Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist?

959 replies

Imdunfer · 07/10/2026 08:29

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here.

Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist and to be trans inclusive, where by trans inclusive they mean males in women's spaces and shortlists (the attitude to sport wasn't stated).

I don't believe that you can truly be both, do you?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 12:53

Well, reading those posts is 5 minutes I'll never get back

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:51

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:47

For the vast, vast majority of people, the meanings of men and women haven’t changed. The SC judgement clarified that any sex specific rights are predicated on … well … sex.

So I don’t see the issue. Even the muppets who take issue with these words know what the law says.

We have to adapt to the times. If people insist you can be a woman with a penis.. then narrow your focus to use specific language. Talk exclusively about genitals (ffs) and knock the wind out the sails of people who want to argue two things at once: that men can be women and that transwomen have the right to be in vagina-only spaces.

These are two different issues (or should be) but everyone is arguing them as though they are one. You might be right. Maybe men can't be women. Personally, I couldn't care less if a man identifies as a woman. But that's not relevant to this argument anyway. Separate it out and you will win. Make it not about identity and you get your single-sex spaces back where there is no supervision.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 12:48

Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 12:46

I'll tell you what men who are not a threat to women and girls do, they stay out of female spaces.

Its a very simple shorthand method of working out who is visibly being a predator.

Exactly. It’s a huge red flag when men do not respect women’s boundaries. Read the Gift of Fear.

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:47

Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 12:38

We absolutely do keep them out because they are men.

Because men as a class are a threat to women as a class.

And 'prove he is no threat' - its like you've never heard of men killing women before. Or raping them. Or drugging and raping their own wives and putting the opportunity out to the rest of the world to come and rape them whilst they are being recorded.

Your points are valid but you won't win with sentimental-sounding, man-bashing arguments.

Keep emotions out of it and speak facts only. Because those are all that matter.

In a perfect world, we could see each other's 'auras' (or something) and know instantly who was a threat and women would know who they could be alone with. Sadly, that's garbage and not gonna happen.

I don't ask men to stay out of unsupervised areas where I'm vulnerable because "historically men have abused women", I do it because 'that person here and now with a possible penis' (man / transwoman) is a stranger I don't trust and don't have to trust. I don't know if they're a danger to me so they need to stay out. And you need to be specific on why. Narrow your focus.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:47

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:43

You hit the nail on the head. It isn't realistic to test the literal / practical application of this. So.. we do have to keep judging based on likelihood of threat. I.e. appearance. If you look like you have a penis then you just don't use vagina-only spaces.

Shame we can't keep the labels of men and women due to how much of a hot topic that is. But the outcome is the same. Just with a solid argument to back it up and shift focus from 'identity'.

For the vast, vast majority of people, the meanings of men and women haven’t changed. The SC judgement clarified that any sex specific rights are predicated on … well … sex.

So I don’t see the issue. Even the muppets who take issue with these words know what the law says.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 12:46

xye · 07/10/2026 12:36

@Awkwardisfunny “Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.”

I would care and wouldn’t want to be alone in an unsupervised location with one.

Yes. It's such a common argument among people who haven't thought this through properly. "I don't mind, so why would you?"

Because we live in a society. Other female people matter too.
The selfishness and lack of perspective drives me mad.

Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 12:46

I'll tell you what men who are not a threat to women and girls do, they stay out of female spaces.

Its a very simple shorthand method of working out who is visibly being a predator.

backformoreofthesame · 07/10/2026 12:43

We do keep people out for safety reasons
and the simple fact is that all people with penises are a significant risk to women and therefore all people with penises - I’ll call them men for short - are given different treatment to women in certain circumstances

because the segregation is seen as a reasonable price to pay for the increased female safety and additional benefits that then brings to society

there is no evidence that PwP ( men ) who identify as women behave like women so I can’t see a PwP as a woman can I? Illogical

btw - just because someone seems nice and doesn’t immediately attack you the first possible opportunity that doesn’t mean they are safe. Indeed the world would be easier if that were the case. Abusive, dangerous men ( well successful ones ) tend to play a long game , win your trust, win the trust of the community …

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:43

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:33

I’m sure there are lots of men who could prove they are no threat for lots of reasons. Perhaps they are too old to be a threat, disabled, ill.

We arent letting them into women’s spaces either, so why on earth should we make an exception for this group of men?

You hit the nail on the head. It isn't realistic to test the literal / practical application of this. So.. we do have to keep judging based on likelihood of threat. I.e. appearance. If you look like you have a penis then you just don't use vagina-only spaces.

Shame we can't keep the labels of men and women due to how much of a hot topic that is. But the outcome is the same. Just with a solid argument to back it up and shift focus from 'identity'.

Shedmistress · 07/10/2026 12:38

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

We absolutely do keep them out because they are men.

Because men as a class are a threat to women as a class.

And 'prove he is no threat' - its like you've never heard of men killing women before. Or raping them. Or drugging and raping their own wives and putting the opportunity out to the rest of the world to come and rape them whilst they are being recorded.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 12:37

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:33

Exactly. And as we cannot do that... Inevitably.. we have to stick with what we always have, which is appearances. Do you look like a man or woman. That is how you win. You need to start with a fact-based argument and then slowly drag people kicking and screaming to the same fecking conclusion we drew hundreds of years ago (or whenever). But I suppose time has passed and people forgot 😒😞

No, we rely on people to be honest, make the right decision and stick to the social contract. It worked fine until about 8 (?) years ago. Most men don't want to be in women's spaces. Even the horrible men, the confused men, the drunk men. Why do you want to make an exception for TW?

xye · 07/10/2026 12:36

@Awkwardisfunny “Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.”

I would care and wouldn’t want to be alone in an unsupervised location with one.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:33

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

I’m sure there are lots of men who could prove they are no threat for lots of reasons. Perhaps they are too old to be a threat, disabled, ill.

We arent letting them into women’s spaces either, so why on earth should we make an exception for this group of men?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 12:33

No men in female spaces. Not your Nigel. Not mine. Not “Nigella” who’s “lovely”.

DialSquare · 07/10/2026 12:33

INeedAPensieve · 07/10/2026 12:13

I've always thought that Debbie Savage is a wind up merchant. Whenever they post on this subject it's always just on the edge of ludicrous and written to sound like something a TRA would say but in a similar tone to how I read Dame Katy Denise's posts on X.

I could be wrong and perhaps they are genuinely a TRA, some are tbf quite dogmatic in their beliefs, but I am mostly certain Debbie is on the wind up.

Also, being a woman is not a feeling inside a man's head - so feminism is sex based and therefore cannot include men and their identity feelings. Seems crazy to have to say it.

I agree. And it’s not just on this subject!

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:33

MagpiePi · 07/10/2026 11:51

We're getting into genital inspection territory here....🙁

Exactly. And as we cannot do that... Inevitably.. we have to stick with what we always have, which is appearances. Do you look like a man or woman. That is how you win. You need to start with a fact-based argument and then slowly drag people kicking and screaming to the same fecking conclusion we drew hundreds of years ago (or whenever). But I suppose time has passed and people forgot 😒😞

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 12:32

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:30

Exactly. So I have no issue with them using a penis-free space.

No. Let's not dismiss valid arguments. Any argument focused on identity and by extension discrimination, will fail. You must focus on facts.

I won't dismiss valid arguments. I just haven't seen any yet.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 12:31

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

Whut?

How's he going to prove that to you?
Are you going to watch him pee?
What if he's no threat to you personally, but he's a potential threat to another female person?
It's not discrimination against men to keep them out of women's spaces!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2026 12:31

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

No, it’s not just because of safety. It’s also because of privacy and dignity. It’s so we don’t have to deal with the sexual harassment of men while we are vulnerable.

If you want to fawn over some gurning man aping sexist stereotypes of what he thinks of women, and pretend you think he is a woman and you’re all girls together in a “men v women” quiz, be my guest. But understand why other women think that’s grim.

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:30

GreyskySexRealistsky · 07/10/2026 11:52

Let's not do this. It's not helpful.
Also, some TW have had their penises removed.

Exactly. So I have no issue with them using a penis-free space.

No. Let's not dismiss valid arguments. Any argument focused on identity and by extension discrimination, will fail. You must focus on facts.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:30

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

A man can do harm to you without his penis.

Is this seriously news to you?

SchoolOfCool · 07/10/2026 12:30

INeedAPensieve · 07/10/2026 12:13

I've always thought that Debbie Savage is a wind up merchant. Whenever they post on this subject it's always just on the edge of ludicrous and written to sound like something a TRA would say but in a similar tone to how I read Dame Katy Denise's posts on X.

I could be wrong and perhaps they are genuinely a TRA, some are tbf quite dogmatic in their beliefs, but I am mostly certain Debbie is on the wind up.

Also, being a woman is not a feeling inside a man's head - so feminism is sex based and therefore cannot include men and their identity feelings. Seems crazy to have to say it.

Yeah I think she posts to help others spell out feminist arguments for lurkers.

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 12:29

Note how @Mouldemortknows how weak their argument is, so is attempting to crowbar race in at every given opportunity, no matter how irrelevant, to try and grant it some legitimacy.

🙄🙄🙄

Awkwardisfunny · 07/10/2026 12:28

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2026 11:58

Removing a penis makes no difference to a persons sex. A man without a penis is still a man.

Okay but if a man proves to me that he is no threat (and that he will sit down to urinate 👀😬), I won't care if he's alone with me in an unsupervised location.

Otherwise: it's just discrimination against men. We don't keep them out because they are men. We do it for safety and that is the angle you must focus on or you will lose.

SchoolOfCool · 07/10/2026 12:28

Mouldemort · 07/10/2026 12:09

Most feminists are trans-inclusive, apart from a small group of almost universally white privileged people with a disproportionate influence. They align with neo-cons, incels and Christian nationalists in their obsessive hatred of transgender people.

The shift in language from anti-trans to pro-women, and from trans-exclusionary to sex-based rights is straight from the old-school bigotry used against black people and gay people forever.

www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09589236.2025.2468805#abstract

This is so racist.

If you think everything should be mixed sex, own it!

If you think people's bodies can change sex, own it!

If you think that an inner feeling about identity is more important than the physical body, own it!

If any of those are genuinely your beliefs, it is your right to hold them and express them here

But to use the struggle for racial equality as a shield to hide your beliefs behind is racist. Make your arguments stand on their own merit.