Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 12/10/2026 13:18

chirrupybird · 12/10/2026 12:56

I don't know any trans people or at least if I do I don't know they are trans which I assume would be their object. I think there is a big difference between a man dressing as a woman to access female spaces and potentially assault women or girls and a trans person who the last thing they want is to be perceived as a man and do not find women sexually attractive.

Single sex spaces are separated on the basis of sex not sexual orientation. HTH.

DialSquare · 12/10/2026 13:18

Strangely, no one gave a shit about the women who would self exclude from their own single sex provision if men were also using them. I haven’t see any hand wringing about them.

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 13:17

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:32

People are allowed to use their own names, love.

Public toilets are entirely public spaces, completely unsafe unless we have company. And I welcome trans women in, because a) they're women, b) I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents and getting assaulted, c) it's cis men who assault is in toilets, both trans women, e) cubicles exist, and f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.

Deadname is just a word, calling it 'male' is ridiculous.

"Compel speech" - you mean, be polite? Respectful? I've met a lot of people who think being forced to stop calling Black men 'boy' is compelled.speech and who insist they should be allowed to be homophobic. Deliberately disrespecting trans people is no different.

Verbal respect for difference is the first step to preventing discrimination and violence. Every single minority which gained legal protection has had the same struggles as trans people.

Stop blaming trans women for male violence.

Let's just focus on one aspect of this TPA

a) they're women
No they aren't. You know this as well as anyone, enough with the lying.

b) I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents and getting assaulted
If this is happening, go tackle the problem of violent men in the Gents. This is not women's problem to solve

c) it's cis men who assault is in toilets
It's men. No need for a made up descriptor

e) cubicles exist
Guess what? They exist in the men's too

f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.
No. Women are harmed because men have broken the social contract and infiltrated their spaces. Mother nature 'decides who's female', take it up with her.

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 13:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 12/10/2026 13:15

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:23

Same as they are already - getting on with their lives, attending school when they can, finding work, falling in love, having kids, caring, going to gigs, borrowing books from the library, doing housework and drinking tea (other beverages are available).

it's anti-trans people who need to decide if they're going to stop clutching their pearls every time a trans person does the above.

Because being trans is normal. It's a small part of their lives.

If only tiresome, fake-outraged people would stop objecting every time a trans/nb person or Pride Progress flag was found to exist (e.g. in a school, online, on TV, at work, on the street) them that would be grand. Would improve their lives no end too, as well.as discouraging the horrific, often daily violence trans people - especially trans children - are forced to endure.

If they could leave their beaks out of the decisions trans people made about the bodies ,and leave medicine to doctors, that'd help too.

...well, as if. This forum is devoted to "trans person seen!" and " oh no, a solitary non-binary child is in my school, emergency! " threads, as well as many, many "this is why I think They exist" conspiracy theories. Leaving a cult is a process, rather than a single act. But please try. There are so many better causes than fretting about what other people's children do with their fringes.

(P.s. Please don't bother telling me that I'm in a cult because my kid knew from an early age, long before he got internet access, that he was trans. Acceptance of a child is normal, obsessing about a minority you may never even meet and clearly do not understand, is not. Have a lovely day all.)

Please don't bother telling me that I'm in a cult because my kid knew from an early age, long before he got internet access, that he was trans.

If that's the case with your child, your child has a very different experience from mine. Mine did not express any hint of "gender incongruence" or "gender dysphoria" until much later on, after he had been bathed in gender identity thinking for years. Either way, my son is male and that can't be changed. The idea that it's necessary to change some aspects of his body is a very novel one, and it's hard to believe that he would have thought of that for himself without the incessant voices whispering in his ear that something is wrong with him and needs to be altered.

murasaki · 12/10/2026 13:15

It's a tad cheeky, if utterly unsurprising, to try to dictate the content of a thread by requesting only reasonable (to you) responses and then contribute.....nothing.

BackToLurk · 12/10/2026 13:14

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:32

People are allowed to use their own names, love.

Public toilets are entirely public spaces, completely unsafe unless we have company. And I welcome trans women in, because a) they're women, b) I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents and getting assaulted, c) it's cis men who assault is in toilets, both trans women, e) cubicles exist, and f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.

Deadname is just a word, calling it 'male' is ridiculous.

"Compel speech" - you mean, be polite? Respectful? I've met a lot of people who think being forced to stop calling Black men 'boy' is compelled.speech and who insist they should be allowed to be homophobic. Deliberately disrespecting trans people is no different.

Verbal respect for difference is the first step to preventing discrimination and violence. Every single minority which gained legal protection has had the same struggles as trans people.

Stop blaming trans women for male violence.

I believe you were going to share your foolproof method for telling the ‘cis men ‘ from the transwomen, given your absolute confidence in identifying’ ‘cis men’

I am again once again confused by your use of ‘us’ in terms of including yourself in the category ‘women’. Are you no longer non-binary? If transwomen are women (and always have been) by virtue of their gender identity, then you aren’t a woman. Your rules.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 13:11

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

BTT

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow

Just to note, you may not realise but that is a manipulative and closed-ended way to frame your question. You are basically saying all the reasons why trans people might not be given exatly what they are asking for, or at least why it can very reasonably be questioned, are out of scope.

It's like saying "I'd like to talk about how we best accomodate psychic healers in the NHS, but before we discuss that I just want to make it clear that I'm making the assumption psychic healing exists and is effective and has a place in the NHS so I'm only going to consider suggestions that start from that assumption".

(Note to Genderists - while you may not like the psychic healing analogy, be aware I rejected a lot of possibly stronger ones that I felt could be seen as provocative. I've landed on psychic healing because there is no connotation of deliberate harm, many have a deep belief in it, many people say they have genuinely experienced it, it has been a topic of serious scientific studies, and it has appeared in different forms in most human cultures)

A more honest version of your question would be

IF gender identity exists and IF there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow, what should such trans people actually do?

I'm talking about IF this was true, what practical measures could be taken to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

Wishesandhorses · 12/10/2026 13:09

Read the guidance and the SCJ. All provided for. Its not a problem.

Not sure why you think it's women's problem to explain (again) if you haven't seen this.

brownbootsandhats · 12/10/2026 13:07

dress how they feel comfortable
change their name if they want
live your life broadly as you see fit

avoid medicalisation because it appears to have a lot of side effects that are not trivial - male or female

remain aware that you have a disconnect in your head / body and that will cause you some inconvenience in life. We all have things that cause us inconvenience- I can’t shop at any time of day I want because the crowds get too much. That’s a me problem so I adapt.

so sport - stick to open categories. Activities that are none competitive. Go rock climbing but don’t enter the wrong sex competition. Changing rooms - probably disabled , family or other sex neutral if the right sex is too traumatic. Toilets. Plan your day. Many cafes only have one toilet so go there not M&S.

don’t try to direct other people to do or say anything they feel is wrong. Don’t prioritise your feelings and desires over anyone elses.

campaign for the things you need. But don’t expect support if you “need” validation from lesbians.

Paganpentacle · 12/10/2026 13:06

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:23

Same as they are already - getting on with their lives, attending school when they can, finding work, falling in love, having kids, caring, going to gigs, borrowing books from the library, doing housework and drinking tea (other beverages are available).

it's anti-trans people who need to decide if they're going to stop clutching their pearls every time a trans person does the above.

Because being trans is normal. It's a small part of their lives.

If only tiresome, fake-outraged people would stop objecting every time a trans/nb person or Pride Progress flag was found to exist (e.g. in a school, online, on TV, at work, on the street) them that would be grand. Would improve their lives no end too, as well.as discouraging the horrific, often daily violence trans people - especially trans children - are forced to endure.

If they could leave their beaks out of the decisions trans people made about the bodies ,and leave medicine to doctors, that'd help too.

...well, as if. This forum is devoted to "trans person seen!" and " oh no, a solitary non-binary child is in my school, emergency! " threads, as well as many, many "this is why I think They exist" conspiracy theories. Leaving a cult is a process, rather than a single act. But please try. There are so many better causes than fretting about what other people's children do with their fringes.

(P.s. Please don't bother telling me that I'm in a cult because my kid knew from an early age, long before he got internet access, that he was trans. Acceptance of a child is normal, obsessing about a minority you may never even meet and clearly do not understand, is not. Have a lovely day all.)

Absolutely.
And if trans-women aka men would keep their biologically male bodies out of female only spaces there would be no issue. Or pearl clutching.

Ponderingwindow · 12/10/2026 13:01

Style themselves however they choose.

If they are adults work with their doctors to get whatever cosmetic procedures they choose. I may not like that our society supports things like face lifts and Botox, but that it is the modern world. People are allowed to engage in body modification to their wallets constraints.

Be a part of society as we revisit historical decisions to segregate some things by sex. It turns out some things don’t really matter and some are important.

Hopefully be well rounded people. The most interesting trans people I know, being trans is not a huge part of their identity.

sashh · 12/10/2026 12:59

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

I don't have a gender ID.

Why won't trans people leave me alone?

Toodarktooearly · 12/10/2026 12:59

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

Why is it women's job to sort this? Did we have a vote I don't remember agreeing to anything I have kids dogs and elderly parents and a husband I don't really want any more responsibility

chirrupybird · 12/10/2026 12:56

I don't know any trans people or at least if I do I don't know they are trans which I assume would be their object. I think there is a big difference between a man dressing as a woman to access female spaces and potentially assault women or girls and a trans person who the last thing they want is to be perceived as a man and do not find women sexually attractive.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 12/10/2026 12:56

Well I'm shocked that the OP hasn't returned unless of course this is already in trans Reddit

PrancingPanda · 12/10/2026 12:54

Violent 'cis' men TPA? Is that men in trousers?
A poster above cited the TW saying they use the mens' loos without any problem whatsoever. Frankly, I think most men would ignore a TW anyway.

As stated many times, women want privacy and dignity away from the male gaze, in any female space. It's not all about toilets ffs.
All men, however they are dressed.

Motnight · 12/10/2026 12:50

Accepting biological reality is a good start.

hastenotwaste · 12/10/2026 12:48

People are allowed to use their own names, love.
Condescendingly addressing someone as "love" is just signalling that actually you have no respect for the people you interract with on here. One word that speaks volumes.

BernardBlacksMolluscs · 12/10/2026 12:48

I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents

I’ve been sending my sons into the gents since they were 8 years old. Thus far no mobs of violent men, cis or otherwise encountered

lunacy

Wowthatwasabigstep · 12/10/2026 12:48

Revisit their GCSE biology and see how it applies to them.

Indulge in some critical thinking and examine what events in their life led them to the belief that they could actually change sex.

The fortitude to recognise that they were sold an ideology which is impossible to achieve and that they can admit they were wrong and then return to their previous life before the cult took hold of them.

allthingsinmoderation · 12/10/2026 12:47

Psychiatric, psychological and medical evaluation to identify the underlying cause of gender dysphoria is imperative. So that the correct treatment plan can be accessed. Is the cause mental health issues,phyiscial issues,cultural and social pressures,internalised homophobia?
After which the person realises they can never change their sex but feels presenting themselves in a sterotypical way of the opposite sex make them more comfortable,so be it ,drugs and surgical procedures only when adult after full and frank counselling about the pros and cons. What they cant do is access the single sex spaces of the opposite sex (because that infringes on the rights of others) or force others to believe or treat them for all purposes as the opposite sex.

MarieDeGournay · 12/10/2026 12:46

BernardBlacksMolluscs · 12/10/2026 12:44

You have the patience of an actual saint

St Marie of the talk boards

😇
If you were St Bernard of the Talk Boards, you'd have a little cask of brandy around your neck and it would come in very handy as a much-needed restorative😁

PrancingPanda · 12/10/2026 12:46

MarieDeGournay · 12/10/2026 12:43

You just don't get that transwomen are men, TPA.
I understand that., you make that abundantly clear.

But unless you do some fancy footwork about 'sociological sex' or 'female brain' or 'feminine essence' or 'wrong body', you are on the wrong side of observable scientific fact.

Maybe that's why you always come with with your studs showing, as they say in footie - always cranked up to 11 and calling people 'love' or 'tiresome' or 'fake-outraged' or worse, because you know you don't have anything else to back up your points.

Abso bloody lutely @MarieDeGournay

hastenotwaste · 12/10/2026 12:45

I would expect behaviour similar to that for any other group that holds a belief (be that gender identity or religion) that not everyone shares. They should realize that they cannot force others to believe in gender identity and should not see it as a personal affront if others refuse to pretend that they do. In contrast, society in general should be more tolerant of people who do not feel at ease in their own skin for whatever reason.