Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WellBN Brighton GP practice do not believe in evidence based medicine. TT at employment tribunal tomorrow

1000 replies

impossibletoday · 07/10/2026 19:53

In case anyone is interested

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

Naomi Cunningham profile picture

Naomi Cunningham (@LoudBonnet) on X

@tribunaltweets For CVP log-in, email [email protected] citing Redvers v NHS Sussex 6020988/2024.

https://x.com/LoudBonnet/status/2107877530602443058

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 13:15

Lunchtime break observations. MS is a middle aged man, receding hairline, smart suit and tie. But he sounds about 25, slightly petulant, irritating verbal tic. He comes across as nervous, hostile and determined to avoid any responsibility for anything.

nauticant · 12/10/2026 13:10

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 13:05

I think CE's point is that, despite a review of the policies which took place on the merger of the three bodies, no changes were made. MS (who was on the executive committee) can't say why, it wasn't him, he's not other people, blah blah.

NHS: We acknowledge that you have these findings in your favour in the Supreme Court judgment/Durrant report. However, you're having a laugh if you expect us to implement the necessary changes.

Szygy · 12/10/2026 13:07

Apologies but I won’t be able to post this afternoon. Perhaps it’s for the best after this morning's befuddlement!

Szygy · 12/10/2026 13:05

From TT:

J not a response to, cannot have
CE making room for the possibility you would revise policy in response to merger, and whether these are response or because of a consideration of the Durant recommendations.?

CE Let's look at what they are? Do you accept that these are unlikely, or could not have, specifically addressed the Durant recos?
MS Yes
CE One last in re recommendation 6, in respect of the allegations against staff policy.
back to p1906, wording of undertaking from Mr D

Bullet pt 2. [I undertake to review policies ...] That is a fulsome undertaking?
MS yes
CE But no review?
MS Says here that there was undertaking. But possibly there was a review but nothing needed?
CE [missed]
CE So no new policies?
MS Just a review of old policies

J Perhaps that is a good point to break for lunch. Can everyone please be back in their places for two o'clock. [Reminds W under oath.]

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 13:05

I think CE's point is that, despite a review of the policies which took place on the merger of the three bodies, no changes were made. MS (who was on the executive committee) can't say why, it wasn't him, he's not other people, blah blah.

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 12/10/2026 13:04

I am vaguely following, so is this another protracted tedious exercise in not taking any responsibility?
Becaue it seems to me to be a feature rather than a bug, I boggle at how these people get away with it all the time. I'd like to make them freelancers and then see how they manage.

StrongestWoman · 12/10/2026 13:02

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 12/10/2026 10:23

The testosterone-voice thing is very interesting if you understand where men’s low voices - in fact, where everyone’s voice pitch - comes from.

Basically, your pitch is dependent on two things - the size of your vocal folds (sometimes called vocal chords) and the length of the resonant cavity - that is, your vocal tract, which is basically the “tube” that runs from your lungs to your lips, and in which the sound vibrations produced by your vocal folds resonate. Big vocal folds + longer vocal tract = lower voice, smaller vocal folds + shorter vocal tract = higher voice.

In male puberty, testosterone tells the vocal folds to grow, while simultaneously telling the rest of the body to also go through a growth spurt - so you get bigger vocal folds and longer overall vocal tract.

When women take exogenous testosterone, it can tell the vocal folds to grow, but it can’t tell the rest of the body to also grow (I don’t know the biomechanics of that - I’m assuming there are other hormones and systems at play). This means that trans-identifying women end up with big vocal folds and an inappropriately short vocal tract, which gives the typical TIM “kazoo” voice.

I was interested to hear that “Sam” sang in a choir. Many detrans women have commented that because of the mismatch between their vocal folds size and their vocal tract size, they ended up developing all sorts of vocal fold issues, like nodules and pain during speech and the like. And I remember at least one who lamented losing her singing voice - she simply couldn’t control the larger vocal folds to the fine degree she had before testosterone.

Wrt choirs though, many choral directors allocate singers to parts (soprano/alto/baritone, etc) simply on the basis of what the singer’s vocal range is, rather than strictly by sex. It does mean you often get female voices singing tenor, which changes the quality of the sound.

To add, a few years ago I was in a choir where a trans woman joined. He first tried sitting with the altos but it really does not work to have someone singing the alto one octave lower than what is written. After a test singing with the conductor he was reassigned to the bases.

I think about it sometimes because it is such a clear example of how one person being coddled and accomodated can destroy the harmony of the full choir.

(For avoidance of doubt, everyone was very welcoming of the transwoman, both altos and bases).

rebax · 12/10/2026 13:02

IS CE suggesting that the Head of People doesn't understand Protected Characteristics? Likely to be an interesting afternoon.

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 13:00

Lunch.

Yay!!!!!

Szygy · 12/10/2026 12:57

From TT:

MS that policy went through many iteratons...I would not have gone back on this, moving forwards not backwards.
SE para 46 of your WS. You say complaint not upheld? I have understood your WS because you were confident that they were fully protected, PCs?
MS Yes
CE in respect of sex disc? gender disc? Gender ID disc?
MS One of nine PCs

CE Doesn't the drafting of your WS indicate a continued misunderstanding of PCs under EqA? Need to revisit?
MS I stand by my statement.
CE Let's be clear ... Draft ix says complaint by SH, partic difficult complaint such as these? Alleg against Staff policies?
CE You deal with this at para 22 of your WS ... You were charged ... No evidence as to how the safeguarding policies updated post Durant.

MS [missed]
CE I am asking about safeguarding policies in para22
MS yes
CE a tranche of work re safeguarding policies,
MS I only know as part of cttee
CE AC could help us with this?
MS yes
Se I want to look at this para 23 of your WS you say first was Alleg against staff. If we go there, p5430.

CE we can go through minor changes, but summing up were any policies revised in response to Durant?
MS The latter I cannot answer. Head of safeguarding was responsible, AC will know, I cannot answer.
CE So your testimony is that AC can better assist tribunal
I think we find at p2000 CE In respect of policy managing allegations, log of amendments.
J Asks changes of policy plugging gap? Merger response rather than response to Durant?

CE [missed]

J Not following ...

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:51

Oh come on CE. I need a pee, I'm hungry, and the washing needs taking out the machine.

Hurry up!

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:50

On repeat.

Schitts Creek Yes GIF by CBC
Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:49

I would hate being stuck in a meeting with him if this is how he talks in real life.

nauticant · 12/10/2026 12:48

So he's saying "I'm still standing"?

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:47

Justabaker · 12/10/2026 12:46

'It wasn't intentional'

Can someone add that to the bingo card

He can't be as clueless as he's making out surely?

Szygy · 12/10/2026 12:47

From TT:

CE [missed]
MS In July 2024
CE re p1764. rec that CCG reviews why PC incorrectly stated
MS yes
CE in your WS you accept no ix took place
MS yes
CE Your decision to depart from that recommendation?
MS [missed]
CE Was it Mr Doyle's decision to jettison?

MS Quick answer no, not my decision
CE As CPO at time, your job to be aware of this reco and that the org had laboured under a misapprehension about a protected characteristic?
MS Durant did not uphold that part of Gx
CE Did you think it was important to understand why

MS no, it was noted as an issue and rectified. I didn't think needed to go back to 2017 iteration of policy, Rectified in 2021 and a lot of disc at away day was about moving forward.
CE Important to consider lessons learned?
MS I didn't make decision, I was not there and moving forward not looking backward.

(My comment: IT WASN'T ME! x 1,000,000)

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:46

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 12:46

A 'going forwards, not looking back mindset'. Yeah, let's just ignore our cockup and keep going.

At least he's standing by what he said!

😶😶😶😶

Justabaker · 12/10/2026 12:46

'It wasn't intentional'

Can someone add that to the bingo card

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 12:46

A 'going forwards, not looking back mindset'. Yeah, let's just ignore our cockup and keep going.

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:43

Moving forwards away day was all about moving forwards not going backwards.

I was moving forwards not backwards

michael jackson moonwalk GIF
Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:41

I'd rather watch paint dry right now.

Boiledbeetle · 12/10/2026 12:40

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 12:40

IT WASN'T ME!

Makes a change from I don't recall.

CriticalCondition · 12/10/2026 12:40

IT WASN'T ME!

Szygy · 12/10/2026 12:39

From TT:

MS Yes
CE And this was Nikky Cambridge?
MS yes
CE Re p4759 list of PCs again, and we see the last one does say sex, but with the qualifier of gender in brackets.

CE In re p1755 this is body of Durant, bottom box has concern of C re statement of PC of sex. Durant recognised, can we say she is concerned with the reference to gender in there?
MS Gx of Dr R not upheld. [Reads from Durant.]

J questions Durant statement re qualification of PC of sex wrt to gender and whether she is troubled by this?
CE So that is where we land with Durant ix. Mr Doyle's letter and his recommendations CCG should review misrepresentation of the PC of sex in its policies?

J This is MR Doyle's letter
CE yes and what CCB is going to do with recommendations, why policy did not reflect law and how it was adopted. There was going to be action to look at why CCGs had wrong policies.
MS And yes ICB will correct

CE p4793 please. This is policy that we have issued on the 7 March 2025?
MS yes correct
CE and in change record p4794, we can see no changes to this policy btw 11/2021 and 11/2024? Difficult to accept how policies reviewed in aftermath of Durant?
MS In new ICB policies reviewed, lots of work streams, merging three into one. So our determination to take through staff equ networks

J [Qs document]
MS/CE agree when it was updated qualifier sex [gender] removed

nauticant · 12/10/2026 12:38

As I understand it, this testimony relates to this:

Redvers submitted a grievance complaint against Amroliwala in Jan 2022. Samantha Durrant was appointed to investigate. The terms of reference for that investigation envisaged the process being all wrapped up by the end of March 2022. Redvers did not get a meeting with Durrant until 21 February, during which she alleged there was a political agenda behind Dr Hall’s complaint, that Amroliwala’s approach had caused people to step down and resign, and that his methods and conclusions were a case for constructive dismissal. She told Durrant Amroliwala had an agenda to “fit me up” from the start.

Durrant found in favour of Redvers on 14 counts, resulting in an apology from Power and Doyle, though she says various recommendations – including one for compensation – were ignored.

That NHS Sussex didn't want to act on implementing the recommendations and stalled/ignored where they could

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.