Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Gallagher v Tavistock, 2nd to 27th November, RCJ

182 replies

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 22/10/2026 09:26

This case seems to have slipped under the radar somewhat, as it isn't a GC beliefs case, but there are parallels. There will be 13 witnesses from the Tavistock. It may well expose the way 'critical theory' in general has captured the NHS and how those who refuse to bow down are bullied, ostracised, and forced out of their jobs.

The claimant states:

"From the disclosure, we found that senior staff at the Tavistock were calling me names in their correspondence with each other. This included calling me a “fascist” and a “racist.” They also referred to me as a “poisonous creature” and a “snake.”
Alongside this, Senior staff openly stated that my beliefs were not likely to be compatible with ethical practice. It was shocking to see, laid bare, the way in which a whole group of NHS professionals could abuse their positions of power to openly bully a trainee. I believe they thought it unlikely that I would be able to defend myself."

"My trial is listed at the Royal Courts of Justice from 2–27 November, with almost the entire month set aside for the Court to hear the evidence and determine my claims.
The Tavistock NHS are calling 13 witnesses. I will be the only witness on my side. I will likely be cross-examined for 3 days.

For those who have followed my case from the beginning, you will know what is at stake for me. My case concerns my allegations that I suffered anti-white racial harassment and discrimination. I am further claiming that I was discriminated against for expressing a colour-blind approach to race. This was expressed in opposition to Critical Race Theory. This is the first lawsuit to bring these claims against the NHS to trial in this way.

I have pursued this case because I believe that equality must mean equality for everyone.

Getting to this point has taken years of determination. Litigation of this scale is demanding and extremely expensive, and the forthcoming trial will involve a substantial amount of preparation and legal work. I have already written and submitted a very lengthy witness statement which took many weeks to write."

I don't know if there will be remote access or if anyone will be covering it on X. I'll add to the thread if I find out.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
Cailleach1 · Today 17:11

WFTCHTJ · Today 16:31

SD going for the Peter Gabriel defence here.

What’s the Peter Gabriel defence?
Eta: Is it I don’t recall anything, at all, ever?

rebax · Today 16:51

WFTCHTJ · Today 16:31

SD going for the Peter Gabriel defence here.

And possibly the strongest witness for the defence so far, because all the others have been shooting themselves in both feet.

WFTCHTJ · Today 16:31

SD going for the Peter Gabriel defence here.

Veilsofmorning · Today 16:25

Some people’s memories are worse than others- strategically, perhaps

FH You letter of 15 January 2024 you say prima facia case to be answered?
SD yes
FH what written concern did you rec before deciding on PF case?
SD I recall a meeting ERS
FH who provided paperwork?
FH What did you read before that meeting
SD no recollection
FH Isabel Bratt, asked you to write to Amy?
SD Don't recall those documents.
FH when you say prior to your suspension in 2022, were you referring to patient incident
SD I don't recall that detail
FH In addition you say, concerns have been raised media, and opinions. Is it fair to say you would have had documents about those contacts and opinions?
SD would have been
FH Were you aware of race as susbstance?
SD don't recall
FH Did you know she was suing?
SD I was quite removed from that detail

Veilsofmorning · Today 15:43

LexLutherPops · Today 14:10

I've just started following this court case since Monday.
I'm sorry if this has been discussed at an earlier time but I'm wondering how AGs team discovered the existence of all of these WhatsApp messages? They seem to be a treasure trove of information wrt their real attitudes..

From this morning‘s evidence, they were provided by someone in the chat group- I think initials RN

BettyBooper · Today 14:25

From TT

Before lunch - with witness Mr Nick W, AG's tutor

FH U accept that told in March 21
MW Yes
FH U dont know if she received supervision in yr absence
MW I found out on my return
FH U hadnt arranged cover
MW I dont think so
FH There'd been a CI when she knocked on the door of another patient

Just now - same witness

Thank you. Mr Hoar?
FH Can you turn to p1119, core evidence bundle and email from you.
NW yep
FH Attaching supervisors report, you say keeping focus q narrow, etc That first draft is immediately behind this at p1120, that first draft didn't state AG had failed to take up replacement supervisor?
NW Doesn't mention my absence at all
FH You then rec'd an email, at 1124-5, from GB 27th June at 16:34. In that email she says you might say clearly you tried to arrange cover so you don't look negligent in this. Do you recall rec this?
NW Yes now I see it I do
FH You say I took this point, but I have not done this before with other trainees, if you think this req'd.
FH Ah I'm sorry, refer to email. TK to AG It says NW has agreed to write the enclose email on condition you sign it off.
NK yes
FH That report, 1115, it says under learning outcomes the last two lines during period of leave I made efforts to provide replacement supervision but this not taken up by her. You didn't make those efforts.
NW My understanding was, I was surprised that Amy [quiet: did not??] have supervision. I had the idea she would have supervision

The stitch-up is strong....

LexLutherPops · Today 14:10

I've just started following this court case since Monday.
I'm sorry if this has been discussed at an earlier time but I'm wondering how AGs team discovered the existence of all of these WhatsApp messages? They seem to be a treasure trove of information wrt their real attitudes..

Cailleach1 · Today 13:53

https://archive.ph/l9l1o

18th November, 2026: Morning session, part 2.

EricTheHalfASleeve · Today 13:21

It makes you think they have done this before to other trainees. Basically they can get rid of any trainee without any investigation or opportunity for the trainee to give their side of the story

Cailleach1 · Today 12:55

I’m aghast at the way they try to spin away when they’ve obviously been caught out. Their necks are solid brass.

The bit where JY et al are exposed as plotting for an easy way to get rid of AG. If it went to the Progression Board instead of FTP, then there’d be no investigation, and no right for AG to present her case. Appeal would only be after the event. Rather than address the allegation that she, and others were plotting to use this as a way to get rid of her without any investigation, JY pipes up that it would be same for all trainee students in that situation (the fact that couldn’t present their side, and only appeal when decision made). All paraphrased.

But the point is they appear to have been deliberately, and underhandedly scheming to stitch AG up and put her in the situation where she’d not be able to present her side of things. So JY piping up that that it would be same for all trainees who find themselves in that situation is a complete red herring of a response. They will duck and dive to avoid addressing the issues, or their antics.

Cailleach1 · Today 12:24

https://archive.ph/UqkiY

18th November, 2026: Morning session, part 1.

For those not on twitter/twix.

BettyBooper · Today 11:29

There are many wft?! moments this morning, but this one...

FH GB says in msg: querillous and persistant cx being a sign of disorder
JY I think so
FH U pathologise her Cx
JY We thought querilous Cx yes

🫪 These people are unreal.

BettyBooper · Today 10:40

Justabaker · Today 09:56

If you can stand to wade through the dense legal arguments - the appeal on Tribunal Tweets 2 is fascinating. Haynes, TW, is appealing the judgment in the county court action. Ban on playing in women's category upheld by judge in that case. Jane Russell appeared for Haynes on one ground of appeal yesterday.

'dense' being the operative word! 😂

lcakethereforeIam · Today 10:40

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 22:08

Wouldn’t they have been forensic psychiatrists rather than therapists?

They all seem to be getting the same training.

It seems to me whatever the job names of the people who decided to release him, they saw his skin colour before him as an individual.

Hermiaxx · Today 10:06

@Justabaker As ever brilliant coverage from Tribual Tweets (2). The judge seems - understandably - a little frustrated (noting his own lack of success in getting HH’s barristers to set out a legal case!).

Justabaker · Today 09:56

If you can stand to wade through the dense legal arguments - the appeal on Tribunal Tweets 2 is fascinating. Haynes, TW, is appealing the judgment in the county court action. Ban on playing in women's category upheld by judge in that case. Jane Russell appeared for Haynes on one ground of appeal yesterday.

Thehorticulturalhussie · Yesterday 22:08

lcakethereforeIam · Yesterday 20:53

Does make you wonder about the mindset of the people who, for example, didn't commit the Nottingham knife murderer because they were worried about the 'over-representation of young black men in detention'. Which, in hindsight, was disastrous for his victims and for the man himself.

Wouldn’t they have been forensic psychiatrists rather than therapists?

lcakethereforeIam · Yesterday 20:53

Does make you wonder about the mindset of the people who, for example, didn't commit the Nottingham knife murderer because they were worried about the 'over-representation of young black men in detention'. Which, in hindsight, was disastrous for his victims and for the man himself.

EricTheHalfASleeve · Yesterday 18:52

Forensic Psychotherapy at the Tavistock seems to be a case of the lunatics running the asylum. Does this give some insight into why forensic psychiatrists so frequently fail to accurately risk assess patients who go on to commit serious violent crime?

Veilsofmorning · Yesterday 18:52

Another double standard- ok for defence to be they were not trained on Equality legislation, so, not their fault, but, when forced to admit claimant was not trained on important points re working with patients, then - she should have known or she should have known to ask for advice as NHS nurse.

Veilsofmorning · Yesterday 17:16

some excellent work by FH, barrister for claimant:

FH you called her a wolf in sheeps clothing and a fascist
TK yes
FH not fit to see patients.
TK yes
FH then you volunteer to be on the panel to assess her suitabilty

Also, there has been meticulous attention to the details by FH (probably by someone on team) in noting ‘word for word’ similarities between one report and another.

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 16:53

They’re as slippery as eels. I’m not sure I’d believe the time of day from any of them so far. And, they work in mental health!!!

archive.ph/JGkrM

17th November, 2026: Afternoon session, part 2.

rebax · Yesterday 16:44

FH I suggest AG was set up to fail, agree?
TK no not really, I qu why she entered the course really
FH why
TK already worked in NHS, understood NHS view on AR, to enter a course that includes that content and context, can see a genuine and sincere desire to practice but
FH so people with those views shouldn't train as forensic psych?

But it was not about her beliefs?

If you're ever involved in a legal case - don't use WhatsApp, disclose everything, and just answer the question you're asked!

AmaryllisNightAndDay · Yesterday 15:44

Also this morning - And there was a fun bit on their anti-racism policy (which seems to me not very compliant with the Equality Act), also their use of WhatsApp and personal email:

SB - Dr Stephen Blumenthal, Consultant Clinical Psychologist and Psychoanalyst (and member of some kind of executive group)

SB I have to say in this situation, output in clinical setting is the health of disturbed people. I take yr point we have not had EQA training but this is a very partic situation the org we work in.
FH are you aware of message groups 203-4-5 of groups discussing AG
SB There was an exec WhatsApp group and staff Whatsappgroup, I looked up last night and one reference on each to AG.
FH That has been provided to us

...
and later with TK

FH Oh so it's ok for you to use a WhatsApp with your colleagues but not for her (*)to use a hotmail account? Isn't this a double standard
TK Yes, I agree it is
FH She would not have been aware of this
TK Training and also an NHS nurse
FH If improper then GB would not have replied to her on the hotmail account?

(*) "Her" is AG

They just don't seem very professional. Maybe their KC is going for the "all total nincompoops" defence?