Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
Datun · 13/10/2026 11:43

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:38

The legal exemption refers to state of undress. I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it. You'd think that if this ubiquitous problem was dealt with that way you would notice billions of women naked doing the washing in the loos…but you don't because they don't.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

As mentioned upthread the exemption depends on achieving a legitimate aim & proportionality.

I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it

Is this the, 'if it didn't happen to me it doesn't exist' justification.

Women's toilets accommodate women's biology. Not men's. Bloody hands, leaking breasts, throwing up, clothes with blood on, all of it.

I threw up every day for three months. The last thing I wanted was a man listening. Miscarriages. Most miscarriages happened on the toilet. Imagine a man outside the door!

And even if you pick non-sex specific things, women still don't want men watching them do it.

Aa a PP said up thread, he had an accident, it was bad enough men being present, let alone women.

Everyone who's not a men's right activist understands this.

Everyone would like their own personal space, just for them. If you can't have it, the last thing you want is the opposite sex being there.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/10/2026 11:23

If being a woman or a man is about presentation and social commonalities, how can anyone be "outed"? What exactly is the untruth being "revealed"?

Can't be true sex because as we are so clearly and often told, Gender is not sex, so the fact of sex can't be especially relevant or needed to be kept secret.

Weird. I wonder what it could be.

nicepotoftea · 13/10/2026 11:19

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:57

I'm not trans so it doesn't effect me personally. But I can appreciate the right to privacy as it pertains to not being 'outed' which compelling trans people to use gender neutral toilets or the toilet that aligns with their sex does.

The section on legislation was in reference to the legal requirements for exemptions for single sex spaces that a poster didn't understand existed so it wasn't about privacy.

The right not to be 'outed' has been overstated.

People are discriminated against on the basis of age, but it is likely that you will have to declare your age multiple times a day.

Pregnancy is a highly personal thing, but it is very difficult to hide pregnancy, and in the rare cases where it might be, any employed woman will need to reveal her pregnancy to her employer to claim her rights.

I agree that sexuality is often unimportant, and that is the association that is claimed by the use of this term, but is it really a good idea to suggest that people spend their lives living in stealth?

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 13/10/2026 11:16

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:18

Ive never witnessed naked women washing their clothes in the loos in my 60 odd years of women's public toilet usage so I don't think that's a real thing. They very occasionally might blot out stains on their garments while wearing them but that's about it.

In any case the public toilets aren't supposed to function as your personal laundromat. They are for peeing & shitting.

I've never witnessed anyone else washing badly soiled clothes following an accident. But I have done it myself, and was relieved that no-one else witnessed it. I would have been doubly embarrassed if someone not of my own sex had been present.

thatsnotmyusernameeither · 13/10/2026 11:02

Trans people should recognise that they may wish to be something they’re not but that doesn’t change the fact they’re not.
I wish I was a millionaire but identifying as one won’t make me one.
I don’t like being short but telling people to say I’m tall won’t change facts.
I’m in a short body therefore I am short.

SwirlyGates · 13/10/2026 11:01

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:57

I'm not trans so it doesn't effect me personally. But I can appreciate the right to privacy as it pertains to not being 'outed' which compelling trans people to use gender neutral toilets or the toilet that aligns with their sex does.

The section on legislation was in reference to the legal requirements for exemptions for single sex spaces that a poster didn't understand existed so it wasn't about privacy.

We can see that trans-identifying males are male. There is no "outing" going on. Plus, anyone can use gender-neutral toilets, so using one is no proof that you are trans or anything else. I might even use one myself if the women's queue spirals round the block yet-a-bloody-gain.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:57

Rightsraptor · 13/10/2026 09:32

Chopping - can you tell us what you mean by privacy in this context? You were asked what rights you think you're lacking, and you answered

'Legally? The right to privacy'

I'd say your first word is superfluous as all rights are enshrined in law, else they're not rights.

You've shared a longish section of legislation, which I regard as an attempt at obfuscation, so can you tell me exactly in simple terms how this perceived lack of privacy affects your life currently?

I'm not trans so it doesn't effect me personally. But I can appreciate the right to privacy as it pertains to not being 'outed' which compelling trans people to use gender neutral toilets or the toilet that aligns with their sex does.

The section on legislation was in reference to the legal requirements for exemptions for single sex spaces that a poster didn't understand existed so it wasn't about privacy.

akkakk · 13/10/2026 10:52

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:38

The legal exemption refers to state of undress. I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it. You'd think that if this ubiquitous problem was dealt with that way you would notice billions of women naked doing the washing in the loos…but you don't because they don't.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

As mentioned upthread the exemption depends on achieving a legitimate aim & proportionality.

As mentioned upthread the exemption depends on achieving a legitimate aim & proportionality.

It does - and 99% of the world understand that it is a legitimate aim and proportional for women to have their own toilet space / changing rooms / rape support services / etc. etc.

I am a bloke and I get it - so it is not just a female belief or vague requirement - it is fundamental to how society respects all people including women.

The arguments you lay out show a distinct lack of respect to women - they become merely vassals or playthings alongside a delusional belief that a man can become a woman - when the entire female sex has to remove dignity and privacy simply to pander to male ego and play-acting then society has gone very wrong.

It is simple - men in men's spaces / women in women's spaces - end of story.
And no, a man can never be a woman - so if born a man, then they have no need ever to enter female spaces.

trying to twist legislation / trying to change the meanings of words / trying to bully a distorted inaccurate set of beliefs into becoming the societal norm - not happening - and fortunately society is beginning to wake up to this...

so stay out of the space you are not entitled to and everyone will be happy.

a 'trans woman' is a man so has all the rights of their own sex, they don't get to steal the rights of the other sex. They already have spaces they can use for toileting / changing etc. - it is called men's spaces. There is no magic third breed / sex / way - there are men and there are women - men have men's spaces and women have women's spaces - we have a society already built around the needs we have. There is no evidence that a man pretending to be a woman is any more vulnerable in men's spaces and therefore has to take over women's spaces - so we don't need to change.

RareGoalsVerge · 13/10/2026 10:51

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 18:25

Alternate third spaces would be so great, not just for transwomen but for all the other men who don't feel safe sharing with men. So many men feel threatened or out of place in men's spaces.

I think this is the thing. Single-user fully-enclosed spaces are the preferred option for getting changed, for huge numbers of people. Except for voyuers, perverts and exhibitionists, most people would far rather get changed in private than in a shared space. Most venues where people need to get changed (swimming pools, gyms, hospital staff) do not want to dedicate sufficient space for everyone to do this, so the basic minimum for maintaining individual dignity is to have communal single-sex spaces. If there are two larger communal changing rooms for the two sexes and a couple of private fully-enclosed rooms, those fully-enclosed rooms would be very popular, and the majority of people wanting to use them wouldn't be trans, so using them isn't "outing" at all, therefore the trans person's privacy is maintained. The subset of trans people (obviously not all) whose main motivation in using wrong-sex facilities is for the thrill of doing so are obviously going to object to all solutions like this, but getting a thrill by transgressing other people's boundaries isn't something that should be accommodated, ever.

SwirlyGates · 13/10/2026 10:48

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:38

The legal exemption refers to state of undress. I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it. You'd think that if this ubiquitous problem was dealt with that way you would notice billions of women naked doing the washing in the loos…but you don't because they don't.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

As mentioned upthread the exemption depends on achieving a legitimate aim & proportionality.

And yet, even five year old girls don't want to share toilets with boys. It went to court and the girl's parents won.

www.irwinmitchell.com/news-and-insights/expert-comment/post/102n7ox/gender-neutral-toilets-in-primary-school-breached-regulations-and-indirectly-disc

FrippEnos · 13/10/2026 10:44

The really sad thing here is that if the trans lobby had approached this differently, they could have another solid ally in feminists.

But instead of trying to remove gender stereotypes, and promoting that we could break stereotypes, clothes are just clothes, wear what you like, toys are for children and not just boys or girls, everyone can play whatever sport they like no matter how they present (sounds familiar doesn't it), they went for men in dresses are women and even more so if they adhere to being a distorted view of what a stereotypical women is.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 10:38

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 10:34

And we are back at women’s opinions and thoughts don’t matter

Just like the incels

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:38

sanluca · 13/10/2026 09:31

I have come out of cubicles with hands covered in blood. Reasonably I would object to having men in the area where I wash my blood covered hands.
Reasonably women and girls will self exclude if all toilets are mixed sex with no self contained setup.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

The legal exemption refers to state of undress. I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it. You'd think that if this ubiquitous problem was dealt with that way you would notice billions of women naked doing the washing in the loos…but you don't because they don't.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

As mentioned upthread the exemption depends on achieving a legitimate aim & proportionality.

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 10:34

And we are back at women’s opinions and thoughts don’t matter

Shedmistress · 13/10/2026 10:29

Lets just refresh our memories, that the ONLY reason that men were told to go into the women's toilets was because their doctors insisted that if they did and nobody said anything, it meant they were 'living as' a woman and 'passed'.

Not one of them even considered that the reason women didn't say anything was because they did not want a punch in the face.

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 10:20

I have no idea who a genderist is - so this may be the opposite of what you are saying - but yes the obsession of the transgender community on toilets is fascinating

what do they need? The right to piss in the wrong toilet. It’s not a strong case for misjuctice

Shedmistress · 13/10/2026 10:17

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:03

Yes & its clear you still don't understand it.

Here, I'll help you out. In the Privacy and Decency (Schedule 3, Part 7)
the law allows for the exclusion of one sex as a legitimate aim if a service or facility involves physical contact or shared spaces where users would reasonably object to the presence of the opposite sex if they are in a state of undress. Given public toilets have locked cubicles it's not clear whether they would meet the standard of 'reasonable'. That would have to be tested in court.

It is perfectly reasonable to want to keep men out of spaces that have gaps in the doors, and only a flimsy board between you and everyone else due to male violence before we even get to issues of privacy.

It is also perfectly reasonable to want to keep space that ARE more sturdy and confined because they, as in men, are well known for installing cameras and filming women in states of undress.

Not wanting videos of you pissing plastered over the internet or sold on the dark web, is most definitely a 'privacy' issue.

So men want privacy but women aren't allowed any? Totally a Men's Rights Activist objective.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/10/2026 10:16

Damn, I got sucked into the Genderist obsession with trans women getting to piss only upon the public porcelain a female person has or will also piss upon.

Given all the ways female people face different social, political and economic challenges to men where transwomen could demand the same treatment, what is it about the khazi that so draws the Genderists' energy?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/10/2026 10:06

sanluca · 13/10/2026 09:31

I have come out of cubicles with hands covered in blood. Reasonably I would object to having men in the area where I wash my blood covered hands.
Reasonably women and girls will self exclude if all toilets are mixed sex with no self contained setup.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

That time I sneezed holding a very full mooncup I had just removed, I was very glad I didn't have to share the khazi with men.

No actually I wasn't especially glad at the time, because it would never have occurred to me anyone would invite men into the women's bogs in the first place. I just got on with the cleanup.

But with hindsight yes. Not least because cleaning all the blood off the floor with bogroll woukd have been orders of magnitude worse if it had been spattered with the pee-drips too many men don't seem to see any problems with leaving.

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 09:54

You know we have again in the papers just today how women’s voices are ignored and their thoughts dismissed as untrue

and we see it here too. Periods should be messy , we are lying , making things up

Waitingfordoggo · 13/10/2026 09:53

The other problem with managing periods (and we all wish we didn’t know this but the cat is out of the bag) is that some men get the horn from hearing plastic/paper rustling sounds of women unwrapping and using sanitary products. Mooncups can make some unexpected noises too.

However unpleasant other women can sometimes be, at least we know they’re extremely unlikely to be getting turned on by listening to us manage our periods.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 09:47

So if toilets are only for peeing and shitting and cubicles exist, what is the problem with men using the men’s @Choppingwoodcarryingwater

Waitingfordoggo · 13/10/2026 09:42

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:18

Ive never witnessed naked women washing their clothes in the loos in my 60 odd years of women's public toilet usage so I don't think that's a real thing. They very occasionally might blot out stains on their garments while wearing them but that's about it.

In any case the public toilets aren't supposed to function as your personal laundromat. They are for peeing & shitting.

Peeing and shitting and dealing with periods. The latter is quite an important one to us women. When I’ve emptied my Mooncup into the loo, it can take several flushes to get rid of all the blood. I obviously try my best but some cisterns take ages to refill and I don’t always have enough time to stand in there and wait to do a second or third flush. I feel a lot more comfortable with the idea of a woman going into that cubicle after me than a man. And like PP, this situation also means I sometimes leave the cubicle with bloody hands to make my way to the sinks (I usually manage to undo the lock and open the door with my elbows, or I’ll hold a tissue while I’m touching the lock and handle).

Also, it gets mentioned a lot on MN, but the situation that many women have been in where we’ve gone into the loos with a pram or buggy and there isn’t enough space in the cubicle, so we have to leave the door partly open so we can see the buggy/prop it in the doorway.

brownbootsandhats · 13/10/2026 09:42

Oh so now we have “I haven’t seen it so it doesn’t happen “

women telling you it does happen doesn’t count because you haven’t seen it with your own eyes

are you make by any chance ? Have you been blissfully unaware of women altering their behaviour to accommodate you ?

would you like a video ? Would that make you feel happy?

Rightsraptor · 13/10/2026 09:35

So toilets are only for peeing & shitting, according to Chopping. Can anyone link to the thread, now fairly old, when we discussed all the things women do in toilets and what we need them for? Because it was rather more than Chopping says.