Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WellBN Brighton GP practice do not believe in evidence based medicine. TT at employment tribunal tomorrow

1000 replies

impossibletoday · 07/10/2026 19:53

In case anyone is interested

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

Naomi Cunningham profile picture

Naomi Cunningham (@LoudBonnet) on X

@tribunaltweets For CVP log-in, email [email protected] citing Redvers v NHS Sussex 6020988/2024.

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
HydrangeaFig · 10/10/2026 11:11

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 10:56

'The Patient Safety Investigation Report was completed in May and published in June of this year. It concluded that WellBN caused “actual potential harm” to its young patients and “fell substantially below” the professional standards of care required.'

Link there to the NHS' own report.

I find the phrase "actual potential harm" strange. In the report they use the term twice, and once say "actual or potential harm" and once "possible or actual harm". I think it makes more sense with the "or". Does "actual potential harm" without the "or" have a special meaning?

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 10/10/2026 11:03

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 10:52

I really wouldn't get your information from these types of blogs- they are highly ideologically driven and biased. Better to read the facts of the case and consider a range of different perspectives/ commentaries.

The link you were given was not to a blog but to video of Dr Hall exhibiting opinions that render her unfit to be a doctor.

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 10:56

'The Patient Safety Investigation Report was completed in May and published in June of this year. It concluded that WellBN caused “actual potential harm” to its young patients and “fell substantially below” the professional standards of care required.'

Link there to the NHS' own report.

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 10:54

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 10:52

I really wouldn't get your information from these types of blogs- they are highly ideologically driven and biased. Better to read the facts of the case and consider a range of different perspectives/ commentaries.

Any sources you'd rec, Lacksie?

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 10:53

MyAmpleSheep · 10/10/2026 09:27

I think that the tenor of the argument is or will be that on the facts she did absolutely nothing that could justify the initiation of an investigation against her, and that the hostile investigation was only (or even partially) because of her attachment to EBM as the appropriate method to determine treatment.

I doubt they discriminated against her based on her " belief" in EBM though. Gender critical beliefs is more plausible, But EBM seems to be a pretty universal value no? So I think she might struggle to demonstrate that on the facts.

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 10:52

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 09:24

@Lacksie there is a video interview further up the thread with Sam Hall, who is a woman presenting as a man who became a GP later in life. She describes herself as like the pied piper towards the children who came to her in distress and she got them pretty much immediately on puberty blockers/cross sex hormones. She is not an experienced GP she was previously a doctor but in a different filed of medicine.

I would suggest reading up on the whole case. It is very sobering. This is helpful….

https://genderblog.net/nhs-knew-of-concerns-about-trans-dr-in-2020/

I really wouldn't get your information from these types of blogs- they are highly ideologically driven and biased. Better to read the facts of the case and consider a range of different perspectives/ commentaries.

MyAmpleSheep · 10/10/2026 09:27

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 09:16

I can see that argument.

I think that the tenor of the argument is or will be that on the facts she did absolutely nothing that could justify the initiation of an investigation against her, and that the hostile investigation was only (or even partially) because of her attachment to EBM as the appropriate method to determine treatment.

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 09:24

@Lacksie there is a video interview further up the thread with Sam Hall, who is a woman presenting as a man who became a GP later in life. She describes herself as like the pied piper towards the children who came to her in distress and she got them pretty much immediately on puberty blockers/cross sex hormones. She is not an experienced GP she was previously a doctor but in a different filed of medicine.

I would suggest reading up on the whole case. It is very sobering. This is helpful….

https://genderblog.net/nhs-knew-of-concerns-about-trans-dr-in-2020/

NHS knew of concerns about trans Dr in 2020

Whistleblower told NHS Sussex and NHS England of problems with Dr Sam Hall’s methods and was accused of transphobia. Dr Sam Hall, former clinical lead at WellBN Brighton An NHS Doctor raised …

https://genderblog.net/nhs-knew-of-concerns-about-trans-dr-in-2020/

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 09:17

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 09:07

@Lacksie just to clarify do you condone the behaviour of Sam Hall and WellBN?

Edited

I don't know enough about the details/ circumstances to make a judgement on that.

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 09:16

MyAmpleSheep · 10/10/2026 09:12

I think the belief element is that as a scientific methodology EBM is the correct way to make decisions about treatment.

A doctor shouldn’t receive discriminatory treatment because of their belief that evidence based medicine is the only appropriate basis for treatment decisions.

Whether the same or a different doctor should be punished on the basis they don’t practice evidence based medicine is a very different question: that’s a finding of fact of not complying with an NHS policy to conduct evidence based medicine as a methodology, if there is such a policy. Belief is irrelevant. Doctors are not free to practice medicine according to their beliefs, they must uphold professional standards as dictated by the GMC.

Edited

I can see that argument.

MyAmpleSheep · 10/10/2026 09:12

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 08:23

Right. It's a scientific methodology, not a belief. And whether a particular doctor or practice is following it properly with regard to a particular medicine/ treatment protocol, is an opinion.

I think the belief element is that as a scientific methodology EBM is the correct way to make decisions about treatment.

A doctor shouldn’t receive discriminatory treatment because of their belief that evidence based medicine is the only appropriate basis for treatment decisions.

Whether the same or a different doctor should be punished on the basis they don’t practice evidence based medicine is a very different question: that’s a finding of fact of not complying with an NHS policy to conduct evidence based medicine as a methodology, if there is such a policy. Belief is irrelevant. Doctors are not free to practice medicine according to their beliefs, they must uphold professional standards as dictated by the GMC.

BlueLegume · 10/10/2026 09:07

@Lacksie just to clarify do you condone the behaviour of Sam Hall and WellBN?

Lacksie · 10/10/2026 08:23

RoyalCorgi · 09/10/2026 14:13

Much as I disapprove of what the NHS is doing here, does anyone think it's slightly odd to argue that a belief in evidence-based medicine is a protected belief? I think it's pushing it a bit. Surely everyone who works in medicine ought to believe in evidence-based medicine as a matter of course?

Right. It's a scientific methodology, not a belief. And whether a particular doctor or practice is following it properly with regard to a particular medicine/ treatment protocol, is an opinion.

rebax · 10/10/2026 08:03

Hedgehogforshort · 09/10/2026 21:18

What I particularly like about the claimant in this case is she is sharp as a nail,

She keeps saying what is your question to BW band standing activities.

She is on my Shero list.

On TT this comes across as BW not being on top of the material and struggling to land any points - is this what it looks like watching?

ArabellaScott · 10/10/2026 07:53

https://genderblog.net/nhs-knew-of-concerns-about-trans-dr-in-2020/

Nick Wallis' write up.

I feel that this case should bring down the whole shitshow, but then I've felt that before.

This seems to me to show that the rot went all the way through the NHS, instigated by mad activists but enabled by the high ups.

And only finally uncovered when a parent threatened to sue.

NHS knew of concerns about trans Dr in 2020

Whistleblower told NHS Sussex and NHS England of problems with Dr Sam Hall’s methods and was accused of transphobia. Dr Sam Hall, former clinical lead at WellBN Brighton An NHS Doctor raised …

https://genderblog.net/nhs-knew-of-concerns-about-trans-dr-in-2020/

Neversofaraway · 10/10/2026 07:48

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 23:28

The Pathways puberty blockers trial asks children for 'assent' as it acknowledges tehy cant give informed consent.

Either way assent or consent is meaning less if neither patients or their parents/guardians have been warned about the long term side effects of drugs.

Prestissimo · 10/10/2026 07:44

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 23:28

The Pathways puberty blockers trial asks children for 'assent' as it acknowledges tehy cant give informed consent.

Yes having listened to SH in that interview and read that WellBN link they certainly don’t have the same understanding of informed consent as I do.

informed consent is not “the patient wanted it so I provided it and they were happy”, it is a process that involves ensuring a patient knows and understands all the risks and intended benefits of a treatment before going ahead. In the field of gender medicine I don’t know how that can ever truly be the case, because there is so little long-term research. But certainly for children how can they possibly consent to anything like PBs when their brains aren’t developed enough to understand the implications of such a massive decision. It’s well-recognised that some decisions are simply too complex for Gillick competence to be valid. This is not the same kind of medicine as providing contraception or fixing a broken arm. Hence the ‘assent’ model in the Pathways trial.

This is why this should be specialist care - because the patient numbers are so small (for most practices, I understand that it is different at WellBN) that no regular GP will see enough of this to have the experience or expertise to prescribe independently. We have about 15,000 patients at my practice and fewer than 20 on the transgender register, not all of whom are prescribed any kind of hormone therapy. As GPs we are good at making sure they get appropriate screening invitations despite their gender marker being different from their sex. We are good at providing other general care. We should not, imo, be starting or supervising cross-sex hormones.

ArabellaScott · 09/10/2026 23:28

Neversofaraway · 09/10/2026 20:19

I understand "informed consent" to mean that a patient cannot consent without being fully informed of the risks of a medical intervention. I don't believe that patients at Wellbn could ever be fully informed since Hall is in denial about any downsides to PBs or cross sex hormones.

The Pathways puberty blockers trial asks children for 'assent' as it acknowledges tehy cant give informed consent.

Hedgehogforshort · 09/10/2026 21:18

What I particularly like about the claimant in this case is she is sharp as a nail,

She keeps saying what is your question to BW band standing activities.

She is on my Shero list.

KittyWilkinson · 09/10/2026 21:02

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 09/10/2026 16:12

Now I have access to watch, and we are finished for the day, I can say that Dr Redvers is coming across very well. Calm and professional.

That's good to hear. Reading TT and the constant badgering by BW, clearly designed to wear her down over the last few days, I was wondering how she was holding up. I really admire her courage, and this has been going on for years and years it seems.

Neversofaraway · 09/10/2026 20:19

I understand "informed consent" to mean that a patient cannot consent without being fully informed of the risks of a medical intervention. I don't believe that patients at Wellbn could ever be fully informed since Hall is in denial about any downsides to PBs or cross sex hormones.

Hedgehogforshort · 09/10/2026 20:17

Justabaker · 09/10/2026 19:46

Testosterone is very powerful. DH says that one of the challenges of being a healthy teenage lad is learning how to deal with testosterone. Without beating the shit out of anyone who irritates you. He says the point of contact sports is to help boys deal with hormone surges.

A woman in her 40s, suddenly starts injecting (I suspect) large doses of T. Contemplate the impact on her. Irrationality doesn't begin to describe it.

I just asked my DH he said that is true. I recall my son struggling with his friends penchant for violent reactions and them wanting to fight, i feel we guided my son well and he learnt to walk away.

Justabaker · 09/10/2026 19:46

heathspeedwell · 09/10/2026 15:08

That interview with Sam Hall is disturbing. She sounds so sinister and extreme, but she keeps trying to smile and look approachable and reasonable - just like Webberley. It really is a cult-like mentality.

When she talks about the model of 'informed consent' I get the strong feeling that what she actually means is she just wants to transition anyone who comes anywhere near her.

Testosterone is very powerful. DH says that one of the challenges of being a healthy teenage lad is learning how to deal with testosterone. Without beating the shit out of anyone who irritates you. He says the point of contact sports is to help boys deal with hormone surges.

A woman in her 40s, suddenly starts injecting (I suspect) large doses of T. Contemplate the impact on her. Irrationality doesn't begin to describe it.

PinkishPanther · 09/10/2026 19:38

MyPearlViper · 09/10/2026 12:26

The whole "Evidence-Based-Medicine is just an opinion" defence reminds me of the moment a few months ago when WPATH came out with the view that their Standards of Care were just an opinion.

If neutral observers like parents can be reassured that the options [give kids drugs and surgery] and [don't give kids drugs and surgery] are equally valid, with equal chances of a good outcome then that absolves (in their minds at least) them of the responsibility of pushing their kids down a particular route

I may be misremembering but one of the ?nurses at WellBN got a paper published a few years ago about using 'the informed consent model' at WellBN. Not a model that is applicable in UK healthcare, and certainly not applicable to children, but it seems they (SH) thought is was. I will see if I can find that paper. I wonder if it is still out there. I am pretty sure Louise (Irvine) has referenced it in some things she has written.

<all of which is irrelevant to the completely idiotic reduction of EBM to a 'belief' as per their arguments, but they seem to be pitting EBM against informed consent>

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.