Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Ageism often lurks within the ideas and rhetoric of trans activists - Victoria Smith

180 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/10/2026 21:10

... In a recent interview to celebrate 80 years of Woman’s Hour, programme editor Karen Dalziel was quizzed on its handling of the “what is a woman?” question. When asked why the programme didn’t simply reflect the law as clarified by the Supreme Court, she offered a rather convoluted response:

One thing we have to remember here is that you’re on Radio 4. Many of our audience are over sixty. They don’t understand the terminology and part of our role in the preceding years has been to help people understand the terms and what all the different terms mean.

A generous interpretation of this could be that this is about complex legal terminology (who wasn’t an expert in case law when they were in their teens and early twenties? Funny how you forget!). Except Dalziel goes on to say that the Supreme Court judgment has “helped listeners have some clarity about what is meant, but this is moving”. For many people, she argues, it’s “a beginning”:

People said that women couldn’t vote. Other people have different ideas and continue to campaign. We follow the story. ...

Full article https://thecritic.co.uk/you-dont-have-to-be-young-to-understand-gender-identity/

Also at https://archive.is/Ye7A0

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 22:15

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 21:52

I don't think you can argue on the one hand that this is ageist while on the other pretending that prefixes like 'cis' are slurs. Either you can grasp language or you can pretend you can't.

"Cis" may not be intended as a slur, but unless one embraces sexist ideas about what type of personality is acceptable for men or for women, it will be perceived as a sexist insult.

And it's entirely consistent that a person rejects both sexism and agism.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 12/10/2026 22:10

I agree the misunderstanding isn't just age related but its more the age old battle between conservative & liberal thinking of traditional values versus social change that is the product of psychological traits of low v high openness to change.

The tension between the two being part of the human condition makes conflict unlikely to be resolved soon without compromise which is the evolutionary point I suppose.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/10/2026 22:04

Anyway, thanks for posting OP. The following chimed with me, for obvious reasons (and as evidenced by this thread already!):

It is not enough to tell us that words can have different meanings — who knew! — when we are questioning the meanings themselves, what possibilities they create, and whose interests they serve. If you don’t want to have that argument, then don’t, but please don’t pretend that fretful ignorance of “the terminology” is the reason many older women (and increasing numbers of younger ones) won’t say the words you want them to say. We know exactly what these words mean. We’re still waiting for someone to tell us why we’re wrong.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/10/2026 21:56

And people say it's the younger generation who are incapable of joined up thinking these days.

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 21:52

I don't think you can argue on the one hand that this is ageist while on the other pretending that prefixes like 'cis' are slurs. Either you can grasp language or you can pretend you can't.