Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
xye · 08/10/2026 17:05

@totino “Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body,”

What is this ‘sense’ of being in a female body?
I know my body is female as I was born a girl, went through female puberty, pregnancy, childbirth and breastfeeding, all of which are unique to females.

totino · 08/10/2026 17:02

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 16:55

How do people know they are “cis”? What is a gender identity? How does e, without using sexist outdated stereotypes, know what a woman or a man is if it’s not biology?

Because when people refer to me as she, a woman, a lady, a daughter, a wife etc., I recognize myself in it and yes, that's some of the things I am. I perceive my female body and even though I of course can be at odds with my body, feel awkward, uncomfortable, depending on the situation, I like it - it's mine. Trans people do not feel that.

murasaki · 08/10/2026 17:00

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Edited

We live it every day. They do not. They have no idea hence their guff about periods etc. They may want to, they may dislike the bodies they have, but they do not experience at all, and even with plastic surgery they never will. And you know that.

It sounds a bit like whichever silly woman it was who had a nose job because she didn't want her baby to have a big nose.

spannasaurus · 08/10/2026 16:59

Being female is a universal woman experience. Perhaps the only universal experience.

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

murasaki · 08/10/2026 16:49

Oh come on, being pregnant is only something that happens to women. Fenale women, whatever they choose to identify as. And there is a universal female experience, being born female. And the equivalent for men.

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 16:55

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

How do people know they are “cis”? What is a gender identity? How does e, without using sexist outdated stereotypes, know what a woman or a man is if it’s not biology?

murasaki · 08/10/2026 16:52

And pregnancy is a universal women's issue, whether it's trying not to be pregnant, wanting to be pregnant, being pregnant, having been pregnant, or not being pregnant and wondering why and finding out. Find me a woman who hasn't experienced one of those.

totino · 08/10/2026 16:50

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 16:45

Surely the number of pages depends on your settings? How would I know what your settings or indeed your reasonings are?

For me this is page 8.

I didn't know that about the threading, makes sense though. Around 16:03 yesterday and then from 19:30 on, then. Again I'm not expecting anyone to read them, but to your point.

murasaki · 08/10/2026 16:49

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

Oh come on, being pregnant is only something that happens to women. Fenale women, whatever they choose to identify as. And there is a universal female experience, being born female. And the equivalent for men.

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 22:56

@totino a pregnant trans man is still a man

I sincerely hope that at some point in the future we will be able to look back at a time when anyone was able to write or read such a comment with a straight face and laugh ourselves witless.

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 16:45

totino · 08/10/2026 16:36

I laid out what my reasoning is in my replies, probably around page 12 to 15 or something. Not that you have read it, or like it, but we do explain ourselves on here. You don't like the arguments but it's the same vice versa

Surely the number of pages depends on your settings? How would I know what your settings or indeed your reasonings are?

For me this is page 8.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 16:42

totino · 08/10/2026 16:36

I laid out what my reasoning is in my replies, probably around page 12 to 15 or something. Not that you have read it, or like it, but we do explain ourselves on here. You don't like the arguments but it's the same vice versa

IIRC you posited that some people might genuinely feel their body is that of one sex despite in reality being the other.

You have not, I think, explained why this makes them more like or more interchangeable with people whose bodies are the opposite sex to theirs than people who are the same sex as them.

Basically, you haven't explained the leap from feels like to is.

That's a pretty massive leap IMO.

It's like saying the mere existence of religious belief is proof that God exists, and furthmore that means we all have to live just like God says we should whether we personally believe in Him/Her or not.

totino · 08/10/2026 16:36

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 16:25

It really would be good if just once, one of them 'men can totally be women' types explained their thinking and reasoning.

Instead of just calling us thick. If they fail to explain thats on them.

I laid out what my reasoning is in my replies, probably around page 12 to 15 or something. Not that you have read it, or like it, but we do explain ourselves on here. You don't like the arguments but it's the same vice versa

murasaki · 08/10/2026 16:29

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 16:25

It really would be good if just once, one of them 'men can totally be women' types explained their thinking and reasoning.

Instead of just calling us thick. If they fail to explain thats on them.

I think this one thinks they have by saying they are sociological women.

Which is utter tripe, of course.

No such thing.

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 16:26

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 15:17

Of course.

Are you saying that you giving your opinion was unintentional? You didn’t mean to write that sentence at all?

I’m saying that my misuse (which I’ve held my hands up to) of the phrase echo chamber was unintentional. I had only understood it as a platform in which an opinion is predominantly echoed back, which I can evidence that this is what I thought when I stated so in another comment. I didn’t know that it in order for it to be called an echo chamber it had to be the only opinion and others not allowed at all.
feel free to call me ignorant/misinformed/stupid for this, but a liar/ fibber I am not.

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 16:25

It really would be good if just once, one of them 'men can totally be women' types explained their thinking and reasoning.

Instead of just calling us thick. If they fail to explain thats on them.

MintyBadgerPrincessCheese · 08/10/2026 16:25

You can no more have trans-inclusive feminism (whereby you INCLUDE trans-identified men and EXCLUDE trans-identified women) than you can have meat-inclusive veganism, sex-inclusive virginity, life-inclusive death, God-inclusive atheism or hot-inclusive cold.

It's an oxymoron.

And I don't care about being snarky. It is a risible stance to take (some men are women if they say so, or some men are women some of the time), and SHOULD be laughed at.

It should be taken as seriously as flat earthers or the people who believe they've been anally probed by aliens. It's absurd. It is not a belief worthy of respect in a democratic society.

The emperor IS naked.

I don't hate trans-identified people - in fact, I wish them all health and happiness. I just do not accept that some people are the opposite sex because they 'feel' it.

Screamingabdabz · 08/10/2026 16:11

If men could really be women then the opposite is true.

Women and girls could thankfully ‘identify’ out of FGM, gynae problems and cancers, rape as a weapon of war, feeling unsafe in isolated areas or walking at night, lower pay, poorly researched medical and safety issues relating to the female body, religious or cultural restrictions, female sports categories etc.

But no. Because everyone knows you can’t change sex.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 16:05

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 15:48

I dont know if they want the gender because its signals woman to them, therefore they need us to embrace it too.

Or the like the gender and its irrelevant if we want it or not?

I suppose the trans umbrella includes both.

Edited

The official version? They just want it because it's who they are. The fact it happens to be "woman" stuff is not why they want it, but given they do want it it can be assumed that "who they are" must be a woman.

The truth? They want it because it's "woman's" stuff. They like the idea of being (or being treated as if they are) a "woman" and especially having access to those mysterious places only women are allowed to go, and therefore anything associated with "women" becomes desirable.

With the caveat I do think some of the younger ASD cohort of trans identifying male people fit somewhat into the first model, "I like girl stuff (or I don't like enough boy stuff) so I must really be a girl (or I can't really be a boy so I must really be a girl)". But still a learned/concluded thought pattern rather than a natural expression of some innate woman/girl identity in a male body.

Heggettypeg · 08/10/2026 16:00

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 13:17

My visualisation of sex and gender is of a woman's body with a load of junk accreting onto her, covering her, hiding her, limiting her movements and weighing her down. The body is herself, simply a human of the sex she is, and the accretions are the gender expectations society layers on top of her body because she is female and these are the things society believes and expects of female people.

So the idea that because most of the (modern) expressions of sexism sit in the Gender zone rather than the directly biological, biology is no longer a factor in sexism or even in the definition of a woman, and that we can look only at that accretion and not acknowledge that it is something women experience because of their sex and how others react to it, is wild to me.

The idea that a woman, who was born into that accretion and has been limited by it her whole life, and a transwoman, who was born outside it and desperately wants to be allowed it, are somehow the same thing rather than direct opposites, is wild to me.

Ironically, as opposites we could work so well together, us throwing the accretions off and trans women picking them up an enjoying them. Us pushing, them pulling, facing different ways but working for the same thing.

It is forcing the idea that we are the same that fractures Feminism, because it tries to force two opposite visions of womanhood into one shape.

The logic seems to be:

" Diamonds are expected to sparkle, and many of them do. So sparkle means diamond."

The trouble is, what is mere wishful-thinking in front of a mirror is fraud in a jeweller's shop.

Pingponghavoc · 08/10/2026 15:48

I dont know if they want the gender because its signals woman to them, therefore they need us to embrace it too.

Or the like the gender and its irrelevant if we want it or not?

I suppose the trans umbrella includes both.

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 15:17

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 13:10

Do you know what unintentional means ?

Of course.

Are you saying that you giving your opinion was unintentional? You didn’t mean to write that sentence at all?

Datun · 08/10/2026 15:17

One of the most lightbulb moments for me was when someone said women are oppressed because of their biology and gender is the way it's done.

It made such perfect sense.

Gender ideology relies on gender to dictate who is male and female. It advocates for it, it cements it in, and it demands you use it.

Not only is it not feminist, it is the means by which sexism is used to oppress women.

Chopping confirms it himself by saying *TW are simply identifying with associations to social category that are group based *

So no, there is no such thing as trans inclusive feminism. The very concept of transgenderism opposes feminism.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 14:38

Anyway, to get back to the OP, feminism includes all women regardless of their religion, age, race, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, and whether they are pregnant or married.

It includes Ivanka Trump and Samantha Niblett and the woman behind the appallingly anti semitic Green Party motion and the woman who failed to be executed in Tennessee. It includes women who have any possible view on abortion and women who believe that God made them subservient to men and women who want to be named as the father on their child's birth certificate. The only relevant question is whether they are female.

It just cannot include men, because then it is meaningless.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 14:15

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 14:07

I was responding to your assertion that ‘ your (my) biggest issue with this thread is _’ . I was countering this directly . Saying “no my biggest issue (in this thread- wasn’t necesary to restate this given I was directly responding to a comment ) is …’ . you misunderstood, that’s fine, but my ‘insult’ to you was an expression of frustration of people not comprehending things that are written and jumping to put words in that aren’t there, which has happened multiple times now .

I’ve also been told how snare and insult is perfectly fine on here

You haven't been told insult is fine by me, and when did it become morally acceptable to do something you have criticised other people for because you think someone else told you it was OK?

As for the rest, I refer you to @GreyskySexRealistsky post

Back in the mists of time, teachers used to say "if several people aren't understanding you, there's a common denominator. You."

OP posts: