Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
nutmeg7 · 08/10/2026 18:36

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 08/10/2026 08:09

You are confusing 'female' with 'woman'. Female is a sex category. Woman is both a sociological & sex category because of social associations.

The heart of your "social construct" of women is gender stereotyping that socially advanced societies reject.

But they don't really on the whole because if they did they wouldn't continue to perpetuate them by expressing sex typical behaviours & most men & women do this to some degree. That you are in denial of this reality doesn't do your credibility much justice particularly given its a centrepiece of gender critical feminism. Do you even understand your own ideology?

Woman is a sex category.

Only in fantasy sociological theorising land is “woman” a social category.

In the real world of normal English usage, it is the word that evolved in English over hundreds of years for the adult human female.

Other languages have also evolved equivalent words for adult human males and females.

BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 18:34

murasaki · 08/10/2026 18:32

Hang on, did some one say that Caitlin Jenner has always been a woman?

Shark well and truly jumped. I have never read such stupidity in my life.

I’m not sure even Caitlin believes that.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:34

I’m not sure I buy the earnestness entirely.

murasaki · 08/10/2026 18:32

Hang on, did some one say that Caitlin Jenner has always been a woman?

Shark well and truly jumped. I have never read such stupidity in my life.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 18:31

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 17:28

Since I don't think there's an "universal woman experience" or an "universal man experience",

We agree 100% on that.

Which is why the only way to define who is male and who is female, as opposed to who anyone (including the person themselves) thinks is male and thinks is female, is by reference to genetics.

If you don't believe this to be true, please describe what makes a woman without any reference to any gender stereotypes or any physical attributes which can be found in the normal distribution overlap between males and females.

Edited

@totino

Still waiting for your definition of a woman, totino.

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 08/10/2026 18:31

totino · 08/10/2026 18:11

The Suzie Izzard thing is amusing because yeah she used to talk about "girl mode" and "boy mode", but a couple of years later and she's just Suzie now. Personal journeys are messy.

Though I did know a nonbinary person who did have "boy mode" and "girl mode" days. It's not for me but the way they explained it made sense to me.

EDIT: I don't know Frank Maloney but yeah, Caitlyn Jenner was also always a woman. Women can be dicks (as well as have them, occasionally).

Edited

So Bruce Jenner, the Olympic athlete who described himself at the start of his transition as a lonely little boy, was in fact a girl and a woman? And we would know that how?

Eddie Izzard claimed in 2020 that he was now in ‘girl mode’ and by 2023 was ‘Suzy’. Strangely Eddie managed to be credited as Eddie in the 2024 film Midas Man. Maybe the paycheck was bigger for boy mode. But sure, he’s a woman.

I still don’t know what you think detransitioners are. Keira Bell? Always a man or a woman?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:30

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:30

Does everyone remember when Steph Pompey announced that there was evidence that showed accurately who was and wasn't transgender?

He got a lot of flak, didn’t he? From Katie Montgomerie IIRC

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:30

Does everyone remember when Steph Pompey announced that there was evidence that showed accurately who was and wasn't transgender?

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 18:29

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:27

I am SOOOOOO excited though that we are going to perhaps finally get a link to the test that can be used to work out who is genuinely transgender and who is not!!!!

It is exciting! And I assume the trans community are very excited too, because they will finally get to show us that their transness is a real, measurable thing!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:28

“Cis woman”: female - actual woman

”trans woman”: male - man, not a woman, faux woman

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:27

I am SOOOOOO excited though that we are going to perhaps finally get a link to the test that can be used to work out who is genuinely transgender and who is not!!!!

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:26

Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

It actually does not mean this when you understand how it has been used.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:26

Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

No it doesn’t. Because if that was the case, a “trans woman” would be an adult female human being who identifies as a man, wouldn’t she? What you mean, is you want to impose your divisive, unconvincing, quasi-religious ideological stance by default.

no?

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 18:26

Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

According to Alex above, trans is about 'breaking out of standard gender binaries', so I would guess that most posters on the feminism board are trans. Alex has been a Stonewall ambassador, so I assume is an authority.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:25

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 18:23

Caster Semenya is not a woman at all. Caster has Y chromosome.

Shall we see if the poster who is arguing that 'cis' is a meaningful word believes that Caster Semenya is a female athlete?

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 18:25

Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

CIS is a completely unnecessary word. Woman means born female.

OP posts:
xye · 08/10/2026 18:24

Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

‘Cis’ and ‘trans’ are made up nonsense.

Woman and man work perfectly well, thank you!

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 18:23

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:20

If Caster Semenya is a 'cis woman' then I suggest that the term 'cis' is meaningless.

Caster Semenya is not a woman at all. Caster has Y chromosome.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:23

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/10/2026 16:42

IIRC you posited that some people might genuinely feel their body is that of one sex despite in reality being the other.

You have not, I think, explained why this makes them more like or more interchangeable with people whose bodies are the opposite sex to theirs than people who are the same sex as them.

Basically, you haven't explained the leap from feels like to is.

That's a pretty massive leap IMO.

It's like saying the mere existence of religious belief is proof that God exists, and furthmore that means we all have to live just like God says we should whether we personally believe in Him/Her or not.

Exactly this.

Imdunfer · 08/10/2026 18:22

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

I refuse to bow down to the trans demand that I should add a word in order to describe myself as a woman who was born female.

Women are born female.

If trans people want to distinguish people who were born female from people who weren't but feel female let them add trans to their description of themselves.

I am a woman. Not a CIS woman.

OP posts:
Mouldemort · 08/10/2026 18:22

@Helleofabore cis means not trans. It's not that complicated.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2026 18:20

Waitingfordoggo · 08/10/2026 17:15

Sorry this still doesn’t make sense. I’m not disagreeing with your definition of echo chamber at all.

I’m saying that to declare a platform ‘an echo chamber’, one would have to go and look at what is said on the platform in order to make that judgement.

You can’t possibly have spent any time on those ‘platforms’ that you declared to be echo chambers. (Because they don’t exist).

Your confusion over this point is baffling to me.

I also made this point.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:20

totino · 08/10/2026 18:06

Women are real and we fucking rule.

We have the words cis and trans to acknowledge that there's a difference. No, I'm not 1:1 to a trans woman. But I'm not 1:1 to all cis women, either. I really do think there's enough room for all of us but I know you don't agree.

If Caster Semenya is a 'cis woman' then I suggest that the term 'cis' is meaningless.

Helleofabore · 08/10/2026 18:19

TheKeatingFive · 08/10/2026 18:13

How can you tell?

How do you propose this is judged? Who does it and under what criteria?

And what do you say to the women who suffer when it goes wrong?

I am looking forward to hearing about the test. At long last!!!

woohoo! Someone can link us up to the test for telling which male person is really transgender and which one isn't!

I am hoping that we can send the link out to the world so that there is finally a tool to be used.

nicepotoftea · 08/10/2026 18:16

totino · 08/10/2026 18:11

The Suzie Izzard thing is amusing because yeah she used to talk about "girl mode" and "boy mode", but a couple of years later and she's just Suzie now. Personal journeys are messy.

Though I did know a nonbinary person who did have "boy mode" and "girl mode" days. It's not for me but the way they explained it made sense to me.

EDIT: I don't know Frank Maloney but yeah, Caitlyn Jenner was also always a woman. Women can be dicks (as well as have them, occasionally).

Edited

Great! If only I had know that it were possible for a woman to father children or win an a gold medal in the men's Olympic decathlon.

Life would have been so much easier!!!!!

Blast. Just realised that I am one of the other kind of women - the ones that need sex specific rights.