This is reaching/wishful thinking on your part. There is zero indication in current law that this would be the case.
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 20:21
Why not? Why couldn’t it be indirect gender reassignment discrimination to not provide a mixed sex spaces for those people? It can be indirect sex discrimination to only provide mixed sex spaces, so why specifically can’t the opposite apply?
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 20:15
Laws against discrimination on the grounds of gender reassignment are clearly laid out in the Equality act. Toilet provision is not included.
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 19:46
As gender reassignment clearly references gender, not sex, then I cannot see the problem
What does that even mean?
Disadvantage due to gender reassignment can still be discrimination
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 19:40
There is no onus on providers to supply unisex provision in all cases in the ERCH as far as I can see.
As gender reassignment clearly references gender, not sex, then I cannot see the problem.
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 19:37
The EHRC is concerned with all the protected characteristics which include gender reassignment. And yes, single sex spaces must be segregated by sex. I haven’t disagreed with that. I’ve only said that only providing single sex spaces with no mixed sex spaces could amount to gender reassignment discrimination.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 19:32
The ehrc is not remotely concerned with gender reassignment. It is very clear that any segregated provision is based on sex alone
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 19:28
The EHRC code makes clear that only providing mixed-sex spaces could be discrimination on the protected characteristic of sex. It’s clear how that could disadvantage women. I think it’s pretty likely that the inverse is true. Only providing single sex spaces could be discrimination on the basis of gender reassignment because it disadvantages people with gender reassignment.
The ECHR code had an example to this effect which I’ve posted up thread
Edited
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 19:23
What is the justification for trans identifying men getting fourth spaces (as we have disabled access spaces already) above any other group of vulnerable men?
This is not about PC btw, PC do not come with special toilet privileges. Aside from disabled access, for which the justification is very clear.
Quoting hihelenhi
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 18:52
I’m sorry, but can you actually read? I’ve been arguing that alternative/third spaces should be provide for trans people, not that we should access spaces for the opposite sex.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
hihelenhi ·
12/10/2026 18:44
I'm also unclear why you imagine that third spaces aren't the answer to everyone's needs here. Why do you insistent on women's spaces being for you, when they're categorically not? It couldn't be because it's less about safety and more about validating yourself as "really" female, could it?
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 18:31
What you’re forgetting here is that gender reassignment is a protected characteristic. It’s not comparable to just being a bit sad about using the space.
I know lots of you would like it not to be a PC, but until then we have rights associated with that PC.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 18:27
Because what’s the justification?
Lots of men could be vulnerable in men’s bathrooms in different ways. Young boys, older men, sick men, gay men. I don’t hear cries for special treatment from them - and tbh I would have a lot more sympathy.
If trans identifying men want to campaign for their own specific faculties, fine, go ahead. But this needs to be balanced with available space and resources.
There is very good reason for providing separate disabled provision, as they simply cannot physically access general provision. That is not the same for anyone else.
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 18:20
Why are you so insistent on trans people sharing with their sex? It’s obvious why it would be a real issue for some trans people
I’m not self hating and won’t be sharing any spaces with men.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 18:04
There is no reason why they can’t share with their sex, just because they present in different clothes.
I’m sure lots of people don’t relish public toilets for lots of reasons, but they don’t go round demanding special treatment.
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 18:00
Are trans people not people now?
I don’t think it’s too hard to understand. Someone who had transitioned, on hormones, had surgery, etc because of severe gender dysphoria and discomfort with their sex is not going to feel comfortable using a space for sex that has brought them such distress. I’m not saying they should use space for the opposite sex. I’m saying some provision needs to be made available for people who can’t share with their sex.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 17:52
Why would transpeople be unsafe / uncomfortable in spaces provided for their sex?
Quoting FlirtsWithRhinos
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 17:50
I would also say that coming at this from the position that trans people should be forced to use spaces that make them unsafe and uncomfortable is motivated by your specific agenda.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
FlirtsWithRhinos ·
12/10/2026 17:42
"Must" doing some heavy lifting there.
I think it's most accurate to say the SC recognised there might be times when the nature of a specific legitimate aim for which a single sex provision is a proportionate solution is such that including even some transmen might be enough to prevent that legitimate aim being met, and should that theoretical scenario actually arise, it might be necessary to exclude transmen from that specific female only resource, in which case said transmen would of course need alternative provision.
What it absolutely did not suggest is any blanket requirement that transmen "must" have alternative provision in all cases of SS resources. In fact, it suggested only in very specific cases directly tied to the purpose of the resource might this be appropriate.
Only someone with a very definite agenda would read it differently.
Quoting TheKeatingFive
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 17:32
It said spaces must be segregated on biological sex, not that every person has to use that space. In fact, the Supreme Court also said trans men can be excluded from female single sex spaces, and then went on to say trans people must not be left with nowhere to go. That would seem to support the argument that alternative spaces must be made available
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheKeatingFive ·
12/10/2026 17:27
Based on what? The SC ruling was very clear that segregation is should be based on sex only.
Quoting nicepotoftea
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 17:24
I didn’t even say that. I just said that forcing a trans person to use a space for their birth sex and not providing an alternative could be gender reassignment discrimination.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
nicepotoftea ·
12/10/2026 17:22
It doesn't therefore follow that anyone has permission to use an opposite sex facility.
Quoting TheywontletmehavethenameIwant
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 17:14
I am well aware that there was a Supreme Court judgement. I was talking about the GLP vs EHRC high court case where it was reiterated that just providing single sex spaces without provision for trans people could constitute gender reassignment discrimination.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheywontletmehavethenameIwant ·
12/10/2026 17:06
It was the Supreme Court and it's your understanding of their opinion that's at fault.
Quoting TheywontletmehavethenameIwant
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 16:51
I think I’ll trust the High Court’s opinion on this over yours. I don’t think it’s hard to recognise that not making alternative provision for trans people could be discrimination.
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
TheywontletmehavethenameIwant ·
12/10/2026 15:33
People with a GRC are protected from discrimination but being asked to use the facilities that correspond to their sex is not discrimination. People who self ID into whatever aren't protected even from reality and 'Trans' isn't a protected characteristic.
Quoting akkakk
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 15:23
Sure, but they also said trans people were still protected in the equality act because of gender reassignment. Forcing a trans person to use a space for the biological sex could be gender reassignment discrimination, and trans people can’t be left with no spaces to use, so it follows that alternative unisex provision must be provided
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
akkakk ·
12/10/2026 15:20
the supreme court made clear that facilities set aside for single sex were based on biological sex - can't get higher than the supreme court - that overrules any other comments...
if you provide a gents and a ladies - no-one is excluded because no-one has ever been born who wasn't one or the other... and the supreme court judges made very clear that for the purpose of single-sex exclusions etc then GRA is irrelevant
Quoting akkakk
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 15:16
Don’t act surprised when people ignore the guidance because no other spaces are provided. Wasn’t it the GLP vs EHRC case where the judge said forcing a trans person into a space for their birth sex could be gender reassignment discrimination?
Quoting nicepotoftea
akkakk ·
12/10/2026 15:09
and who is going to fund such a dramatic change to spaces - every swimming pool needs to add another changing room, every small business needs to add additional loos, not feasible - and esp. not at the behest of a group of people who already have spaces set aside for them - 'trans women' into the gents and 'trans men' into the ladies...
Quoting ChasingTheSunshine
nicepotoftea ·
12/10/2026 14:24
It doesn't seem inclusive to force trans people to constantly assess whether other services users believe they 'pass'.
Adequate unisex provision seems fairer for everyone.
Quoting murasaki
ChasingTheSunshine ·
12/10/2026 14:20
Surely using a space where you don’t look like you belong is the exact opposite of living quietly? 🤔
Quoting Ultraalox
murasaki ·
12/10/2026 13:41
Absolutely. As long as they use the single sex provisions for their actual sex, and not their gender identity, whatever that is.
Also, they could try calling out some of the violent TRAs and say you don't stand for us.
Ultraalox ·
12/10/2026 13:36
I think the majority of trans people are just trying to quietly go about their life and should continue to do so.