Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:29

popery · 07/10/2026 09:11

What if someone thinks that the traits that society assigns to female people don't apply to a large number of female people?

It seems like a poor proxy between the groups of people to work on the basis that people who are traditionally 'feminine' are female and that people who are female are feminine.

Surely better to say your sex doesn't dictate what you're like, and what you're like doesn't dictate your sex (actual or otherwise)?

The thing with self determination means its upto individuals to decide what they believe that's why self identification exists. Identity is a personal determination that people are entitled to regardless of how illogical or impractical or unhelpful others may find it just like atheists don't get to dictate their beliefs onto theists.

hagchic · 07/10/2026 09:28

I define feminism as promoting the needs of the female sex.

'Transinclusivity' is an ideological term - I would read it as 'including people who deny their sex (for a variety of reasons) and expect me to agree with them'

So , women who deny their sex - they are included in my feminism because i'm looking to promote improvement for ALL women, even those who struggle with being a woman. Maybe if we improve womanhood they would be happier to accept it.

Men who deny their sex cannot be included in feminism for me, because they are men.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:27

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:19

Someone's "internal identity" is not relevant here. Being one sex or the other is not something a person determines for themselves.

Feminism, and women's liberation, aim to fight against female inequality in society stemming from our sexed bodies. That's what our foremothers were fighting for. Not for someone's nebulous "gender identity" and most certainly not for the inclusion of male-bodied people.

It is relevant if some people believe that it is relevant and therefore form many of their related opinions and beliefs are centred around it.

You might not believe in an internal gendered identity but a lot of people do resonate with this way of looking at themselves. Denying they exist is pointless. They exist and they develop socio-political values and beliefs that centre around their beliefs about (gender) identity. Not unlike people in here who do not see themselves or the world that way and centre their own values and beliefs around that.

Just like much of a trans inclusive feminist's values will be centred around their beliefs that TWAW (and TMAM), much of your values (ie your feminism) is centred around the belief that they are not. Often to the exclusion of other feminist issues.

But that is why we have different branches if feminism. Different people have different priorities and beliefs about how to achieve equality and where society is unequal to begin with.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:26

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

Are they also more than welcome in female only spaces?

Plenty of men are feminists, there is no requirement to be female to be a feminist.

Unless this post is satirical, I find the reference to either of the sexes as being superior or inferior distasteful.

OP posts:
JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:25

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:19

It doesnt change the fact that trans inclsuionary feminism is a type of feminism as agreed by academics the world over.

Just because you find it distasteful, it doesn't alter its existence at all.

Using the name “feminism” doesn't actually make it feminism though.

We are all aware that a clothes horse is not a horse despite the name, see also hot dog.

And no one is saying that “it doesn’t exist”, just that we disagree with the principle.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:24

JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:20

But why is self defining as female justifiable and self defining as 10 years old not?

After all age also confers a “socially constructed set of roles, behaviours expressions, and norms”.

Why can a man self identify into women’s legal spaces, and I can’t self identify to being 10 years old and apply for a space at my local primary school?

Why can't he self identify as black and get himself on a shortlist list for black and Asian people?

Could any BLM supporter ever support the inclusion of a white person on such a shortlist? Of course not!

As soon as you take this is out of the arena of a man trying to muscle in on the rights of women, it exposes now ridiculous it is.

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:23

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:19

It doesnt change the fact that trans inclsuionary feminism is a type of feminism as agreed by academics the world over.

Just because you find it distasteful, it doesn't alter its existence at all.

That's twice you've made reference to "academics" now. Are the plebs not allowed their opinion?

Be wary of being so in thrall to what "academics" think. They can be wrong. This I know.

luy · 07/10/2026 09:23

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:21

It's nothing to do with gender.

The UN use 'gender' as do many interpretations probably as a result of the usage of man/woman rather than female/male in dictionaries like Cambridge.
But in any case, that doesn't change the over arching point that feminism is about equality not superiority.

https://www.unwomen.org/en/articles/explainer/what-is-feminism

And it's nothing to do with "superiority", it's about equality for women in an unequal world.

Yup that's what I said. Claiming self determination should only apply to natal women & not trans women is superiority not equality.

How can feminism be inextricably linked with the bodily autonomy of men to self determine as women and take women's places in society?
That's an oxymoron.

Places or spaces aren't enshrined in stone to anyone. That's for rights balancing to adjudicate. Equality iis kind of 'funny' that way.

Edited

this kind of post makes me so angry. You don’t get to give away my rights because you think feminism can include males who cosplay as females.

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:21

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:01

Thank you for your attempt to explain, it's appreciated.

But ...

It's nothing to do with gender. Feminism is about the biological sex of a disadvantaged section of society.

And it's nothing to do with "superiority", it's about equality for women in an unequal world.

feminism & liberalism are inextricably linked where personal liberty is emphasised encompassing bodily autonomy & self determination

How can feminism be inextricably linked with the bodily autonomy of men to self determine as women and take women's places in society?

That's an oxymoron.

It's nothing to do with gender.

The UN use 'gender' as do many interpretations probably as a result of the usage of man/woman rather than female/male in dictionaries like Cambridge.
But in any case, that doesn't change the over arching point that feminism is about equality not superiority.

https://www.unwomen.org/en/articles/explainer/what-is-feminism

And it's nothing to do with "superiority", it's about equality for women in an unequal world.

Yup that's what I said. Claiming self determination should only apply to natal women & not trans women is superiority not equality.

How can feminism be inextricably linked with the bodily autonomy of men to self determine as women and take women's places in society?
That's an oxymoron.

Places or spaces aren't enshrined in stone to anyone. That's for rights balancing to adjudicate. Equality iis kind of 'funny' that way.

luy · 07/10/2026 09:21

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:19

It doesnt change the fact that trans inclsuionary feminism is a type of feminism as agreed by academics the world over.

Just because you find it distasteful, it doesn't alter its existence at all.

trans inclusive feminism: otherwise known as fun feminism. Otherwise known as men’s rights activism.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 09:21

AnonyMumAuDHD · 07/10/2026 09:18

I think we can be feminists - ie want female exclusive spaces/right protected - but also have a society that is empathetic and tolerant of the issues faced by trans identifying persons; one where we all work together to ensure that there is no harassment, bullying or infringement of actual human rights (ie no discrimination from access to employment, rental properties etc). But I thought, 15 years ago, that we had that?

The tension came when that was not enough - when a vocal and very dominant section of the trans community, whose drivers and motivations seem to be less about surviving individual trauma/distress and quietly getting on with normal life along side the rest of us, made it about indoctrination, erosion of women’s rights, and the express harming of children and vulnerable teens. Once it became about subverting societal norms, eroding the rights and safety of women and children and LGB people, about policing language and thoughts - then, no. It became impossible to be both a feminist and generally trans inclusive.

And I don’t think we can ever ‘rewind’ the clock to return to that original position because not only has the damage been done now, but it has irreversibly and irreparably destroyed families, children's lives and individual livelihoods. That harm cannot be unseen.

Edited

Exactly. I think most of us on FWR are aware of that change, but there are still plenty of well meaning people who aren’t. Less every year though, which is why support for men in female spaces is on a downward trajectory over time.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:20

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:14

Feminism has always had different branches as it has evolved. There's something like 9 different types now. All with a slightly different idea about how to achieve equality.

Feminism can have different ideas about how to improve the lot of women.

It can't, by definition, include a branch to have ideas about how to improve the lot of men (unless that is achieved by improving the lot of women) because that would be a total contradiction.

Your whole argument on this issue is predicated on believing that men can choose to change sex.

They can't, so do you have any other explanation than that one as to how a genuine feminist can be completely trans inclusive?

OP posts:
JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:20

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:05

Because there needs to be a justifiable reason for the association to man or woman (gender categories not sex) & the reason in the case of trans people is gender. Gender being a socially constructed set of roles, behaviours expressions, and norms that a society associates with being a boy, man, girl, or woman.

But why is self defining as female justifiable and self defining as 10 years old not?

After all age also confers a “socially constructed set of roles, behaviours expressions, and norms”.

Why can a man self identify into women’s legal spaces, and I can’t self identify to being 10 years old and apply for a space at my local primary school?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:19

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:06

Well not if you see trans women as women and not men. You can't both see a trans woman as a man and rationally include them in your feminism so you'd have to believe that woman and man is something one determines for themselves. An internal identity that may or may not align with your external body.

So the first way that it is a different branch of feminism to Trans exclusionsry feminism is because trans inclusive feminists believe you self determine your gender. It isn't determined for you by your anatomy or physiology.

Someone's "internal identity" is not relevant here. Being one sex or the other is not something a person determines for themselves.

Feminism, and women's liberation, aim to fight against female inequality in society stemming from our sexed bodies. That's what our foremothers were fighting for. Not for someone's nebulous "gender identity" and most certainly not for the inclusion of male-bodied people.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:19

Hoardasurass · 07/10/2026 09:16

It's a fact not a wish. Women are discriminated against because of our sex not some notion of gender identity or gendered stereotypes. Gendered stereotypes are the way we have been oppressed over the centuries and are what many men are reinforcing so that by dint of preforming those stereotypes they can claim womanhood. That is misogyny write large and a males supremacist model ie the exact opposite of feminism

It doesnt change the fact that trans inclsuionary feminism is a type of feminism as agreed by academics the world over.

Just because you find it distasteful, it doesn't alter its existence at all.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 07/10/2026 09:18

I think we can be feminists - ie want female exclusive spaces/right protected - but also have a society that is empathetic and tolerant of the issues faced by trans identifying persons; one where we all work together to ensure that there is no harassment, bullying or infringement of actual human rights (ie no discrimination from access to employment, rental properties etc). But I thought, 15 years ago, that we had that?

The tension came when that was not enough - when a vocal and very dominant section of the trans community, whose drivers and motivations seem to be less about surviving individual trauma/distress and quietly getting on with normal life along side the rest of us, made it about indoctrination, erosion of women’s rights, and the express harming of children and vulnerable teens. Once it became about subverting societal norms, eroding the rights and safety of women and children and LGB people, about policing language and thoughts - then, no. It became impossible to be both a feminist and generally trans inclusive.

And I don’t think we can ever ‘rewind’ the clock to return to that original position because not only has the damage been done now, but it has irreversibly and irreparably destroyed families, children's lives and individual livelihoods. That harm cannot be unseen.

Hoardasurass · 07/10/2026 09:18

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:08

How can you support the rights of women to have women only shortlists if you support allowing biological men to be on those shortlists?

That only makes sense if you believe men can change sex, and even then I don't believe you can truly be a feminist if you are prepared to disadvantage large numbers of women who don't believe that is possible to change sex.

Transmen are biological women who identify as men.
Its transwomen who are biological men who identify as being women

Hoardasurass · 07/10/2026 09:16

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:07

That might be how you wish it was.

It's a fact not a wish. Women are discriminated against because of our sex not some notion of gender identity or gendered stereotypes. Gendered stereotypes are the way we have been oppressed over the centuries and are what many men are reinforcing so that by dint of preforming those stereotypes they can claim womanhood. That is misogyny write large and a males supremacist model ie the exact opposite of feminism

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:14

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:12

Oh boy, that's just fabulous.

We agree that you can't be a feminist and completely trans inclusive so we'll invent a "new branch of feminism".

It is not for men to redefine feminism so that it can include them.

Feminism has always had different branches as it has evolved. There's something like 9 different types now. All with a slightly different idea about how to achieve equality.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:13

JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:07

I don’t believe that I have strayed from the question posed in the OP.

And the two points are inextricably linked given the definition of “trans inclusive” posited in the OP.

You cannot believe yourself a feminist and believe men should be included in women’s single sex spaces and categories unless you also truly believe that TWAW.

I'd agree with that and that is why it makes no sense when someone keeps repeating that they are including men. They don't see them as men so the point is moot. That is why they are labelled post modern or trans inclusive feminists. They're including trans women who most with that school of thought see as women.

It doesn't make them more or less right by acknowledging that it is a feminist approach. It just makes you seem like you know what you're talking about and any arguments you do make seem more rational and robust.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:12

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:06

Well not if you see trans women as women and not men. You can't both see a trans woman as a man and rationally include them in your feminism so you'd have to believe that woman and man is something one determines for themselves. An internal identity that may or may not align with your external body.

So the first way that it is a different branch of feminism to Trans exclusionsry feminism is because trans inclusive feminists believe you self determine your gender. It isn't determined for you by your anatomy or physiology.

Oh boy, that's just fabulous.

We agree that you can't be a feminist and completely trans inclusive so we'll invent a "new branch of feminism".

It is not for men to redefine feminism so that it can include them.

OP posts:
popery · 07/10/2026 09:11

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:05

Because there needs to be a justifiable reason for the association to man or woman (gender categories not sex) & the reason in the case of trans people is gender. Gender being a socially constructed set of roles, behaviours expressions, and norms that a society associates with being a boy, man, girl, or woman.

What if someone thinks that the traits that society assigns to female people don't apply to a large number of female people?

It seems like a poor proxy between the groups of people to work on the basis that people who are traditionally 'feminine' are female and that people who are female are feminine.

Surely better to say your sex doesn't dictate what you're like, and what you're like doesn't dictate your sex (actual or otherwise)?

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 09:11

Inclusive of transmen? Sure. Transwomen are men, so no more included than other men.

Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 09:10

It is like asking 'can you truly be a vegetarian and eat meat'.

Erm, no.

Even if your Auntie Sue's neighbour calls herself a vegetarian and hosts hog roasts in the garden and virtue signals her 'vegetarian' credentials by ripping the legs off a pig and chomping down on them slurping about how lovely and meaty they are.