Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WellBN Brighton GP practice do not believe in evidence based medicine. TT at employment tribunal tomorrow

1000 replies

impossibletoday · 07/10/2026 19:53

In case anyone is interested

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

Naomi Cunningham profile picture

Naomi Cunningham (@LoudBonnet) on X

@tribunaltweets For CVP log-in, email [email protected] citing Redvers v NHS Sussex 6020988/2024.

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 11:27

C: Patient safety comes first; and in my view this quite worrying
CM: 140/180 In August 2020 how many should Dr Hall have been prescribing to w/o GIDS supervision under guidelines?
C None

Drag Queen Singing GIF by Paramount+
Szygy · 12/10/2026 11:27

From TT:

CM p1028. Looking at re context. 19 August, 15 days later from second para. When did you learn who investigator was?
C I believe MP sent me CV
CM Would you say relations positive?
C No appalling
CM was he even handed?
C no

CM have you seen any evidence DH complained about DA?
C No
CM Was there any complaint outside of from those on Safeguarding team?
C No
CM Put to you that issue of conflict of interest because of prior social interaction with DH.

CM re social interactions, say someone you met at dinner party. Reporting issues of harming a patient?
C GMC are clear that working relationships, careers don't come first. You must report issues of patient safety.
CM To you knowledge has DH raised any issue complaining about social interactions eg Rainbow Choir
C no
CM p 1187

CM Email of Dr Davies. After interviews before meeting with Doyle and clinicians.
J Who Dr Davies?
C Chief Medical Officer
SM we see at 188 primacy of patient safety and repercussions. Did concerns about Dr Hall dissipate?
C no

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 11:26

Ooh, just noticed the links to the tribunal bundle and claimants witness statement. I may have to abandon my plans for this evening. There is a lot of pages!

Szygy · 12/10/2026 11:25

From TT:

C As a doctor you have to take patients as individual and assess predicament, symptoms etc. Not a broad brush approach, that's not good practice.
CM p773-4, your GMC referral. Gist of concern?
C My worries DH practicing outside competence and risky. Also he was willing to take over prescribing from organisations that were known to be practicing outside of GMC regulation.
CM How can that be reconciled with [missed]
C My medical integrity belief, staying true to that belief

Re RW report, p928. Is this the last page of the summary you received?
C Yes
CM Last two paras [read quickly]. Concerns re transphobia in GC community. You were taken to page [?] says something different.
J Full report?
CM The summary Dr Hall received and summary C say different?

CM When did you see summaries different?
C in bundle first time.
CM Why different?
C I don't know

CM It is claimed DA behaved same to everyone. Please read [missed]. Have you seen notes of the "long, positive" meeting?
C No

Szygy · 12/10/2026 11:24

From TT:

CM And one thing you raised in evidence use of BHCCG transhealth hub email. How might be perceived externally. March 2021 meeting. What steps taken by R re use of that email by Clare Project?
C Don't know.

CM was put to you the full audit of patient could not be done. Refers to a letter.
C Email from Stephen Pike in medicines management
CB Do you accept that ix/audit cannot be done by CCG?
C No
CM Other steps pointed out subsequently

CM were you aware at time of Doyle letter PISR letter?
C no
J What is this letter?
CM Letter was referred by Mr Williams; in reference to what was being done and known about

CM You were challenged re use of activist in re Dr Hall. p4044 transcript of Dr Hall, last 2 paragraphs. [J reading]. It's put to you that activist is inappropriate?
C No, this is clearly activism, supplanting good medical practice

SM You were asked re RW, p665 you described a a perverse fingding.
C GMC subs guidance is very clear about prescribing. Patient needs a suicidality risk assessment before prescribing.
RW said DH not doing this so he could not have been in compliance with GMC guidance.

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 12/10/2026 11:24

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 11:20

An excellent witness. Devastatingly clear and concise. A break now and then Mark Smith.

"MS - Mark Smith, Chief People Officer, R1 (Aug 2022 - Jan 2025) Acting CEO (Jan-June 2025) Deputy CEO & Director of Transition (June 2025 - present)"

From TT

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 12/10/2026 11:22

Threadreaderapp does not appear to have captured all the posts from TT. I'll see if it is fixed later but perhaps @Justabaker can confirm?

X is being a bit glitchy in general for me.

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 11:20

An excellent witness. Devastatingly clear and concise. A break now and then Mark Smith.

Szygy · 12/10/2026 11:19

I've got a little bit of time, so just catching up from the last post to try and fill in the gap a bit -

From TT:

CM You learn ix but not who will lead. You state political nature, and state I have a protected belief and I don't know who investigator is.
C yes
CM 2283. email to Ms Allen Oct 2023. Email you are asked about tribunal. Given that ICB safeguarding and prejudice against those with GC belief

Gx letter Ms Ford. Quoting re ICB, R has a dignity at work policy and protection for beliefs. We recommend action taken to raise awareness of these issues. Did they know you had GC belief?
C They knew.

CM p?170. Interview September 2020 with NHSE and Dr Hall. Last para says current 140 patients are receiving gender realignment treatment, p4100 undisputed transcript Dr Hall gave to Translucent after.

CM [Interview summarised.] Dr Hall explains blowup in patient numbers.
in that passage, where was funding for Dr Hall to enable blowup?
C One through GMS contract with ICB and 2. locally commissioned prescribing service.

C Patient safety comes first; and in my view this quite worrying
CM 140/180 In August 2020 how many should Dr Hall have been prescribing to w/o GIDS supervision under guidelines?
C None
CM Did Dr Hall have GIDS supervision?
C No

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 12/10/2026 11:18

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 12/10/2026 10:23

The testosterone-voice thing is very interesting if you understand where men’s low voices - in fact, where everyone’s voice pitch - comes from.

Basically, your pitch is dependent on two things - the size of your vocal folds (sometimes called vocal chords) and the length of the resonant cavity - that is, your vocal tract, which is basically the “tube” that runs from your lungs to your lips, and in which the sound vibrations produced by your vocal folds resonate. Big vocal folds + longer vocal tract = lower voice, smaller vocal folds + shorter vocal tract = higher voice.

In male puberty, testosterone tells the vocal folds to grow, while simultaneously telling the rest of the body to also go through a growth spurt - so you get bigger vocal folds and longer overall vocal tract.

When women take exogenous testosterone, it can tell the vocal folds to grow, but it can’t tell the rest of the body to also grow (I don’t know the biomechanics of that - I’m assuming there are other hormones and systems at play). This means that trans-identifying women end up with big vocal folds and an inappropriately short vocal tract, which gives the typical TIM “kazoo” voice.

I was interested to hear that “Sam” sang in a choir. Many detrans women have commented that because of the mismatch between their vocal folds size and their vocal tract size, they ended up developing all sorts of vocal fold issues, like nodules and pain during speech and the like. And I remember at least one who lamented losing her singing voice - she simply couldn’t control the larger vocal folds to the fine degree she had before testosterone.

Wrt choirs though, many choral directors allocate singers to parts (soprano/alto/baritone, etc) simply on the basis of what the singer’s vocal range is, rather than strictly by sex. It does mean you often get female voices singing tenor, which changes the quality of the sound.

Another thing is that when males sing alto parts they have to use a falsetto voice which just doesn't have much power. I've played in orchestras accompanying soloists and you have to pipe down a bit for all of them but male alto parts you have to pipe down immensely. I still can't think of "and the land brought forth frogs" from Israel in Egypt (Handel) without getting the giggles.

Women singing alto can really give it some welly because you use the air in your whole chest cavity to vibrate in that register and it is immensely satisfiying! And as far as I understand it's a voice a male simply cannot have (?)

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 11:00

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 10:58

I'm liking these questions by her barrister.

And I'm absolutely loving her answers.

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 10:58

I'm liking these questions by her barrister.

BettyBooper · 12/10/2026 10:55

This is such a good point to make clear to the court

From TT

CM When talking about your GC belief, and your belief in medicine you said they were linked
C In clinical practice sex is a bio fact and relevant to medicine
CM In provision of hormones/PBs
C we have to start off knowing sex of P, its important as affects outcomes

nauticant · 12/10/2026 10:53

A clear version is here: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HUabZZ3XUAAxsye?format=jpg&name=large

nauticant · 12/10/2026 10:52

Here's a lovely graphic that TT are using:

WellBN Brighton GP practice do not believe in evidence based medicine. TT at employment tribunal tomorrow
Justabaker · 12/10/2026 10:38

On the vocal folds, growth spurt thing.

DS2 had a beautiful alto voice and was slow to start puberty (around 14). One day he walked up behind me and said 'Hello Mother' in a lovely baritone. I actually jumped. And thus I knew my baby was ever closer to being a man. He'd started to grow and everything else was developing.

ickky · 12/10/2026 10:26

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 12/10/2026 10:21

Wish someone would ask them to make the courtroom full screen. I'm too nervous of getting kicked out especially as I reported their data breach!

Just put a note in the chat box, ask them to maximise the tribunal window.

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 10:25

Thank you to everyone for the voice and choir explanations. Fascinating stuff.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 12/10/2026 10:23

MyrtleLion · 12/10/2026 09:46

Every trans-identified woman I have met has a squeaky/higher-pitched voice. I knew one woman who was introduced to me in 2011 by a male name and was reasonably short with male-pattern baldness but had the most peculiar voice. I take people at face value, so assumed she was a man, though nowadays I would probably realise.

When I later found out she was trans and had undergone a double mastectomy and hysterectomy but not a phalloplasty, it was blindingly obvious she was a woman.

I am amazed at how masculine many women look once they take testosterone, particularly if they have full beards, but the voice never drops in the same way.

The testosterone-voice thing is very interesting if you understand where men’s low voices - in fact, where everyone’s voice pitch - comes from.

Basically, your pitch is dependent on two things - the size of your vocal folds (sometimes called vocal chords) and the length of the resonant cavity - that is, your vocal tract, which is basically the “tube” that runs from your lungs to your lips, and in which the sound vibrations produced by your vocal folds resonate. Big vocal folds + longer vocal tract = lower voice, smaller vocal folds + shorter vocal tract = higher voice.

In male puberty, testosterone tells the vocal folds to grow, while simultaneously telling the rest of the body to also go through a growth spurt - so you get bigger vocal folds and longer overall vocal tract.

When women take exogenous testosterone, it can tell the vocal folds to grow, but it can’t tell the rest of the body to also grow (I don’t know the biomechanics of that - I’m assuming there are other hormones and systems at play). This means that trans-identifying women end up with big vocal folds and an inappropriately short vocal tract, which gives the typical TIM “kazoo” voice.

I was interested to hear that “Sam” sang in a choir. Many detrans women have commented that because of the mismatch between their vocal folds size and their vocal tract size, they ended up developing all sorts of vocal fold issues, like nodules and pain during speech and the like. And I remember at least one who lamented losing her singing voice - she simply couldn’t control the larger vocal folds to the fine degree she had before testosterone.

Wrt choirs though, many choral directors allocate singers to parts (soprano/alto/baritone, etc) simply on the basis of what the singer’s vocal range is, rather than strictly by sex. It does mean you often get female voices singing tenor, which changes the quality of the sound.

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 10:22

Same here!

ImNotAsCooperativeAsYouMightWantAWomanToBe · 12/10/2026 10:21

Wish someone would ask them to make the courtroom full screen. I'm too nervous of getting kicked out especially as I reported their data breach!

wantmorenow · 12/10/2026 10:20

I'm in too 😄

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 10:13

Ah, visuals and sound now.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 12/10/2026 10:11

Re voice changes, testosterone lengthens the vocal chords but doesn't make the voice box grow in the way that a man's does in puberty. Hence the loose, 'buzzy' effect of chords that don't fit the container and so aren't under the correct tension.

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 10:11

WTTC but no sound and a bunch of black screens.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread