Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
hihelenhi · 12/10/2026 18:42

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:31

What you’re forgetting here is that gender reassignment is a protected characteristic. It’s not comparable to just being a bit sad about using the space.

I know lots of you would like it not to be a PC, but until then we have rights associated with that PC.

What you seem to be accidently on purpose forgetting is that the law doesn't actually give you entitlement to use female spaces. And never did.

Your entitlement or demands for validation (for that is what it is - we know it's not safety as you're no more in danger than any gay man or any other men are) are not comparable to the material needs that actual women have for those spaces. It's why there's a very very long history of them, and why they are intrinsically tied to women's human and equality rights.

hihelenhi · 12/10/2026 18:39

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:20

Why are you so insistent on trans people sharing with their sex? It’s obvious why it would be a real issue for some trans people

I’m not self hating and won’t be sharing any spaces with men.

You seem to be missing the really obvious here.

That you haven't given the slightest consideration to the feeling or needs of the WOMEN whose space you have decided you are entitled to insert yourself into.

Did you bother considering us at all, or that we're not just here for your convenience? That those spaces might be for US, in ways and for needs that are nothing to do with you and don't include or involve you?

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 18:34

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:31

What you’re forgetting here is that gender reassignment is a protected characteristic. It’s not comparable to just being a bit sad about using the space.

I know lots of you would like it not to be a PC, but until then we have rights associated with that PC.

It’s very clear what is protected about gender reassignment and that does not include bathrooms

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:31

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 18:27

Because what’s the justification?

Lots of men could be vulnerable in men’s bathrooms in different ways. Young boys, older men, sick men, gay men. I don’t hear cries for special treatment from them - and tbh I would have a lot more sympathy.

If trans identifying men want to campaign for their own specific faculties, fine, go ahead. But this needs to be balanced with available space and resources.

There is very good reason for providing separate disabled provision, as they simply cannot physically access general provision. That is not the same for anyone else.

What you’re forgetting here is that gender reassignment is a protected characteristic. It’s not comparable to just being a bit sad about using the space.

I know lots of you would like it not to be a PC, but until then we have rights associated with that PC.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 18:27

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:20

Why are you so insistent on trans people sharing with their sex? It’s obvious why it would be a real issue for some trans people

I’m not self hating and won’t be sharing any spaces with men.

Because what’s the justification?

Lots of men could be vulnerable in men’s bathrooms in different ways. Young boys, older men, sick men, gay men. I don’t hear cries for special treatment from them - and tbh I would have a lot more sympathy.

If trans identifying men want to campaign for their own specific faculties, fine, go ahead. But this needs to be balanced with available space and resources.

There is very good reason for providing separate disabled provision, as they simply cannot physically access general provision. That is not the same for anyone else.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/10/2026 18:26

I’m not self hating and won’t be sharing any spaces with men

Neither will I, and that includes transwomen.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 18:25

Alternate third spaces would be so great, not just for transwomen but for all the other men who don't feel safe sharing with men. So many men feel threatened or out of place in men's spaces.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:20

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 18:04

There is no reason why they can’t share with their sex, just because they present in different clothes.

I’m sure lots of people don’t relish public toilets for lots of reasons, but they don’t go round demanding special treatment.

Why are you so insistent on trans people sharing with their sex? It’s obvious why it would be a real issue for some trans people

I’m not self hating and won’t be sharing any spaces with men.

brownbootsandhats · 12/10/2026 18:19

Provision yes - they need to stand up for themselves and demand their own spaces not other people’s

I never come across any specifics - like “there is no where for a transgender person to change at this gym chain” or “Wigan town centre has no toilets for transgender people “

it’s all much vaguer. Women have been able to name specific places where they have been discriminated against through lack of single sex facilities. I’d have more respect if specific
as well as general statements about difficulties could be made

SchoolOfCool · 12/10/2026 18:09

This thread is making me feel a bit uneasy actually. I do know trans people IRL and have done for a very, very long time (albeit not the same people).

I didn't/ don't get this vibe from the trans people I know/ have known, but some of the pro gender ideology posts on this thread and MN in general make it seem as if trans people actually despise women. For our neediness, our inherent vulnerability and - crucially - for speaking about that and asserting boundaries.

I'd really like those posters to pause a moment and think about how this might feel, for women. To have a person assert that they are the same as us, at the same time as demonstrating contempt for us? Can you imagine how threatening that could feel?

For any women who has ever been in an abusive heterosexual relationship, or who has experienced sexual assault, there are echoes of that hate/ entitlement combination here.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 18:06

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:01

How does providing alternative spaces do any of those things?

Did I say it didn't?

I objected to your misrepresentation of the SC. For some reason you seem to be very keen to start an argument about something else. I wonder why?

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 18:04

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:00

Are trans people not people now?

I don’t think it’s too hard to understand. Someone who had transitioned, on hormones, had surgery, etc because of severe gender dysphoria and discomfort with their sex is not going to feel comfortable using a space for sex that has brought them such distress. I’m not saying they should use space for the opposite sex. I’m saying some provision needs to be made available for people who can’t share with their sex.

There is no reason why they can’t share with their sex, just because they present in different clothes.

I’m sure lots of people don’t relish public toilets for lots of reasons, but they don’t go round demanding special treatment.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:01

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 17:57

You'd be wrong. My "agenda" is simply that society not condone the sexist idea that only some feelings, thoughts or ways of dressing are allowed for each sex, nor overwrite the existence and history of the female half of humanity with some sort of mixed sex identity label.

You, however, are very transparently trying to deflect attention away from your attempt to misrepresent the SC ruling.

How does providing alternative spaces do any of those things?

MrsTerryPratchett · 12/10/2026 18:01

Where is OP?

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:00

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 17:52

Why would transpeople be unsafe / uncomfortable in spaces provided for their sex?

Are trans people not people now?

I don’t think it’s too hard to understand. Someone who had transitioned, on hormones, had surgery, etc because of severe gender dysphoria and discomfort with their sex is not going to feel comfortable using a space for sex that has brought them such distress. I’m not saying they should use space for the opposite sex. I’m saying some provision needs to be made available for people who can’t share with their sex.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 17:57

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:50

I would also say that coming at this from the position that trans people should be forced to use spaces that make them unsafe and uncomfortable is motivated by your specific agenda.

You'd be wrong. My "agenda" is simply that society not condone the sexist idea that only some feelings, thoughts or ways of dressing are allowed for each sex, nor overwrite the existence and history of the female half of humanity with some sort of mixed sex identity label.

You, however, are very transparently trying to deflect attention away from your attempt to misrepresent the SC ruling.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 17:52

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:50

I would also say that coming at this from the position that trans people should be forced to use spaces that make them unsafe and uncomfortable is motivated by your specific agenda.

Why would transpeople be unsafe / uncomfortable in spaces provided for their sex?

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:50

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 17:42

"Must" doing some heavy lifting there.

I think it's most accurate to say the SC recognised there might be times when the nature of a specific legitimate aim for which a single sex provision is a proportionate solution is such that including even some transmen might be enough to prevent that legitimate aim being met, and should that theoretical scenario actually arise, it might be necessary to exclude transmen from that specific female only resource, in which case said transmen would of course need alternative provision.

What it absolutely did not suggest is any blanket requirement that transmen "must" have alternative provision in all cases of SS resources. In fact, it suggested only in very specific cases directly tied to the purpose of the resource might this be appropriate.

Only someone with a very definite agenda would read it differently.

I would also say that coming at this from the position that trans people should be forced to use spaces that make them unsafe and uncomfortable is motivated by your specific agenda.

Waitingfordoggo · 12/10/2026 17:45

Meadowfinch · 12/10/2026 15:50

Long before trans was such a headline issue, in the 90s, a business acquaintance of mine transitioned from male to female.

An email was sent by his employer, informing those of us who had dealt with him regularly, that "Alan" would, from the start of January, be known as "Alice". Alice would continue to perform the role of project manager with their complete support and they trusted there would be no need for any further enquiry.

And that was it. No legal threats over pronoun confusion, no demands to use specific toilets, no beligerent insistence over anything.

I continued to work with Alice for several years and the subject was never mentioned again. I think Alice realised that quiet professionalism was her best chance at being accepted. Her employer was equally professional, but without upsetting anyone.

It is the most logical approach. I don't advertise my sexuality at work. It is no one's business but mine, and nothing to do with my employer. I have no desire to know any one else's sexuality at work either. Beyond the actual name change, there was nothing to discuss. It was none of my business because it did not intrude on the rights or the safety of the several hundred women who worked on the site.

What’s the relevance of your last paragraph? What’s the connection between sexuality and gender identity?

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 17:45

Mouldemort · 12/10/2026 17:34

Gender critical people have a habit of ignoring or patronising trans men, or weeping about their top surgery in a borderline creepy way. There existence is inconvenient for gender critical people, but they get less direct hassle than trans women, partly because they are men, and transmisogyny is poisonous.

I some ways, however, they are most affected by the new guidance - in some circumstances there is nowhere left for them to pee.

What transgender people should do is advocate for the acceptance they have in other civilised countries such as Spain or Malta - raise awareness of the complete lack of any evidence for increases in any kind of sexual assault, or even the very modest changes that Theresa May proposed.

The problem isn't transgender people, it's bigots.

If ignoring = don't consider other women a threat
and patronising = wish they weren't so oppressed by gendered expectations.

There existence is inconvenient for gender critical people

Not really.

I some ways, however, they are most affected by the new guidance - in some circumstances there is nowhere left for them to pee.

But on the plus side they still keep the framework of sex based rights that didn't exist a few decades ago, so potato potahto really.

What transgender people should do is advocate for the acceptance they have in other civilised countries such as Spain or Malta

If you want an abortion in Malta, no mount of identifying as a man will help you.

raise awareness of the complete lack of any evidence for increases in any kind of sexual assault

You could end male violence against women tomorrow and women would still need sex based rights regardless of how they identify.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 17:42

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:32

It said spaces must be segregated on biological sex, not that every person has to use that space. In fact, the Supreme Court also said trans men can be excluded from female single sex spaces, and then went on to say trans people must not be left with nowhere to go. That would seem to support the argument that alternative spaces must be made available

"Must" doing some heavy lifting there.

I think it's most accurate to say the SC recognised there might be times when the nature of a specific legitimate aim for which a single sex provision is a proportionate solution is such that including even some transmen might be enough to prevent that legitimate aim being met, and should that theoretical scenario actually arise, it might be necessary to exclude transmen from that specific female only resource, in which case said transmen would of course need alternative provision.

What it absolutely did not suggest is any blanket requirement that transmen "must" have alternative provision in all cases of SS resources. In fact, it suggested only in very specific cases directly tied to the purpose of the resource might this be appropriate.

Only someone with a very definite agenda would read it differently.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:41

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 17:40

There is very specific provision for ‘transmen’ in certain circumstances, yes. Not ‘transwomen’ however.

And yes of course people can use unisex spaces. But not spaces that belong to the opposite sex.

The EHRC guidance also says trans women can be excluded from male spaces

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 17:40

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:32

It said spaces must be segregated on biological sex, not that every person has to use that space. In fact, the Supreme Court also said trans men can be excluded from female single sex spaces, and then went on to say trans people must not be left with nowhere to go. That would seem to support the argument that alternative spaces must be made available

There is very specific provision for ‘transmen’ in certain circumstances, yes. Not ‘transwomen’ however.

And yes of course people can use unisex spaces. But not spaces that belong to the opposite sex.

spannasaurus · 12/10/2026 17:38

In fact, the Supreme Court also said trans men can be excluded from female single sex spaces, and then went on to say trans people must not be left with nowhere to go

You've switched from a sex specific comment by the SC about trans identified women and then desexed that to say it applies generally to trans people.

The judgment said that trans identified women could be barred from female single sex spaces but only if they are provided with a suitable alternative.

Mouldemort · 12/10/2026 17:34

TheyAreLovelyLovelyPeople · 12/10/2026 11:40

What sex of trans person are you talking about? I am finding more and more that referrring to 'trans people' actually means they are talking about natal men (the bepenised kind) and natal women (the cunty kind) are not on the radar.

Gender critical people have a habit of ignoring or patronising trans men, or weeping about their top surgery in a borderline creepy way. There existence is inconvenient for gender critical people, but they get less direct hassle than trans women, partly because they are men, and transmisogyny is poisonous.

I some ways, however, they are most affected by the new guidance - in some circumstances there is nowhere left for them to pee.

What transgender people should do is advocate for the acceptance they have in other civilised countries such as Spain or Malta - raise awareness of the complete lack of any evidence for increases in any kind of sexual assault, or even the very modest changes that Theresa May proposed.

The problem isn't transgender people, it's bigots.