Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 14:13

StandingDeskDisco · 08/10/2026 14:04

Feminism is about fighting to protect women (females).
If the causes of the harm to women have anything to do with toxic masculinity, misogyny, patriarchy, or mentally ill men, a feminist could campaign on all those issues in so far as they affect women, for the sake of women.
A feminist won't be campaigning about men's mental illness for the sake of the men.
The results may look similar on the outside, i.e. women campaigning to help mentally ill men (and keep them away from women), but the motivations are different.

Yes.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 14:12

Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 14:09

An anorexic feels like they are fat when they aren't. We don't give them diet and exercise plans we give them the psychiatric help they need.
When men say they feel like a woman they are just as wrong as the anorexic person and should get the help they need to stop the delusional thinking that has led to that feeling not helped to live the lie that they really are a woman

And we don't endorse the sexist idea that there is a wrong way to be a woman.

Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 14:09

totino · 07/10/2026 19:39

I mean. The difference between a loving marriage or a loveless marriage is a feeling, and I think everyone would agree it's a massive difference. Trans boys feel like impostors being girls. Trans girls feel like impostors being boys. Living a lie is more than "a feeling".

An anorexic feels like they are fat when they aren't. We don't give them diet and exercise plans we give them the psychiatric help they need.
When men say they feel like a woman they are just as wrong as the anorexic person and should get the help they need to stop the delusional thinking that has led to that feeling not helped to live the lie that they really are a woman

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 14:07

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:37

Can I refer you back to your complaint about insults?

I can read. You did not mention time. You mentioned only size. The term you used was "biggest" which would usually mean "most important" in that context. It seems now that's not what you meant and we were supposed to read something other than what you wrote.

Edited

I was responding to your assertion that ‘ your (my) biggest issue with this thread is _’ . I was countering this directly . Saying “no my biggest issue (in this thread- wasn’t necesary to restate this given I was directly responding to a comment ) is …’ . you misunderstood, that’s fine, but my ‘insult’ to you was an expression of frustration of people not comprehending things that are written and jumping to put words in that aren’t there, which has happened multiple times now .

I’ve also been told how snare and insult is perfectly fine on here

StandingDeskDisco · 08/10/2026 14:04

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:24

I’m sorry but you anre wrong. Misogyny and patriarchy plays a huge part in the detriment of men’s mental heath, toxic masculinity and the mental health conditions that exacerbate violence against women. If these aren’t addressed and highlighted by feminists (don’t need to be women), then there will be no reduction in harm to women.

Feminism is about fighting to protect women (females).
If the causes of the harm to women have anything to do with toxic masculinity, misogyny, patriarchy, or mentally ill men, a feminist could campaign on all those issues in so far as they affect women, for the sake of women.
A feminist won't be campaigning about men's mental illness for the sake of the men.
The results may look similar on the outside, i.e. women campaigning to help mentally ill men (and keep them away from women), but the motivations are different.

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 14:00

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:24

I’m sorry but you anre wrong. Misogyny and patriarchy plays a huge part in the detriment of men’s mental heath, toxic masculinity and the mental health conditions that exacerbate violence against women. If these aren’t addressed and highlighted by feminists (don’t need to be women), then there will be no reduction in harm to women.

Do that are you telling men to go about it?

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 14:00

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:16

No, my biggest problem is that the trans debate is the biggest ‘problem’ for feminism and women . I have the same critique of many feminists on the other side

Surely you are free to start whatever campaigns and threads and, well, anything you want but what business is it of yours what anyone else is concerned about?

In my opinion the issue is men and 'trans' ideology obscures so very many of them under the guise of 'inclusion. Not that other male behaviour is not relevant but it's all part of the melting pot of male control over females.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:56

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 13:46

Yes. I've made the point a few times. We get Genderists, whether through bad faith or simply lack of critical thought, complaining that we spend far more time on FWR complaining about trans women than [insert deeply sexist/misogynist thing].

To which I always reply that if people turned up to defend [deeply sexist/misogynist thing] as much as they defend the sexism of treating trans women as women, they would see one hell of a pushback to that as well.

As it is, very few people are claiming [deeply sexist/misogynist thing] is actually ok. The issue is usually that society is not doing anything like enough to stop it happening in practice. And that means the Feminism isn't happening in the realm of ideas where the fight is broadly won, but out there with practical supports and actions where the ideas aren't matching reality.

Genderism, however, is being fought in the realm of ideas. It is based in the idea that some men are really, or as good as, women, or at least different enough to other men that we might as well treat them like women. Without that idea, the whole thing just falls apart. And that battle is not won. Hence, that battle is more visible here.

Exactly. You're on fire today FWR

OP posts:
Derbee · 08/10/2026 13:56

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 22:56

@totino a pregnant trans man is still a man

I sincerely hope that at some point in the future we will be able to look back at a time when anyone was able to write or read such a comment with a straight face and laugh ourselves witless.

I had to read this twice 😂 Hilarious

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 13:51

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:35

It's high profile because it is contentious.

They may argue over the use of resources, but no political party is pro domestic violence or pro unaffordable childcare.

On the other hand a significant number of MPs want to remove the concept of sex discrimination from legislation.

It’s also high profile here because there are a limited amount of spaces to actually take through the issues.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 13:49

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 13:46

But as always, if someone has a personalised definition for words, sentences become essentially meaningless because the intention of the message is not going to necessarily be the message interpreted by the receiver.

It will continue to be this way while others misuse words by changing the meaning. Such as ‘woman’.

Remember some posters describe themselves as super feminine while their behaviour probably doesn’t fit that description in many people’s ideas of what super feminine would mean.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 13:46

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:35

It's high profile because it is contentious.

They may argue over the use of resources, but no political party is pro domestic violence or pro unaffordable childcare.

On the other hand a significant number of MPs want to remove the concept of sex discrimination from legislation.

Yes. I've made the point a few times. We get Genderists, whether through bad faith or simply lack of critical thought, complaining that we spend far more time on FWR complaining about trans women than [insert deeply sexist/misogynist thing].

To which I always reply that if people turned up to defend [deeply sexist/misogynist thing] as much as they defend the sexism of treating trans women as women, they would see one hell of a pushback to that as well.

As it is, very few people are claiming [deeply sexist/misogynist thing] is actually ok. The issue is usually that society is not doing anything like enough to stop it happening in practice. And that means the Feminism isn't happening in the realm of ideas where the fight is broadly won, but out there with practical supports and actions where the ideas aren't matching reality.

Genderism, however, is being fought in the realm of ideas. It is based in the idea that some men are really, or as good as, women, or at least different enough to other men that we might as well treat them like women. Without that idea, the whole thing just falls apart. And that battle is not won. Hence, that battle is more visible here.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 13:46

JanesLittleGirl · 08/10/2026 11:21

Wait what! Gender critical feminism serves to undermine egalitarianism. Please explain your understanding of 'gender critical feminism' that causes you to make that statement?

But as always, if someone has a personalised definition for words, sentences become essentially meaningless because the intention of the message is not going to necessarily be the message interpreted by the receiver.

It will continue to be this way while others misuse words by changing the meaning. Such as ‘woman’.

Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 13:46

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 18:49

Because they need feminism/ feminist ideology to recognise that their issues are intertwined with misogyny and caused by and large, patriarchy

Edited

Tough luck for men then as its not a womens job to do that work.
Men need to recognise toxic masculinity and how it harms them and fix it themselves as its men who created all of these issues.

Soontobe60 · 08/10/2026 13:40

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 21:59

Perhaps they could call it femininism instead.

Or femimenism

GreyskySexRealistsky · 08/10/2026 13:39

Aaagh, this thread!

Back in the mists of time, teachers used to say "if several people aren't understanding you, there's a common denominator. You."

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:37

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:32

Thank god someone can read in this instance

Can I refer you back to your complaint about insults?

I can read. You did not mention time. You mentioned only size. The term you used was "biggest" which would usually mean "most important" in that context. It seems now that's not what you meant and we were supposed to read something other than what you wrote.

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:35

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:16

No, my biggest problem is that the trans debate is the biggest ‘problem’ for feminism and women . I have the same critique of many feminists on the other side

It's high profile because it is contentious.

They may argue over the use of resources, but no political party is pro domestic violence or pro unaffordable childcare.

On the other hand a significant number of MPs want to remove the concept of sex discrimination from legislation.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:35

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 13:27

I think she agrees with you. She’s bemoaning that it takes up so much of feminists’ discussions.

It doesn't, though. She's only looking at the trans feminist discussions and of course they are going to focus on trans issues.

There are feminist discussions going on about feminist issues day in day out.

Also she didn't say anything about time, she called it the"biggest" problem.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:32

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 13:17

My visualisation of sex and gender is of a woman's body with a load of junk accreting onto her, covering her, hiding her, limiting her movements and weighing her down. The body is herself, simply a human of the sex she is, and the accretions are the gender expectations society layers on top of her body because she is female and these are the things society believes and expects of female people.

So the idea that because most of the (modern) expressions of sexism sit in the Gender zone rather than the directly biological, biology is no longer a factor in sexism or even in the definition of a woman, and that we can look only at that accretion and not acknowledge that it is something women experience because of their sex and how others react to it, is wild to me.

The idea that a woman, who was born into that accretion and has been limited by it her whole life, and a transwoman, who was born outside it and desperately wants to be allowed it, are somehow the same thing rather than direct opposites, is wild to me.

Ironically, as opposites we could work so well together, us throwing the accretions off and trans women picking them up an enjoying them. Us pushing, them pulling, facing different ways but working for the same thing.

It is forcing the idea that we are the same that fractures Feminism, because it tries to force two opposite visions of womanhood into one shape.

Right with you. Great post.

OP posts:
sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:32

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 13:27

I think she agrees with you. She’s bemoaning that it takes up so much of feminists’ discussions.

Thank god someone can read in this instance

Hoardasurass · 08/10/2026 13:29

sosomewhereelse · 07/10/2026 17:21

Please, read back my posts you have misread. I haven’t once said feminism needs to focus on men?
I responded to a post that made a blanket statement that things pertaining to men have nothing to do with feminism, which is incorrect. I do not think that should be the main feminist focus , especially for women feminists to address, but they can be acknowledged as issues for feminism and that not take away from it predominantly being a women’s rights movement.

not assuming men can’t do it by themselves . Im saying that they need feminism to do it. Feminism is a school of thought that recognises the patriarchy. The positive male organisations your citing are no doubt promoting ideas like it’s okay for men to show emotions/ cry etc which is only necessary because patriarchy has constructed otherwise. Needing feminism and needing women is not the same thing, there are male feminists.

Dismantling the patriarchy requires a wholistic approach, and yes , that includes men and boys too.

Men may want feminist women to do the work for them but they don't need them and feminist have enough to do trying to sort out women's rights without adding mens issues.
Feminism is by women for women not men nor should any of our time be spent on mens rights or issues

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 13:27

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 13:23

You think the biggest problem for feminism and women in society is the trans debate?

You could not be more out of touch with the lives of ordinary women if you tried.

Domestic violence.
Rape.
Unaffordable childcare.
Increasing maternity related death rates.
Medical misogyny.
Increasing use and availablity of extreme porn.

I could go on but the fight of men to be seen as women is not even in the top 10.

Edited

I think she agrees with you. She’s bemoaning that it takes up so much of feminists’ discussions.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:27

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 13:24

The mistake, I think, is to start from a position that there are broadly two types of feminism- trans-exclusive and trans-inclusive. So called trans-exclusive feminism excludes no one on the basis of being trans, just on the basis of being men. There is no blanket trans exclusion.

That leaves us with trans-inclusive feminists. If they are including all transpeople, either they see transmen as women or they connect feminism with being female. If that is so then why include transwomen? Maybe they would argue that it is about being female and/or being a woman, which then raises the same old questions about where the commonality is and what differentiates transwomen from other male people.

As you say though, in practice the majority of so-called trans-inclusive feminists do accept that there will be times that transwomen will be treated differently. They are not fully trans-inclusive, which sounds a lot like ‘only a bit pregnant’.

Agree.

I think the question is more whether you include women in your trans inclusive feminism or men.

If somebody includes men, you have to ask whether they really understand what feminism is.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 13:24

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:17

That's not how rights balancing works. Women don't 'own spaces' disadvantage does & discomfort doesn't qualify as one.

I'm not sure what you mean here, but a service can be single sex just because it would be reasonable to object to the presence of somebody of the opposite sex. Discomfort is very much taken into account.

Changing rooms are increasingly mixed sex, which I suspect is driven more by the need to supervise opposite children than anything else. However toilet provision is generally single sex or unisex (i.e. enclosed from floor to ceiling including wash basin).

What are you arguing for? Mixed sex toilets?

Swipe left for the next trending thread