it’s not amazing at all unfortunately, it’s boringly predictable and pretty much par for the course when some bloke with special lady feelz behaves like the horrible specimen of a man that he is.
golf clap

totino · 25/10/2026 18:42

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:40

"Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor"

Could you show your hatred for women any more with this comment?

No I think the husband's posturing is a little humorous considering there is no scenario where this would have ever occurred unless the patient was dying and Dr Upton was the literal only Dr on earth

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:40

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

"Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor"

Could you show your hatred for women any more with this comment?

Needapadlockonmyfridge · 25/10/2026 18:40

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

Given what Dr Upton said at the tribunal, I would be pretty alarmed to see him about to treat me, as well

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:37

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

Also, maybe you can answer whether you think female people in Australia should have confidence that if they do ask for a female doctor or female health care professional, that they will get a female person, or at least be told that there are none available right now and other arrangements can be made?

Because there are female people in Australia right now who don't believe they have clarity around that specific scenario.

Do you think that they should?

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:35

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

And the post you quoted stands for your opinion as well.

Including this question:

Do you support Dr Upton if he presented himself as a female doctor if a female patient stated she needed a female doctor? yes or no?

SirChenjins · 25/10/2026 18:34

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

I refer you to my previous post.

totino · 25/10/2026 18:33

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:12

And again, that is your opinion.

Others can read the words and come to a different understanding. Language is great that way. You can choose to dismiss the report, others can understand why it might be more guarded and less explicit.

So, do you support Dr Upton if he presented himself as a female doctor if a female patient stated she needed a female doctor? yes or no?

My understanding is this:

  1. Patient sees and recognizes Dr Upton
  2. Patient becomes alarmed at the prospect of being treated by Dr Upton
  3. Big strong man stands guard in case the hospital forces his wife to get treated by this one doctor

Verdict: Dr Upton GUILTY of being spotted at her place of work.

SirChenjins · 25/10/2026 18:18

Neversofaraway · 25/10/2026 18:16

I would not be concerned about seeing a lesbian doctor, she is no threat to me. But a TIM claiming to be attracted to women, as Upton has stated, is the same threat as any other man.

More of a threat - he's openly admitted he would ignore women's requests. Decent men don't do that.

Neversofaraway · 25/10/2026 18:16

I would not be concerned about seeing a lesbian doctor, she is no threat to me. But a TIM claiming to be attracted to women, as Upton has stated, is the same threat as any other man.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:15

The issue is also that this discussion is also about the lack of clarity in the health policies that also mean that it is time for NSW Health to be very clear whether female people in NSW have the right to ask for a female health care professional and expect only a female health care professional.

I know that there are female patients in Victoria that would love to feel they had the confidence in a positive outcome also.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:12

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:23

There is no excuse for a male doctor to present themselves to a female patient who has requested a female doctor.

There is nothing in the report that even suggests this happened. Unless you know something different?

Meaning he was demanding a female patient, who has a quite high chance of being a vulnerable female patient, decide whether or not he was 'female' and whether she would risk being negatively treated for rejecting him.

Again - there isn't a scrap of evidence that any of this occurred.

And again, that is your opinion.

Others can read the words and come to a different understanding. Language is great that way. You can choose to dismiss the report, others can understand why it might be more guarded and less explicit.

So, do you support Dr Upton if he presented himself as a female doctor if a female patient stated she needed a female doctor? yes or no?

SirChenjins · 25/10/2026 18:10

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 18:05

But they can surely answer for themselves about where they got all the extra information from? Right? I won't hold my breath!

Do what you want with your breath, no-one cares.

SirChenjins · 25/10/2026 18:09

Helleofabore · 25/10/2026 18:02

What an oppressive cycle it is when male people take female people through court for referring to them as male people and that that male person can label as being discriminatory.

It certainly makes speaking directly and explicitly about an incident much more difficult.

Although he did score an own goal as it's now known worldwide that he's a bloke, despite his claims to the contrary. If he'd just behaved appropriately and shown some courtesy and respect to the women he came into contact with, he wouldn't have this following him around. #sadtimes.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 25/10/2026 18:08

alcovecupboards · 25/10/2026 17:06

So being trans?

Did you just admit that "being trans" = pretending to be the opposite sex?
Will wonders never cease?