Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Yes transgender women I am fucked off

153 replies

Mouthyton · 24/10/2026 07:17

Queue for the women’s loo at a big Brighton event.

As per usual, women’s loo is rammed, huge queue.

No queue for the men’s.

Waiting to change a leaking tampon.

And, amongst others, there are 4 people ahead of me, clearly biologically male, presenting as female.

And later on, at the same event, unable to send my 10 year old to the loo alone because there are transwomen using the loos and I do not send my child into spaces to get undressed where there are biological men also getting undressed.

I have zero problems with them wanting to present as female. I do have a problem with them taking up female space.

I can’t challenge this, as a woman with a child as I put myself in a vulnerable position. Yet again made to feel vulnerable by the needs of a man.

And society tells me to put up and shut up.

Sigh.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:35

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 16:40

Sorry @murasaki , but I have to ask, practically how do you plan to not let any man into the women's bathroom?

How the fuck do you think we did it for OVER 100 YEARS until the last 15 years???

callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:33

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 16:31

Hi @murasaki ! You seem to be questioning my point of reasoning and I would love to answer your question!

As a whole this thread, (at least the people I have responded to such as @ALovelyPinkUnicorn @Tears0fTheMushroom ) presents their issues with trans women using the bathroom or, as I'm sure you would say, your bathroom.

My first point of reasoning is that Terfism seems to like using the 'toilet issue' as a talking point. As I understand, there is a belief that a cis man would not enter a women's bathroom and would instead need to 'dress up' as trans women to do so. I do not agree with this belief. A bathroom is simply a room and if a man (an actual man, not a trans woman) wanted to enter such room with bad intensions and act on those intentions he could simply do so. Men, actual men, do not need to dress up as women to harm women in British society, they already do so.

A woman's toilet is not a safe space. And I do not say that because trans women are in that bathroom, I say that because it is a public space. Please do not interpret this statement as me arguing for bathrooms to be privatised, I am simply saying that when in public spaces there is a unfortunate risk of someone being there with bad intentions. Being Trans does not mean you have bad intentions.

I understand the fear of men as a women myself and wholeheartedly sympathise with it but it needs to be clarified that a woman's toilet does not have a magical forcefield around it that stop cis men with bad intentions entering, resulting with them needing to dress up to enter.

I hope this clarified my point of reasoning with these other mumsnet users!

As for the original post, I stand by the fact that excessive queueing is a fault of our country being in late stage capitalism and our public service users feeling the consequences!

If a burglar wants to break into your house, he will simply do so. No point locking your house doors at night... We STRENGTHEN safeguards. We don't throw our hands up in the air and give up!

Yes transgender women I am fucked off
callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:31

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 16:31

Hi @murasaki ! You seem to be questioning my point of reasoning and I would love to answer your question!

As a whole this thread, (at least the people I have responded to such as @ALovelyPinkUnicorn @Tears0fTheMushroom ) presents their issues with trans women using the bathroom or, as I'm sure you would say, your bathroom.

My first point of reasoning is that Terfism seems to like using the 'toilet issue' as a talking point. As I understand, there is a belief that a cis man would not enter a women's bathroom and would instead need to 'dress up' as trans women to do so. I do not agree with this belief. A bathroom is simply a room and if a man (an actual man, not a trans woman) wanted to enter such room with bad intensions and act on those intentions he could simply do so. Men, actual men, do not need to dress up as women to harm women in British society, they already do so.

A woman's toilet is not a safe space. And I do not say that because trans women are in that bathroom, I say that because it is a public space. Please do not interpret this statement as me arguing for bathrooms to be privatised, I am simply saying that when in public spaces there is a unfortunate risk of someone being there with bad intentions. Being Trans does not mean you have bad intentions.

I understand the fear of men as a women myself and wholeheartedly sympathise with it but it needs to be clarified that a woman's toilet does not have a magical forcefield around it that stop cis men with bad intentions entering, resulting with them needing to dress up to enter.

I hope this clarified my point of reasoning with these other mumsnet users!

As for the original post, I stand by the fact that excessive queueing is a fault of our country being in late stage capitalism and our public service users feeling the consequences!

If a burglar wants to break into your house, he will simply do so. No point locking your house doors at night... We STRENGTHEN safeguards. We don't throw our hands up in the air and give up!

callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:26

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 16:06

Hi @Tears0fTheMushroom ! Sorry, I am at a loss! Is that not what you use the bathroom for?

Edited

No. Actual women know it's FAR more than that (even if it was, there are cubicles in the mens room, so they can pee there:

You show callous ignorance of the female sex needs. Women flee to the ladies to escape a man. We cry. Seek help. We miscarry there. We change out at the sinks to go clubbing. We wash blood-stained underwear at the sink, and baby sick off our blouses. We are in a semi state of dress. We don't want MALES there, understand?!???!

callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:20

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 15:24

Hi @Ereshkigalangcleg ! Sorry I am unfamiliar with the term 'ideological jargon' in relation to calling myself a cis woman. Please could you explain?

You're either male, or female. Re-badging males as 'trans' is the Mens Rights Movement loophole and revenge for #MeToo. A male is a male is a male. They can never be a woman. It's racist, sexist and misogynist to call a male a woman.

Hope this helps.

Yes transgender women I am fucked off
Yes transgender women I am fucked off
callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:18

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 15:18

Hi @Tears0fTheMushroom ! I would love to urge you to understand the fact that despising and generalising trans people is not acceptable. Trans women are not attempting to harm or replace you. They simply want to use the bathroom!

However, I understand this fear as the alienation of workers which comes with capitalism can present itself through scape-goating minorities! So I urge you to reconsider your hate of trans women!

Edited

MALES can use the bathroom of their sex. Rebadging MALES as 'trans' won't work.

HTH.

Yes transgender women I am fucked off
callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:17

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 15:11

Hi @ALovelyPinkUnicorn ! I feel that this response doesnt actually relate to my argument and that instead, when being proposed a different view point you have decided to stay close minded. Totally in your rights to do so! Although, I urge you to consider where you blinding hate of trans women actually comes from? As many of these issues are actually produced by the bourgeoisie!

It is you that, through your brainwashing, is closed-minded. This is not a hatred of 'transwomen', as males REBADGED are still MALES. This is a hatred of MALES in female spaces.

I hope you now understand.

callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:15

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 15:00

Hi @ALovelyPinkUnicorn! I completely see and understand your point!

However, I would argue that in this hypothetical scenario where event planners know the gender of each individual attending, trans women would label themselves when booking such event as women (as would I label them as such although I know this is a debatable topic!), and therefore event planners would know the amount of women attending!

The theme of insufficient funds and our contemporary British society being currently in the process of late stage capitalism continues to make issues for, especially for such stratified groups such as, women.

I hope this answered your question!

'gender' is a man-made misogynistic social construct. Only SEX exists. And just because a predatory male with penis and testicles labels himself as a 'woman', doesn't mean women that is actual female human beings - ignore our base level survival instincts and accept a massive unit of a male with penis and testicles in dress as a 'woman'. Any MALE human being is a threat to women. Stranger Danger exists for a reason. Did you forget that?

callmeLoretta1 · 03/11/2026 13:13

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 14:48

Hi, I understand as a cis woman myself the need of using the bathroom for period related issues and the struggle of large queues and such. However, can i urge you to question the fact that instead of blaming innocent trans women for large queues, you question the poor event managing for the amount of people attending and how there is insufficient funds across the UK to cater to the the majority of the UK population?

I would urge people to see this issue as an issue of capitalism rather than innocent women needing the bathroom (you and the trans women).

Edited

Firstly the term 'cis woman' is deeply, DEEPLY offensive to women, and from what I understand, is banned from this site.

Secondly, MALES, which is what 'transwomen' are, fully intact males - males in every single way, adding to the queues hurt women. That is, females. Please consider that you may have been brainwashed to prioritise males with penis and testicles in dresses, over ACTUAL women and girls.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 01/11/2026 00:56

BiologicalRobot · 31/10/2026 21:54

Trans women are not attempting to harm or replace you.

< snorts >

TW can never replace me as a woman. I'm too awesome.

Remember Shon Faye "enjoy your erasure"
That went well then 😂

BiologicalRobot · 31/10/2026 21:54

Trans women are not attempting to harm or replace you.

< snorts >

TW can never replace me as a woman. I'm too awesome.

solerolover · 31/10/2026 20:01

...They're either not very bright, not here in good faith, or not able to argue against what we're actually saying (which is really not that complex!)

I'm not sure which it is in this particular case.

Probably all of the above tbh.

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 31/10/2026 19:53

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 18:49

Neither do we tell homeowners or indeed the general public, “oh come on, you know a burglar will do that whether it’s against the law or not, you were never safe in your own home anyway so here is Paul, he is taking your silver and he is allowed to now” 🤣

How utterly hate filled @CreativeGreen not to let Paul live his true life as house breaker and stealer of things….

Catiette · 31/10/2026 19:14

WildflowerMeadow · 31/10/2026 18:35

My head can't compute the lack of understanding of the issue here - seriously, people aren't really this stupid are they?

A year ago I was menopausal and flooding massively. On at least two occasions I had to leave a toilet stall in only my knickers to rinse blood from my clothes at the sinks.

On both those occasions it was at a busy event where women were queuing to use the cubicles inside the ladies. On one occasion I actually ended up, with the help of another kind lady, quickly stripping off my knickers and fashioning some new underwear out of paper towels, a sanitary towel and some tape before I put my clothes back on.

I would have been humiliated to the extreme had any of the women who had been queuing at the time, and who I was in full view of, were a transwoman aka a man.

But seriously, people want to argue that this is not an issue - my mind kind of explodes at this.

The fact that visitors here need to misrepresent our arguments to extremes that just look a bit, well, silly, speaks volumes to the strength of their own.

When someone's writing about magic force fields, helpfully informing readers here that "a room is simply a room" and claiming actual thinking humans believe that "a cis man... would... need to 'dress up' as trans women" to enter a female bathroom...

...They're either not very bright, not here in good faith, or not able to argue against what we're actually saying (which is really not that complex!)

I'm not sure which it is in this particular case.

murasaki · 31/10/2026 19:12

JanesLittleGirl · 31/10/2026 19:10

You are correct. I can be a right numpty sometimes. Sorry.

And that was the aim, confuse the language. I knew what you meant!

JanesLittleGirl · 31/10/2026 19:10

murasaki · 31/10/2026 19:08

You mean TiMs. TiFs, being women although identifying otherwise, tend not to be rapists etc....

You are correct. I can be a right numpty sometimes. Sorry.

murasaki · 31/10/2026 19:08

JanesLittleGirl · 31/10/2026 19:02

I agree with you in general but TiFs have kicked down the social barrier and all sorts of chancers have slithered through the resultant hole.

You mean TiMs. TiFs, being women although identifying otherwise, tend not to be rapists etc....

Catiette · 31/10/2026 19:07

Exactly. In some contexts, the punishment is the law, and in others, it's the social contract - a universal recognition that someone's transgressing important boundaries at someone else's expense. Rules, regs and collective rebuke are all part of the same complex network. This increasingly common view that It's not illegal and I want to, so I'll do it! is very dangerous. There's a place for it - considered, organised civil disobedience in the context of egregious wrongs when the proposed change won't disadvantage another vulnerable group. But not wanting to use the gender neutral or accessible at the stated expense of hundreds of thousands of women just isn't quite on the same scale.

JanesLittleGirl · 31/10/2026 19:02

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 18:42

I just want to be really clear here that I was trying to argue against the TRA point that men can and do just go everywhere so it’s daft not to let TIMs in our loos. My point was most of the time men who accept they’re men don’t breach that boundary. Women’s loos were safer and closer to female only spaces before this all started up.

I agree with you in general but TiFs have kicked down the social barrier and all sorts of chancers have slithered through the resultant hole.

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 18:49

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 18:44

Yes but you can be punished for speeding and breaking into homes, because we agree that even though some people will always do that, it’s not allowed.

Neither do we tell homeowners or indeed the general public, “oh come on, you know a burglar will do that whether it’s against the law or not, you were never safe in your own home anyway so here is Paul, he is taking your silver and he is allowed to now” 🤣

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 18:44

Catiette · 31/10/2026 18:42

I actually think Olive has a point here.

Posters seem to think that things like social contracts and conventions, and signs, serve as some kind of safeguard against harm.

It's silly, really. I mean, if a criminal wants to break into your home, he technically can - what's stopping him? He doesn't need to dress up in black and white with a swag bag. He can just smash a window!

And speed limits and stop signs? As much as we'd like them to, bits of painted metal and plastic don't generate "you-shall-not-pass" Gandalfian forcefields. It's just silly to behave as if they do. A road isn't a safe space, and I say that because it's a public space.

The one sticking point for me in what Olive says is about the privatisation of bathrooms. I'm all for this. It worked for the railways, the NHS is heading that way too - it's clearly the future.

Bathroomz R Us? Loos 4 Youse! Johnsons' Powder Room!!!

Yes but you can be punished for speeding and breaking into homes, because we agree that even though some people will always do that, it’s not allowed.

Catiette · 31/10/2026 18:42

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 16:31

Hi @murasaki ! You seem to be questioning my point of reasoning and I would love to answer your question!

As a whole this thread, (at least the people I have responded to such as @ALovelyPinkUnicorn @Tears0fTheMushroom ) presents their issues with trans women using the bathroom or, as I'm sure you would say, your bathroom.

My first point of reasoning is that Terfism seems to like using the 'toilet issue' as a talking point. As I understand, there is a belief that a cis man would not enter a women's bathroom and would instead need to 'dress up' as trans women to do so. I do not agree with this belief. A bathroom is simply a room and if a man (an actual man, not a trans woman) wanted to enter such room with bad intensions and act on those intentions he could simply do so. Men, actual men, do not need to dress up as women to harm women in British society, they already do so.

A woman's toilet is not a safe space. And I do not say that because trans women are in that bathroom, I say that because it is a public space. Please do not interpret this statement as me arguing for bathrooms to be privatised, I am simply saying that when in public spaces there is a unfortunate risk of someone being there with bad intentions. Being Trans does not mean you have bad intentions.

I understand the fear of men as a women myself and wholeheartedly sympathise with it but it needs to be clarified that a woman's toilet does not have a magical forcefield around it that stop cis men with bad intentions entering, resulting with them needing to dress up to enter.

I hope this clarified my point of reasoning with these other mumsnet users!

As for the original post, I stand by the fact that excessive queueing is a fault of our country being in late stage capitalism and our public service users feeling the consequences!

I actually think Olive has a point here.

Posters seem to think that things like social contracts and conventions, and signs, serve as some kind of safeguard against harm.

It's silly, really. I mean, if a criminal wants to break into your home, he technically can - what's stopping him? He doesn't need to dress up in black and white with a swag bag. He can just smash a window!

And speed limits and stop signs? As much as we'd like them to, bits of painted metal and plastic don't generate "you-shall-not-pass" Gandalfian forcefields. It's just silly to behave as if they do. A road isn't a safe space, and I say that because it's a public space.

The one sticking point for me in what Olive says is about the privatisation of bathrooms. I'm all for this. It worked for the railways, the NHS is heading that way too - it's clearly the future.

Bathroomz R Us? Loos 4 Youse! Johnsons' Powder Room!!!

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 18:42

CreativeGreen · 31/10/2026 17:14

I have never ever once seen a man dressed as a man enter the women’s loos

I just want to be really clear here that I was trying to argue against the TRA point that men can and do just go everywhere so it’s daft not to let TIMs in our loos. My point was most of the time men who accept they’re men don’t breach that boundary. Women’s loos were safer and closer to female only spaces before this all started up.

WildflowerMeadow · 31/10/2026 18:35

SillyOliveSnake · 31/10/2026 16:31

Hi @murasaki ! You seem to be questioning my point of reasoning and I would love to answer your question!

As a whole this thread, (at least the people I have responded to such as @ALovelyPinkUnicorn @Tears0fTheMushroom ) presents their issues with trans women using the bathroom or, as I'm sure you would say, your bathroom.

My first point of reasoning is that Terfism seems to like using the 'toilet issue' as a talking point. As I understand, there is a belief that a cis man would not enter a women's bathroom and would instead need to 'dress up' as trans women to do so. I do not agree with this belief. A bathroom is simply a room and if a man (an actual man, not a trans woman) wanted to enter such room with bad intensions and act on those intentions he could simply do so. Men, actual men, do not need to dress up as women to harm women in British society, they already do so.

A woman's toilet is not a safe space. And I do not say that because trans women are in that bathroom, I say that because it is a public space. Please do not interpret this statement as me arguing for bathrooms to be privatised, I am simply saying that when in public spaces there is a unfortunate risk of someone being there with bad intentions. Being Trans does not mean you have bad intentions.

I understand the fear of men as a women myself and wholeheartedly sympathise with it but it needs to be clarified that a woman's toilet does not have a magical forcefield around it that stop cis men with bad intentions entering, resulting with them needing to dress up to enter.

I hope this clarified my point of reasoning with these other mumsnet users!

As for the original post, I stand by the fact that excessive queueing is a fault of our country being in late stage capitalism and our public service users feeling the consequences!

My head can't compute the lack of understanding of the issue here - seriously, people aren't really this stupid are they?

A year ago I was menopausal and flooding massively. On at least two occasions I had to leave a toilet stall in only my knickers to rinse blood from my clothes at the sinks.

On both those occasions it was at a busy event where women were queuing to use the cubicles inside the ladies. On one occasion I actually ended up, with the help of another kind lady, quickly stripping off my knickers and fashioning some new underwear out of paper towels, a sanitary towel and some tape before I put my clothes back on.

I would have been humiliated to the extreme had any of the women who had been queuing at the time, and who I was in full view of, were a transwoman aka a man.

But seriously, people want to argue that this is not an issue - my mind kind of explodes at this.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2026 18:17

JanesLittleGirl · 31/10/2026 18:07

I have. He claimed to be a gender non-conforming transwoman.

The ultimate “in plain sight” power trip flex.