Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 17:50

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Edited

No, you’ve got that wrong. It’s not sex realists who say that ‘being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body’.

We say that being female is a matter of biology; nothing to do with ‘sense’ (or feelings or essences or souls).

xye · 08/10/2026 17:48

Every man is born from a woman. No woman is born from a man.

Datun · 08/10/2026 17:44

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue.

You're talking about life here. You won't find many people disagreeing that women have all sorts of different experiences depending on context.

But a universal experience for a woman is, for example, not having a penis. So there's one, right there. Or wondering if she should get a prostate exam.

Likewise, no man on the planet will wonder whether or not he might be pregnant, or why can't he get pregnant, or terrified that he might be pregnant, or miserable that he's not yet. Women deal with their biology all day long. Have I got enough painkillers for my period, why hasn't my period started, will my period start during the party. All universal female experiences, all based on biology.

if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong.

The definition of woman isn't a man who doesn't want to be a man because he doesn't like his male body. How can you not see how sexist this is?

Women are real you know. We are real human beings with our own characteristics, bodies, issues.

It never ceases to amaze me how some people genuinely seem incapable of dragging their focus off the men. They can't seem to actually look at women for more than a nanosecond.

A man who doesn't want to be a man is still a man. It's not the definition of a woman!

And him thinking it is turns every woman into a resource for him. The entire concept of womanhood in fact. Women are not beings in their own right, they're a solution to his problem.

This bloody ideology is so sexist, it's difficult to believe. And it's baffling there's so many people who can't see it. I genuinely think it's their own internal sexism doing a fucking number on them.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:44

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man.

It's not a question of getting them to be anything. Changing sex is not possible. It would seem more helpful to encourage people to accept themselves as they are rather than to promote the idea that they can only be accepted if others pretend to believe something that is impossible. The second seems downright cruel and inhumane.

I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation.

How do you define what is a lie? What trans means? Who are you to say that somebody else has the wrong definition of trans?

But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists.

Under UK law, not without an available penis.

totino · 08/10/2026 17:44

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:30

You are here excluding all the people who identify as trans but don't describe themselves as feeling dysphoric.

Probably because most trans people I ever talked to had dysphoria. I presume it's possible to perceive the incongruence without being distressed by it. But they still perceive it.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 17:41

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

Well of course they belong in these categories. They are SEX categories.

Sex is the clear designator in science, in law and in every single society since time began.

Why on earth should I, as a woman, countenance replacing that for ‘gender’ which no one can even give me a definition for?

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 17:39

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

The topic is men in female jails not prison officers or women. Who cannot rape due to not having penises...but anyway.

You said 'trans women were never men', so how can you tell when it comes to rapists? Which ones would you not put in a female prison?

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 17:38

murasaki · 08/10/2026 17:22

Its pagination identification is in the eye of the beholder, not itself. Remind you of anything?

My left eyebrow did raise when I was typing that.

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 17:17

I read your first one and said 'come again'.

Your reasoning just seems to be 'fuck it, anyone can be anything and nobody should care'.

I cannot work out why you would think a man for example who discovers he is a woman as soon as he is arrested for rape, should be put into the female prison. Can you just try explaining for those of us with teeny tiny brains? Why would you not just think 'hang on a minute, this doesn't seem legit'?

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:30

totino · 08/10/2026 17:02

Because when people refer to me as she, a woman, a lady, a daughter, a wife etc., I recognize myself in it and yes, that's some of the things I am. I perceive my female body and even though I of course can be at odds with my body, feel awkward, uncomfortable, depending on the situation, I like it - it's mine. Trans people do not feel that.

You are here excluding all the people who identify as trans but don't describe themselves as feeling dysphoric.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 17:30

But I reaslise the groundhog day roundabout is spinning up again and about to whip me around once more. I think I'll jump off this time, though I may post links to previous go-rounds as my arguments haven't changed, and IMO have not to date been effectively countered.

@Imdunfer whatever happens in the rest of it, this was a great thread through the first 25 pages or so, and if there are comments to make on the original question I will jump back in for that.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 17:28

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience",

We agree 100% on that.

Which is why the only way to define who is male and who is female, as opposed to who anyone (including the person themselves) thinks is male and thinks is female, is by reference to genetics.

If you don't believe this to be true, please describe what makes a woman without any reference to any gender stereotypes or any physical attributes which can be found in the normal distribution overlap between males and females.

OP posts:
murasaki · 08/10/2026 17:22

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 08/10/2026 17:19

For me this is page 8.

For me too but it could be page 16 or page 1.

Its pagination identification is in the eye of the beholder, not itself. Remind you of anything?

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 08/10/2026 17:19

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 16:45

Surely the number of pages depends on your settings? How would I know what your settings or indeed your reasonings are?

For me this is page 8.

For me this is page 8.

For me too but it could be page 16 or page 1.

murasaki · 08/10/2026 17:18

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 17:17

I read your first one and said 'come again'.

Your reasoning just seems to be 'fuck it, anyone can be anything and nobody should care'.

I cannot work out why you would think a man for example who discovers he is a woman as soon as he is arrested for rape, should be put into the female prison. Can you just try explaining for those of us with teeny tiny brains? Why would you not just think 'hang on a minute, this doesn't seem legit'?

Ah yes, rapid onset prison dysphoria.

Shedmistress · 08/10/2026 17:17

totino · 08/10/2026 16:50

I didn't know that about the threading, makes sense though. Around 16:03 yesterday and then from 19:30 on, then. Again I'm not expecting anyone to read them, but to your point.

I read your first one and said 'come again'.

Your reasoning just seems to be 'fuck it, anyone can be anything and nobody should care'.

I cannot work out why you would think a man for example who discovers he is a woman as soon as he is arrested for rape, should be put into the female prison. Can you just try explaining for those of us with teeny tiny brains? Why would you not just think 'hang on a minute, this doesn't seem legit'?

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 17:17

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

I get that you personally don't see the issue in insisting that a pregnant woman can be a man.

Most of the world, however would think your belief was the height of lunacy, since there is no more definitive proof of being female than to have a body which is developing a new human life.

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:16

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 17:08

The tragic irony is that if you just keep "man" and "woman" as simple sex labels, misgendering is not a possibility.

It is only when you decide "man" and "woman" are personality labels that you create the risk of "misgendering".

Do you see? It is trans people's idea that "man" or "woman" can be something other than the body in the first place that creates the problems they complain about.

Put bluntly, it's only their own sexist projections about how other people feel that makes them feel they are not the right sex for their sex. They literally invent the problem for themselves by insisting sex mean more than it actually does.

Female people exist. Being pregnant is something only available to female people. While not all female people can or will become pregnant, nevertheless you can broadly define female people as people who one cannot say for certain will never be pregnant based on a simple visual check at birth. And everything else, the gender, the social differences - those all follow from that.

It makes no sense at all to say we need a label, and separate spaces, and protected rights, for people who feel a certain undefined way that not only can we not agree on but we cant even agree everyone feels it, but we don't need a label for the half of humanity that is physically female.

If we actually somehow really didn't have the word "woman" meaning adult human female, if we were really in a world where the word had never existed, we'd have invented it pretty damn quickly!

It's only because we are in a world where the word does exist, where we do all understand it but are supposed to pretend we think it means something else (while having the original meaning hanging around in the background to underpin that new defintion) that Generists have the luxury of pretending they don't think we need to recognise the two sexes in law, language or society.

It makes no sense at all to say we need a label, and separate spaces, and protected rights, for people who feel a certain undefined way that not only can we not agree on but we cant even agree everyone feels it

Unless you are writing a dystopian YA novel.

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 17:15

sosomewhereelse · 08/10/2026 16:26

I’m saying that my misuse (which I’ve held my hands up to) of the phrase echo chamber was unintentional. I had only understood it as a platform in which an opinion is predominantly echoed back, which I can evidence that this is what I thought when I stated so in another comment. I didn’t know that it in order for it to be called an echo chamber it had to be the only opinion and others not allowed at all.
feel free to call me ignorant/misinformed/stupid for this, but a liar/ fibber I am not.

Sorry this still doesn’t make sense. I’m not disagreeing with your definition of echo chamber at all.

I’m saying that to declare a platform ‘an echo chamber’, one would have to go and look at what is said on the platform in order to make that judgement.

You can’t possibly have spent any time on those ‘platforms’ that you declared to be echo chambers. (Because they don’t exist).

Your confusion over this point is baffling to me.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:14

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant.

Women?

And do women who 'can't get pregnant' somehow escape the impact of their society's attitude towards contraception and abortion and pronatalist policies? Do you think employers know they 'can't get pregnant' and consider them to be more reliable? If they have years of fertility treatment, is it not a very different procedure to that undergone by men?

Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues

I'd argue that using Stonewall definitions most people are trans. I think it's quite unusual to really define one's identity in terms of masculinity and femininity. I'll give you Pete Hegseth.

But do you really think that identifying as something other than 'cis' means that women don't need sex specific rights?

Why would you be resistant to recognising that women need sex specific rights?

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 17:11

totino · 08/10/2026 17:02

Because when people refer to me as she, a woman, a lady, a daughter, a wife etc., I recognize myself in it and yes, that's some of the things I am. I perceive my female body and even though I of course can be at odds with my body, feel awkward, uncomfortable, depending on the situation, I like it - it's mine. Trans people do not feel that.

Well then they need therapy to cope with that don’t they?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 17:11

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Edited

Red/green colourblind people absolutely truthfully and genuinely canot differentiate between red and green. Their truth, their reality, is that those separate colours do not exist.

Nevertheless, those separate colours do exist. And we haven't agreed to pretend they don't to relieve distress and confusion in the colourblind. We haven't got rid of the word Green and called it TransRed instead.

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 17:10

totino · 08/10/2026 16:56

Is this an experience? If we don't remember it, does it shape us in any way? Because if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong. This is also why people who are cis (like me as well) don't necessarily perceive "gender", because you never get challenged, so you just get to be you. Which is the thing everyone wants.

Edited

No, being female means being IN a female body. A male can never know what it is like to be female and vice versa.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 17:08

totino · 08/10/2026 16:46

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue. Pregnancy protection and support should be for everyone who is pregnant, and reproductive freedom is for everyone who can get pregnant. Since most people are cis, it's not incorrect to say that these are primarily women's issues. But they are not universally women's issues.

Edited

The tragic irony is that if you just keep "man" and "woman" as simple sex labels, misgendering is not a possibility.

It is only when you decide "man" and "woman" are personality labels that you create the risk of "misgendering".

Do you see? It is trans people's idea that "man" or "woman" can be something other than the body in the first place that creates the problems they complain about.

Put bluntly, it's only their own sexist projections about how other people feel that makes them feel they are not the right sex for their sex. They literally invent the problem for themselves by insisting sex mean more than it actually does.

Female people exist. Being pregnant is something only available to female people. While not all female people can or will become pregnant, nevertheless you can broadly define female people as people who one cannot say for certain will never be pregnant based on a simple visual check at birth. And everything else, the gender, the social differences - those all follow from that.

It makes no sense at all to say we need a label, and separate spaces, and protected rights, for people who feel a certain undefined way that not only can we not agree on but we cant even agree everyone feels it, but we don't need a label for the half of humanity that is physically female.

If we actually somehow really didn't have the word "woman" meaning adult human female, if we were really in a world where the word had never existed, we'd have invented it pretty damn quickly!

It's only because we are in a world where the word does exist, where we do all understand it but are supposed to pretend we think it means something else (while having the original meaning hanging around in the background to underpin that new defintion) that Generists have the luxury of pretending they don't think we need to recognise the two sexes in law, language or society.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 17:06

totino · 08/10/2026 17:02

Because when people refer to me as she, a woman, a lady, a daughter, a wife etc., I recognize myself in it and yes, that's some of the things I am. I perceive my female body and even though I of course can be at odds with my body, feel awkward, uncomfortable, depending on the situation, I like it - it's mine. Trans people do not feel that.

These are factual words that reference someone’s sex. There is nothing offensive about them at all.

If people have an issue with being referred to as their sex, then they need to get therapy to cope with that. It’s not up to the rest of us to overturn society norms to accommodate their inability to deal with reality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread