Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
Cyclebabble · 12/10/2026 17:33

To me it's very straight forward. Everyone is entitled to respect. I will happily use your preferred name/pronouns and I am very happy to have trans friends and colleagues.

Some spaces though, changing rooms, prisons, rape crisis provisions etc are however for biological women. As a trans person you should respect these. If you feel uncomfortable using the provision aligned with your biological sex then use a neutral space or service.

This has to be where we are headed.

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · 12/10/2026 17:32

I've got a friend who's a TW, I'll call them Sarah. What Sarah does is
Introduces themself as Sarah. Explains that they are a TW and would prefer she/her pronouns but accepts not everyone agrees so use the pronouns you want. I don't know what their male name was so can't "dead name" them.
Sarah only uses fully enclosed single occupancy toilets. Doesn't try clothes on in shops so doesn't use women's spaces.

Sarah joined the mixed sex social group i know them from. There is also a women only and a men only group.
Sarah wears women's clothes (although is often in jeans and a top, occasionally a skirt. Has a "women's" haircut and wears jewellery and nail varnish. They said they used to wear makeup, but looked like a "man in drag"

I've also met another TW, who was thoroughly unpleasant. Glared at anyone who didn't centre them, would loudly announce they were going to the "ladies", asked us not to refer to ourselves as Mums as "she" couldn't have children and found it upsetting. Told us we were womening wrong, and generally behaved like a man.

TW "should" behave like Sarah. And TM can do the opposite. Other than that they can go to school/ work like everyone else. Fall in love. Buy/ rent a home. Learn to drive. Go to the library. And all the other things TPA mentioned.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:32

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 17:27

Based on what? The SC ruling was very clear that segregation is should be based on sex only.

It said spaces must be segregated on biological sex, not that every person has to use that space. In fact, the Supreme Court also said trans men can be excluded from female single sex spaces, and then went on to say trans people must not be left with nowhere to go. That would seem to support the argument that alternative spaces must be made available

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 17:27

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:24

I didn’t even say that. I just said that forcing a trans person to use a space for their birth sex and not providing an alternative could be gender reassignment discrimination.

Based on what? The SC ruling was very clear that segregation is should be based on sex only.

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 17:27

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:24

I didn’t even say that. I just said that forcing a trans person to use a space for their birth sex and not providing an alternative could be gender reassignment discrimination.

Or it might not.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:24

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 17:22

It doesn't therefore follow that anyone has permission to use an opposite sex facility.

I didn’t even say that. I just said that forcing a trans person to use a space for their birth sex and not providing an alternative could be gender reassignment discrimination.

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 17:22

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:14

I am well aware that there was a Supreme Court judgement. I was talking about the GLP vs EHRC high court case where it was reiterated that just providing single sex spaces without provision for trans people could constitute gender reassignment discrimination.

It doesn't therefore follow that anyone has permission to use an opposite sex facility.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:20

spannasaurus · 12/10/2026 17:17

Only if you read one paragraph out of a multi paragraph discussion would you think that.

The EHRC seems to think that as well, no? The guidance even says trans people must not be left with nowhere to go, so that would suggest just providing sex-based facilities on its own isn’t enough. I think the EHRC chair also said it wouldn’t be reasonable to put a trans woman on a men’s ward at the Women and Equality select committee.

spannasaurus · 12/10/2026 17:17

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:14

I am well aware that there was a Supreme Court judgement. I was talking about the GLP vs EHRC high court case where it was reiterated that just providing single sex spaces without provision for trans people could constitute gender reassignment discrimination.

Only if you read one paragraph out of a multi paragraph discussion would you think that.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:14

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 12/10/2026 17:06

It was the Supreme Court and it's your understanding of their opinion that's at fault.

I am well aware that there was a Supreme Court judgement. I was talking about the GLP vs EHRC high court case where it was reiterated that just providing single sex spaces without provision for trans people could constitute gender reassignment discrimination.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 12/10/2026 17:06

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 16:51

I think I’ll trust the High Court’s opinion on this over yours. I don’t think it’s hard to recognise that not making alternative provision for trans people could be discrimination.

It was the Supreme Court and it's your understanding of their opinion that's at fault.

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 16:57

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 16:51

I think I’ll trust the High Court’s opinion on this over yours. I don’t think it’s hard to recognise that not making alternative provision for trans people could be discrimination.

Which high court?

And what provision do trans people not have?

They all have provision that matches their sex so no problem.

1dayatatime · 12/10/2026 16:57

Basically continue what they previously did which was dressing and presenting themselves as per the opposite sex whilst accepting that a dress does not make a biological man a woman or entitle them to use women's toilets.

In addition the public should be accepting of their chosen lifestyle.

Batties · 12/10/2026 16:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 16:51

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 12/10/2026 15:33

People with a GRC are protected from discrimination but being asked to use the facilities that correspond to their sex is not discrimination. People who self ID into whatever aren't protected even from reality and 'Trans' isn't a protected characteristic.

I think I’ll trust the High Court’s opinion on this over yours. I don’t think it’s hard to recognise that not making alternative provision for trans people could be discrimination.

murasaki · 12/10/2026 16:48

Not relevant. The point is that people couldn't be guaranteed a fair race until this category was put in.

alcovecupboards · 12/10/2026 16:43

murasaki · 12/10/2026 16:09

And when they had an open event at a Masters swimming competition, precisely zero people entered. As the validation wasn't there.

How many trans people competed the year before?

sanluca · 12/10/2026 16:37

Bouncywaves · 12/10/2026 16:17

The most helpful thing is for a trans person to look convincing in their chosen gender. That way they don't have to put up with Mumsnetters wittering on about lavatories. And no, being transgender is not about hair length, having unconventional taste in clothes or using a gender neutral name. The transgender professionals I know are very careful not to give offence or make people uncomfortable. They are certainly not exposing themselves in changing rooms to all and sundry.

I don't think trying to dupe or intimidate people is the right or helpful thing to do. Why do people think this is in any way the best course of action? It is like the trans activists on Reddit gloating how they make women uncomfortable by going into womens toilets. Despicable behaviour.

murasaki · 12/10/2026 16:35

It's so tiresome that women are expected to sort everything out for everyone. If TW were women, they'd take a shift in doing this. But they aren't, so they don't.

And when women do, like FWS, they get vilified for it.

The misogyny is so boring.

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 16:33

Bouncywaves · 12/10/2026 16:17

The most helpful thing is for a trans person to look convincing in their chosen gender. That way they don't have to put up with Mumsnetters wittering on about lavatories. And no, being transgender is not about hair length, having unconventional taste in clothes or using a gender neutral name. The transgender professionals I know are very careful not to give offence or make people uncomfortable. They are certainly not exposing themselves in changing rooms to all and sundry.

Are Mumsnetters allowed to witter on about prisons and the need for comparators in discrimination law and the impact of sex on sport and the need for sex specific health care?

The key purpose of the Equality Act is to prevent unlawful discrimination, and even if humans were not so obviously dimorphic and male violence against women ended tomorrow, women would still require sex specific rights that men don't and it would still be necessary to protect women from discrimination. Are women allowed to have legislation that protects them from sex based discrimination, or is that just too irritating?

Horses7 · 12/10/2026 16:31

PoisonCrystal · 12/10/2026 11:36

My reasonable idea would be to approach some trans people and ask them to come up with ideas that don't encroach on the rights of women and girls to resolve their own problems

First post nails it as usual!

akkakk · 12/10/2026 16:27

Bouncywaves · 12/10/2026 16:17

The most helpful thing is for a trans person to look convincing in their chosen gender. That way they don't have to put up with Mumsnetters wittering on about lavatories. And no, being transgender is not about hair length, having unconventional taste in clothes or using a gender neutral name. The transgender professionals I know are very careful not to give offence or make people uncomfortable. They are certainly not exposing themselves in changing rooms to all and sundry.

convincing means looking like what you are... it can't change who you are...

so a 'trans woman' dressed as a 'man' would be convincing - because they are male...

a 'trans woman' dressed as a woman would be somewhere on a scale between confusing and deceptive.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 16:25

Bouncywaves · 12/10/2026 16:17

The most helpful thing is for a trans person to look convincing in their chosen gender. That way they don't have to put up with Mumsnetters wittering on about lavatories. And no, being transgender is not about hair length, having unconventional taste in clothes or using a gender neutral name. The transgender professionals I know are very careful not to give offence or make people uncomfortable. They are certainly not exposing themselves in changing rooms to all and sundry.

What ‘transwomen’ do though, really?

Is there a single TW in the public eye who actually passes (and I mean when you see them moving and speaking)? Even among those who were puberty blocked? Because I’ve asked this before and there’s never been a convincing suggestion.

Transmen can be slightly more convincing, at first glance anyway.

Rollingpinofdoom · 12/10/2026 16:21

Bouncywaves · 12/10/2026 16:17

The most helpful thing is for a trans person to look convincing in their chosen gender. That way they don't have to put up with Mumsnetters wittering on about lavatories. And no, being transgender is not about hair length, having unconventional taste in clothes or using a gender neutral name. The transgender professionals I know are very careful not to give offence or make people uncomfortable. They are certainly not exposing themselves in changing rooms to all and sundry.

So how would a “transperson” look convincing?

Bouncywaves · 12/10/2026 16:17

The most helpful thing is for a trans person to look convincing in their chosen gender. That way they don't have to put up with Mumsnetters wittering on about lavatories. And no, being transgender is not about hair length, having unconventional taste in clothes or using a gender neutral name. The transgender professionals I know are very careful not to give offence or make people uncomfortable. They are certainly not exposing themselves in changing rooms to all and sundry.