Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Gallagher v Tavistock, 2nd to 27th November, RCJ

151 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 22/10/2026 09:26

This case seems to have slipped under the radar somewhat, as it isn't a GC beliefs case, but there are parallels. There will be 13 witnesses from the Tavistock. It may well expose the way 'critical theory' in general has captured the NHS and how those who refuse to bow down are bullied, ostracised, and forced out of their jobs.

The claimant states:

"From the disclosure, we found that senior staff at the Tavistock were calling me names in their correspondence with each other. This included calling me a “fascist” and a “racist.” They also referred to me as a “poisonous creature” and a “snake.”
Alongside this, Senior staff openly stated that my beliefs were not likely to be compatible with ethical practice. It was shocking to see, laid bare, the way in which a whole group of NHS professionals could abuse their positions of power to openly bully a trainee. I believe they thought it unlikely that I would be able to defend myself."

"My trial is listed at the Royal Courts of Justice from 2–27 November, with almost the entire month set aside for the Court to hear the evidence and determine my claims.
The Tavistock NHS are calling 13 witnesses. I will be the only witness on my side. I will likely be cross-examined for 3 days.

For those who have followed my case from the beginning, you will know what is at stake for me. My case concerns my allegations that I suffered anti-white racial harassment and discrimination. I am further claiming that I was discriminated against for expressing a colour-blind approach to race. This was expressed in opposition to Critical Race Theory. This is the first lawsuit to bring these claims against the NHS to trial in this way.

I have pursued this case because I believe that equality must mean equality for everyone.

Getting to this point has taken years of determination. Litigation of this scale is demanding and extremely expensive, and the forthcoming trial will involve a substantial amount of preparation and legal work. I have already written and submitted a very lengthy witness statement which took many weeks to write."

I don't know if there will be remote access or if anyone will be covering it on X. I'll add to the thread if I find out.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Justabaker · 13/11/2026 12:31

So, in practical terms it works like this:

Parties agree the bundle of documents and the witnesses they will call
Solicitors ask the witnesses to prepare statements and give them access to the relevant documents from the bundle.

Witnesses don't have a right to see the entire bundle.

The transcripts are described as being in the supplementary unagreed bundle. The judge did not (as I recall) decide to admit them until possibly the final preliminary matters hearing on 4 November.

I don't know if the witnesses had access to the transcripts before they prepared their statements but I would assume that the Trust's solicitors would have known they were a topic of discussion. I think in interviewing and giving guidance to witnesses they could/should have mentioned that there is a possibility of transcripts of meetings.

YourWatermelonship · 13/11/2026 12:43

rebax · 13/11/2026 11:14

I believe that the transcripts of the recordings had been disclosed (as they should have been), as there was an exchange with a witness who had clearly seen the transcript before making their witness statement.

I was wondering why they had been disclosed. Sadly we are used to defendants dragging their feet with disclosure. To the point that I'm surprised when something as clearly detrimental to the defence as these recordings is part of the initial disclosure documents.

Kirschcherries · 13/11/2026 13:18

YourWatermelonship · 13/11/2026 12:43

I was wondering why they had been disclosed. Sadly we are used to defendants dragging their feet with disclosure. To the point that I'm surprised when something as clearly detrimental to the defence as these recordings is part of the initial disclosure documents.

It’s the claimant who disclosed them as sensibly she recorded them. I don’t condone secret recording but sometimes when it’s clear you are being discriminated against it’s one option.

Veilsofmorning · 13/11/2026 13:36

TT not able to report this morning.

Justabaker · 13/11/2026 14:16

YourWatermelonship · 13/11/2026 12:43

I was wondering why they had been disclosed. Sadly we are used to defendants dragging their feet with disclosure. To the point that I'm surprised when something as clearly detrimental to the defence as these recordings is part of the initial disclosure documents.

See my note above.

The transcripts are in what is referred to as the 'supplemental unagreed bundle'.

This means they are not in the main agreed document bundle. They may have been a surprise to the defendants because they were made from secret recordings.

YourWatermelonship · 13/11/2026 16:13

Thanks @Justabaker , I think we cross posted.

And thank you for your excellent summary upthread!

I wonder what the next witnesses will bring. GB set the bar high (or low??)

DrBlackbird · 13/11/2026 16:55

I’ve only read some of the TT summaries but that thing with the phone… Did it remind anyone else of the case where the woman ‘accidentally’ dropped her phone in the North Sea so couldn’t be handed over as evidence. Which I’m thinking was the Wagatha Colleen Rooney trial?

rebax · 13/11/2026 17:10

DrBlackbird · 13/11/2026 16:55

I’ve only read some of the TT summaries but that thing with the phone… Did it remind anyone else of the case where the woman ‘accidentally’ dropped her phone in the North Sea so couldn’t be handed over as evidence. Which I’m thinking was the Wagatha Colleen Rooney trial?

I think there were several missing phones in the Lorna Young case.

borntobequiet · 13/11/2026 17:46

Didn’t Boris Johnson have a problem with his phone and couldn’t retrieve WhatsApp messages from the Covid period? In fact I seem to remember that lots of government bods had similar problems at the time, how coincidental.

anyolddinosaur · 15/11/2026 08:41

Dont forget Upton's phone.

borntobequiet · 15/11/2026 08:46

Strange how normal everyday people get through life without endless trouble with their phones and messages.

Veilsofmorning · Yesterday 10:55

Thank-you TT for struggling through and @Justabaker for posting.

rebax · Yesterday 11:51

From Friday

FH an allegation of intimdation by a mbr of staff ix Ag is of obvious relevance to this case.
ES - I directed to her to approp place for ix to take place. I am sorry that I ommitted it. i didn't know abt subsequent suing.

Slightly cryptic but it looks like one of the members on the panel for the final investigation of AG is suing the Tavistock for intimidation (possibly by AB), and this was not included in this witness' statement.

Kirschcherries · Yesterday 12:13

@Justabaker thank you. TT do a fantastic job even in very difficult circumstances.

ES/ERS is doing a good job of revers ferreting on the investigation that wasn’t an investigation but let to “findings”. I find it interesting she never met AG.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · Yesterday 13:15

Friday 13th November Afternoon Part 1 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RyorWBWp4kaBx5ZE3hdNbOH-agks6FCt/view?usp=drive_link
Friday 13th November Afternoon Part 2 https://perma.cc/NC63-FQZD

Monday 16 November Morning Part 1 https://archive.ph/PeMkK

And from today's evidence , Amy Gallagher's solicitor talking to Dr Tomasz Fortuna:

FH - core evidence 247, email from GB telling you and NW about a complaint and the Trust policy on whiteness, so you were aware of that then. On 18th March, 410, that says from GB dear 59F colleagues - those teaching AG group inc you?
...
FH - if you go back to 420 penultimate email, you say hi GB don't know how she can object to people invited or whiteness policy Trust should be robust, here do you suggest the split?

What is this about a "Trust policy on whiteness"? Sounds very dodgy if there was one. I wonder if they still have one.

Veilsofmorning · Yesterday 15:16

Anyone else having trouble getting through to this morning’s TT?

TheDisguiseOfReasonableness · Yesterday 15:25

Bit awkward when the student you’ve claimed was aggressive and threatening turns out to have recorded the meeting . . .

rebax · Yesterday 15:26

Further spiciness

J reads transcript out It's fair to say we thought she was affiliated with R wing or far R orgs.
FH I'll say that is a highly inflamatory remark about a MH nurse

EricTheHalfASleeve · Yesterday 15:42

Tavistock seem to have more than 1 witness who is very obviously lying.

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 16:10

‘FH do you see it says AG, that passage, it is likely she will not meet ethical standard for practice, her beliefs and conduct are likely to impact negatively on her ability to practice. The exec said her beliefs weren't acceptable
JY no her lack of openness and conduct
FH it says beliefs
JY it's notes, might not be accurate it's a distillation’

Then

‘FH but you did send draft to the exec and asked GB to check AG section for accuracy. Email from you, so you do adopt those minutes?
JY the final ones yes’

This is all a bit strange. Why does JY maintain that they didn’t really mean ‘beliefs’ when they wrote ‘beliefs’, as it was just notes. And then it appears the draft minutes were approved and adopted. If it is written down in black and white, and the draft version is adopted, then why try to deny it means what it says as you just come across as dodgy.

I think AG was very wise to record these people.

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 16:14

rebax · Yesterday 15:26

Further spiciness

J reads transcript out It's fair to say we thought she was affiliated with R wing or far R orgs.
FH I'll say that is a highly inflamatory remark about a MH nurse

But so concerned, and made such an impression that now can’t remember what/who those far right orgs were.

Mmmnotsure · Yesterday 16:27

Interesting - and obvious - that once the witness thought they might be personally liable (when the barrister mentioned that outside the court the claimant could call it defamation) they get worried and the judge has to reassure them.

It's like so many of these cases, especially the NHS/government ones. People think they can behave however they want because their views are the right ones, and they are protected, with no personal employment or financial liability.

rebax · Yesterday 16:49

Also from this morning
TF We don't want experience of the trainee to be can only trust one half of the staff.

Suggestion of splits within the staff on the issues.

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 17:18

Well, the ‘half’ that TF probably identifies as trustworthy, look pretty flippin’ untrustworthy now they are exposed to scrutiny.

Swipe left for the next trending thread