Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Are Women To Blame For 'Woke' Workplaces?

40 replies

UtopiaPlanitia · 22/10/2026 16:57

Tanya de Grunwald did a live podcast on this topic at the Battle of Ideas - I thought giving the episode a thread of its own would be useful for future FWR search and archive purposes.

I'm listening to it now and I'm finding it very interesting - the podcast bros who have taken this idea as their new mantra are definitely being incredibly shallow and sexist in their 'analysis' of women in the workplace (but we knew that).

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/9y7FH4ZcXfA

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UtopiaPlanitia · 27/10/2026 19:46

You make some interesting points @dinodart

In previous podcast episodes, Tanya has also discussed the negative effects that staff affinity networks/groups can have on aspects of culture in organisations. It very much depends on the type/attitude of people in the networks/groups as to whether there is a positive or a punitive approach.

OP posts:
dinodart · 27/10/2026 18:12

I've been hearing men blaming women for the state of things because of their higher empathy for awhile. Of course, at first, I had a knee jerk reaction to it but now I do think there is some truth to it. So much of the insanity of the "woke" movement where things have gone to far in the other direction (like with all the identity issues that put emotion and narrative before truth and reality) really come down to wanting to be "nice" and virtue signal how nice you are, afraid to be mean and be seen as a "bad" person. And truly we women tend to have more empathy and are taught that part of our value lies in being "nice" I think is definitely part of the problem.

Men have an easier time being blunt not only because of fundamental differences in the sexes (men are shown time and time again to have higher confidence and egos), but they are also penalized less for it.

That said, men who deride women for this absolutely benefit from it as well. So many crap men wouldn't have girlfriends/wives if the women didn't have enough empathy to put up with their crap. Like so many men take it for granted that women are that way and benefit from it as well in their personal lives.

UtopiaPlanitia · 27/10/2026 17:20

Follow up post from Tanya:

https://x.com/IsntWorkingPod/status/2115103565265924408?s=20

“Are women to blame for 'woke' workplaces? Yes - but so are MEN like this! PS. He's just left his role as chief people officer at the BBC 👋🥳”

ThisIsntWorkingPodcast (@IsntWorkingPod) on X

Are women to blame for 'woke' workplaces? Yes - but so are MEN like this! PS. He's just left his role as chief people officer at the BBC 👋🥳

https://x.com/IsntWorkingPod/status/2115103565265924408?s=20

OP posts:
sweetnsourr · 26/10/2026 05:14

Restingduvet · 25/10/2026 21:04

The strength in trade union has always been the unity of different oppressed groups & doing their best to cater for all their needs

No. This is what trade unions have become after they won all the big employment battles and then got bored of the dullness of upholding employment rights. But actually, the purpose and strength of unions was always upholding their member’s interests. That is what they are for. They’ve weakened themselves by diversifying into being social justice warriors for whatever is the latest popular leftist cause.

They are an embarrassing shambles now of not very bright progressive activists. No wonder union membership is dropping. If unions slowly died out they would only have themselves to blame.

Rly?

Secured Historic Legal Rights (Employment Rights Bill)
Unions like UNISON have hailed recent legislative breakthroughs as a "bright new era" for workers. Key victories now transitioning into law include: 1]

  • Day-one protections: Eliminating waiting periods for statutory sick pay and providing immediate rights to parental leave.
  • Ending exploitative practices: Severely curbing zero-hours contracts and banning unscrupulous "fire and rehire" tactics.
  • Unfair dismissal protections: Strengthening legal safeguards against unfair sackings from the very first day of employment.
  • Industrial action protection: Establishing strict new prohibitions against employers penalizing or causing detriment to workers who take part in lawful strikes. 1, 2, 3, 4]

Expanded Workplace Access and Recognition
Unions have won significant structural reforms that make it much easier to recruit, organize, and represent staff: 1]

  • Physical and digital workplace access: New rules give independent unions a statutory process to access workplaces (both physically and through internal digital systems) to communicate with and support workers. 1, 2]
  • Lower recognition thresholds: The "likely majority" test has been removed. Unions no longer have to prove a majority of the workforce supports them before launching an official recognition application. 1, 2]
  • Expanding into tech and finance: This lower barrier has allowed unions like Unite and FDA to push into previously non-traditional spaces, launching fresh recognition bids at tech startups, maritime companies, and the Financial Conduct Authority. 1]

Delivered a Growing "Union Wage Premium"

  • Higher pay rates: According to TUC data, the union "wage premium"—the pay gap showing how much more union members earn compared to non-unionized peers—grew to 5.3%. 1]
  • Aggressive pay campaigns: Civil service and public sector unions have actively staged strikes and intensive negotiations to demand up to 10% pay rises, better pensions, and localized minimum wage guarantees. 1, 2]

Brought Back Workplace Upskilling

  • Union Learning Fund: The trade union movement successfully campaigned for the re-establishment of the Union Learning Fund. This initiative funds union representatives and stewards to directly provide skills training, education, and career development to their colleagues on the shop floor. 1]

Trade Union Reform

https://www.business.gov.uk/campaign/employment-changes/employee/trade-union-reform/

CoffeeBotherer · 26/10/2026 00:20

Woke is now so wide ranging that it's a meaningless term. But obviously it's been led by and pushed by women and HR, to state anything else is ridiculous. The fact that it's been co-opted and misused is a different argument.

Restingduvet · 25/10/2026 21:04

sweetnsourr · 23/10/2026 01:42

Agree with audience member that progressive values in the workplace are purely profit driven. The idea that HR controls corporate values is ridiculous. They (as in the men & women on these boards) are simply going with consultancy recommendations that often hinge on the prevailing cultural zeitgeist. Very surprised this wasn't brought up by the guest speaker but given she seems to have a conservative bias in her framing the last thing these people will blame is the profit incentive but the first thing they point the finger at is progressives not caring about class interests to avoid responsibility.

Management also has a responsibility for not coming afoul of anti discrimination law that in modernity includes an obligation for being proactive by promoting acceptance in the workplace. In other words, they can be accused of being culpable for instances of discrimination by not preventing a toxic work environment taking hold which she conveniently avoided.

The other critique of trade unions not being concerned with class interests is a tell of how little the guest speaker understands trade union principles which are big tent solidarity values. The strength in trade union has always been the unity of different oppressed groups & doing their best to cater for all their needs. The idea that they have lost interest in basic working conditions not being improved because of diversity is patently false & simply right wing propaganda to create resentment thereby weakening trade union membership. That the guest speaker attempted this line of argument rings alarm bells of what her true motives are.

Don't be fooled by the faux defence of women's responsibility for 'woke'. The right are very good at pretending to be on women's side these days while simultaneously shafting them in practice. She smells like just another corporate shill in sheep's clothing.

The strength in trade union has always been the unity of different oppressed groups & doing their best to cater for all their needs

No. This is what trade unions have become after they won all the big employment battles and then got bored of the dullness of upholding employment rights. But actually, the purpose and strength of unions was always upholding their member’s interests. That is what they are for. They’ve weakened themselves by diversifying into being social justice warriors for whatever is the latest popular leftist cause.

They are an embarrassing shambles now of not very bright progressive activists. No wonder union membership is dropping. If unions slowly died out they would only have themselves to blame.

dracn · 25/10/2026 20:54

FemaleAndLearning · 22/10/2026 17:04

I thought the first rule of misogyny was that it was always the woman's fault!!!

But I've listened to Tanya a lot and there are a lot of misogynistic gay men in the DEI world so I think they shoulder a lot of blame.

I agree about the misogynistic gay men. But the problem in my experience is there is never a shortage of straight white women who will do anything to befriend these men.

MintBird · 25/10/2026 16:48

Depends what you mean by "woke" as it's a very vague and generic term.

Presuming it's a left/right thing according to graphs on social media how certain demographics currently vote, if only women under 40 voted the Greens would be in power and if only men over 50 voted Reform would be in power. So, go figure.

TempestTost · 25/10/2026 01:20

Heggettypeg · 23/10/2026 15:33

I wonder if it's at least partly to do with power, and the types of power available and not available to women.

In a world where men are usually the ones who are stronger- than- thou and richer - than - thou etc, being holier- than - thou is one of the few opportunities for prestige that is equally accessible to women, whereas a man who likes power can envisage other ways of climbing the ladder.

It used to be religious holiness, but the new "religion" of social justice does the a similar job. Once a workplace has taken on board that it has to be seen to be doing, somebody who is up to date with all the latest acceptable vocabulary and social and verbal taboos has endless opportunities for wrong-footing people, even when they're further up the workplace hierarchy. And they can convince themself that they're fighting the good fight and championing people less fortunate than themselves, either as a group, or by taking a particular individual under their wing

In the gender- related employment tribunals, there has seemed to be a pattern of zealous women and of men who I would say are more old-fashioned laissez-faire sexists than TRAs. But that may be because the trans issue doesn't impact men so much; they can afford to go along with it without much actual conviction.

I think this is on the right track.

To some extent I think men and women tend to run parallel power hierarchies.

Sometimes they also have a mixed hierarchy, sometimes not, depending on the society. But I think there is always also a male one and a female one. And the things that men and women do to advance in that hierarchy are not the same.

For women, a big part seems to be to embody social values, whether they are conservative, or whether they are meant to be rebellious or edgy. And also showing virtue, whatever that means for them.

And in terms of power struggles within that hierarchy, one way to do it is by tearing others down by showing them not to be virtuous, or not embodying the right values, and by creating social rejection from the group.

And religion can be used that way, or the idea of being cool, or progressive social justice.

sweetnsourr · 24/10/2026 23:09

Grammarnut · 24/10/2026 23:05

Really? Woke seems to involve slurring people who disagree with whatever is this week's good cause (trans ideology, pro-Palestinianism etc) and threatening to rape, cancel, burn or otherwise harm them. Not treating people well and not very inclusive, either.

By this logic Bindel is 'woke' then? Huh?

https://x.com/socfemoz/status/2113479676840890583?s=20

Kylie Maree (@socfemoz) on X

Julie Bindel is nice.

https://x.com/socfemoz/status/2113479676840890583?s=20

Grammarnut · 24/10/2026 23:07

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 23/10/2026 17:49

Are women at the forefront for driving institutional change to end misogyny and protect minority rights In the workplace?.

Yes, and all power to them.

This is just more 'have women's rights gone too far' misogyny.

All part of trying to pit vulnerable groups against each other. Most cis women stand up for trans people against a common enemy, knowing that we'll be next if we give an inch.

Respect in the workplace costs absolutely nothing, and harms no one.

Transwomen are men and have nothing to do with women's rights.

Grammarnut · 24/10/2026 23:05

Hyroplate · 22/10/2026 17:13

Woke basically means treating people well, so probably

Really? Woke seems to involve slurring people who disagree with whatever is this week's good cause (trans ideology, pro-Palestinianism etc) and threatening to rape, cancel, burn or otherwise harm them. Not treating people well and not very inclusive, either.

UtopiaPlanitia · 23/10/2026 18:28

Heggettypeg · 23/10/2026 18:23

So let's see a bit of respect for women who don't want to get changed in front of a man.

Let's see a bit of respect for women who don't want to discuss their rape with, or in the presence of, a man, and for the rape counsel staff who support them in that.

Let's see a bit of respect for female athletes who know that the winner is pretty much a foregone conclusion because there's a man in their competition.

Since, as you say, respect costs absolutely nothing and harms no-one.

Absolutely!

OP posts:
Heggettypeg · 23/10/2026 18:23

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 23/10/2026 17:49

Are women at the forefront for driving institutional change to end misogyny and protect minority rights In the workplace?.

Yes, and all power to them.

This is just more 'have women's rights gone too far' misogyny.

All part of trying to pit vulnerable groups against each other. Most cis women stand up for trans people against a common enemy, knowing that we'll be next if we give an inch.

Respect in the workplace costs absolutely nothing, and harms no one.

So let's see a bit of respect for women who don't want to get changed in front of a man.

Let's see a bit of respect for women who don't want to discuss their rape with, or in the presence of, a man, and for the rape counsel staff who support them in that.

Let's see a bit of respect for female athletes who know that the winner is pretty much a foregone conclusion because there's a man in their competition.

Since, as you say, respect costs absolutely nothing and harms no-one.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 23/10/2026 17:49

Are women at the forefront for driving institutional change to end misogyny and protect minority rights In the workplace?.

Yes, and all power to them.

This is just more 'have women's rights gone too far' misogyny.

All part of trying to pit vulnerable groups against each other. Most cis women stand up for trans people against a common enemy, knowing that we'll be next if we give an inch.

Respect in the workplace costs absolutely nothing, and harms no one.

UtopiaPlanitia · 23/10/2026 17:37

sweetnsourr · 23/10/2026 16:34

In response to statements make by PP, it's my understanding that Joanna Williams (the guest on the podcast) is an old-school Lefty thinker.

Clearly not anymore with all those word for word right wing talking points.

She's Blue Labour rather than Red Labour.

OP posts:
sweetnsourr · 23/10/2026 16:34

UtopiaPlanitia · 23/10/2026 16:26

That's a really interesting idea. Just trying to think it through: women in most societies tend to enforce the (often patriarchal) social norms and can derive social standing from doing so. Middle-class women have often had stronger social need to do it than working-class women (because the capitalist system often removes the ability to stick to social niceties from those at the bottom of the of social/financial pyramid). It would make sense that increasing numbers of women (of a particular class) in a workplace (which until recently was male dominated in all sectors) would bring that social dynamic with them. Which means, to me, Woke is still superficially socialist as it is not taking class-based needs into account when promoting 'diversity'.

In response to statements make by PP, it's my understanding that Joanna Williams (the guest on the podcast) is an old-school Lefty thinker.

In response to statements make by PP, it's my understanding that Joanna Williams (the guest on the podcast) is an old-school Lefty thinker.

Clearly not anymore with all those word for word right wing talking points.

UtopiaPlanitia · 23/10/2026 16:26

Heggettypeg · 23/10/2026 15:33

I wonder if it's at least partly to do with power, and the types of power available and not available to women.

In a world where men are usually the ones who are stronger- than- thou and richer - than - thou etc, being holier- than - thou is one of the few opportunities for prestige that is equally accessible to women, whereas a man who likes power can envisage other ways of climbing the ladder.

It used to be religious holiness, but the new "religion" of social justice does the a similar job. Once a workplace has taken on board that it has to be seen to be doing, somebody who is up to date with all the latest acceptable vocabulary and social and verbal taboos has endless opportunities for wrong-footing people, even when they're further up the workplace hierarchy. And they can convince themself that they're fighting the good fight and championing people less fortunate than themselves, either as a group, or by taking a particular individual under their wing

In the gender- related employment tribunals, there has seemed to be a pattern of zealous women and of men who I would say are more old-fashioned laissez-faire sexists than TRAs. But that may be because the trans issue doesn't impact men so much; they can afford to go along with it without much actual conviction.

That's a really interesting idea. Just trying to think it through: women in most societies tend to enforce the (often patriarchal) social norms and can derive social standing from doing so. Middle-class women have often had stronger social need to do it than working-class women (because the capitalist system often removes the ability to stick to social niceties from those at the bottom of the of social/financial pyramid). It would make sense that increasing numbers of women (of a particular class) in a workplace (which until recently was male dominated in all sectors) would bring that social dynamic with them. Which means, to me, Woke is still superficially socialist as it is not taking class-based needs into account when promoting 'diversity'.

In response to statements make by PP, it's my understanding that Joanna Williams (the guest on the podcast) is an old-school Lefty thinker.

OP posts:
Heggettypeg · 23/10/2026 15:33

I wonder if it's at least partly to do with power, and the types of power available and not available to women.

In a world where men are usually the ones who are stronger- than- thou and richer - than - thou etc, being holier- than - thou is one of the few opportunities for prestige that is equally accessible to women, whereas a man who likes power can envisage other ways of climbing the ladder.

It used to be religious holiness, but the new "religion" of social justice does the a similar job. Once a workplace has taken on board that it has to be seen to be doing, somebody who is up to date with all the latest acceptable vocabulary and social and verbal taboos has endless opportunities for wrong-footing people, even when they're further up the workplace hierarchy. And they can convince themself that they're fighting the good fight and championing people less fortunate than themselves, either as a group, or by taking a particular individual under their wing

In the gender- related employment tribunals, there has seemed to be a pattern of zealous women and of men who I would say are more old-fashioned laissez-faire sexists than TRAs. But that may be because the trans issue doesn't impact men so much; they can afford to go along with it without much actual conviction.

ChequerToRed · 23/10/2026 09:33

TempestTost · 23/10/2026 02:38

It's silly to try and pin it on any group, that just doesn't make sense.

However, I think there is a very strong pattern that female dominated sectors are most captures and pushing this stuff. Education, health, the arts, libraries.

And I don't buy that it's just that they've been conditioned to be kind. That's just not been my experience at all, many of the women I've encountered who are involved are true believers and push it viciously.

And I don’t think such people are a new phenomenon, they’ve always been with us. 500 years ago they’d have been those deciding the who were the deserving and undeserving poor when dishing out the parish dole, or 150 years ago helping ‘fallen women’ if they demonstrated enough piety and repentance for their sins. Hobbes wrote of ‘The meanness of charity’ in 1651, and there’s always been a tendency for the beneficent to be acting out of nothing more noble than reputational signalling and sheer vanity, in a way that allows injustice to be swept under the carpet.

sweetnsourr · 23/10/2026 06:33

Mapletree1985 · 23/10/2026 06:19

I find it quite useful.

I'm an old socialist and human rights campaigner, and "woke" seems like a handy term of reference for when principles and beliefs that are good in themselves go sour and start causing more harm than good.

The problem is its very subjective & reductive. What one person perceives as principles gone sour might be up to the political position of the person. Diversity is an example where its portrayed as meritless by the right when in fact that's not necessarily so depending on the context.

In fact the guest speaker in the podcast seemed to have the rather bizarre notion that bringing their personal business to work was 'woke' when in fact workplaces by nature are places of personal social interaction.

Mapletree1985 · 23/10/2026 06:19

UtopiaPlanitia · 22/10/2026 17:35

'Woke' is an unhelpful description for a melding of critical theory, and postmodernism from the Frankfurt School tendency in academia, leaking out into the real world and being applied to situations for which it has little of relevance to offer. It has elements of superficial Marxism but doesn't do anything to really address class-based disadvantages in society.

I find it quite useful.

I'm an old socialist and human rights campaigner, and "woke" seems like a handy term of reference for when principles and beliefs that are good in themselves go sour and start causing more harm than good.

2021x · 23/10/2026 03:24

I think the general idea of "being woke" has been corrupted over the last 5 years by bad actors who force people and organisations to participate in an elaborate, coordinated set of behaviours to show the herd they are "good" people.

Pronouns in bios, rainbow lanyards, equity training, etc.- none of it has any real-world value. There is a direct correlation in my experience between people who draw attention to all these causes and the people who are most likely to bully an interns when no one is looking.

The origins are simply instructions to question things by staying "woke", especially when it's wrapped up in sugary language and heavy marketing.

It is fine to simply follow the advice of the Buddah, Jesus etc.. and don't be a dick.

sweetnsourr · 23/10/2026 03:22

TempestTost · 23/10/2026 02:38

It's silly to try and pin it on any group, that just doesn't make sense.

However, I think there is a very strong pattern that female dominated sectors are most captures and pushing this stuff. Education, health, the arts, libraries.

And I don't buy that it's just that they've been conditioned to be kind. That's just not been my experience at all, many of the women I've encountered who are involved are true believers and push it viciously.

But who exactly (& this is where the accusation of female = woke makes sense) made their daughter's 'true believers'?

I know my own strong feminist & egalitarian values no doubt influenced my daughter who is now a 'woke scold'. While my son is a progressive he's not a scold. Generations of parents post civil rights movements particularly women (because of their self interest) have made it their business to raise their children with egalitarian values fermenting the ground for a social revolution. Once egalitarianism & acceptance becomes a principal social value thats underpinned by a long history of oppression its bound to have an influential effect on all spheres of life. And perhaps the reason why some progressives take this too far & become scolds is a kind of generational trauma thing that they are over correcting for rather than narcissistic reasons.

sweetnsourr · 23/10/2026 03:20

Error

Swipe left for the next trending thread