Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:16

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

Cis is a meaningless term because the term includes any male person who has a DSD yet has a body that is **formed around the production of small gametes that has any degree of sensitivity to any of the testosterone that body produces.
Using this word, cis, then means there is no word left for female people.

Because even male people are now saying they are also ‘female’ . When ^^ female means only a person of the sex category where that person's body has been formed around the production of large gametes, regardless of whether the body does, has or ever will produce those large gametes. ie that requires the presence of ovaries or ovarian tissue - never testes. This has also recently been the basis of the new IOC policy too,

(from the IOC policy:

This is under the definitions section:
Sex: Either of the two categories, Male or Female, into which humans are divided according to their reproductive biology.

Biological Female (Female): An individual who, regardless of their legal sex or gender identity, experienced female sex development usually based on their XX-chromosomes, ovaries, and estrogenic hormones.

https://stillmed.olympics.com/media/Documents/International-Olympic-Committee/EB/policy/policy-on-the-protection-of-the-female-category-english.pdf )

In fact, we now have examples of many male people declaring that they are female people. So even the word for female has become meaningless in that sense.

But 'cis' is a* *word that was repurposed from its original usage and is meaningless for the purpose of discussing female people in its current usage. It has been used in academic papers as well in an attempt at using inclusive language which then renders the papers meaningless because the term is not describing a unique grouping of human bodies, even when it claims to be doing just that.

To see how this works, we have been told that 'girl' and 'woman' both now include:
1 Male person who has been incorrectly registered as a female at birth, but has a male body **.
2 Any male person has now claimed a transgender identity using those labels.
3 And any person who has a female body ^^.

Under the label of 'girl' and 'woman', extreme transgender activists have been telling us for years that those labels break down into two types of girls or women:

Cis and Transwomen/transgirls.

These terms mean:
Cis
= (1) Male person who has been incorrectly registered as a female at birth, but has a male body **
and
= (3) Any person who has a female body^^

Trans
= (2) Any male person has now claimed a transgender identity using those labels.
Therefore there is no unique word to mean female people who have a body ^^ formed around the production of large gametes.

Cis is meaningless as a unique description for female people and it always was. It is also misogynistic because it leaves female people with no unique word for their needs.

And that is not even covering the discussion about forcibly categorising someone to believe in gender identity when they don’t, which is what the use of ‘cis’ forces.

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?
xye · 08/10/2026 18:15

@totino “Women can be dicks (as well as have them, occasionally”

In what universe do some women have a penis? Bruce Jenner fathered his children. He didn’t carry and give birth to them.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:14

totino · 08/10/2026 18:11

The Suzie Izzard thing is amusing because yeah she used to talk about "girl mode" and "boy mode", but a couple of years later and she's just Suzie now. Personal journeys are messy.

Though I did know a nonbinary person who did have "boy mode" and "girl mode" days. It's not for me but the way they explained it made sense to me.

EDIT: I don't know Frank Maloney but yeah, Caitlyn Jenner was also always a woman. Women can be dicks (as well as have them, occasionally).

Edited

He won a medal in an event that wasn’t open to women at the time - do you think he should give it back?

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 18:13

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

How can you tell?

How do you propose this is judged? Who does it and under what criteria?

And what do you say to the women who suffer when it goes wrong?

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 18:13

https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/there-no-legal-bars-woman-10297113

Alex's understanding of 'trans' seems a bit different to yours, @totino

Is Alex wrong? lying?

Now she is “blurring the lines” of gender to create safe spaces for people who might have never realised they could break out of standard gender binaries

I definitely want to break out of standard gender binaries, and I reckon a lot of other women do. ('Feminists', you might call them.)

This trans woman wants to broaden how people think about gender

Alex Drummond hopes her visibility in her home city of Cardiff will help broaden people's minds around what men and women are 'supposed' to be

https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/there-no-legal-bars-woman-10297113

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:12

"It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison."

This is also at best mixing fallacy with misinformation, at worst is more misinformation.

There are male people with transgender identities who have committed rape in prisons when they have been housed with female people in the USA , I believe. There are certainly male inmates with transgender identities that have been sexually abusive towards female inmates in other countries across the world too.

It is not to be dismissed as 'it's known that it's the male staff'. Yes, male staff do attack and abuse female inmates. But it would be incorrect and misleading to claim that it was only male staff and to declare that no male inmate with a transgender identity is a risk of harming female inmates.

And female people can sexually abuse other female people. This is known. Including it in that paragraph is just more distraction like the ''it's known that it's the male staff' was there for distraction.

The issue is, why are female inmates put at added risk of harm by including any male inmate in their prison estate?

Yes, they are already at risk from male staff and other female inmates. But why do they have to have this added risk?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:12

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

“Cis” is a meaningless in group jargon word for your fringe ideology. There is only one sex of woman. You can disagree obviously, just like you can think the Earth is flat and you’ll fall off the end.

totino · 08/10/2026 18:11

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 18:06

Is Eddie Izzard a man or a woman? Is that what they have always been. Were Frank Maloney and Bruce Jenner never men (and by extension never boys)?

The Suzie Izzard thing is amusing because yeah she used to talk about "girl mode" and "boy mode", but a couple of years later and she's just Suzie now. Personal journeys are messy.

Though I did know a nonbinary person who did have "boy mode" and "girl mode" days. It's not for me but the way they explained it made sense to me.

EDIT: I don't know Frank Maloney but yeah, Caitlyn Jenner was also always a woman. Women can be dicks (as well as have them, occasionally).

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 18:07

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

How would one know if one were 'cis' or 'trans'? When would it be relevant?

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 18:06

totino · 08/10/2026 17:44

Probably because most trans people I ever talked to had dysphoria. I presume it's possible to perceive the incongruence without being distressed by it. But they still perceive it.

Is Eddie Izzard a man or a woman? Is that what they have always been. Were Frank Maloney and Bruce Jenner never men (and by extension never boys)?

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Datun · 08/10/2026 17:44

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience", I don't see the issue.

You're talking about life here. You won't find many people disagreeing that women have all sorts of different experiences depending on context.

But a universal experience for a woman is, for example, not having a penis. So there's one, right there. Or wondering if she should get a prostate exam.

Likewise, no man on the planet will wonder whether or not he might be pregnant, or why can't he get pregnant, or terrified that he might be pregnant, or miserable that he's not yet. Women deal with their biology all day long. Have I got enough painkillers for my period, why hasn't my period started, will my period start during the party. All universal female experiences, all based on biology.

if you say being female means nothing else but the sense of being in a female body, then some trans woman experience a form of that, in a very disorienting way, which is why they're dysphoric since the body is wrong.

The definition of woman isn't a man who doesn't want to be a man because he doesn't like his male body. How can you not see how sexist this is?

Women are real you know. We are real human beings with our own characteristics, bodies, issues.

It never ceases to amaze me how some people genuinely seem incapable of dragging their focus off the men. They can't seem to actually look at women for more than a nanosecond.

A man who doesn't want to be a man is still a man. It's not the definition of a woman!

And him thinking it is turns every woman into a resource for him. The entire concept of womanhood in fact. Women are not beings in their own right, they're a solution to his problem.

This bloody ideology is so sexist, it's difficult to believe. And it's baffling there's so many people who can't see it. I genuinely think it's their own internal sexism doing a fucking number on them.

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:06

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 18:02

Don't know but it seems to exclude quite a lot of people who identify as trans.

I see.

There have been some posters in the past who claimed that they had academic qualifications who also were very clear arbiters of who was and was not a genuine person with a transgender identity.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:04

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

"I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation."

Please provide this rigorous and accurate test.

Otherwise, you are spreading misinformation. Because if such a test existed, it would be in wide usage around the word.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 18:02

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:01

What natural variation of sex category that people who have claimed to have a transgender identity have?

Did I miss the explanation?

Don't know but it seems to exclude quite a lot of people who identify as trans.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:01

What natural variation of sex category that people who have claimed to have a transgender identity have?

Did I miss the explanation?

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 18:00

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 17:57

“Trans women” male rapists have sexually assaulted female prisoners in the U.K. and in other countries. Hope that helps.

@totinoit is important to acknowledge that this is what you are supporting

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 17:59

If words have personal meanings such as woman / man, female / male, feminism etc, then so to do page numbers. Because how can you change words such as woman and female to include the opposite meaning of what they were established to mean, while demanding that numbers mean a specific concept.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:58

totino · 08/10/2026 17:51

I don't think they're personality labels. Because yeah, we agree, being a woman requires no specific behavior or look or activity. The full range of human behaviors is open to both women and men.

Also understand that these two boxes are indeed neat and tidy, but I simply don't think they're sufficient. I don't think they give you the full picture. Trans people (to me) have a genuine natural variation of sex/gender and I think the big difference is, I don't think accommodating them is harmful or dangerous.

but I simply don't think they're sufficient. I don't think they give you the full picture.

Man and woman?

They are no more supposed to give the full picture than your age or your height. Most of the time sex discrimination is unlawful.

Trans people (to me) have a genuine natural variation of sex/gender and I think the big difference is, I don't think accommodating them is harmful or dangerous.

Nobody is suggesting that trans people shouldn't be accommodated. It's just that where sex is relevant, sex is relevant. See also age. The fact that I can't get a young person's rail card is not because I am not being accommodated. It's because I'm the wrong age. In many ways that is distressing, but that is life.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 17:57

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

“Trans women” male rapists have sexually assaulted female prisoners in the U.K. and in other countries. Hope that helps.

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 17:53

totino · 08/10/2026 17:51

I don't think they're personality labels. Because yeah, we agree, being a woman requires no specific behavior or look or activity. The full range of human behaviors is open to both women and men.

Also understand that these two boxes are indeed neat and tidy, but I simply don't think they're sufficient. I don't think they give you the full picture. Trans people (to me) have a genuine natural variation of sex/gender and I think the big difference is, I don't think accommodating them is harmful or dangerous.

No, trans people don’t have any variation in sex. They are one sex or the other, same as everyone else.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 17:52

totino · 08/10/2026 17:44

Probably because most trans people I ever talked to had dysphoria. I presume it's possible to perceive the incongruence without being distressed by it. But they still perceive it.

https://www.hrc.org/resources/transgender-and-non-binary-faq

However, though many transgender and non-binary people experience gender dysphoria, it is not a necessary requirement to identify as transgender or non-binary. Some transgender people never experience gender dysphoria, or only feel it at certain points in their life.

Plenty of similar definitions available on other sites.

There isn't any particular need to feel incongruence. Trans can just mean having a perspective that it's possible to self define with reference to masculinity and femininity and that one is somewhere in the middle. It doesn't even need to be a fixed identity.

Transgender and Non-Binary People FAQ

Transgender and non-binary people come from all walks of life. The HRC Foundation has estimated that there are more than two million of us across the…

https://www.hrc.org/resources/transgender-and-non-binary-faq

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 17:52

I wish people would get it into their heads that no, we are not going to change the definitions of words so that a group of men can dismantle women’s sex based rights.

Why would we?

Datun · 08/10/2026 17:51

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

98% of all sex offences are committed by men, not women. That's why sex segregation is an instant risk reduction.

And men identifying as trans in prison are statistically even more likely than any other man to have committed a sex crime.

And as for being able to tell? For heaven's sake. Who's going to do that? Who's going sit there and say you, but not you?

Who's going to say you're pretending to be a woman, but you, matey, are only pretending to pretend to be a woman.

This idea that women can tell who's a sex offender and who isn't it so dangerous. If we could tell, we bloody would and no one would ever be raped by their husband, partner, boyfriend.

Not only can we not tell, we end up falling in love with, marrying and having children with these men.

totino · 08/10/2026 17:51

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 17:08

The tragic irony is that if you just keep "man" and "woman" as simple sex labels, misgendering is not a possibility.

It is only when you decide "man" and "woman" are personality labels that you create the risk of "misgendering".

Do you see? It is trans people's idea that "man" or "woman" can be something other than the body in the first place that creates the problems they complain about.

Put bluntly, it's only their own sexist projections about how other people feel that makes them feel they are not the right sex for their sex. They literally invent the problem for themselves by insisting sex mean more than it actually does.

Female people exist. Being pregnant is something only available to female people. While not all female people can or will become pregnant, nevertheless you can broadly define female people as people who one cannot say for certain will never be pregnant based on a simple visual check at birth. And everything else, the gender, the social differences - those all follow from that.

It makes no sense at all to say we need a label, and separate spaces, and protected rights, for people who feel a certain undefined way that not only can we not agree on but we cant even agree everyone feels it, but we don't need a label for the half of humanity that is physically female.

If we actually somehow really didn't have the word "woman" meaning adult human female, if we were really in a world where the word had never existed, we'd have invented it pretty damn quickly!

It's only because we are in a world where the word does exist, where we do all understand it but are supposed to pretend we think it means something else (while having the original meaning hanging around in the background to underpin that new defintion) that Generists have the luxury of pretending they don't think we need to recognise the two sexes in law, language or society.

I don't think they're personality labels. Because yeah, we agree, being a woman requires no specific behavior or look or activity. The full range of human behaviors is open to both women and men.

Also understand that these two boxes are indeed neat and tidy, but I simply don't think they're sufficient. I don't think they give you the full picture. Trans people (to me) have a genuine natural variation of sex/gender and I think the big difference is, I don't think accommodating them is harmful or dangerous.

Rollingpinofdoom · 08/10/2026 17:51

totino · 08/10/2026 17:38

It's not "Fuck it". I don't think you'll get a trans man to be a woman and you don't get a trans woman to be a man. You can put them back in the closet, but they do not belong in these categories. That, in my opinion, would be propping up a lie. I agree that sex and gender should ideally align, which is why I support transition.

Housing sex criminals will never be an easy topic, but I actually do think you can tell the difference between someone who is sincere and someone who lies out of desperation. Especially is a risk assessment is performed. It's also true that trans women as a group are not the ones committing rapes in prison, even if rapist trans women exist. (It's known that it's the male staff.) But for the record I believe cis women can also be rapists. And they are also in prison.

How? How can one infallibly tell the difference? What do a TIM and a woman have in common thst make them both women? Some people also believe the earth is flat. Are they correct? Because that’s as batshit as your belief a male can be a woman

Swipe left for the next trending thread