Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Ageism often lurks within the ideas and rhetoric of trans activists - Victoria Smith

180 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/10/2026 21:10

... In a recent interview to celebrate 80 years of Woman’s Hour, programme editor Karen Dalziel was quizzed on its handling of the “what is a woman?” question. When asked why the programme didn’t simply reflect the law as clarified by the Supreme Court, she offered a rather convoluted response:

One thing we have to remember here is that you’re on Radio 4. Many of our audience are over sixty. They don’t understand the terminology and part of our role in the preceding years has been to help people understand the terms and what all the different terms mean.

A generous interpretation of this could be that this is about complex legal terminology (who wasn’t an expert in case law when they were in their teens and early twenties? Funny how you forget!). Except Dalziel goes on to say that the Supreme Court judgment has “helped listeners have some clarity about what is meant, but this is moving”. For many people, she argues, it’s “a beginning”:

People said that women couldn’t vote. Other people have different ideas and continue to campaign. We follow the story. ...

Full article https://thecritic.co.uk/you-dont-have-to-be-young-to-understand-gender-identity/

Also at https://archive.is/Ye7A0

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 13/10/2026 10:01

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 09:08

'Non' also works well as a differentiator that just determines that somebody isn't in a group, so 'non-christian' can include people of any faith or none.

'Cis' on the other hand describes somebody with a specific relationship with gender.

CIS says nothing about gender. It means born biologically female and identifying as a woman however that woman presents her gender. She can be a CIS woman dressing and acting just like a man some of all of the time.

Soontobe60 · 13/10/2026 09:59

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 09:08

'Non' also works well as a differentiator that just determines that somebody isn't in a group, so 'non-christian' can include people of any faith or none.

'Cis' on the other hand describes somebody with a specific relationship with gender.

It’s ok, we’re happy to be ‘women’. Men who want to pretend they’re women can call themselves ‘non-men’.

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 09:58

MarieDeGournay · 13/10/2026 09:56

Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic....
Like your mother?

Maybe TPA has spotted her mother in photos of terf rallies/LGBA events.
She belongs to that 'certain' demographic ['women of a certain demographic'😁], and from TPA's description of her activism in the past, she sounds just like the kind of sensible, open-minded, principled woman who attends terf rallies/LGBA events.

I assume she will have been shocked to learn that people have been trying to remove the PC of sexual orientation from the equality act.

akkakk · 13/10/2026 09:57

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 02:54

Cis is just a descriptive term to distinguish natal women from trans women that has a legitimate association to what it is describing in both:

Latin Etymology: The prefix cis- comes from Latin and means "on this side" or "on the same side", contrasting with trans-, which means "on the other side" or "across".

Chemistry: In chemistry, cis describes an isomer where functional groups or atoms are arranged on the same side of a double bond or carbon ring (opposed to trans).

Given a critique by the gender critical movement that the shared usage of 'woman' 'erases' the existence of natal women, you would think a prefix distinction would solve that grievance but given their real problem seems to be some bizarre territorial ownership of words, no.

I suspect your misunderstanding regarding stereotypes is because you seem to be confusing prescriptivism with descriptivism. Trans women/men identifying with the typical behaviours of the opposite sex isn't saying that's what defines men & women for everyone, rather they as individuals identify with this categorical social distinction & want to centre that as part of their identity.

Right or wrong, the concepts of 'woman/man' carry both biological & sociological associations that distinguish men from women that has implications on how individuals understand themselves as an identity. Trans people didn't create these categories, the typical behaviours of cis men & women did.

You act as if individuals don't have a right to define themselves as an identity based on what associations they identify with because they violate the norm AND the norm is set in stone when in fact the norm is fluid according to cultural context.

Edited

wow - there is so much wrong with this!

cis does not need to be used to distinguish natal women from 'trans women' - we have words already in place

  • women (natal women)
  • men ('trans women'
the only reason for using cis is to pretend that 'cis' women and 'trans women' are two sub categories of women - i.e. to try and validate that 'trans women' are actual women - they are not, they are men.

So cis - is deeply insulting.

'trans' in 'trans woman' is short for transition - the change from one to another - implying that a man has changed to a woman, it doesn't carry the meaning you imply.

Given a critique by the gender critical movement that the shared usage of 'woman' 'erases' the existence of natal women, you would think a prefix distinction would solve that grievance but given their real problem seems to be some bizarre territorial ownership of words, no.

NO is a simple word - and it means NO. woman has a simple and clear meaning, it means born a woman and always a woman - that is the only criteria needed to be a woman - all those who were born a man can never be a woman, so their use of the word is not shared, it is theft or inappropriate. It is not for men to redefine - men have no jurisdiction over the word woman - it is the core definition of someone born female, and no male gets a say / doesn't get to share it / doesn't get to prefix it... You could not get more male ego-centric and blinkered!

Trans women/men identifying with the typical behaviours of the opposite sex isn't saying that's what defines men & women for everyone, rather they as individuals identify with this categorical social distinction & want to centre that as part of their identity.

there are stereotypes of each sex - which morph over time, but they do not define the sexes - lots of women wear skirts, but wearing a skirt doesn't make you a woman, and a woman wearing trousers doesn't stop being a woman. You can not centre as a part of your identity something you don't have and can never be. A man can never be a woman and can not centre anything female as a part of their identity as they can never be female. All they become is a skirt wearing man - which is fine, but don't claim to be centering femaleness or being a woman - that is crass and makes being a woman superficial and brings down the identity of women to clothes they wear etc.

Right or wrong, the concepts of 'woman/man' carry both biological & sociological associations that distinguish men from women that has implications on how individuals understand themselves as an identity. Trans people didn't create these categories, the typical behaviours of cis men & women did.

It can - but a man adopting what might be seen as the societal norm for women doesn't become a woman - they simply start to extend the boundaries of what is norm for a man. There is no such thing as a 'trans woman' there is a man pretending to be a woman, but they are still a man.

You act as if individuals don't have a right to define themselves as an identity based on what associations they identify with because they violate the norm AND the norm is set in stone when in fact the norm is fluid according to cultural context.

they don't have a right to identify as something they are not - a white person can not claim to be black, a tall person can not claim to be short, a man can not claim to be a woman - it is fake, fraud, deceit.

Imdunfer · 13/10/2026 09:57

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:10

Look, in broad usage that's correct. The main purpose/utility for the distinction is when you're referring to them both as we are in the same conversation otherwise it can cause confusion not to distinguish them. It's really not that bigger deal in every day life because this usage is rarely necessary.

It causes no confusion at all.

"There are three people on the shortlist for the job two women and a trans woman"

There is no need at all for the additional word CIS.

Clear as daylight, and that's the problem that you have with it, that it makes it as clear as daylight that trans women not women.

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 09:56

Soontobe60 · 13/10/2026 09:53

Trans’ you don’t identify with the gender (societal expectations of how a man or woman should behave) associated with your sex

Theres a huge problem with this definition- many of us don’t identify with the societal expectations of how we should behave associated with our sex - and yet we are not ‘trans’. We just don’t believe in the notion of gender expectations.

I just think you have to open your mind.

According to Stonewall definitions, very few people aren't trans.

Pete Hesgeth might by cis, but probably not Donald Trump.

MarieDeGournay · 13/10/2026 09:56

GreyskySexRealistsky · 13/10/2026 09:42

You made some really good points here and then ruined it all by making an ageist comment at the end that invalidated everything you said.

Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic....
Like your mother?

Maybe TPA has spotted her mother in photos of terf rallies/LGBA events.
She belongs to that 'certain' demographic ['women of a certain demographic'😁], and from TPA's description of her activism in the past, she sounds just like the kind of sensible, open-minded, principled woman who attends terf rallies/LGBA events.

Soontobe60 · 13/10/2026 09:53

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 08:21

‘Trans’ you don’t identify with the gender (societal expectations of how a man or woman should behave) associated with your sex.

’Cis’ you do identify with the gender (societal expectations of how a man or woman should behave) associated with your sex.

Genderqueer
A term for people whose gender identity doesn’t sit comfortably with ‘man’ or ‘woman’. It is also used by people who reject binary gender roles and/or normative gender expression. Genderqueer is often used in a similar way to non-binary (so most people?)

Non-binary
A term for people whose gender doesn’t sit comfortably with ‘man’ or ‘woman. (So, again most people with a personality?)

Gender incongruence
A term used to describe the mismatch between a person’s gender and the sex they were assigned at birth. (How would one know that one was aligning unless one lived in a very strict religious community?)

Keeper at Home
A woman who fulfills her godly duty of looking after the home.

Most of these definitions are from Stonewall (definition of gender taken from WHO) and one of them comes from an American Christian website.

I understand what they are getting at. I just think the assumption that it’s necessary to define your identity in relation to gender is sexist, and from a practical point of view actually just includes most people under the trans umbrella.

I suppose you could say gender dysphoric/non gender dysphoric, although that excludes all the people who identify with a gender but don’t feel dysphoric.

I often get the impression that people who self identify as ‘cis’ haven’t really grasped what it means.

Trans’ you don’t identify with the gender (societal expectations of how a man or woman should behave) associated with your sex

Theres a huge problem with this definition- many of us don’t identify with the societal expectations of how we should behave associated with our sex - and yet we are not ‘trans’. We just don’t believe in the notion of gender expectations.

Soontobe60 · 13/10/2026 09:49

Mouldemort · 12/10/2026 22:49

My aging parents had no issues understanding transgender identities once they were explained. Yes, statistically, older people are more reactionary, but it’s not universal.

Statistically?

Soontobe60 · 13/10/2026 09:47

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 21:52

I don't think you can argue on the one hand that this is ageist while on the other pretending that prefixes like 'cis' are slurs. Either you can grasp language or you can pretend you can't.

The use of the term ‘cis’ to describe women who are not men is great at signalling to others that the person using it has a very tenuous grip on reality. When I hear it or read it, my brain instantly goes to ‘oh, this person is ideologically captured and actually believes that humans can change sex, so they’re probably talking utter nonsense about other things too’.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 13/10/2026 09:42

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 13/10/2026 09:20

My mum's in her 80s and is perfectly fine with having a trans grandson. Then again, she marched at Pride events in the 70s and was never racist, unlike many of her generation. Plenty of older people are like her.

The idea that people get more bigoted as they get older is an ageist assumption, certainly in her case and many others.

It's up to the individual to decide whether they accept that younger people have different ideas to them, to listen and learn, or not.

Older people ultimately have a personal, individual responsibility not to use slurs common in their childhood and re-evaluate the prejudices a past society taught them.

And younger people shouldn't make assumptions about older people. Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic....

You made some really good points here and then ruined it all by making an ageist comment at the end that invalidated everything you said.

ChequerToRed · 13/10/2026 09:42

This thread has been, at times, been a classic demonstration of the adage ‘Better to remain silent at the risk of being thought a fool, than to talk and remove all doubt of it.’
And with such brazen confidence, too.

MarieDeGournay · 13/10/2026 09:41

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:06

The point in this context is gender critical feminists believe in socially constructed gender categories…..they just don't like that some people identify with them as an identity because they believe it perpetuates gender stereotypes.

I think that's a good explanation of sex realism/GC feminism, thank you for that!

Yes GC feminists 'believe in socially constructed gender categories' -
the point you seem to be missing is that by defintion GC feminists think socially constructed gender categories are not a good thing - they are limiting to the individual and damaging to society because people do not reach their true potential where gender stereotypes rule.

Where children are subjected to pink/fluffy-rough/tumble stereotypes, society loses out on people who grow up to be the best adult human they can be, in whatever area of life they have chosen, without the constrictions of gender holding them back.

There was a bit of a lull in the 80s and 90s when children were given more freedom to just be kids, but then bang! the princess-butterfly-sparkle backlash, and gender stereotypes came back with a vengeance.

And this time, gender stereotypes were embraced by a movement that muddied the waters by mixing up 'sex' and 'gender', claimed that children could be 'born in the wrong body' or have a 'female brain in a male body', that people could transition from one sex to the other.. or one gender to the other, since no amount of hormones or surgery can change anyone's biological sex.

Which explains why .'they just don't like that some people identify with them as an identity because they believe it perpetuates gender stereotypes.'
Spot on! Who want would gender stereotypes to be perpetuated?

OldCrone · 13/10/2026 09:41

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:10

Look, in broad usage that's correct. The main purpose/utility for the distinction is when you're referring to them both as we are in the same conversation otherwise it can cause confusion not to distinguish them. It's really not that bigger deal in every day life because this usage is rarely necessary.

But how useful is it really?

If 'trans' means 'identify with the stereotypes of the opposite sex' and 'cis' means 'identify with the stereotypes of your own sex', then only a very small minority are actually either 'cis' or 'trans'. Most people are neither.

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 09:39

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 13/10/2026 09:20

My mum's in her 80s and is perfectly fine with having a trans grandson. Then again, she marched at Pride events in the 70s and was never racist, unlike many of her generation. Plenty of older people are like her.

The idea that people get more bigoted as they get older is an ageist assumption, certainly in her case and many others.

It's up to the individual to decide whether they accept that younger people have different ideas to them, to listen and learn, or not.

Older people ultimately have a personal, individual responsibility not to use slurs common in their childhood and re-evaluate the prejudices a past society taught them.

And younger people shouldn't make assumptions about older people. Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic....

And what did your mum think about the passing of the Sex Discrimination Act in 1975? legal access to the pill for unmarried women? legalisation of abortion? introduction of maternity leave and pay? Good? Bad? These things were transformative for some of the women in my family, although too late for others. Do you not think it's a good idea to have legislation and policy that recognises sex and sex discrimination, and that sex is relevant, regardless of identity?

Helleofabore · 13/10/2026 09:39

And again, gender identity is based on a philosophical theory.

So, ‘cis’ is not a scientific term and those using it, as a group, believe it has different meanings. And the meaning is philosophical in nature meaning those who don’t believe they have a gender identity are excluded.

Therefore the term is rendered meaningless, and it is not accurate. It is a term that was acquired and repurposed in a way that misuses the original intended meaning as a prefix.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/10/2026 09:38

gender critical feminists believe in socially constructed gender categories…..they just don't like that some people identify with them as an identity because they believe it perpetuates gender stereotypes.

Ooo HowseThatBaileysInTheWhisperingChoppingTreesOfTottenham are so so close to getting it now!

What HTBIWCTOT are missing:

We don't actually mind people of either sex identifying with the stereotypes at all!

What we object to is labelling those identities as the existing names of the sexes, and leveraging that to demand the rights and resources of that sex rather than coining new names for these gender-based identies.

It's not the identity that's the issue at all!

It's the claim that this identity is the real definition of a woman or a man, and so all the challenges that women especially face because of our physical sex and how society reacts to it are - meh, not really relevant or important or a reason to need sex-specific language, support, analysis or a political voice. Certainly not compared to gender identity anyway.

Obviously, being gender critical feminists, ignoring the challenges, needs and inequities faced by the female half of humanity so our name can be recycled to label an defined bunch of fashion choices, character traits and self images isn't going to fly with us.

But it's not the fashion choices, character traits and self images themselves anyone objects to, just the sexism of labelling them "a woman".

BackToLurk · 13/10/2026 09:36

RoyalCorgi · 13/10/2026 09:32

All this stuff - it's just like saying, "Ah, but you don't understand astrology, do you?" And it's true, I've never made the effort to understand what it means if Mercury is in retrograde or the moon is in Uranus, and the reason I don't make the effort is that it's a load of bollocks. Ditto gender ideology. Please don't insult my intelligence by insisting I greet terms like "cis", "genderqueer" and "Two Spirit" with anything other than a massive eye roll.

It’s time for me to introduce by big new trans star sign campaign, isn’t it?

BackToLurk · 13/10/2026 09:36

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 13/10/2026 09:20

My mum's in her 80s and is perfectly fine with having a trans grandson. Then again, she marched at Pride events in the 70s and was never racist, unlike many of her generation. Plenty of older people are like her.

The idea that people get more bigoted as they get older is an ageist assumption, certainly in her case and many others.

It's up to the individual to decide whether they accept that younger people have different ideas to them, to listen and learn, or not.

Older people ultimately have a personal, individual responsibility not to use slurs common in their childhood and re-evaluate the prejudices a past society taught them.

And younger people shouldn't make assumptions about older people. Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic....

Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic...

The type of framing Tommy Ten Names would be proud of. Well done.

AIiswatchingyou · 13/10/2026 09:34

I'm not up to date with the ideas of Scientology either.

RoyalCorgi · 13/10/2026 09:32

All this stuff - it's just like saying, "Ah, but you don't understand astrology, do you?" And it's true, I've never made the effort to understand what it means if Mercury is in retrograde or the moon is in Uranus, and the reason I don't make the effort is that it's a load of bollocks. Ditto gender ideology. Please don't insult my intelligence by insisting I greet terms like "cis", "genderqueer" and "Two Spirit" with anything other than a massive eye roll.

AIiswatchingyou · 13/10/2026 09:21

@TransParentlyAnnoyed

Do you ever understand that it's not just about you and yours?

You crack on with whatever you're doing, but leave the rest of us alone. We don't want to play your games, or mouth your lies.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 13/10/2026 09:20

IwantToRetire · 12/10/2026 21:10

... In a recent interview to celebrate 80 years of Woman’s Hour, programme editor Karen Dalziel was quizzed on its handling of the “what is a woman?” question. When asked why the programme didn’t simply reflect the law as clarified by the Supreme Court, she offered a rather convoluted response:

One thing we have to remember here is that you’re on Radio 4. Many of our audience are over sixty. They don’t understand the terminology and part of our role in the preceding years has been to help people understand the terms and what all the different terms mean.

A generous interpretation of this could be that this is about complex legal terminology (who wasn’t an expert in case law when they were in their teens and early twenties? Funny how you forget!). Except Dalziel goes on to say that the Supreme Court judgment has “helped listeners have some clarity about what is meant, but this is moving”. For many people, she argues, it’s “a beginning”:

People said that women couldn’t vote. Other people have different ideas and continue to campaign. We follow the story. ...

Full article https://thecritic.co.uk/you-dont-have-to-be-young-to-understand-gender-identity/

Also at https://archive.is/Ye7A0

My mum's in her 80s and is perfectly fine with having a trans grandson. Then again, she marched at Pride events in the 70s and was never racist, unlike many of her generation. Plenty of older people are like her.

The idea that people get more bigoted as they get older is an ageist assumption, certainly in her case and many others.

It's up to the individual to decide whether they accept that younger people have different ideas to them, to listen and learn, or not.

Older people ultimately have a personal, individual responsibility not to use slurs common in their childhood and re-evaluate the prejudices a past society taught them.

And younger people shouldn't make assumptions about older people. Even if they have seen photos of terf rallies/LGBA events and noticed that well over 80% fit into a certain demographic....

Neversofaraway · 13/10/2026 09:18

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:34

No one is contesting that. The context is gender not sex.

I'm not bothered about whatever gender you may think you have, I am only concerned that my sex based rights are maintained. So carry on whittering about gender now you have agreed that it is different from sex.

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 09:16

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:10

Look, in broad usage that's correct. The main purpose/utility for the distinction is when you're referring to them both as we are in the same conversation otherwise it can cause confusion not to distinguish them. It's really not that bigger deal in every day life because this usage is rarely necessary.

Do you think infidel and heathen are useful words?

Swipe left for the next trending thread