Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
Rightsraptor · 13/10/2026 09:32

Chopping - can you tell us what you mean by privacy in this context? You were asked what rights you think you're lacking, and you answered

'Legally? The right to privacy'

I'd say your first word is superfluous as all rights are enshrined in law, else they're not rights.

You've shared a longish section of legislation, which I regard as an attempt at obfuscation, so can you tell me exactly in simple terms how this perceived lack of privacy affects your life currently?

sanluca · 13/10/2026 09:31

I have come out of cubicles with hands covered in blood. Reasonably I would object to having men in the area where I wash my blood covered hands.
Reasonably women and girls will self exclude if all toilets are mixed sex with no self contained setup.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:18

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 09:07

So you are saying that individual fully self contained toilets should not be sex separated but you are happy for the normal locked toilets open washing area to remain single sex ? On the basis that it’s hard to clean your skirt or trousers of blood whilst remaining fully dressed ?

Ive never witnessed naked women washing their clothes in the loos in my 60 odd years of women's public toilet usage so I don't think that's a real thing. They very occasionally might blot out stains on their garments while wearing them but that's about it.

In any case the public toilets aren't supposed to function as your personal laundromat. They are for peeing & shitting.

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 09:07

So you are saying that individual fully self contained toilets should not be sex separated but you are happy for the normal locked toilets open washing area to remain single sex ? On the basis that it’s hard to clean your skirt or trousers of blood whilst remaining fully dressed ?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:03

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:52

We’ve all been over your lack of understanding of the proportionality point Chopping.

Yes & its clear you still don't understand it.

Here, I'll help you out. In the Privacy and Decency (Schedule 3, Part 7)
the law allows for the exclusion of one sex as a legitimate aim if a service or facility involves physical contact or shared spaces where users would reasonably object to the presence of the opposite sex if they are in a state of undress. Given public toilets have locked cubicles it's not clear whether they would meet the standard of 'reasonable'. That would have to be tested in court.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:52

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:44

But no change here being the relevant point.

27
(1)
A person does not contravene section 29, so far as relating to sex discrimination, by providing a service only to persons of one sex if—
(a)
any of the conditions in sub-paragraphs (2) to (7) is satisfied, and
(b)
the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
(2)
The condition is that only persons of that sex have need of the service.
(3)
The condition is that—
(a)
the service is also provided jointly for persons of both sexes, and
(b)
the service would be insufficiently effective were it only to be provided jointly.
(4)
The condition is that—
(a)
a joint service for persons of both sexes would be less effective, and
(b)
the extent to which the service is required by persons of each sex makes it not reasonably practicable to provide separate services.
(5)
The condition is that the service is provided at a place which is, or is part of—
(a)
a hospital, or
(b)
another establishment for persons requiring special care, supervision or attention.
(6)
The condition is that—
(a)
the service is provided for, or is likely to be used by, two or more persons at the same time, and
(b)
the circumstances are such that a person of one sex might reasonably object to the presence of a person of the opposite sex.
(7)
The condition is that—
(a)
there is likely to be physical contact between a person (A) to whom the service is provided and another person (B), and
(b)
B might reasonably object if A were not of the same sex as B.
(8)
This paragraph applies to a person exercising a public function in relation to the provision of a service as it applies to the person providing the service.

We’ve all been over your lack of understanding of the proportionality point Chopping.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:44

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:42

We can all see what the SC judgement clarifies. So nice try. 🫠

But if you want to go ahead and spend your money ‘testing it in law’ you go right ahead.

But no change here being the relevant point.

27
(1)
A person does not contravene section 29, so far as relating to sex discrimination, by providing a service only to persons of one sex if—
(a)
any of the conditions in sub-paragraphs (2) to (7) is satisfied, and
(b)
the limited provision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
(2)
The condition is that only persons of that sex have need of the service.
(3)
The condition is that—
(a)
the service is also provided jointly for persons of both sexes, and
(b)
the service would be insufficiently effective were it only to be provided jointly.
(4)
The condition is that—
(a)
a joint service for persons of both sexes would be less effective, and
(b)
the extent to which the service is required by persons of each sex makes it not reasonably practicable to provide separate services.
(5)
The condition is that the service is provided at a place which is, or is part of—
(a)
a hospital, or
(b)
another establishment for persons requiring special care, supervision or attention.
(6)
The condition is that—
(a)
the service is provided for, or is likely to be used by, two or more persons at the same time, and
(b)
the circumstances are such that a person of one sex might reasonably object to the presence of a person of the opposite sex.
(7)
The condition is that—
(a)
there is likely to be physical contact between a person (A) to whom the service is provided and another person (B), and
(b)
B might reasonably object if A were not of the same sex as B.
(8)
This paragraph applies to a person exercising a public function in relation to the provision of a service as it applies to the person providing the service.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:42

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:40

Women like anybody else don't own spaces because they are subject to cultural standards/laws & context not to mention haven't been all fully tested in law yet.
Special exemptions from anti discrimination law relies on the particular context involved & whether there's a legitimate aim that's yet to be proven yet as it pertains to public toilets.

We can all see what the SC judgement clarifies. So nice try. 🫠

But if you want to go ahead and spend your money ‘testing it in law’ you go right ahead.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:40

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:30

No right to privacy is absolute. If impacting other rights (women’s rights to single sex spaces) then that is not a ‘right’.

Women like anybody else don't own spaces because they are subject to cultural standards/laws & context not to mention haven't been all fully tested in law yet.
Special exemptions from anti discrimination law relies on the particular context involved & whether there's a legitimate aim that's yet to be proven yet as it pertains to public toilets.

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 08:38

Privacy - so third spaces ? Private Unisex spaces? That’s always been the practical solution

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:32

And tbh you’re not actually advocating for a right to ‘privacy’ there. What you are looking for is a right to deceive.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:30

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:22

Legally? The right to privacy.

No right to privacy is absolute. If impacting other rights (women’s rights to single sex spaces) then that is not a ‘right’.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 08:22

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:17

Well tell us then , what rights do you think are lacking ?

Legally? The right to privacy.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 08:17

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 07:57

Rights apportionment being subject to cultural influences is a fluid arrangement. In other words, there is no 'done & dusted' when it comes to rights. Just ask The Suffragettes or The Civil Rights Movement of the sixties..

Well tell us then , what rights do you think are lacking ?

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 08:14

It the onus is now on the transgender community to explain what specific rights are missing and why

when it came to women’s right to vote for example, well I admit the First World War helped change societies perception of the capability of women. It was evidence based.

the genie is out of the bottle as regards demanding the right to access the wrong single sex spaces because the transgender community can’t prove that is a fair because they can’t prove that as a whole they act like the opposite sex. Indeed as a whole transwomen act like men

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 07:57

Shedmistress · 13/10/2026 07:14

What rights? The right to the other sexed people's legally provided single sex spaces?

That's already been done and dusted and put back in the box. They already have their own single sex spaces provided for their sex.

So what 'Rights'?

Do they even know?

Edited

Rights apportionment being subject to cultural influences is a fluid arrangement. In other words, there is no 'done & dusted' when it comes to rights. Just ask The Suffragettes or The Civil Rights Movement of the sixties..

Shedmistress · 13/10/2026 07:14

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 06:49

'I'm making the assumption that women exist & their demand for equality will require practical measures to minimise problems for men"

Perhaps this rephrasing will help you to understand the offensiveness of the notion of appeasement to power.

To answer your question, trans people should continue to advocate for their rights however they see fit. And that doesn't mean they should be appeased either, rather its for our legal system to determine how rights should be apportioned not power.

What rights? The right to the other sexed people's legally provided single sex spaces?

That's already been done and dusted and put back in the box. They already have their own single sex spaces provided for their sex.

So what 'Rights'?

Do they even know?

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 06:49

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

'I'm making the assumption that women exist & their demand for equality will require practical measures to minimise problems for men"

Perhaps this rephrasing will help you to understand the offensiveness of the notion of appeasement to power.

To answer your question, trans people should continue to advocate for their rights however they see fit. And that doesn't mean they should be appeased either, rather its for our legal system to determine how rights should be apportioned not power.

Rollingpinofdoom · 12/10/2026 22:48

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 21:44

I guess we will discover with time how much gender reassignment much be accommodated in terms of mixed sex spaces

But as gender and sex are different, why should people with a trans identity use the mixed gender single sex facilities already available?

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 22:12

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 21:44

I guess we will discover with time how much gender reassignment much be accommodated in terms of mixed sex spaces

As it’s got nothing to do with sex I’d hazard to no degree

Theeyeballsinthesky · 12/10/2026 22:11

I think chasing knows exactly what this board is like - they have a very familiar posting style. I very much doubt this is their first visit.

NormalityIsOverrated · 12/10/2026 22:04

OP, this is Mumsnet. This is the angry, furious, TERFy Mumsnet Women’s Rights board. This is the wrong place to try to discuss how women (I refuse to use natal or cis, they’re not necessary) can help to solve men’s perceived problems arising from legally being denied access to female SSS.
For many, many years there has been a social contract whereby ordinary and decent men stay out of our SSS. Didn’t need policing except for a very tiny minority of predators.
As many others here have said, please use your energy to campaign for additional spaces but do not expect any help from us and do not think that we will ever accept men in what are and what will remain our safe spaces.
I have empathy with anyone who is uncomfortable in their skin and wish them well.
Our rights were hard fought for. Suggest you do the same but leave us out of it.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 21:44

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 21:17

It's hard isn't it?

At what point does someone's belief about other people become so unreasonable it can no longer be accomodated?

It's like some religions with strict rules about sex segregation. Society says "you can live your beliefs and you are welcome to do everything you can to avoid the other sex on your own account. However, we will not accomodate you by restricting the freedom of the opposite sex so you do not ever encounter or interact with them. If that means your ability to function within society is compromised, that is your choice to make."

Trans people have very strong beliefs about what type of personalities align to each sex. They have every right to believe that. However, most people do not believe personalities align to sex, and many people find that suggestion reductive and sexist. So eventually, there has to be a point we say no. No, trans people are not in reality some third, or other sex, or mentally aligned with the oppoiste sex, even if they believe they are.

I personally believe that point should have been recongised a long time ago, when (some parts of) society first suggested it was reasonable that a man could live "as a woman" if he adopted certain types of dress and mannerism. I believe that was a function of a more sexist cultural background and enshrining it in laws today is anachronistic.

I also believe that if the main protagonists back then had been women pushing to be accepted as men rather than vice versa, it would never have gained traction. I think that if the popular image of so called "sex change" surgery had been a woman made into a "man" by attaching a non-functioning phallus rather than a man made into a "woman" by removing the penis and creating a hole, men would never have accepted it as valid.

Nevertheless, we are where we are. As things stand, for whatever reason, society is currently accomodating the belief some people have that their personality or self image is incompatible with others of the same sex. But that's not the same as treating the belief as real. So to what degree does society say "we understand that being with others of your sex is distressing for you so we will build extra provisions for you" and to what degree does society say "we understand that being with others of your sex is distressing for you, but that is something you will have to find a way to live with"?

I guess we will discover with time how much gender reassignment much be accommodated in terms of mixed sex spaces

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 21:17

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 20:21

Why not? Why couldn’t it be indirect gender reassignment discrimination to not provide a mixed sex spaces for those people? It can be indirect sex discrimination to only provide mixed sex spaces, so why specifically can’t the opposite apply?

It's hard isn't it?

At what point does someone's belief about other people become so unreasonable it can no longer be accomodated?

It's like some religions with strict rules about sex segregation. Society says "you can live your beliefs and you are welcome to do everything you can to avoid the other sex on your own account. However, we will not accomodate you by restricting the freedom of the opposite sex so you do not ever encounter or interact with them. If that means your ability to function within society is compromised, that is your choice to make."

Trans people have very strong beliefs about what type of personalities align to each sex. They have every right to believe that. However, most people do not believe personalities align to sex, and many people find that suggestion reductive and sexist. So eventually, there has to be a point we say no. No, trans people are not in reality some third, or other sex, or mentally aligned with the oppoiste sex, even if they believe they are.

I personally believe that point should have been recongised a long time ago, when (some parts of) society first suggested it was reasonable that a man could live "as a woman" if he adopted certain types of dress and mannerism. I believe that was a function of a more sexist cultural background and enshrining it in laws today is anachronistic.

I also believe that if the main protagonists back then had been women pushing to be accepted as men rather than vice versa, it would never have gained traction. I think that if the popular image of so called "sex change" surgery had been a woman made into a "man" by attaching a non-functioning phallus rather than a man made into a "woman" by removing the penis and creating a hole, men would never have accepted it as valid.

Nevertheless, we are where we are. As things stand, for whatever reason, society is currently accomodating the belief some people have that their personality or self image is incompatible with others of the same sex. But that's not the same as treating the belief as real. So to what degree does society say "we understand that being with others of your sex is distressing for you so we will build extra provisions for you" and to what degree does society say "we understand that being with others of your sex is distressing for you, but that is something you will have to find a way to live with"?

Rollingpinofdoom · 12/10/2026 21:14

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 19:09

This section of the EHRC code is pretty interesting:

Example
13.123 A service provider operates a shopping centre and decides to renovate the centre. It initially intends to only provide separate-sex toilets to improve the safety and comfort of users. This disadvantages trans people because it means that a trans person cannot access a toilet catered towards their acquired gender. They also note that this option may cause safety risks and distress for trans users if required to use the toilets designated for those of the same biological sex. The service provider therefore decides to also provide toilets in individual lockable rooms with handbasins, which can be used by people of either sex.

That’s nice. I’m sure the lovely transpeople will be very grateful

Swipe left for the next trending thread