Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:41

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 09:38

The clue is in the name. If it’s centring men, it’s not feminism.

And if you don't understand that trans inclusive feminists don't see trans women as men, then you aren't really part of the conversation.

popery · 07/10/2026 09:40

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

Why would a feminist of any stripe think that 'woman' is the lesser gender?

Am I missing something or is this a joke post? (Sorry, I don't always get when something is a joke!)

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 09:40

PeachyDaisy · 07/10/2026 09:38

I think arguing over who is and who isn't a feminist is a bit pointless in my opinion. GC feminists are going to say trans inclusive feminists are not real feminists and trans inclusive feminists are going to say GC feminists are not real feminists.

Why would the women defending women’s sex based rights not be feminists?

JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:40

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

Can you give me some examples from the last decade where transwomen have “helped dismantle the patriarchy”. Actual practical steps?

I would also like to see examples of transwomen joining the “ranks of the oppressed” if possible.

Are transwomen accepting reduced pay, a greater burden of childcare, care for the elderly, unpaid domestic labour?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:40

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:33

Yes but you don't seem to understand the difference between "I disagree with that approach to feminism" and "that isn't feminism".

It isn't feminism if it includes men.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:38

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:35

Because there is no legitimate association demonstrable in reality. Age requires chronological associations. Gender only requires sociological associations that trans women possess.

Female is a sexed term btw. Woman is both a sex & gendered term. Trans women aren't claiming to be natal females they are claiming to be sociological women.

Trans women aren't claiming to be natal females they are claiming to be sociological women.

Fixed that for you.

And some trans women ARE claiming to be natal females. You are so out of the loop on this sometimes.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 09:38

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:33

Yes but you don't seem to understand the difference between "I disagree with that approach to feminism" and "that isn't feminism".

The clue is in the name. If it’s centring men, it’s not feminism.

PeachyDaisy · 07/10/2026 09:38

I think arguing over who is and who isn't a feminist is a bit pointless in my opinion. GC feminists are going to say trans inclusive feminists are not real feminists and trans inclusive feminists are going to say GC feminists are not real feminists.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:38

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:33

"academics", especially in the field of sociology, don't hold the most respected views in the world right now.

Even more so given that it's a field where opposing voices have been actively, life changingly, silenced.

All reputable academic will acknowledge that trans inclusinary feminism is a branch if feminism, irrespective of how much they disagree with it. So they might say "trans women arent women and that is why they shouldn't be centred or even included in feminist principle", but they wouldnt argue that some feminists believe differently.

The whole "you is not a feminist" is the work of buffoons on the internet from both sides.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:36

Paganpentacle · 07/10/2026 09:35

No.
Because men are not women.

This, basically.

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:35

JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:20

But why is self defining as female justifiable and self defining as 10 years old not?

After all age also confers a “socially constructed set of roles, behaviours expressions, and norms”.

Why can a man self identify into women’s legal spaces, and I can’t self identify to being 10 years old and apply for a space at my local primary school?

Because there is no legitimate association demonstrable in reality. Age requires chronological associations. Gender only requires sociological associations that trans women possess.

Female is a sexed term btw. Woman is both a sex & gendered term. Trans women aren't claiming to be natal females they are claiming to be sociological women.

BackToLurk · 07/10/2026 09:35

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:27

It is relevant if some people believe that it is relevant and therefore form many of their related opinions and beliefs are centred around it.

You might not believe in an internal gendered identity but a lot of people do resonate with this way of looking at themselves. Denying they exist is pointless. They exist and they develop socio-political values and beliefs that centre around their beliefs about (gender) identity. Not unlike people in here who do not see themselves or the world that way and centre their own values and beliefs around that.

Just like much of a trans inclusive feminist's values will be centred around their beliefs that TWAW (and TMAM), much of your values (ie your feminism) is centred around the belief that they are not. Often to the exclusion of other feminist issues.

But that is why we have different branches if feminism. Different people have different priorities and beliefs about how to achieve equality and where society is unequal to begin with.

What is it with all the ‘denying they exist’ rhetoric?

Paganpentacle · 07/10/2026 09:35

No.
Because men are not women.

hagchic · 07/10/2026 09:35

@DebbieSavage So, you are saying men can be feminists - men can promote the needs of the female sex. This is possible I think.

Men who pretend to be women aren't doing this though - they are denying the needs of the female sex and prioritising their own wants - that they want validation and for women to be subjugated into putting their wants, (men's wants) before their own needs.

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:34

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:32

Disagreeing with the principle doesn't mean it isnt feminism, though. It's feminism because it acknowledges that men hold more structural and societal power and that has led to ongoing oppression. That's all feminism requires.

No it's not all feminism requires.

Feminism requires that you don't actively do things that damage women.

OP posts:
Justme56 · 07/10/2026 09:34

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

Male and female bodies are different. If they were truly fighting the patriarchy they wouldn’t be taking advantage of this difference and taking sports awards from women.

JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:33

Claiming self determination should only apply to natal women & not trans women is superiority not equality.

The point would be that I don’t “self identify” as a woman.

I am obviously, observably and provably a woman.

My femaleness is not something I “feel” it is material reality.

My femaleness is also the reason for the social, political, financial, medical, professional and legal disadvantage I have operated under my whole life.

And self identifying as a man wouldn't remove any of those disadvantages.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:33

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:32

"Denying they exist is pointless" - did I deny they exist? That's somewhat hyperbolic.

I know they exist. And I happen to think their beliefs are wrong and not based in fact, science or biology.

"Some people believe it" isn't sound reasoning. Some people believe lots of things that aren't actually true.

Yes but you don't seem to understand the difference between "I disagree with that approach to feminism" and "that isn't feminism".

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 09:33

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:19

It doesnt change the fact that trans inclsuionary feminism is a type of feminism as agreed by academics the world over.

Just because you find it distasteful, it doesn't alter its existence at all.

"academics", especially in the field of sociology, don't hold the most respected views in the world right now.

Even more so given that it's a field where opposing voices have been actively, life changingly, silenced.

OP posts:
Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 09:33

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:32

Disagreeing with the principle doesn't mean it isnt feminism, though. It's feminism because it acknowledges that men hold more structural and societal power and that has led to ongoing oppression. That's all feminism requires.

Yes the men that pretend they are women do hold the power. Hence why they are absolutely nothing to do with 'feminism'.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 09:33

I include all women in feminism. Including women who claim to be men. And zero men. Including men who claim to be women. It’s really that simple. Some people claim to be vegetarian as a pp said, but this claim often falls short when they have the occasional bacon sandwich or eat fish.

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:32

JaneJaneAnne · 07/10/2026 09:25

Using the name “feminism” doesn't actually make it feminism though.

We are all aware that a clothes horse is not a horse despite the name, see also hot dog.

And no one is saying that “it doesn’t exist”, just that we disagree with the principle.

Disagreeing with the principle doesn't mean it isnt feminism, though. It's feminism because it acknowledges that men hold more structural and societal power and that has led to ongoing oppression. That's all feminism requires.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 09:32

Lexibletheflexible · 07/10/2026 09:27

It is relevant if some people believe that it is relevant and therefore form many of their related opinions and beliefs are centred around it.

You might not believe in an internal gendered identity but a lot of people do resonate with this way of looking at themselves. Denying they exist is pointless. They exist and they develop socio-political values and beliefs that centre around their beliefs about (gender) identity. Not unlike people in here who do not see themselves or the world that way and centre their own values and beliefs around that.

Just like much of a trans inclusive feminist's values will be centred around their beliefs that TWAW (and TMAM), much of your values (ie your feminism) is centred around the belief that they are not. Often to the exclusion of other feminist issues.

But that is why we have different branches if feminism. Different people have different priorities and beliefs about how to achieve equality and where society is unequal to begin with.

"Denying they exist is pointless" - did I deny they exist? That's somewhat hyperbolic.

I know they exist. And I happen to think their beliefs are wrong and not based in fact, science or biology.

"Some people believe it" isn't sound reasoning. Some people believe lots of things that aren't actually true.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 09:32

Choppingwoodcarryingwater · 07/10/2026 09:29

The thing with self determination means its upto individuals to decide what they believe that's why self identification exists. Identity is a personal determination that people are entitled to regardless of how illogical or impractical or unhelpful others may find it just like atheists don't get to dictate their beliefs onto theists.

They can decide what they believe.

They cannot decide what they ARE when all objective, verifiable, scientific evidence says otherwise.

Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 09:30

DebbieSavage · 07/10/2026 09:22

Yes of course. Trans women are more than welcome in the fight to dismantle the patriarchy. They honour us by rejecting the lesser gender that they were born with and joining the ranks of the oppressed class. That is something that deserves a hell of an amount of recognition from the rest of us cisgendered women who never had the option to identify out of oppression.

How are 'trans women' aka men who say they are women joining the oppressed class when literally every law and institution and service has been bent sideways and backwards including language itself, to accommodate, facilitate and never upset them?

That is not an oppressed class, that is a highly priviledged class.