Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Gallagher v Tavistock, 2nd to 27th November, RCJ

179 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 22/10/2026 09:26

This case seems to have slipped under the radar somewhat, as it isn't a GC beliefs case, but there are parallels. There will be 13 witnesses from the Tavistock. It may well expose the way 'critical theory' in general has captured the NHS and how those who refuse to bow down are bullied, ostracised, and forced out of their jobs.

The claimant states:

"From the disclosure, we found that senior staff at the Tavistock were calling me names in their correspondence with each other. This included calling me a “fascist” and a “racist.” They also referred to me as a “poisonous creature” and a “snake.”
Alongside this, Senior staff openly stated that my beliefs were not likely to be compatible with ethical practice. It was shocking to see, laid bare, the way in which a whole group of NHS professionals could abuse their positions of power to openly bully a trainee. I believe they thought it unlikely that I would be able to defend myself."

"My trial is listed at the Royal Courts of Justice from 2–27 November, with almost the entire month set aside for the Court to hear the evidence and determine my claims.
The Tavistock NHS are calling 13 witnesses. I will be the only witness on my side. I will likely be cross-examined for 3 days.

For those who have followed my case from the beginning, you will know what is at stake for me. My case concerns my allegations that I suffered anti-white racial harassment and discrimination. I am further claiming that I was discriminated against for expressing a colour-blind approach to race. This was expressed in opposition to Critical Race Theory. This is the first lawsuit to bring these claims against the NHS to trial in this way.

I have pursued this case because I believe that equality must mean equality for everyone.

Getting to this point has taken years of determination. Litigation of this scale is demanding and extremely expensive, and the forthcoming trial will involve a substantial amount of preparation and legal work. I have already written and submitted a very lengthy witness statement which took many weeks to write."

I don't know if there will be remote access or if anyone will be covering it on X. I'll add to the thread if I find out.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Veilsofmorning · 13/11/2026 13:36

TT not able to report this morning.

Kirschcherries · 13/11/2026 13:18

YourWatermelonship · 13/11/2026 12:43

I was wondering why they had been disclosed. Sadly we are used to defendants dragging their feet with disclosure. To the point that I'm surprised when something as clearly detrimental to the defence as these recordings is part of the initial disclosure documents.

It’s the claimant who disclosed them as sensibly she recorded them. I don’t condone secret recording but sometimes when it’s clear you are being discriminated against it’s one option.

YourWatermelonship · 13/11/2026 12:43

rebax · 13/11/2026 11:14

I believe that the transcripts of the recordings had been disclosed (as they should have been), as there was an exchange with a witness who had clearly seen the transcript before making their witness statement.

I was wondering why they had been disclosed. Sadly we are used to defendants dragging their feet with disclosure. To the point that I'm surprised when something as clearly detrimental to the defence as these recordings is part of the initial disclosure documents.

Justabaker · 13/11/2026 12:31

So, in practical terms it works like this:

Parties agree the bundle of documents and the witnesses they will call
Solicitors ask the witnesses to prepare statements and give them access to the relevant documents from the bundle.

Witnesses don't have a right to see the entire bundle.

The transcripts are described as being in the supplementary unagreed bundle. The judge did not (as I recall) decide to admit them until possibly the final preliminary matters hearing on 4 November.

I don't know if the witnesses had access to the transcripts before they prepared their statements but I would assume that the Trust's solicitors would have known they were a topic of discussion. I think in interviewing and giving guidance to witnesses they could/should have mentioned that there is a possibility of transcripts of meetings.

Kirschcherries · 13/11/2026 12:10

@rebax you are correct the transcripts will have been disclosed so it was mock outrage that was quashed immediately.

The problem for all their witnesses is the recordings reveal tone, how it was said etc. completely disproving the bananarama defence.

Justabaker · 13/11/2026 12:10

There may be some TT reporting later on. But Microsoft outage means no remote access today.

Cailleach1 · 13/11/2026 11:46

Wondering about the ‘EC - Didnt realise transcrpit was taken ? by Isabel? by Trust?’ bit too.

Was it performative, I wonder?

FH’s response ‘FH - I think you know..’ would lead one to think it might have been, and EC was maybe very well aware of where the transcript came from. Wanted to act out a little vignette, though.

lcakethereforeIam · 13/11/2026 11:42

Perhaps it should be read 'No!? Because it's a transcript...', otherwise I'm confused too.

SylvanMoon · 13/11/2026 11:28

rebax · 13/11/2026 11:14

I believe that the transcripts of the recordings had been disclosed (as they should have been), as there was an exchange with a witness who had clearly seen the transcript before making their witness statement.

But if that was the case, wouldn't all the witnesses have seen what's been disclosed? If so, why did FH respond to her "No because its a transcript"?

rebax · 13/11/2026 11:14

I believe that the transcripts of the recordings had been disclosed (as they should have been), as there was an exchange with a witness who had clearly seen the transcript before making their witness statement.

Kirschcherries · 13/11/2026 10:54

Having read yesterdays TT, this exchange with EC is interesting
FH - There is a transcript of meeting -take you to it. Meeting with AG on 03/03
EC - Didnt realise transcrpit was taken ? by Isabel? by Trust?
FH - I think you know..
EC - dID i give permission?
FH - I am asking q in any event.
EC - Ive never seen this before!
FH - No because its a transcript but its a trancript of that meeting and i will ask q about whtether you rememebr what was said in that meeting. This is where AG says re white as a problem.. Black Lives Matter, focused everyones attenton on race.

I wonder if GBs contact with her solicitor whilst giving evidence was because she suddenly realised AG had recorded meetings etc. It was to warn other witnesses their interactions with AG may also have been recorded.

This exchange seems to be mock outrage from EC that she had been recorded.

What does come through is the bananarama defence is being disproved and that potentially other students with rigid views were not treated like AG because they were considered the “right” views.

Justabaker · 13/11/2026 10:27

No action from Gallagher yet. Unclear how much impact from Microsoft outages but we are assured that they have not started yet.

rebax · 13/11/2026 10:19

IANAL but am struggling to understand the defence argument. It is clear that there was detrimental treatment in preventing AG from seeing patients needed for progression. It is also clear that AG was picked out for reasons which completely fall apart under cross-examination (if there were no recordings then might survive 'he said, she said'). There is a philosophical belief which should pass WORIADS. There seems to be no groundwork for a 'bastard or incompetent defence'. So why is it being dragged out over 13 witnesses for the defence?

borntobequiet · 13/11/2026 10:15

Thank you for that superb summary, @Justabaker . I particularly like the immune system analogy!

DrBlackbird · 13/11/2026 10:07

Interesting. She’s criticised (and ostracised) for perceived rigidity of views. whilst the other students complaining appear to have been lauded and supported for their rigidity of views.

It’s all become such a mess really.

The pendulum had to swing from the overt racism of the past and well meaning, well intentioned voices pushed for greater recognition and change. So policies changed and education involved raising awareness and EDI was born. All of those ought to have been positive steps. Some were.

Yet, now we, as a multicultural society, find ourselves veering all over the place. CRT (which I still don’t really understand but think it means all white people are racist?) on the one hand, and complaints of two tier policing and English flags on poles on the other. It feels like societal divisions are growing. Not helped by these professionals who ought to have been more thoughtful and professional and less reflexively knee jerk. God knows I wouldn’t want to have to be counselled by any of these respondents.

FH - You said you were worried re AG unhappy and distressed, wondererd if more might be going on outside lecture - doesnt that treat her disagreement as a psychological symptom
EC- I was concerned she was distressed.

This ^ takes me right back to working alongside psychologists and psychiatrists, where every accurate criticism of them was batted back with tut tuts and mutterings of ‘projection’. It was always a psychological issue with those (legitimately) criticising and never anything to do with their own inadequate or bad judgement. Very few were effective.

WiltingAtTreadmills · 13/11/2026 10:01

Thank you. I have been meaning to read TT this weekend to catch up on it.

Justabaker · 13/11/2026 09:38

I've been trying to gather my thoughts about the last 3 1/2 days. AG had no witnesses other than her and so the defence started putting on witnesses, mid afternoon on Monday.

And they were eviscerated by a good barrister, Francis Hoar. He's on X and known to be fiercely gender critical.

Here's my brisk summary of what happened: AG started her psychotherapist course in September 2020; the height of Covid and as BLM/CRT hysteria took hold of institutions. The Tavi, where AG was doing her course, seized anti-racism like a new religion and they were zealots. The majority of students yawned, nodded like donkeys and said what they needed to do to get along. AG stood up and said 'I follow Martin Luther King Jr and judge by character, no need to apologise for being white'. The organisation rejected this philosophy and responded with what sounds like an immune system response - mobilised to protect itself and it's beliefs. (Imagine AG as a pathogen being surrounded by white blood cells).

The problem all the witness are having/will have is several fold.

First,they are used to never being corrected or confronted and shoot from the hip. So GB made some hyperbolic claims about AG which were believed as God's own truth. And then amplified and exaggerated by others. They blithely create a documentary record full of smoking guns....the 'resident racist' comment by GB is a great example of that. But there are so many. If I had sent that resident racist email about a staff member it may well have been gross misconduct and maybe dismissal. It's breathtaking that they wrote this about someone who they had pastoral responsibilities.

Second, the recordings are a deadly counterpoint to the exaggeration, mis-remembering, and basically skewer the Fun Boy 3/Bananarama defense. They seem to be retreating to 'impression' and 'attitude' and 'body language'.

Third, they remain convinced of their moral and intellectual superiority. There is a real sense of surprise from the witnesses so far that someone might criticise them for treating AG differently for expressing her views from students who wanted her silenced for expressing her views. A side effect of cancel culture is the desire to silence others rather than debate views and therefore sharpen the saw. And they are highly educated but have less street sense and lack street fighter skills.

Both barristers have irritated or annoyed the Judge. FH is not as concise, precise and organised in his questioning as the Judge would like. (He reminds me of Jacob Rees-Mogg, at least physically and in his dress and accent). And of course GW is trying to wrangle her witnesses and give them proper instructions about giving evidence without crossing a line into telling them what to say. GB was lucky not to be sanctioned for what was clear contempt of court, I think. It was actually a comment about someone who is not a party to the matter so may he may have given her some slack because of it. But it was an incident that was very revealing of her character.

Just my thoughts, IANAL.

rebax · 12/11/2026 20:57

The defence disclosure seems to have been good with possibly even draft emails disclosed. However the witness statements seem poor, often contradicted by disclosed documents. There is an even bigger gap between them and the transcripts of the claimants recordings and a gaping chasm between the witness statements and the recordings themselves. It feels the defence have not been taking the claim seriously and grossly underestimating the risk from recordings.

The Bananarama defence is not going to work when there are tapes.

Marymanna · 12/11/2026 20:23

Wow, I have just managed to catch up. Yet another case in which taxpayers' money is being wasted on an NHS defence that is more full of holes than Swiss cheese. And showing the extreme views and intolerance that is official NHS policy.

Some really shocking behaviour on the witness stand, and some excellent cross-examination. At this point I think i can put down reading cross-examinations on TT as a hobby!

Its so ironic that people with these extreme left-wing views (like men can be women, and white people are a problem so we can be racist about them) are so intolerant. Its like ultimate virtue-signalling while being totalitarian and intolerant at the same time. I really enjoy seeing them tie themselves in knots when their lies and hypocrisy are revealed in public. But I'm not sure even that leads to any introspection or self-understanding.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 18:10

(That was my reflection on the latest witness Thursday afternoon part 2)

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 18:04

I am unhappy about the way the Tavistock seemed to be conflating "anti-racism" with "critical race theory". Critical race theory is only one theory and practice of anti-racism. Race-blindness is an alternative. CRT picks up on some weakness in race-blindness but it is very limited as a stand-alone theory and in practice it easily gets into murky waters itself (e.g. see Evergreen college)

It's reasonable in an academic setting to argue the strengths and weakness of both, and to consider how, when or whether to apply either one in a therapeutic context. Someone can believe in one and not the other and still be anti-racist.

Treating students differently for believing in one and not the other approach to anti-racism is crappy.

Transperson · 12/11/2026 17:31

Critical theory just seems like sociology and is just a natural thing for a society that is intolerant to intolerance?

Veilsofmorning · 12/11/2026 17:14

Thehorticulturalhussie · 12/11/2026 17:06

Bigly bollocks.

Bigly is totally justified!!!

Thehorticulturalhussie · 12/11/2026 17:06

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 12/11/2026 17:02

So it is a load of bollocks, with or without bigly writing!

Bigly bollocks.