Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
GailBlancheViola · 13/10/2026 13:58

Datun · 13/10/2026 12:43

And regarding the OP.

You know it's a men's sexual rights movement, when a bunch of women, feminist women no less, are being asked to find a solution to a man's erroneous self image.

I mean, I'm sure the answer most of the women here actually think is no, fuck off, you do it. What's it got to do with me?

It's the old, deeply incomprehensible question when it comes to this issue.

Why? What's in it for women?

Absolutely it is a Mens Rights Movement, how strange it is that all the TRAs and their supine allies, many of whom are women, never raised a peep at the prospect of women identifying as men losing abortion and maternity protection rights if the SCJ had not clarified the correct meaning of the word sex as per the EqA. Funny that.

All of a sudden women identifying as men are on the TRA and allies agenda, suddenly they become somehow useful - where was the concern beforehand?

Where were the TRAs and their allies demanding rights of entry to all men's spaces, awards, clubs for women who identify as men?

Where was the pushback on Gay men not including women who identify as men as prospective partners?

Where were the TRAs and their allies objecting to the special clause in the GRA that made damn sure that men who identify as women would absolutely be protected so they would receive Hereditary Titles and landed estates? Strange how the male sex was paramount in those cases, no worries about 'outing' there.

TRAs and their allies have proven time and time again that their sole aim is to retain all the rights and privileges bestowed on them by virtue of their male sex and simultaneously remove all the rights and privileges applicable to the female sex.

Quite why people who support this Men's Rights Agenda, particulalry women, cannot see what is staring them in the face makes me question their motives and thinking skills.

spannasaurus · 13/10/2026 13:45

LordEmsworthsGirlfriend · 13/10/2026 13:41

Sorry for the digression, but I can't resist - @Beowulfa, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/videos/c989d4r59ywo

He complains of being addressed as 'darlin'.

Edited

Im not sure that anyone now days would describe most of the men in that video as having long hair.

PhilOPastry62 · 13/10/2026 13:32

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

You can make that assumption if you like. Most of us don't believe in gender identity in the sense of some pre-existing essence that can be mismatched to someone's body. (I do think people have a gendered sense of ourselves, as the result of growing up in and living in sexist societies, but that's different.)

Here's a reasonable idea. Trans-identifying people can believe what they like about themselves, so long as they don't encroach on anyone else's lives. That means they don't insist anyone else affirms their belief that they're the opposite sex or no sex at all, and they don't go into spaces reserved for the opposite sex. In the case of trans-identifying women who've made the decision to have medical intervention such that they look like pretty convincing men, they need to stay out of women's spaces as well. That means not going to places that don't have mixed-sex facilities. Too bad if that means there are a few places from which they're excluded - there are still far more places from which physically disabled people are excluded, and that's not the result of a decision those disabled people have made.

I'm not against service providers making additional mixed-sex facilities available so long as single-sex facilities and provisions are available when women need them for safety, privacy and dignity (and men where appropriate, though it's more usually women). That's a practical measure that can be taken. Otherwise, it's on trans-identifying people not to create problems more than they can help through their own beliefs, and where they've created problems, to come up with solutions that don't negatively impact the rights of others.

LordEmsworthsGirlfriend · 13/10/2026 13:24

Beowulfa · 12/10/2026 12:08

I recommend young trans people watch a load of old episodes of Top Of The Pops from the 80s. They might learn that dressing in a non-conforming way used to be called having a personality. Being young and experimenting with your appearance used to be very cheap as well as enormous fun; and an entirely normal and healthy way of sticking it to The Man.

There is an old interview with a very young David Bowie being interviewed by some RP speaking old stuffed shirt who expresses shock and disbelief at males with long hair. Some people still need it explaining that men with long hair are.....men with long hair.

Wasn't he claiming to be the society for the prevention of cruelty to men with long hair or something? When he was about 16? 😄

In answer to the original title question, I would just say ditch the sexism. Without sexism, all of this evaporates in a puff of smoke.

MyrtleLion · 13/10/2026 13:23

Rightsraptor · 13/10/2026 13:18

Re Chopping's reply to me at 10.57: I wouldn't be so sure the poster doesn't understand the legislation if I were you. As to your references about state of undress/being undressed etc I believe you are wrong if you think it necessary means being stark naked. When women use the toilet we are in a state of 'undress' as we have to be naked from the waist down. Personally, I object to being seen in my nightwear, even if wearing a robe or dressing gown over, by men I'm not close to. That, to me, is a state of undress.

Ask yourself what items of clothing the police are allowed to ask people to remove in public. It's outerwear only. Because it's acknowledged that both sexes can get very uncomfortable if it gets past there.

Aaaand - back to the nonsense about being outed by using the correct sex facilities: we can see men! We can hear them and smell them! We know what they are. Seeing a bloke going into the gents, even if he's wearing a dress, is not 'outing'.

Also as many women eventually find out, if you're in a one-piece swimming costume, you are essentially naked to the knees. Nearly naked if it's a jumpsuit and you're wearing a bra.

They don't even think about this.

On top of that, many religiously-observant women are not allowed to be unchaperoned in the presence of a man who is not family/not their husband or son. The moment women's toilets let in one trans-identified man, they become mixed sex and those women cannot use public toilets.

Men who are trans can use men's toilets or the accessible toilets. And if there are many facilities, or they are not good enough, then campaign for them. There was a time when I would have gladly joined them in such a campaign, but they have behaved so badly they can do it on their own.

But this is what I think will happen...

tumbleweed GIF
Rightsraptor · 13/10/2026 13:18

Re Chopping's reply to me at 10.57: I wouldn't be so sure the poster doesn't understand the legislation if I were you. As to your references about state of undress/being undressed etc I believe you are wrong if you think it necessary means being stark naked. When women use the toilet we are in a state of 'undress' as we have to be naked from the waist down. Personally, I object to being seen in my nightwear, even if wearing a robe or dressing gown over, by men I'm not close to. That, to me, is a state of undress.

Ask yourself what items of clothing the police are allowed to ask people to remove in public. It's outerwear only. Because it's acknowledged that both sexes can get very uncomfortable if it gets past there.

Aaaand - back to the nonsense about being outed by using the correct sex facilities: we can see men! We can hear them and smell them! We know what they are. Seeing a bloke going into the gents, even if he's wearing a dress, is not 'outing'.

MyrtleLion · 13/10/2026 13:07

I use accessible toilets all the time. I look able-bodied but I have severe IBS and my bowel can be shy in a women's toilet, which means later I will probably have diarrhoea.

I also have mobility issues and a blue badge, but I look like I can walk properly. And that's because if I walk too far or stand for too long, I cannot walk at all the following day.

I have a friend who has a colostomy bag. You can't tell. He is very dapper and elegant and he uses the accessible facilities to empty his bag. He probably doesn't want to do that in front of other men, and that's fine.

And I have another friend with a shy bowel, who doesn't have a disability, but she uses the accessible facility to have a poo or she gets constipated.

So when I use the accessible loo, I am not "outing" myself as trans or "outing" myself as someone with IBS, I am "outing" myself as someone who has a reason to use an accessible toilet. Much like trans-identifying men and women will do when they use the facilities.

Loads of people use accessible toilets, using one doesn't "out" anyone as trans.

solerolover · 13/10/2026 12:59

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/10/2026 11:23

If being a woman or a man is about presentation and social commonalities, how can anyone be "outed"? What exactly is the untruth being "revealed"?

Can't be true sex because as we are so clearly and often told, Gender is not sex, so the fact of sex can't be especially relevant or needed to be kept secret.

Weird. I wonder what it could be.

Questions that need answering!🤔

FlirtsWithRhinos · 13/10/2026 12:47

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:02

yes, I agree. The problem is that transactivists don’t think trans women are men identifying as women. They truly believe that in the process of “transitioning “ they’ve become actual women and as such should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman.

They truly believe that in the process of “transitioning “ they’ve become actual women and as such should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman.

They claim to believe this. They may even believe they believe it.

But in reality I'd say what they truly believe (and this may not be on a conscious level) is that the differences between transwomen and actual women matter less than the emotional needs of transwomen, and for that reason a transwoman should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman because it makes the transwoman happy and women's needs aren't really that hurt by it.

MagpiePi · 13/10/2026 12:47

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:18

Ive never witnessed naked women washing their clothes in the loos in my 60 odd years of women's public toilet usage so I don't think that's a real thing. They very occasionally might blot out stains on their garments while wearing them but that's about it.

In any case the public toilets aren't supposed to function as your personal laundromat. They are for peeing & shitting.

They are for peeing & shitting.

Why do some men use them for filming themselves experiencing, let's call it 'gender euphoria' ? We are continually told that men who want to use women't toilets only want to pee.

Datun · 13/10/2026 12:43

And regarding the OP.

You know it's a men's sexual rights movement, when a bunch of women, feminist women no less, are being asked to find a solution to a man's erroneous self image.

I mean, I'm sure the answer most of the women here actually think is no, fuck off, you do it. What's it got to do with me?

It's the old, deeply incomprehensible question when it comes to this issue.

Why? What's in it for women?

akkakk · 13/10/2026 12:43

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:26

I agree but have seen firsthand in my family the scale of
the delusion: people really do start to believe they’ve changed sex or that they’ve always been the sex they now claim to be. I completely agree that they’re fully aware, underneath the self deception, they absolutely know. Every time they use the toilet, speak,
move, etc they know.

I think that is right - deep down they know the reality that sex is immutable, but they have so much invested in how they present that it becomes the new reality for them

it starts with the simple deception that sex is not to do with biology and from that - almost anything related is believable

and they will fight with everything they have anyone who brings out the truth into the light to state that sex is biological / natal / immutable - because if you accept that then the whole facade collapses - and to allow that to happen is to to destroy who you are living as...

I feel a lot of compassion for anyone in that place - almost always the fault is not theirs originally, but others who fed them lies carefully curated to match their emotional place and took them on a journey which led them deeper and deeper into a pace they can't escape...

it is why it is so important to simultaneously and publicly

  • stop all experimentation on children and teenagers
  • keep reiterating the simple truth of biological sex
  • keep reiterating that you can be the shape of man / woman you want - but you can't change from being a man / woman
  • keep separating women's areas and men's areas as appropriate based on sex
  • encourage and support MH work in this area
  • de-stigmatise girly boys / tomboys and other language or categorisations to allow boys to cry / boys to play with dolls / girls to climb trees & be rocket scientists and the rest...
  • etc.

because all of this should stop that journey from starting...

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:37

Datun · 13/10/2026 12:37

If they were treated like an actual woman, no one would give a flying fuck what they wanted tho

very true!

Datun · 13/10/2026 12:37

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:02

yes, I agree. The problem is that transactivists don’t think trans women are men identifying as women. They truly believe that in the process of “transitioning “ they’ve become actual women and as such should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman.

If they were treated like an actual woman, no one would give a flying fuck what they wanted tho

Pingponghavoc · 13/10/2026 12:36

In trying to think of a situation where a women is needed, and a man with a certificate will do, but a man without wouldn't?

Especially when the certificate is only based on the mans feelings about his gender and body.

Pingponghavoc · 13/10/2026 12:27

I think when trans identifying men talk about privacy, they mean they want to keep their sex private. Its taken from the GRA where a certificate cannot make someone the opposite sex, or even appear the opposite sex but a certificate can 'hide' their sex in certain situations.

Obviously, when women talk about privacy, they mean privacy from men.

Female spaces are designed for womens privacy, not trans identifying mens privacy. Its impossible to use different definitions and assume the space will work.

Women spaces are designed for female people for their privacy away from men. Trans identifying men are male and want to conceal their sex.

Its two different groups of people with two different outcomes.

A womens space cannot conceal a mans sex. And a space that can conceal a mans sex cannot provide privacy for women.

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:26

lifeturnsonadime · 13/10/2026 12:18

I'm sorry I don't agree.

They know they are not women, this is all about exerting their male privilege.

Who cares about the needs and rights of real women?

In my opinion this is a form of MEN's rights activism.

I agree but have seen firsthand in my family the scale of
the delusion: people really do start to believe they’ve changed sex or that they’ve always been the sex they now claim to be. I completely agree that they’re fully aware, underneath the self deception, they absolutely know. Every time they use the toilet, speak,
move, etc they know.

MarieDeGournay · 13/10/2026 12:25

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 09:03

Yes & its clear you still don't understand it.

Here, I'll help you out. In the Privacy and Decency (Schedule 3, Part 7)
the law allows for the exclusion of one sex as a legitimate aim if a service or facility involves physical contact or shared spaces where users would reasonably object to the presence of the opposite sex if they are in a state of undress. Given public toilets have locked cubicles it's not clear whether they would meet the standard of 'reasonable'. That would have to be tested in court.

It would be very useful if there was a declaration that just as the EA2010 means biological sex when it refers to men and women, the same is true for all other legislation. That would put an end to the 'Ah but that's only the EA2010' objection which is highly illogical and lacking in common sense.

But the law is sometimes an ass, and maybe it is strictly speaking true that although in one piece of legislation, the meaning of 'man' and 'woman' have been made perfectly clear, what 'man' and 'woman' mean in all other pieces of legislations is anyone's guess.. Daft, but possible!

But it's so daft that I think the onus should be on someone to argue in court that 'man' and 'woman' mean something else in all legislation other than the EA2010. Perhaps the GLP ....?

But 'laws like houses lean on each other' and there is already evidence that the separation of some facilities by sex is the accepted configuration, and post SC, it is reasonable to assume that the intention is for the separation to be by biological sex.

Anything else, like that it is by 'gender' or 'sociological sex' or 'what somebody's personal preference is', doesn't appear to be accepted, e.g.-

789 ...Considerations of privacy or decency might require a public changing room or lavatory attendant to be of the same sex as those using the facilities.
Equality Act 2010 - Explanatory Notes

35 The obvious albeit unspoken premise of regulation 20 is the provision of private space for each sex for reasons of conventional decency.

37 It is clear from this that the objective of regulation 20 is that men and women should use conveniences in separate rooms, not together in the same room.
good law project-EHRC-AC-2025-1953-judgment-13Feb26

(1) Toilet accommodation in buildings other than dwellings—
(a) must consist of—
(i) (ii) reasonable provision for male and female single-sex toilets, or where space precludes provision of single-sex toilets, universal toilets, and

(b) may consist of universal toilets in addition to single-sex toilets.

(2) In this requirement— “single-sex toilet” means toilet facilities which—
(a) are intended for the exclusive use of persons of the same sex, and
(b) provide washbasins and hand-drying facilities in—
either the toilet room or cubicle, or
a separate area intended for use only by persons of that sex.
Building Regs.
Approved Document T - Toilet accomodation

SwirlyGates · 13/10/2026 12:19

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 13/10/2026 11:16

I've never witnessed anyone else washing badly soiled clothes following an accident. But I have done it myself, and was relieved that no-one else witnessed it. I would have been doubly embarrassed if someone not of my own sex had been present.

Once I took off a shirt in a nightclub toilet to wash blood out of it in the sink, leaving me in just a bra. Someone else's blood, he'd been stabbed near me. I may have been a bit drunk.

lifeturnsonadime · 13/10/2026 12:18

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:02

yes, I agree. The problem is that transactivists don’t think trans women are men identifying as women. They truly believe that in the process of “transitioning “ they’ve become actual women and as such should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman.

I'm sorry I don't agree.

They know they are not women, this is all about exerting their male privilege.

Who cares about the needs and rights of real women?

In my opinion this is a form of MEN's rights activism.

TheKeatingFive · 13/10/2026 12:14

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:02

yes, I agree. The problem is that transactivists don’t think trans women are men identifying as women. They truly believe that in the process of “transitioning “ they’ve become actual women and as such should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman.

I don’t think very many of them actually think that, they’re just pretending to.

And if they do, they are wrong. There is no objective, verifiable, scientific criteria by which they are women. They can have that belief, but it should be treated as any other unverifiable belief in law.

sanluca · 13/10/2026 12:13

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 13/10/2026 10:38

The legal exemption refers to state of undress. I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it. You'd think that if this ubiquitous problem was dealt with that way you would notice billions of women naked doing the washing in the loos…but you don't because they don't.

And why are we arguing about toilets again? Is a transwoman a woman when it comes to toilets but not for changing rooms, sports, health care and prisons?

As mentioned upthread the exemption depends on achieving a legitimate aim & proportionality.

So you are ok with all the other excemptions, thereby agree transwomen aren't part of the sex class woman, but it is just toilets you would like all to be mixed sex.

nufe · 13/10/2026 12:02

Datun · 13/10/2026 11:43

I like my co workers & millions of women who have had the blood stained situation happen at work. What we never did is swan around the ladies butt naked while putting a load on to deal with it

Is this the, 'if it didn't happen to me it doesn't exist' justification.

Women's toilets accommodate women's biology. Not men's. Bloody hands, leaking breasts, throwing up, clothes with blood on, all of it.

I threw up every day for three months. The last thing I wanted was a man listening. Miscarriages. Most miscarriages happened on the toilet. Imagine a man outside the door!

And even if you pick non-sex specific things, women still don't want men watching them do it.

Aa a PP said up thread, he had an accident, it was bad enough men being present, let alone women.

Everyone who's not a men's right activist understands this.

Everyone would like their own personal space, just for them. If you can't have it, the last thing you want is the opposite sex being there.

yes, I agree. The problem is that transactivists don’t think trans women are men identifying as women. They truly believe that in the process of “transitioning “ they’ve become actual women and as such should be treated in exactly the same way as an actual woman.

AlwaysExtraHot · 13/10/2026 11:57

OP, what problems do you mean specifically?
I can't answer without having more clarity on that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread