Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · 12/10/2026 20:42

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:11

what does that have to do with alternative spaces?

You’re asking why we’re ’insistent’ that trans people share with their own sex and the answer is ‘it’s the law’, unless there is a third space available.

What sort of campaigning have you done so far for third spaces? I can think of quite a lot of feminists who would support you in that. It’s mystifying as to why so few trans people seem to have been campaigning for it in all these years.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 20:40

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:39

This is an interest exchange that happened at the Women and Equalities select committee. I think there is some indication that it could be gender reassignment discrimination but as always it depends on the specific situation.

Nadia Whittome: Very briefly, just going back to third spaces in the
NHS, obviously availability of side rooms is very limited. Would a trans
person whose care is delayed while finding an available third space side
room for them be able to claim gender reassignment discrimination?

Dr Stephenson: It would depend on the circumstances. If it is a
situation where you have a rule that applies to everyone—that they would
be expected to use a single-sex space and then they cannot and you
provide another space—that might be indirect discrimination. It is very
fact-specific so it is hard to give a concrete answer; it would depend on
the circumstances of the case. That is a potential issue and is one reason
why service providers need to think about making sure they provide
services to everybody.

If you want to cling on to this you are more than welcome to. We can all see what the law actually says.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:39

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 20:22

This is reaching/wishful thinking on your part. There is zero indication in current law that this would be the case.

This is an interest exchange that happened at the Women and Equalities select committee. I think there is some indication that it could be gender reassignment discrimination but as always it depends on the specific situation.

Nadia Whittome: Very briefly, just going back to third spaces in the
NHS, obviously availability of side rooms is very limited. Would a trans
person whose care is delayed while finding an available third space side
room for them be able to claim gender reassignment discrimination?

Dr Stephenson: It would depend on the circumstances. If it is a
situation where you have a rule that applies to everyone—that they would
be expected to use a single-sex space and then they cannot and you
provide another space—that might be indirect discrimination. It is very
fact-specific so it is hard to give a concrete answer; it would depend on
the circumstances of the case. That is a potential issue and is one reason
why service providers need to think about making sure they provide
services to everybody.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 20:22

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:21

Why not? Why couldn’t it be indirect gender reassignment discrimination to not provide a mixed sex spaces for those people? It can be indirect sex discrimination to only provide mixed sex spaces, so why specifically can’t the opposite apply?

This is reaching/wishful thinking on your part. There is zero indication in current law that this would be the case.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:21

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 20:15

Laws against discrimination on the grounds of gender reassignment are clearly laid out in the Equality act. Toilet provision is not included.

Why not? Why couldn’t it be indirect gender reassignment discrimination to not provide a mixed sex spaces for those people? It can be indirect sex discrimination to only provide mixed sex spaces, so why specifically can’t the opposite apply?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 12/10/2026 20:16

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 12/10/2026 19:57

Yet to hear why TIM's can't use the men's loo's, the men's have cubicles so there's no reason a man who can't use an urinal can't still use the men's.
I've yet to hear why it would be unsafe for a man to use the men's and why it's a woman's job to solve a man's problem.

Quite.

Why does a trans woman (a gender non conforming man)‘s feelings of being uncomfortable in a space with those of the same sex, trump a woman’s feelings of being uncomfortable being in a space with a man?

We are constantly told if a man wants to do you harm they’ll do it anyway (in bathrooms). The sign on the door is irrelevant. So why would trans women be safer in the women’s then?

Lastly, can someone finally provide stats on trans women being attacked in male bathrooms. That would be appreciated.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 20:15

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:46

As gender reassignment clearly references gender, not sex, then I cannot see the problem
What does that even mean?

Disadvantage due to gender reassignment can still be discrimination

Laws against discrimination on the grounds of gender reassignment are clearly laid out in the Equality act. Toilet provision is not included.

Wadsworthy · 12/10/2026 20:12

Therapy to help them learn to accept their sexed body.

For men who don't feel they're men, they could do with some good old feminist analysis of sex-based stereotypes - they could analyse & deconstruct the way that masculinity disciplines men.

And they could then do what women like Mary Wollstonecraft and the suffragettes did - get active in breaking down gender roles & sex-based stereotypes, to find a way of living that allows them to be less masculine.

And they could be brave about being a so-called "feminine" man. Many women throughout history have been courageous in this way - they've fought for their freedom to be a fully human person, not constrained by oppressive sex-based stereotypes. For women this has taken huge amounts of courage (women were chucked in mental asylums for rebelling against oppressive femininity, or force-fed in prison for hunger striking for the vote).

So men could gather up some courage. But they rarely do, because to challenge masculinity in the way that women have challenged oppressive femininity for centuries, would be to give up the power that comes with masculinity. Including the power to force women to call them "her."

Of course, if a man is an autogynephile, it's a sexual fetish, and that would mean self-knowledge, honesty and a shedload of therapy to help him overcome a distressing desire that is getting in the way of honest relationships with integrity.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:11

Waitingfordoggo · 12/10/2026 20:06

We’re ’so insistent’ because it’s the law.

Similarly I’m quite ‘insistent’ that people shouldn’t use disabled parking spaces if they don’t have the relevant badge.

what does that have to do with alternative spaces?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 12/10/2026 20:10

BobbleBear · 12/10/2026 18:51

Their imaginary problem so they can find the solution. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Blunt, but yes this.

Waitingfordoggo · 12/10/2026 20:06

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 18:20

Why are you so insistent on trans people sharing with their sex? It’s obvious why it would be a real issue for some trans people

I’m not self hating and won’t be sharing any spaces with men.

We’re ’so insistent’ because it’s the law.

Similarly I’m quite ‘insistent’ that people shouldn’t use disabled parking spaces if they don’t have the relevant badge.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 12/10/2026 19:57

Yet to hear why TIM's can't use the men's loo's, the men's have cubicles so there's no reason a man who can't use an urinal can't still use the men's.
I've yet to hear why it would be unsafe for a man to use the men's and why it's a woman's job to solve a man's problem.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 12/10/2026 19:49

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 17:50

I would also say that coming at this from the position that trans people should be forced to use spaces that make them unsafe and uncomfortable is motivated by your specific agenda.

unsafe and uncomfortable

Which do you really mean? Can you show evidence of them being unsafe without that word really meaning uncomfortable?

spannasaurus · 12/10/2026 19:47

Examples in the guidance need to be read in the context of the paragraph of which they are an example. Example 13.123 is specifically in reference to cases where it would be proportionate to provide a mixed of services - it doesn't say that it would be discriminatory to only provide single sex spaces/services and neither does the example

13.122 In many cases, it will be proportionate to take a holistic approach to service provision by providing a mix of services which may include both separate or single-sex services and mixed-sex services. The mix of services in terms of the size of the separate or single-sex services and of the mixed-sex services should reflect the needs and relative numbers of service users with different needs.

Example
13.123 A service provider operates a shopping centre and decides to renovate the centre. It initially intends to only provide separate-sex toilets to improve the safety and comfort of users. This disadvantages trans people because it means that a trans person cannot access a toilet catered towards their acquired gender. They also note that this option may cause safety risks and distress for trans users if required to use the toilets designated for those of the same biological sex. The service provider therefore decides to also provide toilets in individual lockable rooms with handbasins, which can be used by people of either sex.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:46

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 19:40

There is no onus on providers to supply unisex provision in all cases in the ERCH as far as I can see.

As gender reassignment clearly references gender, not sex, then I cannot see the problem.

As gender reassignment clearly references gender, not sex, then I cannot see the problem
What does that even mean?

Disadvantage due to gender reassignment can still be discrimination

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:43

Soontobe60 · 12/10/2026 19:41

No.

Ok. Thank you for your contribution.

Soontobe60 · 12/10/2026 19:41

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 15:16

Don’t act surprised when people ignore the guidance because no other spaces are provided. Wasn’t it the GLP vs EHRC case where the judge said forcing a trans person into a space for their birth sex could be gender reassignment discrimination?

No.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 19:40

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:37

The EHRC is concerned with all the protected characteristics which include gender reassignment. And yes, single sex spaces must be segregated by sex. I haven’t disagreed with that. I’ve only said that only providing single sex spaces with no mixed sex spaces could amount to gender reassignment discrimination.

There is no onus on providers to supply unisex provision in all cases in the ERCH as far as I can see.

As gender reassignment clearly references gender, not sex, then I cannot see the problem.

Bellablahhole · 12/10/2026 19:39

petiteetoile · 12/10/2026 11:36

Trans people should recognise that they can not change sex, and that sex matters in many situations.

If necessary they should have counselling to help them come to terms with this.

They should use facilities and services meant for their sex, not the sex they want to be.

Just this @BTT. Nothing more, nothing less.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:37

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 19:32

The ehrc is not remotely concerned with gender reassignment. It is very clear that any segregated provision is based on sex alone

The EHRC is concerned with all the protected characteristics which include gender reassignment. And yes, single sex spaces must be segregated by sex. I haven’t disagreed with that. I’ve only said that only providing single sex spaces with no mixed sex spaces could amount to gender reassignment discrimination.

Bellablahhole · 12/10/2026 19:34

.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 12/10/2026 19:32

Kokonimater · 12/10/2026 15:44

If you had a son or daughter that had identity issues would you be so harsh?

What is harsh about that?

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 19:32

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:28

The EHRC code makes clear that only providing mixed-sex spaces could be discrimination on the protected characteristic of sex. It’s clear how that could disadvantage women. I think it’s pretty likely that the inverse is true. Only providing single sex spaces could be discrimination on the basis of gender reassignment because it disadvantages people with gender reassignment.

The ECHR code had an example to this effect which I’ve posted up thread

Edited

The ehrc is not remotely concerned with gender reassignment. It is very clear that any segregated provision is based on sex alone

FrippEnos · 12/10/2026 19:29

MyrtleLion · 12/10/2026 18:50

and the SC ruling was careful to mention trans-identifying women who look a lot like men that it may be permissible to exclude them from women's single-sex facilities and spaces. For example, I don't think trans-identifying women who have taken extensive amounts of testosterone should be allowed to participate in women's sports for doping reasons.

Whilst it is true that trans men can't take part in women's sport due to the doping rules, several have taken part in women's sport by not starting treatments

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:28

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 19:23

What is the justification for trans identifying men getting fourth spaces (as we have disabled access spaces already) above any other group of vulnerable men?

This is not about PC btw, PC do not come with special toilet privileges. Aside from disabled access, for which the justification is very clear.

The EHRC code makes clear that only providing mixed-sex spaces could be discrimination on the protected characteristic of sex. It’s clear how that could disadvantage women. I think it’s pretty likely that the inverse is true. Only providing single sex spaces could be discrimination on the basis of gender reassignment because it disadvantages people with gender reassignment.

The ECHR code had an example to this effect which I’ve posted up thread