Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
ChequerToRed · 12/10/2026 14:12

Well, in the case of natal males they could do with a change in attitude. For instance, they need to realise that their many formative years of male socialisation don’t magically disappear when they embrace their new gender identity, in fact they seem to cling to it quite enthusiastically, and it gives them a sense of undeserving entitlement that is very male coded. They also need to learn that demanding endless empathy from others is pretty bloody rich when they’re so shockingly poor at displaying empathy themselves (see my previous point about entitlement).
They may think they ‘feel like a woman’, and sometimes go to great lengths to look like one (with very mixed results), but their personalities certainly don’t pass.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 14:01

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/10/2026 13:30

Stop blaming transwomen for male violence

Why? They're men. They're as violent as other men are.

To add to that:

No one is "blaming" transwomen for male violence 🙄

All anyone is saying is that transwomen should be included on the "man" side in the mechanisms society currently has in place to protect women from men.

Yes these mechanisms are paltry and do not cover where women are arguably most at risk ie their own (fucking) home. That is a valid topic. But it's a different topic.

To the degree protections and mitigations do exist, transwomen should not be exempt from them simply because these men happen to call themselves women.

Igmum · 12/10/2026 14:00

You haven’t changed sex, that is impossible.

Women are actual human beings with opinions and rights.

Disagreement does not equal hatred or wishing you dead or denying your existence. You are not Tinkerbell. Don’t listen to anyone who says it does because believing this will damage your mental health.

Respect others people’s rights.

You can solve your own problems

allthemind · 12/10/2026 13:59

I really feel sorry for people, and mainly the parents, who bought into the ridiculous ideology that activists pushed relentlessly for a decade or so that it was possible, normal, desirable for people to be told they could transition or chnage sex. Someone really ought to be accountable. Those activists have done so much damage to famillies.

And now the realist majority are saying no, I'm sorry, this is ridiculous, we have the sad spectacle of parents who cant row it back, cant admit they were duped and can't admit their children have been damaged more. Sad, and cruel all round.

ThatGoldScroller · 12/10/2026 13:52

If you relate to/ want to live with the clothes typically worn by either a woman or a man. Then wear them, they are all clothes. If you prefer long or short hair, or prefer to look androgynous, I’m 100% behind you.
If the dressing up is sexual / a fetish, keep it private.

If you don’t want the body you have and it distresses you. You want to make it look like a body of the other gender, I’d suggest specialised counselling over a period of time.
If you really can’t improve and are aware of the risks, have surgery/take hormones. However you have to know this is a body dysmorphia and you haven’t changed your biological sex.
I’m sorry you have struggled, I hope people are kind to you. Hopefully you can just live your life.

Hoardasurass · 12/10/2026 13:50

It would be nice if they could stop threatening women who say no to them with death and rape.
It would also be nice if they could drop the perpetual victimhood claims that we all know are false.
Also it would be nice if they could accept that very few people will believe in their cult and that not seeing them as the opposite sex and objecting to the use of cis or non trans isn't denying their existence we just dont believe in their cultist beliefs.
However I very much doubt that they will do any of the above so why dont you ask them what they would be willing to do

KaleidoscopeSmile · 12/10/2026 13:48

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:23

Same as they are already - getting on with their lives, attending school when they can, finding work, falling in love, having kids, caring, going to gigs, borrowing books from the library, doing housework and drinking tea (other beverages are available).

it's anti-trans people who need to decide if they're going to stop clutching their pearls every time a trans person does the above.

Because being trans is normal. It's a small part of their lives.

If only tiresome, fake-outraged people would stop objecting every time a trans/nb person or Pride Progress flag was found to exist (e.g. in a school, online, on TV, at work, on the street) them that would be grand. Would improve their lives no end too, as well.as discouraging the horrific, often daily violence trans people - especially trans children - are forced to endure.

If they could leave their beaks out of the decisions trans people made about the bodies ,and leave medicine to doctors, that'd help too.

...well, as if. This forum is devoted to "trans person seen!" and " oh no, a solitary non-binary child is in my school, emergency! " threads, as well as many, many "this is why I think They exist" conspiracy theories. Leaving a cult is a process, rather than a single act. But please try. There are so many better causes than fretting about what other people's children do with their fringes.

(P.s. Please don't bother telling me that I'm in a cult because my kid knew from an early age, long before he got internet access, that he was trans. Acceptance of a child is normal, obsessing about a minority you may never even meet and clearly do not understand, is not. Have a lovely day all.)

I don't think you're "in a cult".

I DO think that your increasingly ludicrous, clearly untrue** contributions to MN are probably affected by your not actually believing that a person can change sex and that your child is "trans".

Otherwise who are you trying to convince as it isn't likely that it'll be anyone on FWR?

**".....horrific, often daily violence trans people - especially trans children - are forced to endure....."

SirChenjins · 12/10/2026 13:48

No response from the OP I see - how disappointing, given the importance of the topic.

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 12/10/2026 13:45

Don’t really care it’s nothing to do with me just don’t want men in women and girls spaces - that’s not a fix that should be available .

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 13:43

Ultraalox · 12/10/2026 13:36

I think the majority of trans people are just trying to quietly go about their life and should continue to do so.

It would be helpful if these people made it very clear that they are not seeking to dismantle women’s sex based rights.

I am not hearing that from very many of them.

Pingponghavoc · 12/10/2026 13:42

Ultraalox · 12/10/2026 13:36

I think the majority of trans people are just trying to quietly go about their life and should continue to do so.

And not to campaign to remove single sex services?

murasaki · 12/10/2026 13:41

Ultraalox · 12/10/2026 13:36

I think the majority of trans people are just trying to quietly go about their life and should continue to do so.

Absolutely. As long as they use the single sex provisions for their actual sex, and not their gender identity, whatever that is.

Also, they could try calling out some of the violent TRAs and say you don't stand for us.

Ultraalox · 12/10/2026 13:36

I think the majority of trans people are just trying to quietly go about their life and should continue to do so.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 12/10/2026 13:36

Without assuming gender identity is real, just as I am not required to believe God/Allah etc are real, trans people are perfectly entitled to live their lives precisely as they have done for decades: living, working, using single-use/unisex facilities in public or employment spaces, accepting that if anyone misgenders them it is not a capital crime but a person who has no interest in their personal movement or private lives - much in the same way that a muslim or jew or vegan has to navigate the world.

Ie understand that their private beliefs and opinions about themselves are of no interest and concern to other people, have no place [like politics] to be centred into every social or workplace interaction; and that religious preferences, cultural preference for halal/kosher/vegan foods is for them to police and monitor and no one else’s responsibility; and, yes, refrain from being abusive to - or threaten violence towards - people who do not share the same their perspective.

Justme56 · 12/10/2026 13:35

I would ask what is meant by ‘reasonable’. TP are not some mass of people who all think the same. There are obviously some who want to be treated as if they are the opposite sex in all circumstances and won’t accept anything less, whilst others who don’t.

wishingonastar101 · 12/10/2026 13:35

They should seek help for their mental health disorder... thinking your body is wrong is a mental health issue. Like anorexia.

spannasaurus · 12/10/2026 13:34

chirrupybird · 12/10/2026 12:56

I don't know any trans people or at least if I do I don't know they are trans which I assume would be their object. I think there is a big difference between a man dressing as a woman to access female spaces and potentially assault women or girls and a trans person who the last thing they want is to be perceived as a man and do not find women sexually attractive.

Trans identified men are not all gay, plenty of them are attracted to women and call themselves lesbians

Pingponghavoc · 12/10/2026 13:32

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:23

Same as they are already - getting on with their lives, attending school when they can, finding work, falling in love, having kids, caring, going to gigs, borrowing books from the library, doing housework and drinking tea (other beverages are available).

it's anti-trans people who need to decide if they're going to stop clutching their pearls every time a trans person does the above.

Because being trans is normal. It's a small part of their lives.

If only tiresome, fake-outraged people would stop objecting every time a trans/nb person or Pride Progress flag was found to exist (e.g. in a school, online, on TV, at work, on the street) them that would be grand. Would improve their lives no end too, as well.as discouraging the horrific, often daily violence trans people - especially trans children - are forced to endure.

If they could leave their beaks out of the decisions trans people made about the bodies ,and leave medicine to doctors, that'd help too.

...well, as if. This forum is devoted to "trans person seen!" and " oh no, a solitary non-binary child is in my school, emergency! " threads, as well as many, many "this is why I think They exist" conspiracy theories. Leaving a cult is a process, rather than a single act. But please try. There are so many better causes than fretting about what other people's children do with their fringes.

(P.s. Please don't bother telling me that I'm in a cult because my kid knew from an early age, long before he got internet access, that he was trans. Acceptance of a child is normal, obsessing about a minority you may never even meet and clearly do not understand, is not. Have a lovely day all.)

Who can forget the time a non binary person borrowed a book from the library, and all hell was let loose.

Everyone was so outraged, it made the news.

RareGoalsVerge · 12/10/2026 13:32

Live freely and wholeheartedly in the gender presentation that works for you.

Acknowledge that sex is not the same as gender, and sex never changes, so don't use anything single-sex that has been designated for the opposite sex. Use unisex and fully-enclosed single-user facilities and campaign for more provision of unisex and fully-enclosed single-user facilities to be installed alongside single-sex facilities anywhere where such things don't already exist. (We will support such campaigns alongside you). Participate in sports either within the category for your own sex, or in an "open" or unisex category - other participants in those sports are not tools for you to use to demand affirmation.

Understand that disagreement is not the same as hatred. People existing near you who don't believe the same things about gender identity as you do does not make you "unsafe" and is not "denying your right to exist" - people who do not believe you are a member of the sex you present as can and should nevertheless uphold your human rights and respect your dignity and personal choices. Your human rights do not include requiring people to agree with you.

Make whatever cosmetic changes you wish to your own body with your own funds after a careful process that is in your best interests to establish whether it really will improve your ability to accept yourself. These should never happen before the age of 25 because the human brain is still developing before this point and you cannot know where that development will take you. Almost zero cosmetic surgeries should be funded by the taxpayer - with very very limited exceptions where the bar should be extremely high (as it is with all other cosmetic surgeries which are very rarely funded on the NHS) for extremely strong evidence that it is appropriate. We do not treat anorexia with liposuction - theraputic support to help you to accept your body as it is, with no implication that this should make you choose differently in terms of your gender presentation, is almost always a more appropriate treatment.

Protect gender non-conforming and homosexual kids from the harms of puberty blockers. A very very few trans adults might genuinely have been helped by recieving these drugs when they were young but a huge number of the kids taking them are not in the same category and would have grown up into balanced, healthy, self-accepting homosexual adults if allowed to do so without being told their feelings are wrong for their sex. The harms done by the drugs being prescribed when they weren't appropriate (stunting intellectual development, damaging fertility, destroying the capacity for sexual pleasure and causing lifelong medical issues) outweigh many times over the harms done in the cases where they could have been beneficial but weren't. Research needs to focus on identifying how to tell the difference as early as possible - this research could be done with longitudinal studies that do not require giving any harmful drugs to kids until rigorous evidence has been generated for how to identify the minority of cases when it might help.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/10/2026 13:30

Stop blaming transwomen for male violence

Why? They're men. They're as violent as other men are.

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 13:28

TheKeatingFive · 12/10/2026 13:17

Let's just focus on one aspect of this TPA

a) they're women
No they aren't. You know this as well as anyone, enough with the lying.

b) I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents and getting assaulted
If this is happening, go tackle the problem of violent men in the Gents. This is not women's problem to solve

c) it's cis men who assault is in toilets
It's men. No need for a made up descriptor

e) cubicles exist
Guess what? They exist in the men's too

f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.
No. Women are harmed because men have broken the social contract and infiltrated their spaces. Mother nature 'decides who's female', take it up with her.

f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.

I'm slightly confused by this comment. Where does this leave trans identifying men who are clearly male? No more at risk than any other man who might be considered to be in a vulnerable group? Is there a bit of consensus here?

NowSober · 12/10/2026 13:28

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists

Sorry, I need to stop you right there. Gender identity doesn't exist it's just a made up thing like having a soul is a made up thing. As you are starting from a false premise the rest of your OP is irrelevant.

Some people want to abuse drugs to alter their appearance. When it's bodybuilders abusing drugs to alter their appearance we criminalise it. Bizarrely Genderists think that it's right & normal for teenage girls to abuse the same drugs to alter their appearance or allow pervy middle aged men to take oestrogen so they can sprout tits.

PowerTulle · 12/10/2026 13:26

I would start by asking what aspects of gender identity differs from plain old sex role stereotypes. There is never an answer to this.

I would then suggest a short practical session on why sexism and sex role stereotyping is unhealthy, impacts negatively on both sexes and oppresses women in particular.

Gofaster2023 · 12/10/2026 13:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/10/2026 13:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow. I hadn't put that together before. That is indeed very - inconsistent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread