Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Surgeon Neil Hopper, who wanted his legs amputated

80 replies

madnessallaround · 08/10/2026 08:23

was watching a documentary (on Amazon i think) about this vascular surgeon in Cornwall who is currently serving out a 3 year sentence in prison. In court, when he admitted to putting his legs in dry ice for hours to force an eventual double amputation, his lawyer said he’d had body dismorphia and felt his legs/feet weren’t part of him and were unwelcome. Oh and also that he felt like and wanted to be a female from a young age.

So, one is a mental health condition, but the other is a gender identity ? How? Make it make sense.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 18:23

His sentence also included ten months for extreme sadistic porn.

EricTheHalfASleeve · 10/10/2026 18:19

I think he's actually in prison for fraud after claiming on his critical illness or life insurance for self inflicted injuries. Very similar to the Scottish surgeon who was willing to amputate healthy legs from men claiming to have body dysmorphia.

borntobequiet · 10/10/2026 18:08

I can understand breast reduction surgery for very heavy, uncomfortable breasts that affect one’s everyday life. I’ve known people with such. But dancing and sport? Not comfortable with that idea.

murasaki · 10/10/2026 16:18

borntobequiet · 10/10/2026 16:16

I’m horrified to hear that dancers have breast reduction surgery to facilitate their careers. I’ve known quite a few dancers, and have never heard of it happening. That’s not to say I don’t believe it happens, but I don’t think it’s as routine as implied by a pp.

I don't know about dancers, but the tennis player Simona Halep did.

borntobequiet · 10/10/2026 16:16

I’m horrified to hear that dancers have breast reduction surgery to facilitate their careers. I’ve known quite a few dancers, and have never heard of it happening. That’s not to say I don’t believe it happens, but I don’t think it’s as routine as implied by a pp.

murasaki · 10/10/2026 13:50

Well quite. If the child is now happier being indulged in this delusion, surely TPA would not be being furious on the internet so much. They'd be patting themselves on the back for their top parenting.

Oh.

lcakethereforeIam · 10/10/2026 13:40

madnessallaround · 09/10/2026 14:16

I think this is why TRA parents come back here repeatedly, to try to continually justify why they chose to
affirm their vulnerable child down an irreversible and impossible path, rather than gently challenging gender dysphoria.

Or even, if they're happy with what the future holds for their dysphoric sprog, bother with this board at all. Who are they trying to convince and why? By the lights of ta we're a tiny minority, who will all be dead soon. Why not leave us to our <checks notes> echo chamber. The circles of the apparently tiny minorities of trans identifying people and GC feminists would be hardly likely to intersect except that ta's keep invading our spaces and events.

I'm minded to think many of them have their doubts, are possibly worried about what they're doing to themselves or their loved ones. Going out of their way to argue with us is to create a white noise to drown out their own fears.

2021x · 10/10/2026 04:45

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Seriestwo · 09/10/2026 20:14

What do you hope the outcome for your child will be, @TransParentlyAnnoyed? Do you think it is possible for someone who wishes to be the opposite sex to find happiness - if they have all the interventions and evryone accepts them as the opposite sex?

I don’t know where you live where there are hardly any trans id people, but round these parts it’s pretty common. Every class has one or two. The LGBTetc lunchtime club at school is standing room only.

OldCrone · 09/10/2026 16:02

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 12:47

Every word of that, is untrue.

Trans children are individuals who happen to be trans. There aren't that many of them. All of them understand (and think deeply about) the consequences of being out.

Conspiracy theories aren't real life, I'm afraid. Much as I'm sure you'd prefer them to be.

Individuals simply exist while being trans, and every one of them deals with that differently. They don't require ignorant adults to make blanket statements about how they feel, act, process information or exist.

Trans people aren't cartoons, or caricatures. They can think for themselves - and no one created them, promised or sold them anything.

Coming out is a relief, not euphoria. Trans children know exactly what to expect at school, and unfortunately often encounter worse. They are beaten, touched, assaulted and constantly harassed, massively disrupting their lives and seriously impacting their mental health.

Does that sound like "euphoria" to you? My son had years of it at school, and yet remains trans. There is no euphoria, simply resignation that existing in a trans-hostile world is the price paid for alleviating their dysphoria.

Being trans is only a small part of who my son is, same as any other trans person. He isn't acting in a play, just walking the streets as himself.

It's deeply unhealthy that you spend quite so much time obsessing over a cohort you do not belong to, and transparently fail to understand. Please educate yourself.

Trans children are individuals who happen to be trans. There aren't that many of them. All of them understand (and think deeply about) the consequences of being out.

This obviously isn't true. There's another thread at the moment about a child in a reception class being 'trans'. How deeply do you think this 4 or 5 year old child has thought about this? How well do you think they understand the consequences? At that age, it's obviously all coming from the parents.

And what do you mean by 'happen to be trans'? Do you believe that people are literally born in the wrong body?

ElanaohElana · 09/10/2026 14:56

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 19:40

Agree @EdithStourton

If our taxes are helping to pay for traumatised/autistic/vulnerable/mentally ill young women to take excess amounts of testosterone/have mastectomies/phalloplasties as ‘treatments’ for their mental health crises, it is everyone’s business. And it is everyone’s business that the NHS will also be funding revision surgeries (phalloplasty is a pretty primitive procedure with many potential risks) and lifelong medical care for these very damaged young women. And that’s before you even get on to the detransitioners and the physical and mental health care that they will need through their lives.

I don’t find it acceptable that public money is spent on treatments which have so many risks, and for which there is an extremely weak evidence base, if any at all. The success criteria is surely: ‘do these treatments improve people’s mental state?’

Where is the evidence that they do? We don’t have it. So weighing up the risks vs the potential benefits looks very uneven indeed.

I consider it to be safeguarding vulnerable people to oppose these operations. There appears to be very flimsy evidence that it’s helpful and large amounts of evidence that it will cause terrible harm - physically and mentally. No responsible doctor would perform an operation in any other specialism in these circumstances. I believe out of reasonable concern for our vulnerable people, it is vital no further medicalisation goes on. Instead, long term therapy should be offered.

madnessallaround · 09/10/2026 14:16

Rollingpinofdoom · 09/10/2026 13:10

Or their parents could get them therapy to accept they are not the opposite sex, just gender non conforming children rather than affirming them in their beliefs and getting upset when no one else will play along.

I think this is why TRA parents come back here repeatedly, to try to continually justify why they chose to
affirm their vulnerable child down an irreversible and impossible path, rather than gently challenging gender dysphoria.

OP posts:
DrBlackbird · 09/10/2026 13:59

We all know hyperfixation plays a large part in autism. Many autistic children and young adults are also highly suggestible. Why is it so hard for people (including doctors and teachers as well as parents) to recognise that a belief that you’re in the wrong body is just as much a fixation as is counting trains or dinosaurs? But with rather more harmful and permanent consequences.

Edited to add: hyperfixation of a fetish nature is just as likely to occur in autistic adults… even a surgeon. I believe there are also studies finding higher degree of sociopathy in surgeons as well. Stands to reason, a too empathetic surgeon doesn’t work either.

DrBlackbird · 09/10/2026 13:47

Seriestwo · 08/10/2026 13:21

The acceptance of fetishes by people who are too stupid to see them has broken institutions

This.

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 13:37

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 12:47

Every word of that, is untrue.

Trans children are individuals who happen to be trans. There aren't that many of them. All of them understand (and think deeply about) the consequences of being out.

Conspiracy theories aren't real life, I'm afraid. Much as I'm sure you'd prefer them to be.

Individuals simply exist while being trans, and every one of them deals with that differently. They don't require ignorant adults to make blanket statements about how they feel, act, process information or exist.

Trans people aren't cartoons, or caricatures. They can think for themselves - and no one created them, promised or sold them anything.

Coming out is a relief, not euphoria. Trans children know exactly what to expect at school, and unfortunately often encounter worse. They are beaten, touched, assaulted and constantly harassed, massively disrupting their lives and seriously impacting their mental health.

Does that sound like "euphoria" to you? My son had years of it at school, and yet remains trans. There is no euphoria, simply resignation that existing in a trans-hostile world is the price paid for alleviating their dysphoria.

Being trans is only a small part of who my son is, same as any other trans person. He isn't acting in a play, just walking the streets as himself.

It's deeply unhealthy that you spend quite so much time obsessing over a cohort you do not belong to, and transparently fail to understand. Please educate yourself.

Educate myself? But in the same breath, you claim anyone reading up on the issues is 'obsessing' and to be derided?

Try reading up on the current Employment Tribunal, Dr Sam Hall, and Brighton WellBN. Then tell me everything is peachy in 'gender' healthcare.

Read up on WPATH and Standards of Care v8. Tell me that children can identify as eunuchs and should be entitled to be castrated to 'affirm' their identity.

Read the evidence of outcomes in gender incongruent people post 'transition'.

I very much hope your child does not face any harassment or poor treatment. I find it very sad what happens to children who go down the path of 'trans affirmation'. I'm sure that under all these attacks you make on women on here, you have a lot of difficult things to work through. I hope you find a way through.

spannasaurus · 09/10/2026 13:21

The Trevor Project thinks that gender euphoria is a real thing and define it as

" the satisfaction or joy caused when someone’s gender experience or expression aligns with their gender identity, rather than with the sex they were assigned at birth."

https://www.thetrevorproject.org/blog/what-is-gender-euphoria/

What is gender euphoria?

What is gender euphoria? Discover how this deep sense of satisfaction and joy impacts the mental health of people of all identities.

https://www.thetrevorproject.org/blog/what-is-gender-euphoria/

Rollingpinofdoom · 09/10/2026 13:10

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 12:47

Every word of that, is untrue.

Trans children are individuals who happen to be trans. There aren't that many of them. All of them understand (and think deeply about) the consequences of being out.

Conspiracy theories aren't real life, I'm afraid. Much as I'm sure you'd prefer them to be.

Individuals simply exist while being trans, and every one of them deals with that differently. They don't require ignorant adults to make blanket statements about how they feel, act, process information or exist.

Trans people aren't cartoons, or caricatures. They can think for themselves - and no one created them, promised or sold them anything.

Coming out is a relief, not euphoria. Trans children know exactly what to expect at school, and unfortunately often encounter worse. They are beaten, touched, assaulted and constantly harassed, massively disrupting their lives and seriously impacting their mental health.

Does that sound like "euphoria" to you? My son had years of it at school, and yet remains trans. There is no euphoria, simply resignation that existing in a trans-hostile world is the price paid for alleviating their dysphoria.

Being trans is only a small part of who my son is, same as any other trans person. He isn't acting in a play, just walking the streets as himself.

It's deeply unhealthy that you spend quite so much time obsessing over a cohort you do not belong to, and transparently fail to understand. Please educate yourself.

Or their parents could get them therapy to accept they are not the opposite sex, just gender non conforming children rather than affirming them in their beliefs and getting upset when no one else will play along.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 12:47

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 09:22

Comorbidities in gender incongruent young people often go unnoticed, because everything gets obscured by the 'trans' label.

Underneath, there us a cohort of terribly vulnerable, suffering children, who have been sold unevidenced nonsense, supported and enabled by medics and activists who put 'trans' issues above the wellbeing of this abandoned cohort.

These poor kids have been manipulated, let down, harmed and mistreated. The damage done, both physical and mental, is stark. And the issues that led.to their gender incongruence or dysmorphia have not gone anywhere in the meantime. They are still children with neurodivergent traits, trauma histories, etc.

Once the euphoria wears off, they find themselves with all the same issues, only now with another whole layer added on top.

Every word of that, is untrue.

Trans children are individuals who happen to be trans. There aren't that many of them. All of them understand (and think deeply about) the consequences of being out.

Conspiracy theories aren't real life, I'm afraid. Much as I'm sure you'd prefer them to be.

Individuals simply exist while being trans, and every one of them deals with that differently. They don't require ignorant adults to make blanket statements about how they feel, act, process information or exist.

Trans people aren't cartoons, or caricatures. They can think for themselves - and no one created them, promised or sold them anything.

Coming out is a relief, not euphoria. Trans children know exactly what to expect at school, and unfortunately often encounter worse. They are beaten, touched, assaulted and constantly harassed, massively disrupting their lives and seriously impacting their mental health.

Does that sound like "euphoria" to you? My son had years of it at school, and yet remains trans. There is no euphoria, simply resignation that existing in a trans-hostile world is the price paid for alleviating their dysphoria.

Being trans is only a small part of who my son is, same as any other trans person. He isn't acting in a play, just walking the streets as himself.

It's deeply unhealthy that you spend quite so much time obsessing over a cohort you do not belong to, and transparently fail to understand. Please educate yourself.

lcakethereforeIam · 09/10/2026 10:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 09/10/2026 10:27

Revealed: More than 1,000 patients a year have trans chest surgery on the NHS

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/02/10/revealed-thousands-of-trans-surgeries-carried-out-by-nhs/

Archive version to evade paywall

https://archive.ph/A9m2x

Waitingfordoggo · 09/10/2026 09:24

@TransParentlyAnnoyed I’m not ablist mate, I’m neurodivergent myself as is one of my DC and several other family members. ASC and ADHD aplenty in this family. Some autistic people can get very fixated on ideas and the ‘right’ way to deal with things. I’m sure you know that.

If you’re right that there aren’t many people getting surgeries, and that surgeries aren’t funded by the NHS, that is great news. There seem to be lots of girls and women on high doses of testosterone though, which obviously has long term consequences. Very difficult for those girls who then change their minds about wanting to pretend to be male.

I don’t know what surgeries you’re talking about re ‘cis’ people but it sounds like cosmetic surgery. I’m not a fan of any cosmetic surgeries- certainly the NHS shouldn’t fund them. (Breast reduction can be needed for physical reasons, so can rhinoplasty in some cases. Quite happy for the NHS to fund surgeries which are carried out for physical reasons).

Google says that the NHS funds ‘gender reassignment’ treatments and surgeries. I don’t believe they should fund any of it. What they should fund is high quality mental health support. If patients want surgeries and hormones they can fund that themselves.

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 09:22

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 07:08

p.s. The single biggest cause of mental ill-health in young trans people, is transphobia. Bullying, street violence and sexual harassment are destroying young trans lives. Please don't add to that by circulating harmful myths about them - these myths enable the violence they all suffer.

Comorbidities in gender incongruent young people often go unnoticed, because everything gets obscured by the 'trans' label.

Underneath, there us a cohort of terribly vulnerable, suffering children, who have been sold unevidenced nonsense, supported and enabled by medics and activists who put 'trans' issues above the wellbeing of this abandoned cohort.

These poor kids have been manipulated, let down, harmed and mistreated. The damage done, both physical and mental, is stark. And the issues that led.to their gender incongruence or dysmorphia have not gone anywhere in the meantime. They are still children with neurodivergent traits, trauma histories, etc.

Once the euphoria wears off, they find themselves with all the same issues, only now with another whole layer added on top.

heathspeedwell · 09/10/2026 08:08

It's significant that the documentary plays down the fact that Hopper claims to be a transwoman, and that his main motivation is sexual fetish.

It's often said that surgeons are far more likely to be sociopaths than other people. Hopper obviously didn't just enjoy watching people experience extreme pain on his screen. He was happy to put his wife and children, the people he loves most, through the pain of thinking he had sepsis and could die, so that he could enact his sexual fetish.

When Hopper watched the live stream of another man being castrated, he sent a photo of his own erection to the man cutting off another man's penis.

Castration fetish and eunuch fetish are clearly a part of being trans for at least some transwomen. Even one of the heads of WPATH.

<a class="break-all" href="http://web.archive.org/web/20230315100144/reduxx.info/top-trans-medical-association-collaborated-with-castration-child-abuse-fetishists/" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">Top Trans Medical Association Collaborated With Castration, Child Abuse Fetishists - Reduxx

Being 'trans' is clearly not just an innate thing like being left handed.

Top Trans Medical Association Collaborated With Castration, Child Abuse Fetishists - Reduxx

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH),  the international association which sets guidelines for the medical ‘transitioning’ of children, has been collaborating with participants of a fetish forum that hosts and produces fict...

http://web.archive.org/web/20230315100144/https://reduxx.info/top-trans-medical-association-collaborated-with-castration-child-abuse-fetishists/

Rollingpinofdoom · 09/10/2026 07:15

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 09/10/2026 07:08

p.s. The single biggest cause of mental ill-health in young trans people, is transphobia. Bullying, street violence and sexual harassment are destroying young trans lives. Please don't add to that by circulating harmful myths about them - these myths enable the violence they all suffer.

No. The single biggest cause of mental health in “transpeople” is being told they can be the opposite sex if they feel like it. And then getting upset when people refuse to affirm their beliefs.