Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 13:24

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 08/10/2026 12:57

There are also the TRAs who shout that TWAW but accept that they should be excluded from female sports & rape centres so their rather incoherent position is that TWAW except when they are not.

The mistake, I think, is to start from a position that there are broadly two types of feminism- trans-exclusive and trans-inclusive. So called trans-exclusive feminism excludes no one on the basis of being trans, just on the basis of being men. There is no blanket trans exclusion.

That leaves us with trans-inclusive feminists. If they are including all transpeople, either they see transmen as women or they connect feminism with being female. If that is so then why include transwomen? Maybe they would argue that it is about being female and/or being a woman, which then raises the same old questions about where the commonality is and what differentiates transwomen from other male people.

As you say though, in practice the majority of so-called trans-inclusive feminists do accept that there will be times that transwomen will be treated differently. They are not fully trans-inclusive, which sounds a lot like ‘only a bit pregnant’.

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:24

Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 13:15

Mens health and the way the patriarchy effects men is nothing to do with feminism
Feminism is about the effects of the patriarchy and misogyny effects women and our rights.
If your feminism includes men and their issues then its not feminism

I’m sorry but you anre wrong. Misogyny and patriarchy plays a huge part in the detriment of men’s mental heath, toxic masculinity and the mental health conditions that exacerbate violence against women. If these aren’t addressed and highlighted by feminists (don’t need to be women), then there will be no reduction in harm to women.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:23

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:16

No, my biggest problem is that the trans debate is the biggest ‘problem’ for feminism and women . I have the same critique of many feminists on the other side

You think the biggest problem for feminism and women in society is the trans debate?

You could not be more out of touch with the lives of ordinary women if you tried.

Domestic violence.
Rape.
Unaffordable childcare.
Increasing maternity related death rates.
Medical misogyny.
Increasing use and availablity of extreme porn.

I could go on but the fight of men to be seen as women is not even in the top 10.

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 13:19

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 16:57

To identify patriarchy and its impact on these things.

Thats mens work women and feminism are not here to do the work of men

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 13:17

My visualisation of sex and gender is of a woman's body with a load of junk accreting onto her, covering her, hiding her, limiting her movements and weighing her down. The body is herself, simply a human of the sex she is, and the accretions are the gender expectations society layers on top of her body because she is female and these are the things society believes and expects of female people.

So the idea that because most of the (modern) expressions of sexism sit in the Gender zone rather than the directly biological, biology is no longer a factor in sexism or even in the definition of a woman, and that we can look only at that accretion and not acknowledge that it is something women experience because of their sex and how others react to it, is wild to me.

The idea that a woman, who was born into that accretion and has been limited by it her whole life, and a transwoman, who was born outside it and desperately wants to be allowed it, are somehow the same thing rather than direct opposites, is wild to me.

Ironically, as opposites we could work so well together, us throwing the accretions off and trans women picking them up an enjoying them. Us pushing, them pulling, facing different ways but working for the same thing.

It is forcing the idea that we are the same that fractures Feminism, because it tries to force two opposite visions of womanhood into one shape.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 13:16

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:12

TW are simply identifying with associations to social category that are group based so it doesn't apply to individuals.

Sounds very much like sexism.

The general idea of the Equality act is that discrimination is unlawful and only permissible in a limited circumstances.

That’s because this poster is a very sexist individual.

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:16

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:00

You are reading a very different thread from the one the OP, that's me by the way, started and has been reading.

The thread I'm reading has a robust exchange of views back and forth with snark and insult generally happening as a result of the snark and insult posted by the trans inclusive posters.

I had not been rude in any way to anyone before my intelligence was called into question. That's typical for these threads.

We have had disagreements about what constitutes feminism between the non trans-inclusive feminists on the thread with no personal insult whatsoever.

I've found the thread very interesting. I started it in good faith and most posts were made in similar good faith.

If you can't cope with this type of discussion then I'm afraid that your problem is with joining in forum discussions in general, on any topic, because the level of debate on this particular forum on all topics is far higher and more civilised than that of very many others.

To be honest it comes across that your biggest problem is simply that we won't agree with you that men can turn into women.

Edited

No, my biggest problem is that the trans debate is the biggest ‘problem’ for feminism and women . I have the same critique of many feminists on the other side

Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 13:15

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 16:30

Men's mental health is absolutely a feminist issue. Feminism is about identifying and calling out the patriarchy, and the patriarchy plays a huge role in causing mens mental health struggle , it's mostly feminists who even recognise the patriarchy as a thing in the first place.

I never said it was the issue or that it should overshadow the ones that directly affect women. But the comment I replied to said anything to do with men isn't feminism, and that's just not correct.

Mens health and the way the patriarchy effects men is nothing to do with feminism
Feminism is about the effects of the patriarchy and misogyny effects women and our rights.
If your feminism includes men and their issues then its not feminism

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 13:15

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:10

Do you know what unintentional means ?

The thing is, you didn’t read carefully enough to realise that it was posters’ names rather than social media platforms, so how could you have been being truthful in any way dismissing the “social media platforms” as echo chambers? Not constructive dialogue, is it?

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:12

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 00:07

Its been answered repeatedly. You don't want to listen to the answer. TW are simply identifying with associations to social category that are group based so it doesn't apply to individuals. They didn't make up the social associations to women, society did.

Edited

TW are simply identifying with associations to social category that are group based so it doesn't apply to individuals.

Sounds very much like sexism.

The general idea of the Equality act is that discrimination is unlawful and only permissible in a limited circumstances.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 08/10/2026 13:11

The "safe spaces" thing is still repeated by some posters on FWR though (not on this thread, I don't think)

That's why it's important to challenge it every time

NotAtMyAge · 08/10/2026 13:11

If you mean including trans-identifying males, of course not. Feminism centres female needs and concerns and is inclusive of all those born female. If men want a movement that centres the needs and concerns of those born male, they need to get busy organising it themselves. Women have other things to do.

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:10

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 12:58

Is it ‘far right’ to point out when someone is fibbing?

Do you know what unintentional means ?

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 13:09

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 13:04

Its why Starmer stated to talk about safe spaces rather than single sex spaces.

He was priming everyone to see some spaces as safe, and therefore under different rules. A refuge can literally have someone on the door, and its difficult to argue men should be included.

Whereas by not talking about toilets or changing rooms, the implication is that they are not important or are unmanageable.

So instead of talking about which men should be included and why, he talked about a subset of spaces.

Edited

This was a very dishonest framing and I’m glad it was nipped in the bud

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 13:04

Its why Starmer stated to talk about safe spaces rather than single sex spaces.

He was priming everyone to see some spaces as safe, and therefore under different rules. A refuge can literally have someone on the door, and its difficult to argue men should be included.

Whereas by not talking about toilets or changing rooms, the implication is that they are not important or are unmanageable.

So instead of talking about which men should be included and why, he talked about a subset of spaces.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:00

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 12:02

The point/observation I was making was that OP knew that opposing views would inevitably be met with snark, derision, insult, dismissing them as ‘word soup’ with no other engagement, intentional obtuse misrepresentation and mockery by a large number of frequent posters - which is evident throughout- coming from those who share OPs opinion, which makes the original post seem disingenuous in it’s pretence that it actually wanted to hear another viewpoint. Fine, I misused the word echo chamber (unintentionally), although some but it doesn’t change that pint .

My other points are not invalidated by this.There has been constant incorrect conflation between inclusion and prioritisation, as well as other misreadings an example: I said in one comment “I am not a ‘fully trans inclusive feminist’” and someone responded later saying ‘you said your not a feminist’ , that is not comprehending.

You are reading a very different thread from the one the OP, that's me by the way, started and has been reading.

The thread I'm reading has a robust exchange of views back and forth with snark and insult generally happening as a result of the snark and insult posted by the trans inclusive posters.

I had not been rude in any way to anyone before my intelligence was called into question. That's typical for these threads.

We have had disagreements about what constitutes feminism between the non trans-inclusive feminists on the thread with no personal insult whatsoever.

I've found the thread very interesting. I started it in good faith and most posts were made in similar good faith.

If you can't cope with this type of discussion then I'm afraid that your problem is with joining in forum discussions in general, on any topic, because the level of debate on this particular forum on all topics is far higher and more civilised than that of very many others.

To be honest it comes across that your biggest problem is simply that we won't agree with you that men can turn into women.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 12:58

That’s actually a good point I hadn’t quite thought through @Waitingfordoggo

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 12:58

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 12:24

Bravo.

What's is so disappointing is not only the absence of good faith but dumbed down reactionary narratives but I suppose that goes with the territory they are attempting to defend which is to exploit very legitimate grievances of natal women & distort them into far right oversimplifications of supremacy, illiberalism & dehumanisation.

One might easily drop this intellectual desert but that would be abdicating responsibility. There are so few serious discussion on line forums for everyday women its our duty to not to let the garden waste.

Edited

Is it ‘far right’ to point out when someone is fibbing?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 12:58

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 12:49

@FlirtsWithRhinos

”Unless”

No I was being totally genuine. People name change a lot on MN for different reasons. I just wanted to acknowledge I might be treating someone as a newbie who actually has a lot of prior knowledge.

If they aren't a newbie they can skip the background and start at the paragraph beginning "Frankly", the point still holds.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 08/10/2026 12:57

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 12:49

By ‘not fully trans inclusive’ do you mean you only include some transpeople, ie transmen, or do you mean you only include some men, ie transwomen, only some of the time? Because they are very different things.

There are also the TRAs who shout that TWAW but accept that they should be excluded from female sports & rape centres so their rather incoherent position is that TWAW except when they are not.

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 12:56

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 12:02

The point/observation I was making was that OP knew that opposing views would inevitably be met with snark, derision, insult, dismissing them as ‘word soup’ with no other engagement, intentional obtuse misrepresentation and mockery by a large number of frequent posters - which is evident throughout- coming from those who share OPs opinion, which makes the original post seem disingenuous in it’s pretence that it actually wanted to hear another viewpoint. Fine, I misused the word echo chamber (unintentionally), although some but it doesn’t change that pint .

My other points are not invalidated by this.There has been constant incorrect conflation between inclusion and prioritisation, as well as other misreadings an example: I said in one comment “I am not a ‘fully trans inclusive feminist’” and someone responded later saying ‘you said your not a feminist’ , that is not comprehending.

You seem to be arguing about the thread as a whole and how you feel about the original post, rather than responding to my point that your mistake wasn’t a problem but your lie was.

I can see why in a tired state you might have thought those were social media sites. But I can’t understand why you said that they are echo chambers. That wasn’t just you giving an opinion on some actual social media platforms, it was you telling a fib, and that’s why I won’t pay much attention to any of your other posts on the thread.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 12:55

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 12:45

He wouldn’t be if they had them. I think the point is moot at the moment as the shortlists are only used if the number of female MPs fall below a particular level.

Ah ok, good point. Labour has tons of female MPs. Not managed a female leader yet of course.

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 12:49

@FlirtsWithRhinos

”Unless”

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 12:49

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 12:02

The point/observation I was making was that OP knew that opposing views would inevitably be met with snark, derision, insult, dismissing them as ‘word soup’ with no other engagement, intentional obtuse misrepresentation and mockery by a large number of frequent posters - which is evident throughout- coming from those who share OPs opinion, which makes the original post seem disingenuous in it’s pretence that it actually wanted to hear another viewpoint. Fine, I misused the word echo chamber (unintentionally), although some but it doesn’t change that pint .

My other points are not invalidated by this.There has been constant incorrect conflation between inclusion and prioritisation, as well as other misreadings an example: I said in one comment “I am not a ‘fully trans inclusive feminist’” and someone responded later saying ‘you said your not a feminist’ , that is not comprehending.

By ‘not fully trans inclusive’ do you mean you only include some transpeople, ie transmen, or do you mean you only include some men, ie transwomen, only some of the time? Because they are very different things.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 12:48

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 12:02

The point/observation I was making was that OP knew that opposing views would inevitably be met with snark, derision, insult, dismissing them as ‘word soup’ with no other engagement, intentional obtuse misrepresentation and mockery by a large number of frequent posters - which is evident throughout- coming from those who share OPs opinion, which makes the original post seem disingenuous in it’s pretence that it actually wanted to hear another viewpoint. Fine, I misused the word echo chamber (unintentionally), although some but it doesn’t change that pint .

My other points are not invalidated by this.There has been constant incorrect conflation between inclusion and prioritisation, as well as other misreadings an example: I said in one comment “I am not a ‘fully trans inclusive feminist’” and someone responded later saying ‘you said your not a feminist’ , that is not comprehending.

With respect, unless you have name changed you are a very new poster who has spent almost no time yet on FWR.

I think before you start judging the use of terms like "word soup" you read some of the threads recently and going back years.

You will realise there is a small group of what are clearly the same few posters, each with a very distinctive and frankly often very rude or patronising style, who have been prolifically trying to drown out Gender Critical Feminist points and views with their own bad takes and sexist assertions about what it means to be a woman in this world. They don't engage other than to insult and misrepresent. Eventually one learns no to bother trying to discuss, but simply to highlight and demolish the false claims and incoherent demands.

Frankly being accused of "word soup" is like being dusted with rose petals compared to the barrage of insults and patronising women face on FWR.

I actually really appreciated your first few posts on this thread about the importance of Feminism in recognising the impact of patriarchy on men. I had that in mind when I posted about Feminist Analysis vs Feminism.

I was very disappointed to see you later go down the "it's just an echo chamber with no other perspectives allowed" route, and if I read your more recent posts revealing a "we might as well treat some men as women" position.

My view on this is supporting men expressing elements patriarchy devalues for being of, or associated with, women is Feminist and one in the eye for patriarchy right up until there's a suggestion these men actually are somehow women rather than men, or even just more like women than other men, at which point it instantly flips over into just basic Patriarchy again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread