Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Disgraceful lies and hyperbole from the guardian

57 replies

mardirousse · 21/10/2026 14:18

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/oct/21/washington-anti-trans-sports-genital-exams. I'm appalled at the Guardian. To claim that protecting the female category for school sports will require girls to undergo genital checks is disgraceful. What pediatrician doesn't know the sex of their patients?

‘Invasive and extreme’: doctors fight anti-trans measure requiring genital exams for student athletes

A Washington referendum has drawn broad opposition from adults who work with queer and trans teens

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/oct/21/washington-anti-trans-sports-genital-exams

OP posts:
theilltemperedmonster · 21/10/2026 16:59

The Guardian has always been dreadful at science and this is no exception. A rigorous journalist would include an explainer about the significance of hormone measurements and dna tests versus anatomical observations, the implications for girls with DSDs, and the reason why a birth certificate isn't enough.

In the UK, anyone under eighteen can prove their biological sex with an original birth certificate. Why is the US different? Guardian can't be bothered to find out.

It's this incurious attitude to facts, so typical of gender identity believers, that is exercising the OP over on the 'motivated reasoning' thread.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 21/10/2026 16:56

Same shit, different day.
My takeaway is that in the halcyon days of radio silence and enforced cancel culture, TRAs and their useful idiots in impolite society didn't have to talk at length.
Now that they do, where they have to justify positions and actions, as we see in this article, they're more and more shown to be hyperbolic and extravagant.
Can anyone remind us what the standard sex test was up until the late 90s when it was stopped?
Genital tests? No, a simple cheek swab, good for life.

Arran2024 · 21/10/2026 16:10

MarieDeGournay · 21/10/2026 15:58

I don't read The Guardian, and it is behind a paywall so I often don't even read the articles that are linked to here.
This time I put into Skip the Paywall and read it in full.

It's the very antithesis of what journalism should be.
I can accept that media outlets adopt positions; I could accept if The Guardian took the position that trans-IDing boys should be allowed to participate in girls' sports and made an argument for that. I wouldn't agree with it, but I don't expect every news outlet to only say things I agree with.

But what they have published is just a screed of one-sided, easily-disproved hyperbole and lies, as the thread title says.

The most obvious being that genital inspections are not how sports organisation test the eligibility of men and women. We all know - and so, undoubtedly do the writer and The Guardian editors - that a simple cheek swab is all that's needed.

The nastiest part is
She added that any policy that puts girls through intrusive medical procedures “opens up a can of worms” given the horrific crimes of Larry Nassar, an ex-USA Gymnastics doctor who was convicted in 2023 of sexually abusing girls for decades.
associating people who support girls' sports being solely for girls with a vile serial child abuser like Nassar.

That seems to be a trans-ally trope - we've had a few posters on this board who have responded to concerns about safeguarding by accusing GC women of having a 'dodgy' interest in children's genitals.

There isn't even a token few lines given to the other side of the argument - not even a hint of objective reporting.

You can easily read Guardian articles by typing theguardian.com into your browser. I have the UK Guardian app which grants me access to about 30 stories per month but the .com version is always available - how daft is that?

Anyway, what a one sided article. Aren't they supposed to cover both sides? No mention of the girls who walked off the cross country team when a boy joined up.

QiBengong · 21/10/2026 15:59

Well, they should be very glad that a simple sex verification test using nothing more invasive than a cheek swab already exists, and that efforts are being made to make this well established test cheaper and readily available. Anomalous results from such tests can be dealt with discreetly and fairly, and may even trigger appropriate investigation, treatment, information and counselling fir athletes with previously undiagnosed differences in sex development at an earlier stage. This would be much better than similar tests being performed on athletes at high level, under the eye of the media and public.

A genital exam would be invasive and inappropriate, and even more so when you consider the only reason girls might have to undergo one in these circumstances is because of the behavior of the male individuals, men and boys who have identity issues and demand the rite to compete unfairly in sex segregated sports. Males who won't consider the rights, boundaries and needs of the very people they claim to identify with.

I am also curious why the guardian has never expressed the same level of outrage over the drug testing regimes for high level national and international athletes that involve witnessed urination before drug testing? These also involve girls and young women and as a process are equally intrusive.

MarieDeGournay · 21/10/2026 15:58

I don't read The Guardian, and it is behind a paywall so I often don't even read the articles that are linked to here.
This time I put into Skip the Paywall and read it in full.

It's the very antithesis of what journalism should be.
I can accept that media outlets adopt positions; I could accept if The Guardian took the position that trans-IDing boys should be allowed to participate in girls' sports and made an argument for that. I wouldn't agree with it, but I don't expect every news outlet to only say things I agree with.

But what they have published is just a screed of one-sided, easily-disproved hyperbole and lies, as the thread title says.

The most obvious being that genital inspections are not how sports organisation test the eligibility of men and women. We all know - and so, undoubtedly do the writer and The Guardian editors - that a simple cheek swab is all that's needed.

The nastiest part is
She added that any policy that puts girls through intrusive medical procedures “opens up a can of worms” given the horrific crimes of Larry Nassar, an ex-USA Gymnastics doctor who was convicted in 2023 of sexually abusing girls for decades.
associating people who support girls' sports being solely for girls with a vile serial child abuser like Nassar.

That seems to be a trans-ally trope - we've had a few posters on this board who have responded to concerns about safeguarding by accusing GC women of having a 'dodgy' interest in children's genitals.

There isn't even a token few lines given to the other side of the argument - not even a hint of objective reporting.

TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2026 14:51

All they do is lie

NotAtMyAge · 21/10/2026 14:50

It's the US arm of the Guardian. Absolutely par for the course on these issues.