Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What should trans people actually do?

367 replies

BTT · 12/10/2026 11:29

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists and that there can be a mismatch between it and sex which will likely cause distress and a desire for trans people to find a safer and more comfortable place in society somehow.

I'm talking about practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people. Please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas.

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 15:27

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 15:16

Don’t act surprised when people ignore the guidance because no other spaces are provided. Wasn’t it the GLP vs EHRC case where the judge said forcing a trans person into a space for their birth sex could be gender reassignment discrimination?

No.

Lack of additional unisex provision may be discriminatory, but a space that can be used by both sexes is just a mixed sex space. Lack of single sex provision may also be discriminatory.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 15:23

akkakk · 12/10/2026 15:20

the supreme court made clear that facilities set aside for single sex were based on biological sex - can't get higher than the supreme court - that overrules any other comments...

if you provide a gents and a ladies - no-one is excluded because no-one has ever been born who wasn't one or the other... and the supreme court judges made very clear that for the purpose of single-sex exclusions etc then GRA is irrelevant

Sure, but they also said trans people were still protected in the equality act because of gender reassignment. Forcing a trans person to use a space for the biological sex could be gender reassignment discrimination, and trans people can’t be left with no spaces to use, so it follows that alternative unisex provision must be provided

akkakk · 12/10/2026 15:20

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 15:16

Don’t act surprised when people ignore the guidance because no other spaces are provided. Wasn’t it the GLP vs EHRC case where the judge said forcing a trans person into a space for their birth sex could be gender reassignment discrimination?

the supreme court made clear that facilities set aside for single sex were based on biological sex - can't get higher than the supreme court - that overrules any other comments...

if you provide a gents and a ladies - no-one is excluded because no-one has ever been born who wasn't one or the other... and the supreme court judges made very clear that for the purpose of single-sex exclusions etc then GRA is irrelevant

murasaki · 12/10/2026 15:20

So if there were a mixed sex toilet in addition to the single sex ones, would you use it? Or is it all about the validation.

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 15:16

akkakk · 12/10/2026 15:09

and who is going to fund such a dramatic change to spaces - every swimming pool needs to add another changing room, every small business needs to add additional loos, not feasible - and esp. not at the behest of a group of people who already have spaces set aside for them - 'trans women' into the gents and 'trans men' into the ladies...

Don’t act surprised when people ignore the guidance because no other spaces are provided. Wasn’t it the GLP vs EHRC case where the judge said forcing a trans person into a space for their birth sex could be gender reassignment discrimination?

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 12/10/2026 15:13

It's a big assumption that gender identity actually exists, but if it does, it is only relevant to the individual in question therefore should not have any bearing on public spaces or treatment by services who provide sex based provisions.
Basically, dress, talk and behave how you like (within reasonable bounds) but don't expect your gender identity to impact on anyone else.

PrancingPanda · 12/10/2026 15:12

Waitingfordoggo · 12/10/2026 14:37

Alexis Blake and his boyfriend/husband were also quite intimidating to Mr Menno at a Pride event. (Mostly the boyfriend to be fair, because Alexis wouldn’t get aggressive for fear of looking unladylike). They insisted Menno delete the video he had taken of their conversation, whilst retaining a video they had taken of Menno. They had been having quite a nice chat together until Menno mentioned JKR and then the atmosphere turned a bit.

I was quite shocked by this video; I thought Mr Menno was his usual, polite self but was absolutely vilified by this couple. The partner came across as very aggressive.

akkakk · 12/10/2026 15:09

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 14:24

It doesn't seem inclusive to force trans people to constantly assess whether other services users believe they 'pass'.

Adequate unisex provision seems fairer for everyone.

and who is going to fund such a dramatic change to spaces - every swimming pool needs to add another changing room, every small business needs to add additional loos, not feasible - and esp. not at the behest of a group of people who already have spaces set aside for them - 'trans women' into the gents and 'trans men' into the ladies...

Pingponghavoc · 12/10/2026 15:02

I think trans people need to start being honest about what they want.

The idea is that they feel as if they are the opposite sex, and wish to live as such. They say this is just living a quiet life.

But they cannot be the opposite sex. Its not a reasonable adjustment for everyone they come into contact with to ignore their sex and pretend that they are the other. It doesn't matter if it preferred pronouns or use of single sex spaces, no one else should be troubled with this.

As soon as trans people make demands on others - changing language, using the wrong single sex services, attempting to remove sex based laws, they are involving others and everyone else has a right to highlight what they are doing.

RunsABit · 12/10/2026 14:52

Stop rewriting history (see claims about the Stonewall Riots and lesbians not nursing gay men during the AIDS epidemic).

Stop bringing LGB into it. We are nothing to do with you. LGB without the T.

Stop invading women's spaces, sports, jobs, organisations, meetings, dating sites and events.

Stop insisting everyone play along. They are not and never will be women (or transmen, men).

Stop making up new words to accommodate their made-up ideology. 'Cis', 'they/ them' and 'deadnaming' are the equivalent of Newspeak.

MagpiePi · 12/10/2026 14:52

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:32

People are allowed to use their own names, love.

Public toilets are entirely public spaces, completely unsafe unless we have company. And I welcome trans women in, because a) they're women, b) I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents and getting assaulted, c) it's cis men who assault is in toilets, both trans women, e) cubicles exist, and f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.

Deadname is just a word, calling it 'male' is ridiculous.

"Compel speech" - you mean, be polite? Respectful? I've met a lot of people who think being forced to stop calling Black men 'boy' is compelled.speech and who insist they should be allowed to be homophobic. Deliberately disrespecting trans people is no different.

Verbal respect for difference is the first step to preventing discrimination and violence. Every single minority which gained legal protection has had the same struggles as trans people.

Stop blaming trans women for male violence.

"Compel speech" - you mean, be polite? Respectful? I've met a lot of people who think being forced to stop calling Black men 'boy' is compelled.speech and who insist they should be allowed to be homophobic. Deliberately disrespecting trans people is no different.

Where are all the people who think being forced to stop calling black men 'boys'? Do they go to another school?

In any case, adult men of whatever colour are not boys so these hordes of homophobic racists they are being 'compelled' to speak the truth, which is the total opposite of compelling people to call a man a woman.

I feel disrespected when a man appropriates womanhood, but obviously as a boring cunty type of woman that just makes me a hateful bigot.

Kudos for bringing racism and homophobia into the argument though...

sanluca · 12/10/2026 14:49

Stick to the law for a change. If asked to leave, leave without that aggressive behaviour. Get therapy to learn to live with your dysphoria. Think of others. Stop the manipulation and blackmailing.

If you want all sex based protections to be removed by law, campaign for it. Don't use the 'it applies to everyone but I am special' reasoning.

TheyAreLovelyLovelyPeople · 12/10/2026 14:49

oh goodie, we are going to hear about clownfish now, yes?

<claps hands excitedly>

RareGoalsVerge · 12/10/2026 14:49

nicepotoftea · 12/10/2026 14:20

I am certainly finding it difficult to understand the point of your post.

Read the OP again.

OP asked for examples for practical measures to minimize problems for trans and non-trans people, saying "please respond only if you have some reasonable ideas" and also starts off assuming that Gender Ideology beliefs are true.

@SchoolOfCool gave a number of entirely equivalent analogies for other areas of tension between different groups and how stupid it would sound if you asked for ideas for how people could co-exist in peace if and only if you accept that one side or the other is correct.

What we need is ideas for how both schools of thought can coexist without assuming that one side is correct and the other side are nasty and malevolent.

murasaki · 12/10/2026 14:48

And that is the space designated for your biological sex. not whatever is going on inside your head.

brownbootsandhats · 12/10/2026 14:47

Belong - that means the spaces associated with your sex as opposed to places you feel you belong to which is different

FirmSnake · 12/10/2026 14:47

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 14:32

They don't "pass" because sex is immutable
If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you

You beleive otherwise? Based upon what?

ChasingTheSunshine · 12/10/2026 14:46

murasaki · 12/10/2026 14:34

No. Going into the spaces where you belong is living quietly. Going into the others (and often taking pics of your 'joy' or trying to talk to actual women in there) is making a point, and absolutely the opposite of living quietly.

I certainly do agree that using spaces where I belong is the best option

oldwhyno · 12/10/2026 14:46

"I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists"

Okay, let's start there. Make the opposite assumption, that it does not exist. Explore your thinking from that basis. Report back.

murasaki · 12/10/2026 14:45

Let's call it what it is, child abuse.

DeeperShadeofRed · 12/10/2026 14:42

As well as all the suggestions about seeking therapy, I'd also suggest the affirming parents of trans children require therapy.

There's clearly some deep seated issues around gender roles/ homophobia where a parent would happily advocate for dangerous medical intervention, ceasing the biological norms of puberty in a child, in lieu of acceptance that a child may be gay/ doesn't conform to societal gender norms... You will never convince me that (outside of true intersex conditions), parents pushing affirming medical intervention on minors isn't anything but a form of Munchausen syndrome by proxy, and as far as I'm concerned is only a few steps away from eugenics.

Soontobe60 · 12/10/2026 14:40

chirrupybird · 12/10/2026 12:56

I don't know any trans people or at least if I do I don't know they are trans which I assume would be their object. I think there is a big difference between a man dressing as a woman to access female spaces and potentially assault women or girls and a trans person who the last thing they want is to be perceived as a man and do not find women sexually attractive.

Try reading about AGP men, or look up Transwidows.
https://quillette.com/2019/11/06/what-is-autogynephilia-an-interview-with-dr-ray-blanchard/

What Is Autogynephilia? Interview with Dr Ray Blanchard

Modern trans activists reframed transsexualism/transgenderism as a political problem rather than a clinical problem.

https://quillette.com/2019/11/06/what-is-autogynephilia-an-interview-with-dr-ray-blanchard/

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 12/10/2026 14:38

I'm making the assumption that gender identity exists

That's a false assumption, GI doesn't exist and until that's recognised and people stop making these 'assumptions', there can be no practical solutions to the mess that GI has caused and no help for those who have been harmed by it.

Waitingfordoggo · 12/10/2026 14:37

Alexis Blake and his boyfriend/husband were also quite intimidating to Mr Menno at a Pride event. (Mostly the boyfriend to be fair, because Alexis wouldn’t get aggressive for fear of looking unladylike). They insisted Menno delete the video he had taken of their conversation, whilst retaining a video they had taken of Menno. They had been having quite a nice chat together until Menno mentioned JKR and then the atmosphere turned a bit.

Soontobe60 · 12/10/2026 14:35

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/10/2026 12:32

People are allowed to use their own names, love.

Public toilets are entirely public spaces, completely unsafe unless we have company. And I welcome trans women in, because a) they're women, b) I don't want them.meeting a mob of violent cis men in the Gents and getting assaulted, c) it's cis men who assault is in toilets, both trans women, e) cubicles exist, and f) all.wo!an are harmed by dividing us by sight & deciding who's female.

Deadname is just a word, calling it 'male' is ridiculous.

"Compel speech" - you mean, be polite? Respectful? I've met a lot of people who think being forced to stop calling Black men 'boy' is compelled.speech and who insist they should be allowed to be homophobic. Deliberately disrespecting trans people is no different.

Verbal respect for difference is the first step to preventing discrimination and violence. Every single minority which gained legal protection has had the same struggles as trans people.

Stop blaming trans women for male violence.

Beyond the 245 legally male prisoners identifying as women (151 with sexual offense convictions), there are 50 transgender prisoners with a legal gender as female (5 or fewer with sexual offense convictions, withheld for privacy), totaling 295 transgender prisoners without a GRC. Historical 2019 data showed 58.9% of male-born prisoners identifying as transwomen had sexual offense conviction
The evidence from the Ministry of Justice proves that within the male prison population with a sex offence conviction, a greater % of those offenders identify as transwomen than do not. And you’d be amazed just how many of those only discovered they were transwomen after they committed their offence for which they were convicted. Who’d have thought! I’d place bets on you now claiming that those sex offenders aren’t really trans, they’re just pretending to be.
https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/18973/pdf/