Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Gallagher v Tavistock, 2nd to 27th November, RCJ

180 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 22/10/2026 09:26

This case seems to have slipped under the radar somewhat, as it isn't a GC beliefs case, but there are parallels. There will be 13 witnesses from the Tavistock. It may well expose the way 'critical theory' in general has captured the NHS and how those who refuse to bow down are bullied, ostracised, and forced out of their jobs.

The claimant states:

"From the disclosure, we found that senior staff at the Tavistock were calling me names in their correspondence with each other. This included calling me a “fascist” and a “racist.” They also referred to me as a “poisonous creature” and a “snake.”
Alongside this, Senior staff openly stated that my beliefs were not likely to be compatible with ethical practice. It was shocking to see, laid bare, the way in which a whole group of NHS professionals could abuse their positions of power to openly bully a trainee. I believe they thought it unlikely that I would be able to defend myself."

"My trial is listed at the Royal Courts of Justice from 2–27 November, with almost the entire month set aside for the Court to hear the evidence and determine my claims.
The Tavistock NHS are calling 13 witnesses. I will be the only witness on my side. I will likely be cross-examined for 3 days.

For those who have followed my case from the beginning, you will know what is at stake for me. My case concerns my allegations that I suffered anti-white racial harassment and discrimination. I am further claiming that I was discriminated against for expressing a colour-blind approach to race. This was expressed in opposition to Critical Race Theory. This is the first lawsuit to bring these claims against the NHS to trial in this way.

I have pursued this case because I believe that equality must mean equality for everyone.

Getting to this point has taken years of determination. Litigation of this scale is demanding and extremely expensive, and the forthcoming trial will involve a substantial amount of preparation and legal work. I have already written and submitted a very lengthy witness statement which took many weeks to write."

I don't know if there will be remote access or if anyone will be covering it on X. I'll add to the thread if I find out.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Thehorticulturalhussie · 12/11/2026 17:06

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 17:02

So it is a load of bollocks, with or without bigly writing!

Bigly bollocks.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 17:02

So it is a load of bollocks, with or without bigly writing!

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 17:00

It can be hard to pick out as I'm only going by TT but they did seem to be talking about a reading group over Zoom:
Thursday morning session 2

WA- I read it no concerns, we were starting the reading group
FH- First session, AG only spoke to introduce herself
AG- Cannot remember
FH- Was she silent at next session
WA- Think so due to emails I have seen since
FH- She attended all sessions
WA- Not sure, cannot remember
WA- She probably did
FH- Another witness said she did, can direct you
WA- Yes
FH- Session on 28 Jun on chapter of HM book
WA- Cannot remember if it was that session but we discussed that chapter
FH- Introduced chapter from HM book, this was by zoom.
WA- Yes
FH- Chapter heading- the disavowel (?) of whiteness
WA- Yes

....
WA- My experience was that she did shut down things in the reading group. I wanted to be able to keep the reading group going and to be clear about that.
WA- I recall her saying other things.
FH- If the email does go the the DOET I am not sure about the line about her being vocal as she only spoke up in one group. She wasn't shutting down discussion when she wasn't saying anything in earlier groups
WA- No
FH- Nor was she when she mentioned most people are colour blind, which you agreed with.
WA- Do not agree with that. Another context in my WS there was something unnerving as someone in the room looked uncomfortable and there was shutting down effect.
....
And Thursday afternoon session 2

FH - EN back to the reading groups meeting 21/6/21. You've already seen zoom link. You say 6-8 participants. That appears like 6-8 boxes on a zoom call? EN - yes FH - Different ways it can be shown- J - Pause for a moment [Discussing live transcription and having tech difficulties. Pausing for new link sent out] [Working now] FH - So I was asking. You agree the normal zoom call is shown by boxes onscreen? And was that the way it was being shown for that meeting? EN - yes FH - Were you referring to that book on screen or did u have a printed version? EN - How they groups are run is that we read and then discuss. FH - So you screen was all the small boxes? EN - yes FH - AG was on mute? EN - in which bit? FH - In paragraph 10 [EN reads] EN - yes FH - Your attention was on the text and whoever was speaking? EN - At times but also..I think you are also observing what's going on. I would be tracking like if someone wanted to speak. I wouldn't just be looking at the person I dont think. I'd be looking at group as well

Yes, Zoom.

Edit attempt to remove bigly writing, dunno where that came from!

Veilsofmorning · 12/11/2026 16:52

ickky · 12/11/2026 16:48

I didn't realise it was a Zoom meeting.

Might be me that’s wrong- but the basic point we are all making is the same whatever the platform.

Thehorticulturalhussie · 12/11/2026 16:51

ickky · 12/11/2026 16:37

Could call it body language

Unless AG was nose to nose and glowering, I fail to see how this is of any consequence.

So she didn't say anything wrong or shout

We can get her on tone and body language or failing that, a feeling.

She did say something wrong according to our own purity test but we can't say that in court.

WTF

It’s so hard not to deduce that her account is fiction, written (poorly) to suit the argument that AG is the aggressor and not the victim. No need for unpalatable facts here. No wonder there was some under the counter messaging going on, they have 13 witnesses to whip into a single narrative.
And this is costing us how much????

ickky · 12/11/2026 16:50

Veilsofmorning · 12/11/2026 16:46

Am I correct that we are asked to believe that this judgement of body language could be made on a Zoom call with multiple windows open - especially if the person saying they can make that judgement was supposed to be running the session and so should/would have concentration on doing that and listening to whoever was speaking at the time?

Well if it's anything like the court video sessions, you can barely see anything.

What a complete load of made up nonsense.

BiologicalRobot · 12/11/2026 16:50

Bloody hell. So they've actually gone further than saying it was the tone of her voice, or the words she used...it was how she held her body 😮

ickky · 12/11/2026 16:48

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 16:46

Can one be nose to nose and glowering in a Teams meeting? Who has body language in a Teams meeting anwyay? It's possible to dominate a Teams meeting and silence other people but only if the person running the meeting lets you.

Maybe calling so many witnesses for the respondent wasn't so smart after all? They seemed to have trashed a student's reputation via a growing chain of hearsay. The more witnesses with flaky memories in the chain and all relying on each other and bigging the story up, the worse they all look. Seems like a gift to the claimant's barrister. And they still have what, 10 more witnesses to go?

I didn't realise it was a Zoom meeting.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 16:47

Sorry, Zoom call not Teams meeting @Veilsofmorning But yes, we think alike!

Veilsofmorning · 12/11/2026 16:46

rebax · 12/11/2026 16:21

Way beyond Bananarama

but there was something about her behaviour
FH - Context is AG hardly made any qs at all
EN - Could call it body language

Am I correct that we are asked to believe that this judgement of body language could be made on a Zoom call with multiple windows open - especially if the person saying they can make that judgement was supposed to be running the session and so should/would have concentration on doing that and listening to whoever was speaking at the time?

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 16:46

Can one be nose to nose and glowering in a Teams meeting? Who has body language in a Teams meeting anwyay? It's possible to dominate a Teams meeting and silence other people but only if the person running the meeting lets you.

Maybe calling so many witnesses for the respondent wasn't so smart after all? They seemed to have trashed a student's reputation via a growing chain of hearsay. The more witnesses with flaky memories in the chain and all relying on each other and bigging the story up, the worse they all look. Seems like a gift to the claimant's barrister. And they still have what, 10 more witnesses to go?

ickky · 12/11/2026 16:37

Could call it body language

Unless AG was nose to nose and glowering, I fail to see how this is of any consequence.

So she didn't say anything wrong or shout

We can get her on tone and body language or failing that, a feeling.

She did say something wrong according to our own purity test but we can't say that in court.

WTF

rebax · 12/11/2026 16:21

Way beyond Bananarama

but there was something about her behaviour
FH - Context is AG hardly made any qs at all
EN - Could call it body language

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 15:49

TT Thursday Morning Session Part 2 https://archive.ph/9QTyc 12 November 2026
TT Thursday Afternoon Session Part 1 https://archive.ph/pV1AA 12 November 2026

Thehorticulturalhussie · 12/11/2026 15:44

Good grief this is depressing.
My bold.

JH-You are linking opposition to CRT with her ability to work with patients
AH- No, it was the manner in which she expressed them, normal opposition would not go to a progression board. Not what she said, the manner in which she said it.
JH- You say loud, there was no mention of this in the document. GB said this
AH- Would not recall this detail
JH- You cannot recall it yourself and you cannot recall is GB said it.
AH_ No
JH- You gave just made it up
AH- I don't have full recollection of the progression board meeting

Banarama are doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

Justabaker · 12/11/2026 15:28

Ah, the Fun Boy 3/Bananarama defence.

TheDisguiseOfReasonableness · 12/11/2026 14:40

This seems even vaguer than the usual Bananarama stuff - it’s all “I just had a feeling” and “there was just something”

Cailleach1 · 12/11/2026 13:15

https://archive.ph/Vu7AR

Morning session, part one, 12th November, 2026.

YouCanCallMeMonster · 12/11/2026 10:31

If possible, GB came across even worse on Wednesday than she did on Thursday.

I cannot believe that any ET Judge could possibly suggest that she was a credible witness.

MalcolmTent · 11/11/2026 23:20

Justabaker · 10/11/2026 18:03

It was a barn burner this afternoon, contempt of court (sent a message to another witness that had not given evidence yet), a previously undisclosed Whatsapp group that had discussed the claimant and was unknown to the NHS Trust, and then was forced to agree with the barrister that she had actually breached the instruction NOT to contact the claimant by contacting the claimant at least 5 times.

Wow!

Justabaker · 11/11/2026 21:14

A quick note on archive links. Archive has been having a big bot purge. If you're getting non-working links, try clearing your cache and cookies and restarting.

And on this case - usually the witch finder or leader of mob is not called by the defence to give evidence and so the case swirls around the whirlpool of their absence. The Trust chose to put GB on for the defence. Make of that what you will.

EricTheHalfASleeve · 11/11/2026 21:07

I wonder if some people working in psychology & psychiatry become very used for being in a position of having lengthy unwitnessed interviews with patients, and where the professional's word is generally accepted even if the patient disagrees. There was a psychiatrist struck off for lying in a court report (for an employment tribunal)- only exposed because the person recorded the interview & reported them to the GMC.

https://www.bmj.com/content/365/bmj.l1585

borntobequiet · 11/11/2026 19:36

Although I thought the key point was that the J can infer things from the behaviour that the witness might not like J to infer

Astonishing that she’s a psychoanalyst/psychotherapist, of all things. Except that a psychotherapist relative of mine demonstrates strange, poorly regulated and sometimes vindictive behaviour which she doesn’t seem to be aware of, so perhaps it’s a feature.

rebax · 11/11/2026 19:17

ie J will likely decide that GB is not a credible witness and will infer dishonesty. That seems to be the ultimate punishment. You are a liar and I will assume the totality of your evidence is BS.

Barrister has been laying the groundwork that other witness statements rely on being told by BG that the student is a problem.

YourWatermelonship · 11/11/2026 19:10

rebax · 11/11/2026 13:28

Things are getting spicy re WhatsApp messages

FH do you wish to allege, under oath that AG has committed the offence of perverting the course of justice, by manufacturing evidence, possibly fraud?
GB no I do not wish to allege that
FH do you wish to accept that you did send the messages
GB - I think that is a conclusion that others will have to make

GB is coming across as an experienced liar. Oh to be a fly on the wall when she was being grilled and forced to admit she was fibbing!

On top of that she communicated with other witnesses in the middle of giving evidence.I bet she'll face no consequences whatsoever for any of it.